1,118 karma · joined June 24, 2008
The first minute establishes the conditions.
You've sidestepped #1 entirely, so I'll leave that be.
#2, I have over 100 apps, most of which came with the phone and/or are components of other things. It's like your grandma's Windows desktop in there. It's not much of a pain to get things more usable on the home panes, it's just a UX headache that doesn't need to exist.
And as for inconsistency, the original article was talking about inconsistency among different apps, not phones/UIs.
1: When I plug in my phone to my computer, I have to mount two separate drives and then hunt for the file I'm looking for.
Where's my music? Is it in "My Documents" or "MP3" on the phone storage? How about "data" or "documents" or "My Music" on the card?
The whole thing is a huge mess. Every app has its own little scheme for storing data.
2: Okay, so I hit "install" and now it's installing. I do something else for a minute, and now I want to put it on a page and launch it. Where is it? The app list. Where in the app list? I dunno. What's its name? Is it the same as the one in the market? Not always. Google Reader is "Google Reader" in the market and just "Reader" in the list.
3: No, he doesn't like having to hunt for something, then manually place it before being able to use it easily. Why isn't the option to place an app on a pane given at install?
4: Do you use Android at all? There's no adherence to an interface standard.
5: You're right on this one. Multitasking works great without me having to bother it at all.
The reading experience for books made of text, yeah. This isn't that.
I can't really get that from anyone but Apple. I've got a Thinkpad, but even that very nice machine is in a lower class of industrial design compared to Apple products. Likewise, my HTC Incredible is a great phone, but bits of it are clearly of lower quality than my friends' iPhone 4s.
That's why some of Apple's practices annoy me-- because they're so damn good at everything else, they tempt me anyway.
Even just an archive of these uploaded somewhere with a server would make them accessible.