HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

q845712

739 karma · joined November 9, 2013

submissionscomments
q845712··on Anyone else witnessing a panic inside NLP orgs of big tech companies?
I was just using bing translate last night, and it was literally making up english words that do not exist - I tried to google for them to see if it was just some archaic word, and it was complete fabrication. So I dunno how many years are left before we all trust machine translation unflinchingly, but I agree today's not the day.
q845712··on Just Write
see also https://catandgirl.com/polymaths/
q845712··on Just Write
absolutely - I'm really not trying to detract from Lena Dunham's work ethic (she's a prolific creator) nor from the thrust of the article which is encouraging other people to be prolific creators.

-- it's just that if someone else is writing a ton and wondering why they can't succeed, it's helpful to understand what other ingredients are involved.

I also think there's some amount confidence in one's prerogative to create and publish, when for example both of one's parents are also in creative fields. Confidence that creating is worth the effort and confidence that if one's creations improve in quality that there will be help to find an audience.

q845712··on Just Write
Not to detract from the message or discourage anyone from writing, but if you're looking to reproduce the specific career arc mentioned in the article it may be helpful to keep in mind that Lena Dunham started her career with well-connected parents and at least a modest amount of family wealth.
q845712··on Highways fatalities up 22%. Our smartphone addiction is a big reason why
sliding scale? https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/06/in-finland-speeding-t...

Almost any penalty one can come up with will be harder for the already-disadvantaged, and still shrugged off by someone with sufficient resources.

q845712··on Highways fatalities up 22%. Our smartphone addiction is a big reason why
lol fair enough.
q845712··on Highways fatalities up 22%. Our smartphone addiction is a big reason why
imo there's already a bunch of inconsistent nanny-state stuff when trying to use a smartphone as a passenger/navigator. There's things I'm not allowed to do without unplugging the phone briefly, and there's also things I'm allowed to do that absolutely require looking down at a zero-haptic-feedback touchscreen.

It seems like there's always corner cases that aren't considered (in your proposal above, what if the navigator doesn't have a phone because they're a child, or because their phone ran out of batteries? What happens when the sensors/algorithms are wrong about how fast we're going? What happens when the sensors are wrong about whether or not there's another device? What if that second device keeps disappearing and re-apparing while somebody tries to do a multiple step operation?) ... Trying to build some water-tight mechanism to keep us out of trouble but also with access to full functionality "when we can use it responsibly" is an endless rabbit hole.

IMO it feels like a systemic problem asking for a systemic solution. Whether we think that solution is self-driving cars, rail travel, walkable cities, or taxis probably says as much about our politics as anything else though.

q845712··on What a good debugger can do
in my experience a large portion of go programmers seem to think this. I would guess (but haven't confirmed) that there's someplace where rob pike and/or russ cox are on the record telling folks that they don't really need debuggers because printf is great.
q845712··on The mission to discover if Jupiter’s moons support life
i think those of us with the [mis?]fortune to have watched the movie "2010" have this iconic phrase perpetually ready. To be honest I barely remember the movie, but that one line really sticks somehow. The gist of it is that whatever power is associated with the mysterious monoliths is starting life on Europa, so the humans shouldn't mess with that "world".
q845712··on What’s Wrong with Bananas (2018)
hard to find commercially in the US but we tend to call them "crabapples" (many crabapples are too small or only suitable for juicing but some are large enough for culinary use), or you can look for some cider homebrewing enthusiasts who may know how to source tart/dry apples in your area.
q845712··on Ask HN: How do you add novelty to your days?
+1 to the above. the strangest thing about meditation, in my experience, is there's a state that's sometimes available in which every moment is truly novel and surprising.

I read (once, somewhere??) that some lifetime meditators put under FMRI often have the signature activation pattern that in the rest of us basically happens when we're about to say "Oh wow, look at that!" (i.e., excited by novelty) So I'm a little captivated by the idea that part of the nature of these states called "liberation" and "enlightenment" is an unending feeling of amused and interested novelty. In the literature they'll talk about "the freshness of every moment" and other similar phrases, so it seems to really be part of the sales pitch and goal.

For me it wears off pretty fast, and isn't always available. :) But definitely it's one of the things that keeps me coming back to the cushion, because ... yeah, you said it :)

q845712··on Tech's Elite Hates Labor
I've been working on re-framing nepotism as "selective altruism" -- it's like there's an "in" group, within which the members feel completely justified and even a little obligated to help each other out. So it's our usual human tribal stuff, basically, but we can recognize the altruism in there.

Of course the next step would be leveraging this thought to propose a mechanism to convince them to expand their notion of "in-group" to include, i dunno, everyone who works for them? Everyone who was integral in their success? Every living being with whom they share a planet? So that the altruistic instinct could be expanded to be helpful to many many more.

... no particular ideas atm, but commenting in case it helps someone else reach an actionable insight :)

q845712··on Ask HN: Something you’ve done your whole life that you realized is wrong?
sorry, late reply: REI sells a totally ok pair, i'm not even wearing silk ones. The trick for me is that in this era of remote work, I'm not required to be in places heated to the warmer end of room-temperature. And I can pretty casually take them off if/when the day warms up.
q845712··on All programming philosophies are about state
It's been a while but I used to enjoy telling folks in the early years of their career that software engineers and anarchists have a lot in common because both view "the state" as the main cause of problems.
q845712··on Europium UltraGlow Powder – Green
it's a slightly poetic and roundabout way of saying "This website will sell you some funny toys and some slightly radioactive stuff [like uranium ore, i guess, from previous comments]. "By the way, remember when the US invaded Iraq because we claimed they had stuff which is [allegedly, maybe, i dunno] remarkably similar to what you can order as a gift from this website?"

A "secret santa" is a gift giving tradition where you pool a group of people together and each person gets the name of someone and buys them a Christmas gift (generally within some price range) but they don't know who bought them the gift. So it's an opportunity to buy joke-gifts for someone you aren't particularly close to, if you happen to draw their name.

q845712··on Go 1.20 released
matlab had a constant random seed around 2005, no idea whether they've changed it.
q845712··on BioGPT: A language model pre-trained on large-scale biomedical literature
I dunno man, I'm with the poster above (do we call that the gp?): We have lots of evidence that people in general don't have great truthiness filters for things they read online, and we have a tool that can very confidently say things that seem truthy but are not. Even before the internet, just in the age of radio and early TV, Churchill said "A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on."

Now we have a tool that isn't lying through malice, volition, or any sort of intent, and that will combine jargon and phrases that seem authoritative into its misinformation.

IMO responsible engineering involves considering the ups and downs of each solution - that's where the famous HA saying "if you have two you have one; if you have one you have none" comes from, dictating that we need at least 3 instances of a server for high-availability, right? What would it take to engineer this new tech for high accuracy? Where is anything other than the hubris of "we were so busy asking if we _could_, we never stopped to ask if we _should_" ?

q845712··on Ask HN: What is the best source to learn Docker in 2023?
hmm I understood it as, "when i push a new branch to CI, I want to automatically deploy a container running that code." maybe I was wrong!

btw, imo, nearly all commercial shops' use cases are a long distance from needing kubernetes, but that doesn't seem to be stopping very many people... :)

q845712··on Ask HN: Something you’ve done your whole life that you realized is wrong?
I'm one of the sweatiest people I've ever met. I've slowly gotten better at layering and how to use clothes for different situations, but I agree it's a big factor and there's some unwinnable combinations.

For instance, I've finally learned to embrace "long-john" style long underwear under my pants, but it's only possible because I'm working from home. They are amazing layers for warmth, but unlike additional shirts, hoodies, jackets, scarves, hats, long underwear can't be casually removed. You have to take off your shoes and your pants! So if (when) I was going into an office, I always made the choice to have cold legs during the commute but comfortable legs all day. Now I can wear them in the morning, take them off if the day warms up, and put them back on whenever the temp. drops again.

But overall I'll echo a few comments in here that some of the more expensive gear, even as base layers, really is better technology. And getting to know my body and my situational habits, it's been possible to figure out layering clothing that worked for me, but only because I was working in tech and felt like I had enough money to get it wrong a couple times... If I were still living on a student or even "average" budget, I would've been much shyer about trying some new $30 shirt just to see if it agreed with me.

q845712··on Ask HN: What is the best source to learn Docker in 2023?
It sounds to me like you have a project that involves on-demand deployment of containers. Like it or not, the current standard for that is kubernetes. As someone is already saying on here, there will still be Dockerfiles and container technology involved, but not necessarily "docker compose" or "docker swarm." Just my guess, but I think that's part of why you're struggling to find the tutorials you're looking for, is that since 2020-ish (idk someone can correct my chronology, maybe 2018? 2021?) they've increasingly become k8s tutorials, not "docker" tutorials.

that's just my guess though :) Happy hacking!

q845712··on Is tipping getting out of control? Many consumers say yes
I think tipping at its very best is an opportunity to give a stranger a small gift. I recognize your points -- sometimes it feels like an obligated payment and probably in nearly all cases the capital owning class could and/or should contribute more, but i think you're excluding some optional perspectives. Sometimes I just want to help someone have a nice day by giving them something they didn't expect, like a generous tip. The escalation of niceness and virtue signalling seems right now to be creating an expectation of that generosity, which undermines it, since it can feel non-optional, but sometimes it's still just a nice thing one human can do to recognize another human.
q845712··on Ask HN: Has anyone successfully started their career over in their 30s?
with full agreement re. growth mindset, I've definitely worked with people above me who were more, less, and completely un- interested in leveling me up. It still makes a difference.
q845712··on Stock market charts you never saw (2021)
just a nit, but especially given the economics outlook advanced by and named for the U of C, the line between the University of Chicago and a for-profit corporation is both thin fuzzy.
q845712··on Ask HN: Has anyone worked at the US National Labs before?
I interned at Sandia around '04-'05. That was a little bit before the current "FAANG" thing we have now (IIRC amazon was turning itself from a bookstore into an e-commerce startup, and google was still not being evil) but certainly it was already less glamorous than getting a Microsoft or even Apple internship.

My recollection is that the whole experience depended on which group you were in, and mine was fortunately very chill. Smart, friendly people who arrived and left more or less at the same time every day. Lots of matrixing and loaning of people from different orgs -- I had the feeling that if I were making a career there I would wind up slowly drifting around between projects.

The biggest surprise to naive me-in-my-early-20s was that "Department of Energy" is a euphemism for "Department of Nukes." Nuclear stockpile stewardship was a large portion of the activity there, and so a lot of your colleagues will be people who are at least vaguely comfortable with that.

There was a ton of "basic research" too -- some high-energy group had a daily experiment that would deliver a "whomp" of a shockwave around 3:15pm most afternoons, there was a room temp. fusion group, lots of interest in assisted driving cars and unmanned aerial vehicles... you just had to appreciate that all the first applications of all this tech was going to be military.

Also the security clearances.... the joke was that the "L" clearance stood for "Lavatory pass" because in our building until you got one, you needed a line-of-sight escort at all times, even in the bathroom. Even for the "L" the process was quite onerous, and I understood that the 'Q' clearance held by nearly all full-time staff was even more burdensome. I heard stories of people waiting for their clearance getting stuck in rooms with nothing to work on. One person in my group basically got sent offsite to some "think tank" or something for several months while he waited for his clearance - I only met him once the whole summer, at a conference.

q845712··on Cantable Diffuguesion: Bach chorale generation and harmonization
Thanks for sharing - I've been wondering how the newer generation of AI-stuff would do on chorales.

I don't think this would have gotten great marks in my collegiate music theory IV class (iirc covered special cases of voice leading and rarer harmonic progressions like the augmented 6th and neapolitan chords), but honestly neither did I. In my highschool classes this probably would've gotten passing grades, at least on short exercises.

Is there an easy way to get it to "true up" the intonation on the longer chords? IMO part of the magic of this style of music is that a capella performances aren't constrained to equal temperament, and get really nice resonances on anything they hold.

q845712··on Tech companies are irrational pop cultures
I expected the example at the end to be kubernetes, but instead it's layoffs. I think the article works almost equally as well if you swap in k8s, blockchain, or a few other buzzy buzzwords, which is kind of a testament to the truthiness of the argument.
q845712··on Five mildly anti-Buddhist essays
I had a teacher (also from Karma Kagyu) who would use a racecar metaphor: the point of a racecar is to be a really fast vehicle. That doesn't mean that a racecar is the most suitable vehicle for all tasks, or "best" in any overall sense of the word. Racecars are only well suited to certain conditions, and are usually driven by people who trained and practiced specially to drive them. Some tasks and lifecycles need a pickup truck, others a minivan, others an 18-wheeler, and personally I love to point out that the bicycle is the most efficient form of wheeled transportation.

So anyways the vajryana is the racecar. The point of that metaphor wasn't to flesh out which schools corresponded to a sedan or anything, but more like to point out how few people drive racecars, how few tasks or challenges are well solved by racecars, how much training, respect, and caution you might want to have before you started driving racecars at full speed, the conditions under which you would consider driving a racecar, etc. etc. And like you said, there's no judgement for not driving a racecar -- if anything there's a lot of respect and/or demand for people to drive more practical vehicles.

tho idk, personally, even though in my material life I prefer a bicycle, in my spiritual life I'm still trying to train to drive the racecar, so maybe it needs an even less sexy anology.

q845712··on The Lost Art of System Administration
Isn't it knowing kubernetes now? Which does kinda tend to require you to also know a fair bit of "single machine" admin tools along with a whole slew of new complexity.
q845712··on Cognitive loads in programming
hey seriously, i've been grappling with this: what better candidate to be a global variable than a shared cache that otherwise has to be passed through dozens of function calls (which imo adds cognitive load at many places through the stack).
q845712··on The Dhall Configuration Language
I said this above as well: ytt (https://carvel.dev/ytt/) lets you embed starlark into valid yaml, among other cute tricks for managing biz-logic in configs.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →