HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rodelrod

414 karma · joined July 8, 2009

submissionscomments
rodelrod··on Good code is rarely read
Basically he's saying that if the API is great you rarely need to read the implementation. To which: sure, in some blessed cases where the API was great to start with and nothing changed so you don't need to change the API or the implementation.
rodelrod··on Good code is rarely read
This is only (theoretically) true in the sense that if you build the perfect abstraction, you should not have to think too often about it.

Building good abstractions requires: 1. skill that is in relative terms rare in the profession; 2. enough experience with the problem domain that the abstraction provides the perfect balance between ease-of-use and flexibility as the context changes; 3. a dedicated individual or a small team who nurtures and gatekeeps the evolution of the abstraction obsessively.

For the other 99% of real world cases, the best you can do is try your best to build decent, not-too-leaky abstractions for the problem as you face it today, and the underlying code better be readable because you'll need to maintain it constantly, as will all kinds of other people in varying states of cluelessness.

rodelrod··on Rethinking Window Management
Pop Shell has solved the problem, please don't rethink too much.
rodelrod··on The past is not true
"History is not true. You can change history. The actual factual events are such a small part of the story. Everything else is interpretation."

OK, you've discovered post-modernism.

Next step is to avoid its pitfalls.

The actual factual events are infinite and one is exposed to a small subset to interpret. That does not mean you're allowed to make up, distort, and selectively ignore facts to suit whatever narrative you'd like to push. You need to construct the narrative in good faith, based on the best possible set of facts you're exposed to, and adjusting it when you're exposed to new facts.

Unless you want to organize a cult or a totalitarian regime, in which case go as crazy as possible with the narrative. People love it.

rodelrod··on Dark Waters of Self-Delusion: The crash of Transair flight 810
Captain Okai should be in the Airplane cockpit with Roger Murdock, Victor Basta and Clarence Oveur [0]. Missed opportunity.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2OBZf0QdKdE

rodelrod··on The History of Coffee (2015)
“The famed Brazilian coffee owes its existence to Francisco de Mello Palheta, who was sent by the emperor to French Guiana to get coffee seedlings.”

Small nitpick: at this time Brazil was a Portuguese colony and the monarch was called King John V, not an “emperor”. Brazil only got an emperor when it became independent about one century later.

Why did Peter, the son of a Portuguese King ruling over territories spanning 4 continents, decided to call himself an Emperor when ruling over a single (albeit large!) territory? I don’t know, ego?

rodelrod··on When you lose the ability to write, you also lose some of your ability to think
Most of the comments here are assigning this as Plato's opinion.

I'd just like to point out that Plato very rarely wrote in his own voice so it's very hard to say if it's his views or not that are being expressed.

In this case however, this is almost certainly an expression of Socrates' views, not Plato's. Not only because it's in the voice of Socrates but also by what's transparent in their actions: Socrates didn't leave anything in writing and Plato left us arguably the most important written corpus of classic Greek philosophy.

Maybe he felt ambivalent about it, but he certainly thought there was a value in the writing.

rodelrod··on The seven specification ur-languages
> frankly you don't have enough information to say that there is no relation

I'm not a scholar of this subject. If there is good scholarship out there presenting good arguments in your direction I'll take it. I was just helping out a fellow that has a doubt with my best knowledge of the subject, which is not just a guess.

> has been used as a metaphor for the origin of things for thousands of years, even ancient Greece

Has it really? I'd love to see an example. Sure it's listed in the Bible along with a bunch of other place names, but as a metaphor for the origin of things?

Even if there are examples, I'd really love to see an etymological trace of how it would end up as a prefix. Was it used as such in ancient Greek? In Latin? Sounds like a folk etymology.

rodelrod··on The seven specification ur-languages
You're assuming wrong, I'm afraid. No relation to the city of Ur.
rodelrod··on The seven specification ur-languages
The etymology is unrelated to the Sumerian city you link to.
rodelrod··on The seven specification ur-languages
Original, primordial, the source. Comes from German.
rodelrod··on Semaphore: A Full-Body Keyboard
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_flags_with_blue,_red,_...
rodelrod··on Apple Music Classical
I was going to chime in with "also Primephonic" and learned that Apple bought them a couple of years ago and this basically is Primephonic.
rodelrod··on Ask HN: Anyone go through Montessori education until age 12 (end of grade 6)?
I spent two years in a rough-ish public school. It was the hardest period in my life but it taught me very much about valuing people from all walks of life and especially on adapting my behavior to get positive outcomes in any social setting. I can absolutely see how that experience is lacking on some of my friends that spent all their lives in protected environments.
rodelrod··on The plague of emoji insertion in French docs
Best reference I could find is here: https://www.lalanguefrancaise.com/articles/espace-insecable

Actually before the ":" specifically there should be a regular non-breaking space, not a narrow one. Except in Switzerland. Other punctuation marks take the narrow non-breaking space.

rodelrod··on The plague of emoji insertion in French docs
CORRECTION: narrow non-breaking space goes before ";", "!" and "?". Before ":" you should use regular non-breaking space. That is, in France. In French-speaking Switzerland it's a narrow non-breaking space everywhere.

This is the best reference I could find: https://www.lalanguefrancaise.com/articles/espace-insecable

rodelrod··on The plague of emoji insertion in French docs
I think the point of the GP is that it inserts NO-BREAK SPACE instead of a NARROW NO-BREAK SPACE. If that's the case, it's a bug.
rodelrod··on The plague of emoji insertion in French docs
This is mostly correct, but I don't see how it contradicts my statement.

Did the 646 standard account for variable-width characters at all?

rodelrod··on The plague of emoji insertion in French docs
A narrow non-breaking space, please.
rodelrod··on The plague of emoji insertion in French docs
This space before the colon and other marks in French should actually be a narrow non-breaking space (U+202F) [0]. There's no key for it in the AZERTY layout.

This has been a problem since the typewriter age. People having to get on with their jobs coped with it by using a full, breaking em-space. Unless this gets replaced automatically by the word processor, you get horrid typography and misplaced line breaks all over the place.

The Académie Française should have dealt with this years ago, if their ass wasn't stuck in the 17th century.

[0] https://www.compart.com/en/unicode/U+202F

rodelrod··on Kill Bill – Open-Source Subscription Billing and Payments Platform
I've built a (proprietary) telecom billing system with the same name back in 2005. I can't claim that as a particularly brilliant pun since the system we were replacing was called "BillGates" so it was kinda obvious.
rodelrod··on The Moorish invention that tamed Spain's mountains
Madeira was initially settled by the Portuguese in the 15th century, 200 years after the end of the Portuguese Reconquista, so it's quite a stretch to claim that the "levadas" were "established by the Moors", even if they initially brought the technology to Iberia.
rodelrod··on Emmaüs: Thrift Store Shopping in France
"Aigu" does not take a trema. The feminine form "aigüe" does, and the trema is there because otherwise you'd pronounce it "/ɛɡ/" instead of "/ɛ.ɡy/". It does not change the sound of the "u" at all.
rodelrod··on Emmaüs: Thrift Store Shopping in France
The two dots here are not an umlaut. They're a trema [0], which happens to look the same. It's used to break digraphs or diphtongs into separate vowels.

Without the trema, this word would be pronounced something like "/emo/". With it, it's pronounced "/ema.yz/".

If you see two dots in French, Spanish, Portuguese (and English as written by The New Yorker!) you're looking at a trema.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diaeresis_(diacritic)

rodelrod··on Soft deletion probably isn't worth it
Or you can see it the other way around: soft-deletes are a pragmatic alternative to event sourcing that provides a lot of the value without requiring a team of super-humans and a radical redesign of the existing systems.
rodelrod··on ‘Just stop buying lattes’: The origins of a millennial housing myth
> There's nice areas in the UK which are dying because everyone wants to live in some metropolitan area.

Maybe because

> My colleagues used to commute in by train from two hours away each day

?

rodelrod··on ‘Just stop buying lattes’: The origins of a millennial housing myth
> The cost to purchase an entire house and the land it sits on is at that multiple or slightly more.

Where is this magical place?

rodelrod··on Organice: An implementation of Org mode without the dependency of Emacs
Agenda opens every underlying file in the emacs session so I would assume it would work. I've never used encryption, though.
rodelrod··on How to stay informed without getting paralyzed by bad news
"From its beginnings in 1843, when The Economist newspaper was founded by a Scottish hat manufacturer to further the cause of free trade [...]" [0]

It is liberal in the classical sense and in my opinion this was quite transparent in the writing at least when I was a subscriber throughout the 2000s.

[0] https://www.economistgroup.com/about-us

rodelrod··on When old historic maps overlap with modern political maps
Putting it in these terms, what I'm trying to say is something like:

  geography → economy → old empire

  geography → economy → current day politics
The biggest caveat to this is that the importance of geography is conditioned by technology, and technology changes over time. So a more detailed model could be something like:

  geography + current tech → agriculture/commerce/industry/military → economy/culture → politics
See how the dominant powers changed with the shift from bronze to iron or with the development of open ocean navigation.
Page 1 of 6Next →