HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

overscore

274 karma · joined December 3, 2020

submissionscomments
overscore··on Asked to do something illegal at work? Here's what these software engineers did
> I would argue that you have a moral and ethical responsibility to say no when your manager asks you to do something illegal, even if it does cost you your job.

When your access to food, housing, heating and healthcare for your family are dependent on your income, you may find yourself facing very difficult decisions. Most parents will risk whatever legal ramifications to care for their kids and that's inherent moral and ethical, even if the downstream outcome is not. That is because it is the socioeconomic system rather than the individual who is acting immorally.

> The law is the law, and there is no excuse for breaking it.

This is an infantile view. The law is a framework and there are lots of circumstances where breaking it is not only excusable, it's the only moral action.

overscore··on Announcing Tinker
Tinker was a Traveller slur long before the verb - denying that is just wilful ignorance itself. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/tinker
overscore··on Announcing Tinker
Yes, it is, and 37 years later, it is no longer acceptable to use such terms.
overscore··on Announcing Tinker
The formation etymology (whether from tin or onomatopoeia) is uncertain. The part that is certain is the semantic chronology. The noun tinker was used from at least the 13th century for an itinerant mender of pots, the Travellers. By the 16th century it became a slur for Travellers.

The verb to tinker doesn’t appear until the mid-17th century, first meaning to work as a tinker and only later coming to mean what you're familiar with.

So while the root word’s sound-shape is debated, the order of senses is clear: the Traveller sense comes first, the modern “casual repair” sense comes later and was derived from it. This is the etymological order given in all sources, eg https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/tinker

overscore··on Announcing Tinker
The colloquial meaning carries all of that baggage. You just weren't aware.
overscore··on Announcing Tinker
It's definitely not forgotten? What makes you think that? Commonly used in Ireland, the UK, Australia, Canada, parts of the US.

> they're probably due for some self-reflection on what offends their sensibilities.

Or maybe what they're willing to accept?

overscore··on Announcing Tinker
> Almost anything can be a slur in some context.

Eh, this is a very particular and long-standing racist term, and the meaning used by the authors is derived from the slur, so it's not incidental.

overscore··on It's been three years. Stop saying your European visitors are important to you
How so?
overscore··on My take on the study from MIT that predicts “societal collapse”
> Wow. I put myself in your shoes for a second and felt fear.

It is actually the only thing that keeps me up at night. I am crew on a lifeboat and need to live within a certain distance from the boathouse, otherwise I would move tomorrow. The RNLI is too important a part of my life to leave behind otherwise. I may be able to afford some land higher up (60m+ in the future).

> I always wanted to do the same (be self-sufficient in such ways).

I am definitely not self-sufficient (especially not socially)! I could maybe take care of my family for one calendar year (one growing season and one winter), but it's a maybe. If we're talking about a situation where people are physically (violently) competing for resources, then I'd be in the same boat as everyone else (by design, I'd add - I have no desire to be the lone survivor behind a fence or whatever while other families starve).

> I probably will never be living like that (unless homelessness count, bleh), but good for you, I envy you. :)

Thanks! It actually happened because I gave up on living in a city. Certainly, there's a lot of people I knew in SF/Bay Area, London, and Dublin who could do what I did overnight (probably even as a side project), but don't, so I don't think funding is the limiting factor for most.

I hope things work out for you. I know it's trite to say online, but if you decide to do it, it's certainly a path you can take. It will involve sacrificing other paths not taken, though - the bill for opportunity cost escapes no-one.

overscore··on My take on the study from MIT that predicts “societal collapse”
I was an infantry soldier and learnt very fast how fragile the logistics of necessities can be in the modern world.

I don't believe that world civilisation will collapse (at least not in any way that can be prepared for), but I have moved out of the city, begun to farm organically, and have a plan to cook and live without mains power or fuel for months on end. I know people think I'm a nutjob, but I've also seen first-hand whole cities who thought that progress was a one-way street end up in terrible circumstances.

That said, I'm not an alarmist. I am a founder, put a sizeable amount of my wealth into the global stock market, drive cars, fly (outside of COVID-19) to various places, and - most riskily of all, IMO - live only 1.6m above the high water mark/strand line of the sea.

overscore··on On the evilness of feature branching
> If you've got integration tests that include state, now you've got to either run your tests serially or set up and tear down multiple copies of the state to prevent tests from clobbering each other.

That is a very normal setup.

> Worse, they'll start to become unreliable due to the number of operations being performed. So you'll end up with a test suite that takes potentially multiple hours to run, and may periodically fail just because.

This is called flakiness and is generally a symptom not to be ignored, as it is almost always indicative of bigger issues. It's rare that flakiness is limited to test environments. Instead it's much more likely that whatever your smoke tests are experiencing is a something end-users are also intermittently hitting.

> The feedback loop becomes so slow that it's not helpful during actual coding.

Devs can write their own unit tests when working on their assigned tasks. Smoke tests are designed to run when you're trying to integrate those changes into the existing codebase. At that point, you have the calculus all wrong. Smoke tests slow down devs enough that they don't merge broken code into production. That is a useful release gate unto itself.

If unit tests pass but smoke tests fail, then often (the vast majority of the time in my experience) the issue is that either the dev didn't understand the task or, more often, didn't understand the system they were integrating into.

overscore··on Delta pilot sues the airline for allegedly stealing an app he designed
In some jurisdictions. Certainly not all.
overscore··on Why Google's bookmark manager and Docs have purposefully bad UI
> Google’s core business is now ads, not search.

It has been for over 20 years now, since October 2000.

overscore··on EU draft exempts private jets, cargo from jet fuel tax
General Aviation - the category that encompasses private plane ownership.
overscore··on EU draft exempts private jets, cargo from jet fuel tax
GA in the EU is definitely the preserve of the rich.
overscore··on Steve Wozniak speaks on Right to Repair [video]
> Patents are incentives.

They are also regulations. You can't opt-out of the patent system.

> You can weigh the benefits or lack thereof and chooses to opt-in or opt-out.

What is your proposed mechanism to opt-out? Do you mean that an inventor can choose not to apply for a patent? If so, that's not an opt-out of the patent system. You are still subject to all other valid patents.

> Regulations are a government-created burden.

Including patent regulations. It seems you support the regulations that you consider "good" and call them incentives.

Environmental and consumer rights regulations are both regulations and incentives in exactly the way patents are. They are enforced by the state and incentivise certain behaviours.

> You can't opt out of a regulation.

True. As stated, you can't opt-out of patent regulations either.

overscore··on Steve Wozniak speaks on Right to Repair [video]
Environmental and consumer rights regulations are also compatible with a free market.
overscore··on Our plans to improve navigation on Gov.uk
> Of course they need cookies (or some other form of session management)

In the UK, cookies used for only that purpose don't require consent. In their cookie policy, you can see they don't ask for permission to set such cookies - they rely on a different legal basis: https://www.blog.gov.uk/cookies/

overscore··on Two days before condo collapse, a pool contractor photographed damage in garage
After reading your comment, I did Google "elevator death", expecting to be dismayed. I came away oddly reassured. It seems that fatal elevator accidents are rare, and that you have much more to fear from your fellow elevator passengers than the apparatus itself, if the news articles are anything to go by.

I do have a new fear of drowning in an elevator, though: https://www.israelhayom.com/2020/01/05/young-couple-drowns-i...

overscore··on Big tech face EU blow in national data watchdogs ruling
I also believe anyone in Northern Ireland who consider themselves to be British are British. However, does that imply usage of the term "British Isles"?

Simply Britain and Ireland (or Ireland and Britain) is far more commonly used if referring to the archipelago.

overscore··on Big tech face EU blow in national data watchdogs ruling
No-one is obviously hyperbole, but it's extremely uncommon in Ireland. It's a shortcut to start an argument, for sure.
overscore··on Big tech face EU blow in national data watchdogs ruling
As your own link states, it's a controversial term and its use is objected to by the Irish Government: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Isles_naming_dispute

The talk pages and edit history for the Wikipedia article on the British Isles term are interesting. You can see the arguments and edit wars. Much like the insistence on naming the country page for Ireland the "Republic of Ireland' (which is our football team and country descriptor, not the name of the country), I think Wikipedia are on the wrong side of history here, but some editors até vociferous in their objections to change.

overscore··on Somewhere Under My Left Ribs: A Nurse’s Story (2018)
I think nurses do get a lot of respect in the hospitals I've worked in. You certainly wouldn't be long tolerated if you were dismissive to them, at least.
overscore··on An app that swiftly sends CPR volunteers to heart attack sufferers in Denmark
We have a similar system in Ireland, but where volunteers take shifts on call with an AED. It has been severely scaled back due to COVID-19, but prior to that, volunteers would frequently reach patients with an AED more than 10 minutes before an ambulance arrived in rural areas. We would also provide BLS in the event of anaphylaxis, OD, stroke, attempted suicides, etc. A very effective system.
overscore··on What3Words sends legal threat to security researcher for sharing an alternative
Right - four months in, there hasn't yet been any divergence, but the GDPR no longer applies to the UK. You don't have recourse to EU enforcement measures or courts.
overscore··on What3Words sends legal threat to security researcher for sharing an alternative
The GDPR no longer applies to the UK (although it does apply to UK organisations operating in our marketing to the EU). From ICO: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/dp-at-the-end-of-the-tr...
overscore··on Europe seeks to limit use of AI in society
There are almost always these exemptions for military/law enforcement use cases in EU Directives and Regulations, because while the constituent countries in the EU have miltary and law enforcement co-operation, they would veto new legislation that impacts their independence in those areas.
overscore··on School custodian refuses to download app that monitors location, got her fired
That is location tracking.
overscore··on Stop Spotify Surveillance
That sounds like a nightmare to me - the antithesis of something good.
overscore··on Brits head home to avoid being deported as illegals in Spain
Yes, that's certainly fair. Hopefully I didn't offend.

I'm Irish, but once was an immigrant/expat in the US (in that I intended to stay permanently and to become a citizen, but things ended up not working out that way). I always thought of myself as an immigrant, but there were a lot of people I met who called themselves expats and never immigrants. Some almost seemed offended by the word. I think your comment about exceptionalism probably captured the reason why.

Page 1 of 5Next →