HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ktrgardiner

148 karma · joined August 15, 2011

t: @KatyGardiner e: katy@protiumco.com w: katygardiner.com

CEO & Co-Founder of Protium. Making things that at least one person wants.

(I am that one person)

submissionscomments
ktrgardiner··on Kickstarter backers ready class action lawsuit against Code Hero dev
At the very least, I would be wary of any project which offers so many rewards for so little money. It's poor planning and poor allocation of money. And thus it reflects poorly upon the project creators.

For this project you have 1217 backers at the $42 level who get a digital download, a usb drive boxed up and signed by the whole team, and a t shirt. Obviously for such little money and so much in return, this is going to be incredibly popular. So now you have to sit your entire team down to sign their name 1200 times, purchase 1200 USBs and produce 1200 tshirts. That's too much time and money wasted. And yet money is exactly what you're asking for.

ktrgardiner··on A Review of the TV Show Start-Ups: Silicon Valley
But anyone familiar with Bravo programming knows that it's just par for the course. After all, it's on the same channel as all the Real Housewives shows. Bravo reality shows depict glamorous and dramatic lives that most people won't experience, whether it be first or second-hand. They're realistic, but in a weed through ten thousand people until you find 5 who fit the mold you want to fill kind of way. They're not all like American Pickers or other shows in that sub-genre which depict normal, everyday people that you encounter every day.
ktrgardiner··on For Zelda-playing daughter, Dad gives Link a sex change
Probably my absolute favorite book series are The Enchanted Forest Chronicles by Patricia C. Wrede. The protagonist is a princess who grows up hating all the typical princess things she's being taught so she convinces people to teach her swordfighting, magic, Latin, and other things princes are taught. When she gets fed up she runs away to be a dragon's princess and has all sorts of great adventures.

Those books are so refreshing and brilliant that I still reread them to this day.

ktrgardiner··on Something is wrong with my generation, i.e. what happened to the social network
I don't know about everyone else, but I've tweeted/shared pictures of food before. It's almost always food I've made. I grew up in a family where food meant contentment and happiness. Food was made with joy and love. And sometimes, when I get that warm fuzzy feeling over food I've made, I just want to express it.
ktrgardiner··on Show HN: I'm bootstrapping my company and this is my first product. Thoughts?
On an aesthetics note: pick a cleaner, more serious font than the script. It shows that you mean business with your app and it's meant to be used seriously rather than as a fun one-off.

On a consistency note: the examples in your copy should match those in your example image. You have 30 min for exercise and 1 hour for emails in the image but they're the opposite in your copy.

The app looks good though and quite useful. Might I also suggest, instead of listing all the features to have them displayed around the image with arrows pointing to what they're referring to. Context can make all the difference, especially with a long page.

ktrgardiner··on Why I now, unfortunately, hate Hacker News..
But that would only work to a certain extent. All you would need is one lucky submission (think Steve Jobs' passing) to get around this.
ktrgardiner··on Former Facebooker Scoops Up $1.4 Million for Freshplum (YC S11)
Freshplum sounds very interesting and like something I may find useful in the near future, but I fear that this may be because of how vaguely it is described. "Virtual goods" isn't specific enough (in my opinion). I think everyone would be better served with some sort of concrete example of a good that was priced or even a list of the most common goods that Freshplum works with.
ktrgardiner··on An Extremely Rational Bubble
Perhaps some good points were in there, but they were too deeply buried under her grating writing style and overuse of sarcasm. She could have talked more about Greece and written something of substance but instead she decided to go with this obnoxious stream of consciousness.
ktrgardiner··on Justin Bieber, Venture Capitalist
I doubt he'll get anything more than a slap on the wrist. Not just because he is famous, but because this is his first offense, he has a clean record, and he's unlikely to be a repeat offender.
ktrgardiner··on Startup CEOs, stop acting like victims.
As The Eagles said in Hotel California: "We are all just prisoners here of our own device."
ktrgardiner··on Old People Icons That Don't Make Sense Anymore
The article began with an introduction to what could have been a really great dialogue. Why do those who didn't experience the inspiration for icons still inherently understand them? Yet it dropped that in favor of the same schtick for each icon.
ktrgardiner··on How much of Settlers of Catan is Luck?
Short answer: a fair amount. Anecdotal story: The one time i played, having never even heard of the game before, I learned as I went along and ended up winning. I'd say my final few plays were the only ones based more upon strategy and less upon "Is this a fair play? Yes? Well then here's my play." So a good deal of luck is involved because a novice can't beat pros in a game based entirely upon skill.
ktrgardiner··on My idea to "Kill Hollywood"
I think this idea has a lot of strong elements to it. However, the issue that sticks out the most to me is the pricing model. $.99 per viewing? That would make making a profit incredibly difficult. It just isn't realistic.

Instead, I think a price closer to renting a movie on demand would work better with a bargain price for each view after that. Perhaps $2.99 or $3.99 for the first view and $.99 for each view after that. And then maybe when the viewer gets up to a certain view count, each view after that is free. This way, you can gain a profit with less viewers while also instilling loyalty in repeat viewers who are most likely to spread the word.

ktrgardiner··on Graduating in 3 years a good idea?
You seem to have a lot of career experience and have built up a nice resume for yourself. But you need to ask yourself if you have and will have enough college experience. Prepping for a job is not the only thing you should be getting out of college. You haven't mentioned anything outside of work-related things, and perhaps I am being presumptuous in assuming this, but it sounds like you've been very busy with one aspect of college. If this is the case, do yourself a favor and enjoy your time at school. Let loose, make mistakes, have fun, be crazy. There is so much more to college than academics. Don't deny yourself what it has to offer by rushing to finish. Stay the four years.
ktrgardiner··on What we're *really* afraid of
Perhaps the word you're looking for is half-hearted? That's how I felt as well after reading this. I was nodding along in agreement until I reached the end. I live and breath what I do and love every minute of it. And my level of devotion doesn't make me fear failure nor link myself to it. Failure is a moment. You've only failed when you've stopped trying. Until then, you're just continuing on the winding road to success and experiencing every stop along the way.
ktrgardiner··on "Lifestyle" CEO bootstraps business to 30 MM unique visitors: The wikiHow story
Even many startuppers, who often work insane hours on the assumption that their options will turn to gold when their company is acquired or goes public, seem to reserve special pity for lifestyle entrepreneurs who haven’t won Sand Hill Road money and aren’t perpetually “killing it” or “crushing it” in the way Silicon Valley culture demands.

Pity for people who make a good living doing what they love? I don't know who the author thinks he is speaking for, but I highly doubt it's "many" people in the startup community. Replace pity with admiration and then you have an accurate statement.

ktrgardiner··on Response to 'I'm turning 30 and I've produced no amazing art'
Honestly, I think that's just the normal scenario for niche apps. You have a product that people react to in one of two ways: "why would I ever need that?" or "holy crap, that's exactly what I need." If the number of people in group two is small enough, you have an enormous obstacle. It's not enough to just solve a problem. You have to solve a problem that enough people have.

Anyway, if I think of a better response/solution than "it is what it is", I will be sure to let you know. Good luck in the mean time.

ktrgardiner··on Response to 'I'm turning 30 and I've produced no amazing art'
I was going to say the same thing regarding this app. I love cooking but I absolutely hate figuring out what to make for dinner to the point where I sometimes avoid making anything beyond pasta. Something that makes the decision for me is appealing.

So there you go: the target audience has grown by one.

ktrgardiner··on SOPA creator received half a million dollars from the TV/Film/Music lobby
Surely there are better ways to support a candidate than money. If you want to donate something to a candidate, donate hours of your time toward their campaign. If you have easily stated reasons for supporting a candidate, you will be more likely to get more supporters for said candidate with your word of mouth than with your money.
ktrgardiner··on Facebook settles with FTC, under privacy watch for 20 years
> Obtain periodic assessments of its privacy practices by independent, third-party auditors for the next 20 years.

This is assuming Facebook will be around in 20 years.

ktrgardiner··on Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn Hard)
I go to a fairly prestigious engineering school and it works the opposite way here. Math and science grades are always curved. You have no idea what grade you are going to get for the class until you get it. The grades you receive are more often than not more than you've earned. Either, the grading scale is lowered (90 and up is an A, 86-90 is A-, etc.) or your grade is boosted at the end. For example, I got a B in an organic chemistry class when it should have been a C-.

On the other hand, every humanities class I've taken, I've gotten the exact grade I have earned.

ktrgardiner··on Why Science Majors Change Their Minds (It’s Just So Darn Hard)
The math-science death march. Now that is a perfect name for it. It's exactly what I lived through and why I changed my major halfway through college from chemical biology to art and technology. Why, you might ask?

- being pushed through a system that treats you like a number (In two years, I never met my advisor or received any guidance from faculty)

- having your entire college career already planned out with no wiggle room or a chance to explore other interests (until the very last semester where there was one free elective)

- professors who spoke English poorly

- classes that were taught straight from books with no added knowledge or insight

And the list goes on and on. For all those who managed to make it through, more power to you. But it wasn't until I switched majors that I started enjoying the academic aspect of college.

ktrgardiner··on Apple Celebrates Steve Jobs at Memorial
The Apple stores putting up curtains and temporarily closing is just so lovely and classy. What a beautiful aspect of the memorial.
ktrgardiner··on The Agony and The Ecstasy of Steve Jobs
That is not what I am saying at all and I am sorry if that is how I am being interpreted. My comment was not made in malice or ignorance. Understanding that this is not the worst option is the first step to understanding the situation as a whole. Please read my response to jtbigwoo for further clarification.
ktrgardiner··on The Agony and The Ecstasy of Steve Jobs
In response to: If every person's situation is relative, then how do we oppose slavery or abuse? It's better than starving to death, right?

While I get what you are saying and am by no means arguing in favor of Fox Con, I believe you are turning my shades of gray argument back to black and white. There isn't a strict dividing line between the acceptable and unacceptable; it's a gradient. There is worse than Fox Con and there is worse than what is worse than Fox Con (and so on, ad nauseam).

My point is that it is foolish to use Fox Con as the poster child of this issue when there are far worse situations. It does a great disservice to the argument. Most people will stop at Fox Con in their exploration of the situation and say to themselves "That's horrible. We should do something about that," instead of "It's horrible that Fox Con is a better option for most people and that there is worse out there. We should dig deeper and fix the problem from the ground up until Fox Con is the worst of the worst and then we can fix that."

ktrgardiner··on The Agony and The Ecstasy of Steve Jobs
We talked about exactly this in my Ethics in Technology class and came to the same conclusion you've stated. Yes, this is terrible from our perspective because we outlawed those kind of working conditions years ago. But if there were better options, then there wouldn't be so many people working for Fox Con. And if it's bad to us but manageable to them, then there is worse out there that they are trying to get away from.

Thinking and talking about the situation in terms of our lives sensationalizes more than it informs.

ktrgardiner··on Why don't developers dress better?
Well I was dressed well for YCNYC. But that's because I'm a girl and I enjoy dressing well. So I wore a nice dress and a short sleeved jacket.

I felt really confident about what I was wearing until someone told me I looked like I didn't belong there. Now I'm left wondering if this suit stigma applies to females.

ktrgardiner··on YCNYC: A lost opportunity
Chance meetings are wonderful. But when you have an opportunity as rare as this one, why fall back upon chance when you can facilitate? When you can do more, you should.

For instance, what if the color coding was expanded upon and added to the invite application? Each individual could place themselves in the category that describes them the best and then know at the time of the event the people they should be talking to rather than wandering around hoping their next chance meeting is the one that makes the difference.

ktrgardiner··on Tell HN: YCNYC Feedback
I agree with this 100%. The talks were wonderful and incredibly inspiring. But oh wow, was the networking overwhelming. It was such a challenge to figure out who to talk to and many people that I did talk to agreed.

Obviously this wasn't something that could be anticipated. But there definitely needs to be a solid system (I like the idea of designated areas) for next time so everyone can use their time as efficiently as possible and talk to the people they need to talk to.

ktrgardiner··on Ask HN: Founding a startup in New York City?
As someone who also lives in Hoboken, I second the suggestion of living here. It's beautiful, safe, and fun. A good amount of the population is young and everything is within walking distance. And you're just a 10 minute PATH ride to the city. Its definitely something to look into.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →