HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartayyar

293 karma · joined September 17, 2012

submissionscomments
kartayyar··on Gemini 3 Flash: Frontier intelligence built for speed
Can confirm. We at Roblox open sourced a new frontier game eval today, and it's beating even Gemini 3 Pro! ( Previous best model ).

https://github.com/Roblox/open-game-eval/blob/main/LLM_LEADE...

kartayyar··on We will be shutting down neeva.com
I tried Neeva, and the quality of results was just not there. Would have been happy to pay.

"It is one thing to build a search engine, and an entirely different thing to convince regular users of the need to switch to a better choice."

This line in post doesn't seem intellectually honest about why I think Neeva failed: it was never a 10X better experience. e.g. ChatGPT isn't complaining about acquiring users.

I believe Google when they say competition is just one click away. A bunch of things I would have asked Google now go to ChatGPT.

kartayyar··on Ask HN: Can someone ELI5 transformers and the “Attention is all we need” paper?
- You can develop a very deep understanding of a sequence by observing how each element interacts with each other over many sequences.

- This understanding can be encapsulated in "compressed" low dimensional vector representation of a sequences.

- You can use this understanding for many different downstream tasks, especially predicting the next item in a sequence.

- This approach scales really well with lots of GPUs and data and is super applicable to generating text.

kartayyar··on BigCode Project Releases StarCoder: A 15B Code LLM
The quality delta is so huge that it's in a different league.

Replit's model seems to have focused on being cheap to train and run. StarCoder seems to be vastly better on quality.

kartayyar··on UK Blocks Microsoft’s $69B Activision Deal
In other words, a shallow big == bad without taking specfic context into consideration?

Imo I want competition and choice as a consumer. This basically sets things up so that consoles become a non competitive market because Xbox lacks exclusives that Sony has.

kartayyar··on Ask HN: Does Google use the text inside gdocs and Gmail for training AI models?
About emails:

No for ads.

Yes for training models for Smart Reply, from: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.04870.pdf

Privacy Note that all email data (raw data, preprocessed data and training data) was encrypted. Engineers could only inspect aggregated statistics on anonymized sentences that occurred across many users and did not identify any user. Also, only frequent words are retained. As a result, verifying model’s quality and debugging is more complex.

kartayyar··on How to Sell Your Startup
I think the article should more accurately be titled as how to do a small scale feature tuck in / acquihir-ish soft landing.
kartayyar··on Two weeks of dealing with Google as a developer
I had a similar experience with an Adwords account getting banned for "Circumventing systems", and we were completely confused as to why we got the rejection.

And then the appeals process after that was just like yours: copy pasta email without any explanation about how to fix the problem.

kartayyar··on Ask HN: Do you use an optimization solver? Which one? Do you like it?
A past project used OR Tools. I generally liked it. It was a bit confusing at times and the documentation was a bit cryptic for using some of the advanced features, though the community was good about answering questions.

In general, I would recoment OR Tools.

kartayyar··on Spotify and Google Announce User Choice Billing
The post is about Spotify, not Shopify.
kartayyar··on Why is a browser extension required to access research papers?
The real problem is that the LatestInML subreddit is effectively an ad for the extension.

Solution: don't subscribe to that Subreddit.

kartayyar··on Don't send your Google phone in for warranty repair/replacement
How do you get a notification for what picture was viewed? I don't see any Google account setting for that.

That kind of makes me doubt this report, at the very least part of it.

kartayyar··on J2ObjC is a command-line tool that translates Java to Objective-C
It was started by Inbox.
kartayyar··on J2ObjC is a command-line tool that translates Java to Objective-C
This is by design: the project came out of Inbox.

The thinking was that having portable widgets was not a good thing and for the highest quality app you still want native UI, while having portable "model" [ as in model in model view controller ] code.

Flutter was developed by a different team, and has a different philosophy about this - and in part this is driven by solving for a different goal. For super sophisticated complex apps with large teams, native is still the way to go. If you look at all of Google's own major apps, they are all native.

kartayyar··on To learn a new language, read its standard library
A different take: read unit tests for the standard library.

That shows you call sequences in context, rather than just getting lost in the code.

kartayyar··on How to train large deep learning models as a startup
TLDR of the top two point: "get accepted to YC and use cloud credits." and use dedicated servers from Cirrascale.

Saved you a click.

kartayyar··on The Perils of M1 Ownership
You don't buy a Mac (M1 or otherwise) to live an adventurous life. You get it because it has really well executed take on an opinionated computing platform that just works for normal people.
kartayyar··on Ask HN: How to learn proper systems programming?
Get a job in the field. Some places might be willing to take a chance on you if you are a good generalist engineer.

Also, make the case that many things that you learn while doing frontend programming like asynchronous programming are skills that will port over just fine.

kartayyar··on S3 Strong Consistency
This is one reason I have been a big fan of Google Cloud Storage over AWS S3: at a past company AWS consistency was a huge pain, and GCS has had this for years.

https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/how-google-cloud-...

kartayyar··on Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June 2021
What is the bait and switch ? The stuff you uploaded already is still free. It's for more usage.

You don't like it, you have the option to take your photos somewhere else.

kartayyar··on Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June 2021
It also means they will hopefully clamp down on worse monetization features like sending you notifications to go buy a photo book.

Charge me for it and then just focus on making the best product.

I like this change a lot.

kartayyar··on Ask HN: Good C++ code bases to read?
The problem with this codebase is it's not modern C++.

Modern C++ and it's use of std::unique_ptr / std::move is so much nicer vs. manual memory allocation.

kartayyar··on Ask HN: Good C++ code bases to read?
I suggest looking at some of Google's open sourced projects.

- Abseil: https://github.com/abseil/abseil-cpp https://cs.opensource.google/abseil

- Tensorflow: https://github.com/tensorflow/tensorflow/tree/master/tensorf... https://cs.opensource.google/tensorflow

- Chrome https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src.git/+/refs/he... https://source.chromium.org/chromium

There is a very high bar for C++ code quality at Google, and also a published style / best practices guide as well as a code search engine to browse the code more easily.

kartayyar··on The AMD Radeon Graphics Driver Makes Up Roughly 10.5% of the Linux Kernel
Hacker News: Nvidia is evil because they don't have an open source driver !

Also Hacker News: AMD is evil because they increase the size of the kernel by 10%.

Honestly, I think Nvidia made the right call by just focused on ordinary users who just want the card to work and can just focus on their work.

kartayyar··on AppStore Reviews Should Be Stricter
90% of this could be summarized as freemium has made software worse.

But I don't think I like any solutions which involves giving Apple more power to disintermediate developers from users even more.

I consider limiting the kinds of apps that developers can build a free speech issue.

I think making an "Editors Choice Lite" label would help. I.e. that apps can sign up for an optional extra level of vetting to indicate they are free of some of the monetization dark patterns listed in this post.

kartayyar··on Tim Sweeney on Apple and Google
The difference is the cut that Epic takes is much less than 30% - he is walking the walk rather than just talking about it.
kartayyar··on Facebook says Apple blocked it from informing about App Store 30% fee
Would you be okay with if a web based company, say Google:

1) Delisted you if you didn't support their payment option. 2) Blocked any content that tried to criticize it. 3) Forced you to support their login as an option, and also didn't place it as the first option on the list.

Then why are we okay with someone trying to do this for the mobile internet?

Apple treats apps like they own the phone. My own mental model is it's my phone, and apps are an extension of the mobile internet.

kartayyar··on Apple, Epic, and the App Store
Fully agree with this sentiment - if there is anything which becomes so common place like say a road, then I think there should be some kind of oversight.

Apple saying no to people being able to bring their own payment provider feels akin to saying the road provider only allows cars they vet, and then charge 30% car manufacturers 30% of the price of the car.

kartayyar··on Apple, Epic, and the App Store
I don't get the whole objection to mutiple app stores.

Instead of clicking icon A, I click icon B and if I get a cheaper game, all power to Epic.

I don't spend time in an app store. I spend time playing the game.

kartayyar··on Google Update Tanks Traffic
I don't get how companies can blame Google for loss of traffic. Google is going to do what it thinks will produce the best results.

And if you somehow think that gives you a right to show up in those results or be there if you benefited from showing up in results in the past, that's flawed thinking.

Page 1 of 3Next →