HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

codewench

246 karma · joined March 24, 2016

submissionscomments
codewench··on Google avoids a breakup of its ad tech business
This is far from impossible, and happens all the time when, for example, a company spins off a subsidiary, or any number of other situations.

It's hard isn't really a blocker, it's just saying 'this isn't convenient for us', which is why it would have to be forced by legislation.

codewench··on WH proposes rules giving political appointees final approval on research grants
So we haven't found a cure for cancer because those silly scientists are too busy farting around with unimportant stuff? That's your take away here?
codewench··on DuckDuckGo search saw 28% more visits after Google said people love AI mode
You also have to consider a ( I would argue large ) percentage of those evangelists are simply lying for financial gain. They see profit, or at least reduced costs, and quite simply don't give a shit about customer experience or anything like that.
codewench··on OpenAI’s o1 correctly diagnosed 67% of ER patients vs. 50-55% by triage doctors
Yes? That's a very important piece of information, and I hope would be a thing a doctor asks, especially if there are concerns about weight or nutrition.
codewench··on A new bill in New York would require disclaimers on AI-generated news content
How is that useless? You adding the warning tells me everything I need to know.

Either you generated it with AI, in which case I can happily skip it, or you _don't know_ if AI was used, in which case you clearly don't care about what you produce, and I can skip it.

The only concern then is people who use AI and don't apply this warning, but given how easy it is to identify AI generated materials you just have to have a good '1-strike' rule and be judicious with the ban hammer.

codewench··on Springer Nature book on machine learning is full of made-up citations
So given that the output of an LLM is unreliable at best, your plan is to verify that a LLM didn't bullshit you by asking another LLM?

That sounds... counterproductive

codewench··on ICE Deports 3 U.S. Citizen Children Held Incommunicado Prior to the Deportation
Seeing as how this article is talking about the deportation of US citizens, I'm going to question what exactly you mean by "here illegally".

Expanding the argument: I've just decided that you are illegally, and will thus be deported. As there is no due process, my word is law, have fun wherever you end up I literally do not care.

Does that seem fair? And before arguing "well this wouldn't happen, I'm not here illegally", again, this is an article about the deportation of US citizens. Children no less.

codewench··on If you use AI to write me that note, don't expect me to read it
Well someone has to shovel in all the coal we need to power those AIs
codewench··on US accidentally sent Maryland father to Salvadorian prison, can't get him back
>Is he (a) legally (b) morally entitled to open fire on them?

Given how these "arrests" seem to be done by plainclothes individuals who don't identify themselves?

Yes. Legally (depending on state) yes, and morally always.

(Arrests in quotations because anyone arrested has rights, something that seems to be skipped over here)

codewench··on U.S. national-security leaders included me in a group chat
18 USC 793(f) seems to apply here:

"Whoever, being entrusted with or having lawful possession or control of any document, writing ... through gross negligence permits the same to be removed from its proper place of custody or delivered to anyone in violation of his trust ... and fails to make prompt report of such loss, theft, abstraction, or destruction to his superior officer—

Shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than ten years, or both."

We can only guess about the "prompt reporting of the issue", but from what I've seen and heard I'm willing to put money on the fact that, no, this was not reported.

codewench··on BYD says new fast-charging system could be as quick as filling up a tank
Gogogo - very popular, and pretty extensive coverage [0]. The only problem is the scooters themselves are so quiet they sneak up behind you on the street.

[0] www.gogoro.com/gogoro-network

codewench··on Every line is a potential bug (2009)
Conversely, it's far better to have a slightly more verbose section of code that is immediately readable than a super slick one-liner that like two people can parse.

Maintainability is, in my opinion, just as important as other considerations when writing code. And often the more verbose approach is composed of simpler steps, meaning bugs can be easier to spot during code reviews

codewench··on "Ensuring Accountability for All Agencies" – Executive Order
> Nothing prevents the next president from having a radically different opinion.

Of course, this is only relevant if they are interested in having a 'next' president, something which it seems a segment of society is less than open to.

codewench··on NYC Congestion Pricing Tracker
> There is a reason no country provides it.

While small, Luxembourg is still considered a country. And their public transit is both free, and fantastic

codewench··on Restart of Three Mile Island tests US appetite for nuclear revival
How do they compete for the same role? Nuclear is the definition of base power generation, whereas solar/wind/etc (when backed with massive battery farms) are perfect peaker plants due to their near instantaneous demand response.
codewench··on OpenAI to become for-profit company
I suspect that if you have ever posted copyrightable material online, you will have valid cause to sue them, as they very obviously have incorporated your work for commercial gain. That said, I unfortunately put your chances of winning in court very low.
codewench··on The Third Atomic Bomb
Obviously looking at it from today's perspective it's (hopefully) unthinkable, but there is a lot written from contemporary sources which make a fairly persuasive argument.

The main concerns were that the Japanese government was simply not in a place where it could surrender, which meant a ground invasion of the Japanese mainland was seen as mandatory. Given the prior experiences of how dedicated Japanese defenders could be (eg Mount Suribachi), it was assumed that any actual attempt to take the Japanese mainland would result in untold deaths, to the point where the US has enough Purple Heart medals created (in anticipation of the casualties am invasion would involve) that they didn't have to restart production until 2008. As horrifying as it is, the first atomic bomb was considered the lesser evil. That said, Nagasaki is much much harder to defend.

Unrelated, but I recommend everyone who can to visit Hiroshima and visit the museums there. Hopefully it will instill in everyone a fervent desire to never again see such horrific things enacted again.

codewench··on Why the CrowdStrike bug hit banks hard
That's pretty much what Microsoft tried with the UAC prompts, and that was fairly universally disliked. Not that I disagree with you, running as admin by default is a terrible practice, but it's a tough sell to the general public
codewench··on Give Me the Green Light Part 1: Hacking Traffic Control Systems
SNMP stands for Simple Network Management Protocol, and is a way to directly address not just individual hardware elements, but to access specific functions or methods within that device via a "simple" addressing scheme. A MIB file describes the various endpoints available on a device, much like a wsdl file would describe a SOAP endpoint.

So you might have an SNMP address like 2.1.4.3.0.1* which the MIB file would translate to "the current temp for CPU1"

codewench··on MTV news website goes dark, archives pulled offline
The logical decision then is to entrust the preservation to once of the few organizations capable of surviving thousands of years, and forming a religion based on the preservation of works.
codewench··on The tiny chip that powers Montreal subway tickets
Taipei has single use NFC tokens that people can buy, but they are non-disposable. Instead, they are coin shaped, and are deposited in the ticket machine at the end of the trip so they can be re-used.
codewench··on EA CEO: "Real hunger" among developers to use AI to speed up development
>AI reduces the need for low skill humans

Except the focus on AI has been replacing _high_ skill jobs like artists, writers, and developers. The end-goal of AI devotees is that humans will dig the ditches, and AI will do all the 'fun stuff'.

It's not a great plan, but they seem really gung-ho about it.

codewench··on The question that no LLM can answer and why it is important
> I don't think we have the correct word for what LLMs do but lie and hallucinations are not really correct.

I believe 'bullshit' is accurate, as in "The chatbot didn't know the answer, so it started bullshitting".

codewench··on How to Escape from the Iron Age?
Wootz (and Damascus) steels for example were of much higher quality than what was usually produced in Europe. I can't say if this is what gave European smiths the knowledge they needed to create their own quality steels, or if it was a case of parallel invention, but for a time Asia was producing much better stuff.
codewench··on The United States has its first large offshore wind farm, with more to come
Also previous attempts[0] have been bogged down in endless red tape by groups against the creation of such projects.

[0] see for example the Cape Wind project: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cape_Wind

codewench··on Reddit's long, rocky road to an IPO
I don't have any inside knowledge, but I believe it was a mix of wanting to simplify things for users, and to keep users within their system.

I suspect that the rise of imgur as it's own community was seen as a threat, or at least competition, and the question "why are we basically helping our competitors" was asked at least once.

codewench··on Reddit's long, rocky road to an IPO
Imgur for example was created by a reddit user specifically for hosting content posted on reddit.

The move to reddit itself hosting content came much later

codewench··on Experienced engineers are struggling to get hired
They are fairly entrenched in their approach, which has been good for individual developers for sure, but has (in my opinion) produced little of actually legitimate societal value.
codewench··on Giant 'sand battery' holds a week's heat for a whole town
Another concern is losses. Water can evaporate, can leak, and tends to corrode fittings.

Sand? If some spills just grab a skid loader and stuff it back in.

codewench··on Yishan Wong: "Google's Gemini issue is not about woke/DEI"
To be fair, that is at least consistent with Google's past history
Page 1 of 2Next →