HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

staunch

28,228 karma · joined February 20, 2007

I love you and thank you.
submissionscomments
staunch··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
In fact, the average person in Silicon Valley is as clueless as you are about Steve Jobs and would agree he was merely a good salesperson.

But people that know what it takes to build great products almost universally respect his world-class design and leadership, and even his deep technical knowledge.

staunch··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
The fools are the people who express more hatred for Steve Jobs than cigarette, oil, and pharma CEOs that irreparably injury and kill millions of humans simple because of his obnoxious methods of demanding the best from his highly privileged teammates.

Standards are important. So is perspective.

staunch··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
Woz in this case was acting as a subcontractor, doing a one-off favor for a friend. This was before they became partners when creating Apple.
staunch··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
Things are always more complicated than this...

As a rule, Apple gave stock to employees prior to the IPO, many of whom got rich. But some employees weren't eligible according to the criteria Steve (really, the board) came up with, and so they did not receive stock. Their criteria were typical for the time.

Woz and a few others felt bad about this and shared some of their stock.

Whether those ineligible people "deserved" stock is a matter of judgement...

staunch··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
Steve Jobs gave Woz half of the base amount, which is what Woz agreed to. Jobs withheld the fact that he was going to receive a bonus on top of the base amount, and did not share any of that money.

Was it an ethical mistake? Sure. He should have at least disclosed that he was receiving the bonus money, even if he didn't want to share it.

But claiming it was a "major ethical mistake" seems fairly out of touch with reality.

And of course, taken in the context of all of the good things they did together, it was completely insignificant and Woz has said as much.

staunch··on Sam Altman is showing us who he really is
Steve Jobs was a superficial asshole but was fundamentally a good and ethical person. There's only one major ethical mistake documented in his entire life (being an absentee father while his first daughter was young), which he spent decades making amends for.

The people that emulate Steve Jobs poorly are usually real assholes with a long list of ethical mistakes.

staunch··on Steve Wozniak: When I die these are the moments I want to remember
Woz was a great engineer. He was years ahead of any other engineer on the planet in terms of building awesome PC designs. Millions of the computers he designed and programmed were sold, for billions of dollars. The computer he created was the "Model T" of the personal computer industry. It's hard to be more technically accomplished as an engineer.

He could not have done it without Steve Jobs. But Steve Jobs could not have done it without him, either.

Steve Jobs was a major believer in the idea of the 100x engineer. During his entire career, he always tried to hire them.

And why did Steve Jobs believe in hiring 100x engineers? Because he knew and worked with Steve Wozniak.

staunch··on S3 is files, but not a filesystem
> Believe the hype.

I'd rather believe the test results.

Is there a neutral third-party that has validated S3's durability/integrity/consistency? Something as rigorous as Jepsen?

It'd be really neat if someone compared all the S3 compatible cloud storage systems in a really rigorous way. I'm sure we'd discover that there are huge scary problems. Or maybe someone already has?

staunch··on Julius Caesar's Year of Confusion
Update: seems like it was already ~2 months out of sync when Caesar went to Gaul, so this is basically incorrect?
staunch··on Julius Caesar's Year of Confusion
Caesar procrastinated so hard he changed time itself!

(This is funny, but I'd be interested to read a source on how true this is. Presumably there were priests that could take care of such things. He took care of lots of other Roman business while he was in Gaul.)

staunch··on Larry Ellison: Oracle Database 1,000x Faster Than AWS Aurora
It would be unsurprising to find that Oracle's MySQL cloud service is 1000x faster than AWS Aurora for some specific things, or maybe even entire classes of problems.

It would be equally unsurprising if Aurora is 1000x faster for other classes of problems.

staunch··on Larry Ellison: Oracle Database 1,000x Faster Than AWS Aurora
That's a very misleading set of partial quotes to assemble in that order...

Ellison wasn't confused about any of the technical topics around cloud computing. He was complaining about the marketing trend at the time of slapping the "cloud computing" buzzword on all kinds of things that already existed.

This is a thing that happens in the tech world a lot, and it is pretty annoying. A more modern example is the over-use of "serverless" buzzword.

staunch··on The tiny corp raised $5.1M
I agree the DGXA100 is a "complete solution" because it's NVIDIA selling NVIDIA customized integrated/certified/tested/supported hardware and software.

NVIDIA's advantage is that they're a proprietary company and they're the ones actually making the chips they're putting in a box.

That's very far away from a random little open source startup slapping third-party GPUs in a generic box.

staunch··on The tiny corp raised $5.1M
I like George's style and wish him well. But I'm not optimistic about their chances of selling $15k servers that are $10k in parts (or whatever the exact numbers are).

It's just too easy for anyone to throw together a Supermicro machine with 6x GPUs in it, which is what it sounds like they'll be doing.

My guess is they'll end up creating some premium extensions to the software and selling that to make money. Or maybe they can sell an enterprise cluster manager type thing that comes with support. He's good at software so it makes sense for him to sell software.

And maybe the box will sell well initially just as a "dev kit" type thing.

staunch··on Tech companies keep falling for the forever fallacy
In the great tradition of correcting someone only to be corrected ;-)

> ... strictly monotonic growth ...

Their growth is hardly "strictly monotonic" since their growth can fluctuate up and down, as can their subscriber count.

staunch··on US Air Force shoots down drone swarm with THOR microwave weapon
> Because a test that doesn't test "what happens when the enemy knows the weaknesses" is not a test.

Sure it is, if the opponent can't deploy effective counter-measures.

It doesn't matter if a protected drone is possible what matters is whether or not the opponent is capable of actually deploying protected drones. In a cat-and-mouse game all that is important is having an advantage for some period of time. It's not necessary to have the advantage persist indefinitely.

See: Russia's military being battered by very old technology every day in Ukraine, where in many cases counter-measures are well known but unavailable.

staunch··on What was the impact of Julius Caesar’s murder?
> Show me a serious battle in Italy or a battle in Rome that resulted in serious destruction as a result of Caesar's civil war.

The people fighting in Spain, Greece, and Africa were largely Italian Romans or non-Italian Romans or allies. Caesar and Pompey were Italian Romans. It was in every way a civil war of Romans. What difference does it make that, for logistical reasons, the battles took place outside of Italy proper?

> It was a handful of battles and sieges. It's nothing compared to other campaigns.

Greece was the hardest campaign of Caesar's life. For the first time, he was fighting a complete military peer that had more resources, more soldiers, and more money. Pompey even had important Gallic leaders and Caesar's #2 (Labienus) leading a much larger cavalry force. Pompey's army matched and beat Caesar's in siege warfare.

Caesar almost lost multiple times and was beaten and in retreat when he turned around to fight and win at Pharsalus. Had Pompey avoided a full scale engagement, it's very likely that he would have won.

staunch··on What was the impact of Julius Caesar’s murder?
> The Roman Republic was dead when Caesar won the civil war

The Republic had been in trouble for a long time. IMHO it officially died as soon as the First Triumvirate was created. Rome was in complete control of just three people for many years.

Pompey was the leading figure of the First Triumvirate, so arguably he deserves more blame than even Caesar for the downfall. The fact that more senators chose him over Caesar says very little about how truly republican any of them were by that point.

The war between Caesar's party and Pompey's party was really just a battle for who would be Dictator for life. Neither of them had any intention of handing real power back, because they could honestly tell themselves it was unlikely to fall into any better hands.

Had he won, Pompey would have continued to (through military threats) control the Senate the same way he had for many years prior to the civil war.

staunch··on What was the impact of Julius Caesar’s murder?
> Julius Caesar's civil war with Pompey was neither long nor protracted...

Compared to what? It was nearly two years just for the portion with Pompey.

> .. and never actually involved the populus of Italy, let alone Rome.

Of course it did involve a great many people from Italy and a great many Romans.

> Pompey's Macedonian strategy ultimately failed as soon as it was contested.

It failed after very nearly succeeding multiple times and after months of skirmishes, sieges, storming of cities, back-and-forth trench warfare on huge scale, and marches with counter-marches. It was a slugfest between the largest and most modern forces of the day.

staunch··on Investors conclude that Tesla is a carmaker, not a tech firm
> The difference seems to be that Tesla was 5-10 years ahead on everything...

This is pretty much the definition of a great tech product: it's ahead of anything else by N years. What makes a great technology company is that they manage to consistently maintain that lead with product after product.

We'll see if Tesla can maintain its lead. It's not looking good and it probably depends mostly on whether or not Elon Musk can regain his grip on reality.

staunch··on “My PGP key is compromised, and at least many of my bitcoins stolen”
Yes, the ledger is public, but good luck identifying which transfers are bribes paid to informants within your government. This is same problem any foreign government would have.
staunch··on “My PGP key is compromised, and at least many of my bitcoins stolen”
> ...a black ops funding scheme...

More specifically, a scheme to enable transferring funds in/out of foreign countries to securely bribe informants and supply agents with money.

It's the logical companion to Tor, which was created by the U.S. government to facilitate secure information transfer in/out of foreign countries. But when they created Bitcoin, they decided to make it anonymous after the mistake of doing Tor in the open.

Maybe...

staunch··on A search engine for searching books in the Z-Library index on the IPFS network
I'm looking forward to some new AI system making it possible to generate high quality audiobooks from epub files.

This "AI book reader" doesn't exist yet, right?

staunch··on Ask HN: Risk of unsafe software in automobiles?
1. Cars have had computers in them for a very long time now.

2. The code, in many cases, is probably an unmaintainable mess. Embedded programming is not always modern programming, for good and bad.

3. Today, the computers in cars are doing more, and the systems are more complex. It's reasonable to expect more serious problems as a result.

4. Companies do safety testing, of course, but there's no such thing as as "100%" test coverage for complex physical machines running outside of a lab.

5. The best way to judge the safety of cars is the best way to judge safety for airplanes: let other people test them out for a while and then check whether or not they report problems.

staunch··on Ask HN: What would you learn if you would have three to six months free time?
It's hard to justify spending lots of time learning fundamentals while working on real projects. The kinds of things taught in college.

So, assuming one is a programmer, whatever one's weakest areas are: math, algorithms, assembly, operating systems (Linux), networking, distributed systems, electronics, machine learning, etc.

Or if one is already really solid in all fundamentals, and lacking more practical expertise, then a modern popular programming language like TS/JS, Go, Rust.

Or if you just want to learn for fun, I'd read recommend reading a lot of biographies of historical figures. And/or learning a foreign language.

And of course, learning how to cook your own food, exercise your body, and sleep well are probably more important than anything else you could possibly do for yourself.

staunch··on The Fermi paradox revisited: Technosignatures and the contact era
My pet theory (which I'm sure is not original) is that absolutely all intelligent life, through AGI and/or genetic engineering, eventually converges into an undifferentiated super intelligent state.

These super intelligences continuously decide, for one reason or another (but always the same reason(s)), not to expand their presence into the universe in an invasive way.

Maybe it would simply be unnecessary for them to do so, or maybe they consider it unethical, or maybe they do it but in a way that is undetectable to non-super intelligences.

staunch··on John Carmack Leaves Meta
Nothing could be a stronger indictment of Mark Zuckerberg's ability to lead teams and create innovative products than the fact that he wasn't able to utilize John fucking Carmack properly.

Even with all the money in the world, Zuckerberg is just too conventional, uncreative, and lacking in genuine enthusiasm. He's been totally unable to create the kind of esprit de corps present in every great team.

He cloned and acquired his entire career and it's made him weak. He was never forced to actually get good.

What inspiration there is at Meta today was brought there by Palmer Luckey and John Carmack years ago. And, since it can't be cloned or bought by Zuckerberg, it has simply dwindled away year by year.

The upside is that Oculus launched the VR industery. And now it's just a matter of time until VR evolves from a toy to a powerful tool. Maybe Meta will eventually make it happen, they certainly have the money, but more likely Apple or a startup will give it The Big Push.

staunch··on JFK Assassination Records – 2022 Additional Documents Release
The JFK assassination, and other historical events, seem like they could be such great applications for the kind of AI systems we have now. It really seems as if something like ChatGPT could "read" every document related to the JFK assassination and put together the pieces for us.

I'm already convinced it was some combination of anti-Castro Cubans, Italian-American mafia, and members of the CIA that were involved in a conspiracy to kill JFK. That seems pretty clear just from reading the Wikipedia pages, but I'd love to have an AI system assemble the full story in detail. There's a lot of unanswered questions, like how far up the chain did things go. Who was involved in the cover up, and much more.

At the very least, we probably need a system that is trained on just the raw source material so that it is not biased by all the existing theories.

staunch··on No, Google did not hike the price of a .dev domain from $12 to $850
It's worth considering the fact that this being a "premium domain" is the only reason it was even available register in the first place. If it had been a $12/year domain, some annoying domainer would have snatched it up on the first day it was available.

Premium domains really do seem to be a win-win for registries and regular buyers.

staunch··on The extraordinary shelf life of the deep sea sandwiches
FYI: anyone eating wild apples should take care to avoid "beach apples" cause they're highly toxic.

https://www.google.com/search?q=beach+apple&source=lnms&tbm=...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchineel

Page 1 of 34Next →