HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sideshowb

2,415 karma · joined November 21, 2014

submissionscomments
sideshowb··on ArXiv receives $10M for upgrades
At a higher level of abstraction, arxiv is an attempt to fix problems with the review process. Attempting to fix more problems with the review process would.... Etc
sideshowb··on ArXiv receives $10M for upgrades
I wonder if they could use some of it to make an experimental post-publication review system. I'm not sure what the future of peer review is, but I doubt it would hurt for them to try.
sideshowb··on Meta is banning people from advertising after running ads for Python and Pandas
Or they could, you know, spend some of their billions on employing humans to review these cases.
sideshowb··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
> The entire notion of any sort of property tax is also predicated on the idea that individual land ownership is a tradeoff between the interest of the individual and society at large.

Indeed, and I like this concept, I don't think we should ever "own" land in the same way as I own, say, my phone. All we ever do is borrow it from society (or even nature).

However, some aspects of land ownership are a net positive for society at large. In particular, the incentive to look after it better if it's really yours until you sell it or you die. With this in mind I like some proposals I've heard whereby unpaid land value tax can be accrued to be paid at death or on sale. That way the stewardship aspect of ownership is reinforced without the freeloading on land value increases.

Returning to the valuation question. I think you're assuming an efficient market when it clearly isn't one. It would be like having to reapply for your own job, except it's rebidding for your own house. Not a kind thing to do to anyone.

sideshowb··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
So you want people to bid for their own homes? Glad you're not dictator mate
sideshowb··on Detroit wants to be the first big American city to tax land value
Given the friction (inconvenience) in having to move house/business etc, that hardly seems fair. It also defeats the object of land ownership if you can be kicked off it at any time.
sideshowb··on MemGPT – LLMs with self-editing memory for unbounded context
Does anyone else find that self editing a linear memory evokes images of the theoretical Turing machine with its infinite tape?
sideshowb··on Ask HN: For those trying to hire how hard is it to find people currently?
This mostly sounds good but I wonder if you'd make it better by dropping the strict postgres requirements.

I've never used postgres. I've worked with umpteen technologies over the years, including lots of gis, just never needed to use postgres yet. But I know it's out there and I'm confident if I needed to, it wouldn't take more than a few days to catch up.

Not a dig at you specifically but a lot of companies seem to look for specific tech experience rather than a track record of just learning whatever tech is needed.

sideshowb··on Ask HN: Which (if any) computing device for a 6 year old?
Ice cream for 3 meals a day, obviously.
sideshowb··on Ask HN: Which (if any) computing device for a 6 year old?
Thanks. You got me thinking back to when I started programming. Realised it wasn't until 9 or so. There's no rush is there.
sideshowb··on Ask HN: Which (if any) computing device for a 6 year old?
Nah mate. Following discussion of the above, we are now going with an iNothingAtAll for the time being ;-)
sideshowb··on AI beats human sleuth at finding problematic images in research papers
The article seems to discuss manipulation (a valid concern) but the research focuses on duplication. I'm not entirely clear what the link between the two is?
sideshowb··on Prophetic Perfect Tense
You should start a Wikipedia page for misidentified tense.
sideshowb··on Working remotely can more than halve an office employee’s carbon footprint
Down votes are being used reddit style, I see. I'd love to know what the disagreement is exactly?
sideshowb··on Working remotely can more than halve an office employee’s carbon footprint
These issues are key. Thanks for raising them.

In some recent transport modelling work we decided there wasn't yet enough evidence about wfh, specifically because people may move further from the office. If this study fills some gaps, it's good work.

...edit: ok so it doesn't address causality. Alas. We need a study following a cohort for a few years after wfh became available, vs another cohort denied wfh.

sideshowb··on PeerReview4All: Fair and accurate reviewer assignment in peer review
On arxiv, of all places ;-)
sideshowb··on Tidal energy is not renewable
All this doom and gloom, I say let's go for it though, most of us would benefit from a few extra hours in the day right? We can switch off the tidal power once it gets to 26 hours or so ;-)
sideshowb··on Historians have an increasingly strong incentive to tell dramatic stories
I often think the same, in fact in my todo list is (in the background) think of more ways to reduce the bureaucracy I face on a daily basis, which takes many forms - from arguing with reviewer #2 over whether or not my finding is notable, to trying to convince a panel that my idea is worth funding.

From a system design perspective, alas resources are limited and have to be allocated somehow, and in the absence of any metrics at all as you suggest, it would ultimately come back to who can tell the better story about their work. This is still at best only weakly correlated with the actual quality of the work.

And so we run up against https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Pournelle's_ir...

The situation could definitely be better than the current one, but alas I don't have any magic solution.

sideshowb··on Neutrons prove ‘Bond villain’ did not cause Arecibo telescope collapse
Isn't the modern consensus that Sean Bean being cast to play a character carries that information implicitly?
sideshowb··on A search for technosignatures around nearby stars
Iirc if you get close enough to a black hole for time dilation to be substantial, then things are going to be pretty inhospitable in other ways. We couldn't survive the gravitational field gradient, for example. Strong imagination required to imagine aliens that would cope with it.
sideshowb··on What learning APL taught me about Python
This. Ideally we'd have jitted python loops be efficient. I love array syntax for simple examples but for more complex ops a loop is often clearer.
sideshowb··on The anesthetic effect of air at atmospheric pressure
Fair. My appropriate point of comparison (if I wasn't currently nitrogen drunk) should in fact have been mountains <1000m. Which I also love, but they don't have that clear headed altitude feeling.
sideshowb··on The anesthetic effect of air at atmospheric pressure
Probably not in my case, haven't measured co2 but I am lucky to live in a small village.
sideshowb··on The anesthetic effect of air at atmospheric pressure
Anecdotally, as a mountaineer, I love the effect of a little less atmospheric pressure.

Not loads less, above 3000m it starts getting inconvenient. But 1000-2000m my mind feels more clear and focused than at sea level.

I wonder if this is related?

sideshowb··on Paris to bring back swimming in Seine after 100 years
Meanwhile in the UK https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-57947635
sideshowb··on Scientists hit with massive bills after speaking at COVID-19 ‘webinars’
In the UK I suspect it would qualify as unfair terms (ianal)
sideshowb··on The best place to drink is the emptiest bar in the city
Well I don't know New York but in a proper pub they will be fine with whatever trousers and shoes you have. For that matter I once walked into a country pub (not one where they know me) in only wet swimming trunks and we persuaded them to serve us on credit.
sideshowb··on The best place to drink is the emptiest bar in the city
Interesting perspective!

On a light note, ... You don't own any pants or shoes at all?

sideshowb··on Stackoverflow is investing into baking GenAI
Closed as duplicate of "how do I do that using X" even though on close inspection that!=this
sideshowb··on Why does nuclear power plant construction cost so much?
I wonder whether this time round the price will be high enough to actually change anything.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →