128,989 karma · joined December 29, 2010
I think these jobs are actually the most likely to be replaced by AI. They have resisted automation to date because there's too much fuzz in the inputs/outputs to make it feasible to computerize. LLMs solve exactly that problem.
This is exactly why everything like Disney has moved upmarket, with pricing rising far above inflation.
The NYT touched on this issue in a podcast about NAFTA: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/08/podcasts/the-daily/americ.... AI is going to be NAFTA on steroids. Politicians will be able to point to growing top-like GDP to say it was a good thing. But it’s going to brutally hit a lot of people and most of those folks will never regain a secure economic footing.
So the question is is the chat bot better than people trying to understand complicated government websites by themselves?
You have to measure that problem against the status quo, which is that current government websites are very hard to understand and leave people with very little idea of what’s going on.
Or are you disagreeing that violence is necessary to maintain civilization. Why do you think literally every country has police and an army?