1,249 karma · joined January 5, 2008
TLDW: He wants to open source the ranking algos and make the history of each posts ranking transparent.
One big problem that never seems to be discussed when talking about the PTAB and IPRs is the collateral damage it causes for small business and small inventors. The big tech companies lobbied to set the rules in their favor. "Patent Trolls" are not the problem they are a symptom of a different more fundamental problem. If you are a small business owner or small inventor the patent system is to expensive for you to use on an even footing with large companies, so you can be put into a situation where you have to work with a "patent troll" just to have the legal resources to play the game. By the way my company built it's own factory to build our products in the USA. We have since had to close our factory down and let all our employees go becuase we have been unable to protect the unique IP of our product, I know of at least 100 companies using the IP we created, and have 3 patents coveeing. As a small business entrepreneur the patent system and the IPR/ptab system has utterly failed me so far.
Edited for spelling.
Here is an article on why they are dangerous if you want to know more... https://www.cbsnews.com/news/grill-barbecue-metal-brush-dang...
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u23Hqq8QbeE
And article about students involved...
http://eng.umd.edu/news/story/maple-seeds-inspire-robotic-fl...
http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/a21181/greatest-a...
http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2016/06/26/cuozzo-ipr-death-americ...
and one in particular that explains how Lee's management of USPTO policy has hurt small business patent owners...
"The AIA also allows the Director discretion to stop harassment of patent owners, but Lee has never once used that power despite the fact that at least several patent owners have had seven or eight inter partes review challenges filed against the same patent. The PTAB itself has finally started to consider harassment as grounds to refuse to institute. So bad and lopsided are the PTAB proceedings, that the Federal Circuit has found PTAB decisions to be arbitrary and capricious, and with respect to covered business method (CBM) challenges, the Federal Circuit has slammed the PTAB for creating its own definition and standard while ignoring the statute and regulations. So if Lee was referring to the PTAB and post grant challenges the most honest assessment is that the Office has utterly and completely failed patent owners and the patent system."
http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/02/02/michelle-lees-patent-qu...
Anecdotally as a man any time I am in a group that has a majority of woman the men get talked over by the woman all the time. I grew up in a family that was a majority woman and the same thing happened all the time, I would say generally in social settings where one sex has the majority they tend to talk over the opposite sex and control the conversation. It is human nature. However we can and should be better then that but it is hard.
For example, say you as a small time inventor have a valid patent on some great new widget. Big company X starts selling the widget you invented, you approach them and ask if they would license your patent, Big company X can afford to keep filing IPR's against your patent and it will cost you ~$200,000 each time. Big company X can milk you dry and draw things out for years so it becomes much more difficult as a small business to defend and license your patent. Lee seems to have really helped large tech companies at the expense of small inventors.
Reference: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_law_of_prohibition
"An October 2014 report from the Department of Energy’s Office of Inspector General points to a change in the packaging procedure at LANL that specified organic cat litter, when an inorganic sorbent was likely intended. Investigators traced a series of internal communications in which the specifications for “kitty litter/zeolite clay” were transformed into “kitty litter (clay),” the report says. Combined with inadequate technical review, this resulted in LANL workers filling waste containers with a mixture of nitrate salts and sWheat Scoop, a cat litter that is 100% wheat, according to its manufacturer. “It would have been much clearer if they had said an inorganic zeolite sorbent,” Hobbs says. “It’s been a very expensive mistake, costing at least half a billion dollars.”
High-End VR: Gaming and graphic intensive applications will run on computers wired to special HMD systems. Vive, Oculus and PSVR
Smartphone VR: This will be the GearVR type experience, dedicated VR appstore of content.
Casual VR: Google Cardboard type devices used for viewing 360 photos and video,download content from existing Play store and Apples App Store.
full disclosure we are making and selling things in the casual VR category (https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/smartvr-make-your-phone-a...)
http://www.mlive.com/business/west-michigan/index.ssf/2015/0...
I had no idea lyft was losing 3x the their revenue. That is crazy.