HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

phwd

2,489 karma · joined September 9, 2010

submissionscomments
phwd··on Facebook enters the age of accidental oversharing
500 friends inclusive of acquaintances, co-workers, relatives, classmates from high school, classmates from university. It makes no sense being all semantic about it; Facebook "friends" are different from what a person would call a friend in reality, hence the new categorization, subscriptions and smart list options given.
phwd··on Facebook enters the age of accidental oversharing
This is partly the fault of the user (yes, there is a dialog that says what exactly is going to happen, so the ignorance is there no matter how much you think the user is clueless) and mostly the fault of Facebook partners. Facebook partners and web companies with close relationships with Facebook get access to the Open Graph actions first (Spotify was in this group).

Thus, less experienced developers and lesser known companies follow the path these companies take and believe that this is how the Open Graph should be. There are many questions on Stack Overflow or the Facebook developers group from people inexperienced asking how to make articles automatically read when users arrive at their site (the news.read action).

phwd··on Startup logo design
What's the difference between "startup logo design" and "logo design"? Just call it logo design.
phwd··on Make Your Email Hacker Proof
> Hey, This Sounds Like a Pain!

Yes, because it is a pain. Try going on a vacation, you know the one where you don't use cell roaming. SMS is out, so then one must find a Wifi hotspot to use one of the smartphone time based tokens (edit: seems the token don't need a network connection, could have fooled me). And those time based tokens go out of wack if your phone didn't sync the timezone properly to match Google's setup, so every token ends up not working.

Use the print out backup verification codes on a piece of paper? No, because they are single use. So you end up using up all your backup codes depending on the length of your vacation. I've used 2 step for a long while, I liked it, but I really could not get used to whipping out my phone every time I needed to check something related to Google.

I've had other hiccups such as mobile provider down, phone died etc. Maybe my best option was to keep all the backup codes on hard plastic with checkmarks next to used backup codes and secure them the same way I do my banking cards, maybe, I'll just try this one day.

If one is going to jump through all these spy-style codes might as well just change your password on a regular basis, forcing all previous sessions to invalidate.

phwd··on Tupac image performs at Coachella [video]
Just because you don't like rap doesn't mean your snark is wanted.
phwd··on The Horror of setting up a Google+ account for my mom
I once thought this but not again. Your family, at least the elders, would more appreciate that you pick up the phone or send postal mail than use technology.

You think it's a big part but you are in fact making that personal connection weaker.

At the very most in the world technology, email would suffice for your family.

phwd··on Quora’s Demise
Ah, now how does one find the sweet spot between this and say Stack Exchange? Many times, I have heard users complain about the barrier for Stack Exchange and overzealous moderators. There is not really a way to please everyone.

I never really understood how moderation works on Quora so I assumed there was none. Not to say that I hate Quora (I like it a lot), I just feel there is nothing preventing it from becoming Yahoo Answers in a couple years time. No barrier, no moderation.

phwd··on RIM to support iPhones, Androids; opens up its secure network
It wasn't really what I was hoping for but it's a start. My expectations are for BlackBerry to open their BBM network for other companies.
phwd··on Simple - An Obtvse clone written in Python
Nice work with the Python style, though I believe Simple and Obtvse missed the point as with every clone of something out there that tries to replicate what they could see on the outside. Skipping over Dustin's attitude of the situation, no one really knows how Svbtle.com works on the inside do they?

From the outside look and the screenshots (because that's all Dustin showed you) it's a simple design and that's the point; it was never supposed to be a complex work of design for you to be proud that you could replicate it in 1 day in rails. Yeah, Dustin put some work into thinking what could work for the layout but once the application of the design is done, replication is beyond simple.

Clone all you want I think it's great but Dustin was really telling the story of the "network" the idea of a closely knit community of writers (pseudo-writers whichever you prefer). I look at it as similar to the Deck Ad network or Dribbble (before every desperate Designer begged for an invite). Or when an HN clone comes along, no one ever migrates across, they always come back here.

Point is, the one thing you are never going to have is the network, that human element that sets apart the clone from the real deal.

phwd··on Apology from Geeklist
Well if you believe, it is not possible to resolve something(not specifically this issue)/anything/at all without calling it "fucking disgusting" such that each/and every situation with getting customer support from a company (must) turn into a PR shit show for public study and discussion about how bad the company handled it, further giving bad examples to others that it is okay to throw tantrums/offensive statements to get support, from companies recycling the vicious cycle, then yes you are by all means right, there's really nothing about this situation for you or I to discuss productively.

Other than that the apology wasn't well played out. That's a given.

phwd··on Apology from Geeklist
I guess this is how it should be done yes?

Be humble, always give apologies no matter how offensive the messenger/complainer/customer?

Unfortunately, not every one has this skill and I hope some will realize that at some point you cannot give in.

Geeklist is the villain for giving in and letting it slide downhill (it is always a PR disaster after it hits the fan) but Kane was first to throw the rock. You don't win the argument by showing how angry you can be, you win it by being the most civilized and logical about it. This isn't a "Lighten Up" situation, this is a mind your tone and I can understand the serious nature of the issue without it.

phwd··on Show HN: Meme generator for hipsters
That is indeed what I did, there is no source shown here http://www.pinwords.com/pins/e68d21f0720b11e1aaccfd54b73b70c.... Try it http://www.thesartorialist.com/photos/on-the-street-somewher...

> The page at www.pinwords.com says: Not a valid image.

Which to me, means it's either not able to scan the page for images or only accepts direct links to images.

phwd··on Show HN: Meme generator for hipsters
Could someone explain how the original content source is kept?

Seeing that you cannot link to a page but must hot-link to the image then I am failing to see how the source is kept.

For example, here is a regular pin for http://www.thesartorialist.com/photos/on-the-street-somewher..., http://pinterest.com/pin/189151253069642005/. The content is shown as coming from thesartorialist.com

Now trying with pinwords.com, I must upload the direct image (which makes sense, how else would it work to mark up the image) which results as http://pinterest.com/pin/189151253069642015/ The content is shown as coming from thesartorialist.com The content is shown as coming from pinwords.com. Though going into the original pin at pinwords there is no mention of thesartorialist.com in site.

I understand these are how previous bookmarklets have worked for other apps, yet I hate this so much. Not only does it make easier for users to mark up content they may or may not own, it makes it harder for Pinterest to remain mostly true about keeping content creators (the ones who actually produce the content) copyright concerns in mind.

phwd··on Download any SoundCloud song
Does it work for Chrome (using 17.0.963.65 Mac)? Using It seems to just break the individual song page and does not affect songs within the /dashboard. 1-2 of the reviews seem to share my experience. I have it queued up as answer to a question a user had here

http://webapps.stackexchange.com/questions/20868/hide-commen...

phwd··on Call yourself a 'brogrammer'? Then get the hell away from me.
There are two things that needs to be defined here (Well three if you include how media never portrays the story as it was interviewed, media always searches for the dramatical pitch [1])

The first is that of the Brogramming meme. The definition at Urban Dictionary is a joke in itself. It's a joke accept it, don't accept it. No developer in their right mind goes around proclaiming that they are a brogrammer and if they are saying that they are serious (like some say in the case of Facebook and Zynga) you are being deceived [2].

There is a second definition which that I think everyone clumps with this meme and that is of the asshole/douchebag/sexist employee. He is everywhere. Not just in software development. These individuals are the ones making the majority of sexist comments, makes sexist jokes while a female employee is in a cubicle nearby, trying to hit on female coworkers during work hours and going to bars every night. They have existed long before any reference to Brogramming.

Now, I will say this. It was not smart of this individual to try advertise the meme to the SfGate readership. Just based on the prefix "bro" alone will bring about perception of sexism even if the original intent was not to be.

[1]: http://www.facebook.com/ariadoss/posts/305742279480205 [2]: http://www.facebook.com/getwiththebrogram/posts/373108606051...

phwd··on Commenting, community deterioration, and Hacker News
Maybe there should be a comment rate limit based on your avg score. The higher your avg score, the more comments within a certain time period you can make.

This depends on current data for avg karma vs rate of comments which is not publicly available (to my knowledge). This also depends on whether users with the highest avg score actually give great constructive comments but I have not been able to find a way to list those users -- http://webapps.stackexchange.com/questions/20612/list-users-...

phwd··on Hidden Features of Java
Maybe you could not have recreated the problem but you could have indeed described the symptoms and the problem statement. It's not written anywhere in the FAQ but SO places the subliminal message to write better, communicate better and research better. The more you do this, the more you understand your own problem and you will be able to reach your solution.

See: http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2011/02/how-to-write-withou...

Did some digging and found this

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/8449696/project-doesnt-re...

This doesn't look like something to point someone in the right direction. Yes, you are working with proprietary code but you could think of ways to describe what is happening without disclosing information otherwise you are making users play the 20 questions game with your question (as noted by a moderator). A high rep and top contributor to the site (Jon Skeet) was trying to help you but you didn't seem to want to reciprocate with more information. As I said earlier, clear communication is key in SO, don't make users point in the dark. You are wasting their time and yours with the back and forth clarifications.

phwd··on Hidden Features of Java
It becomes unmanageable. It's the bike shed problem. No one seems to want to edit or read the question for an answer that is a duplicate of what the user wants to say but everyone wants to put their fingerprint/mark on the question. Compare Hidden Features of Java with Hidden Features of C# where the community actively maintained the question into something that could be easily traversable (contents). So the harm in leaving the question open tells new users that it's okay to post questions like this since it has a high number of votes. But a high number votes neither proves or disproves the value of a question. At the onset it might but as popularity increases more votes are meaningless and it thusly turns into a popularity contest.

It would interesting to see how many users (who voted) actually paged through all 100 answers.

Take instead the Greatest Hits which do take into account data to determine value http://stackoverflow.com/questions/greatest-hits and you will notice none of these hidden features or list of x questions make the cut.

The argument used to keep them open is that they have value (which is why the notice was added), developers and moderators alike have said that they have gotten valuable information from these questions (Nick Craver, Joel Coehoorn, Bill the Lizard)

> This question exists because it has historical significance, but it is not considered a good, on-topic question for this site, so please do not use it as evidence that you can ask similar questions here.

As for the single binding vote made by a moderator this could have been a result of many flags made by users that he had to act on. SO moderators and to an extent SE moderators will always be called http://www.google.ca/search?q=%22overzealous+moderators%22+s... and that's something they just have to live with in order to keep StackOverflow a place that is different from a forum. SO emerged because of a need to get Q&A different from a forum. Elections (http://stackoverflow.com/election) are held every year to get moderators knowledgeable of the process and users the community trusts to make decisions the community might not normally. Most SO moderators never see the main site regularly and are stuck in the flag queue answering the community needs.

phwd··on What are the lesser known but cool data structures?
I don't seem to understand what you are saying. Answers and comments are transferred when a question is migrated. In all cases where users have a problem it is best to raise your issue on meta.stackoverflow.com or at least reference the question you are talking about above.
phwd··on What are the lesser known but cool data structures?
It will most likely never happen. Mods and the community have a hard time as it is maintaining a base standard of what defines a SE Q&A site. The point of StackExchange was to create sites that did not duplicate already existing discussion forums.

As communities grow they learn and change the scope and that's what has happened here.

The current list questions that are open are under close scrutiny by a few community members. For example http://stackoverflow.com/questions/194812/list-of-freely-ava... is cleaned regularly for duplicates, arranged by language and alphabetically sorted.

A site like the one you would wish for would be highly popular but no user would ever want to clean it up, instead they will add another duplicate answer that may have been mentioned 1-2 years earlier.

phwd··on Trouble in the House of Stackoverflow
Interesting, seeing that these /overzealous/ moderators do not actually browse the 2M+ questions. They respond to flags that are brought to their attention. Alot of these old questions are not bumped to the front page unless they get heavy traffic and when they do, new users take it upon themselves to answer the question. Thus resurfacing an old historic question which will be closed, but not deleted. The information is still there.

These are users flagging questions. Whether they are overzealous or not is a next question altogether. Moderators respond to flags not perfection. If 10 users flag a question as not constructive because of the new scope, then the moderators must listen to the community. The community at one time accepted these questions, now based on discussion in meta.stackoverflow.com , they don't. Communities change over time.

Also a flock of moderators cannot close a question. Ideally one. What you may have seen as a flock could be one of the following options

* 1 moderator (his/her vote is binding) * 1-4 users + 1 moderator (remember a moderator vote is binding) * 5 users

These users are ordinary community users not moderators. If their decision was wrong to close a question, it will be reopened by 5 other /regular/ users.

Additionally it would help to show these example questions that you feel were closed justly so that a /community/ user not a mod can tell you why it was closed or what chance it has to be opened.

So if you can reply with the question that was closed wrongly, maybe some of us /ordinary/ users can help you.

Otherwise I feel your accusations towards moderators are misdirected as most times these questions are closed by regular users just like you and me.

phwd··on Path just evolved with an entirely revamped product
This can work. Just based on the 150 friend cap. You are in a way forced to choose your most active, friends. Those that you actually engage with via in person, email, Facebook messages, Skype etc., on a daily basis.

There was an article floating around somewhere on the concept of having an application with only 7 or so friends and how would a user deal with this restriction. Path is in the right direction for this. Also as opposed to Facebook, since a normal user does not have "Life Events" every day, I like the fact that Path has the awake/sleep feature (no matter how trivial it sounds).

phwd··on How does SOPA threaten Stack Overflow?
Yes, system messages shouldn't be abused like this. They are supposed to be the exception not norm. Even though the message gets to the front of your attention on every single page, it would have been better if this was to be placed as a community ad or a blog post.

Seeing that this is directed to the US users of Stack Overflow, I am not sure what the rest of the world should be doing other than spreading the message.

To play devil's advocate, since SO has dumps of their data under CC, anyone from another country can still get the content.

The community and the system of asking and answering questions are threatened, the previous data will still be around.

phwd··on Arrgh Facebook is lying about me
Maybe I am wrong, but Dave you said you deleted your account. Are you sure that is your account, if it was shouldn't it resolve to your _username_ you chose?

> But when I went to my URL, or at least what I remember my URL to be:

> http://www.facebook.com/dave.winer

The account Ben showed doesn't seem to be yours.

http://graph.facebook.com/100002526165063 (no username showed here)

whereas

http://graph.facebook.com/dave.winer (false i.e. gone)

Unless Facebook releases usernames after deleting accounts (or you remember that this is indeed your Facebook ID) I think these are all different accounts. There is also another http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001554391855 which as well does not show your username.

phwd··on Apple Sucks At Social
Social networking (where I make the generalization within Google Plus, Twitter, Tumblr and Facebook) is saturated. I don't want to invite my friend to not-another-social-network. What is needed is refinements.

Apple being bad at social is okay with me.

phwd··on The Facebook Timeline is creepy as hell
True, that would be a great feature to have as I mentioned in another thread post, you can _at least_ set any public posts you made to friends only. In privacy settings > Limit the Audience for Past Posts http://cl.ly/AMpv
phwd··on The Facebook Timeline is creepy as hell
A "public" post versus a friends post[1]. And the option to switch any previously public posts to friends[2].

[1]: http://cl.ly/ANI0 [2]: http://cl.ly/AMpv

phwd··on The Facebook Timeline is creepy as hell
No actually it is memorialized and family members can request removal.

https://www.facebook.com/help/?faq=13941

phwd··on [dead]
Relevant to which part of the group exactly?

- Those who comment? (These are hopefully looking for good content/topic for which to discuss)

- Those who lurk? (It should not matter for this group, they will just skip over the topics if need be.)

- Those who up vote? (This group in terms of the front page will push it to top and may not necessarily even read the article)

Since the group is actually all of the above, then the long tail new users (1 year and less) [I am assuming it is a long tail, it would be great to have data to back this] will be dominant and no matter what you do once it massively popular (not necessarily on topic) it will remain on the front page.

My personal workaround is to assume the users who signed up earlier in HN maintain a certain scope and flag and vote as appropriate and roll with news.ycombinator.com/classic for the next few days until it dies down.

phwd··on [dead]
Never really understood how you can "ripoff" an idea. Technology or even design but an idea? I am not so sure. That is a problem, people need to stay clear from that notion. I agree with the cherry picking though, it would make sense. You are not going to turn a blind eye to the competition.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →