HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pedanticfreak

279 karma · joined August 3, 2010

submissionscomments
pedanticfreak··on Android Market Web Store just Launched
The Chrome Web Store looks like the native iTunes store. That is not a compliment.

Despite that it is still better looking than the Android Market Web Store. The best thing I can say about the Android Market is that it is remarkably fast.

pedanticfreak··on The case of the identical rabbit games
I find it incredible someone with enough expertise to build the project and get it on the Mac Store can be so clueless with regard to licensing.

Not only are they using unlicensed game assets, but it seems they are violating the GPL as well.

I suspect iCoder knew what it was doing all along.

pedanticfreak··on The Future of Cheap Androids Begins Now
Nevermind the cheap device. The $25 per month service that includes 300 minutes, unlimited text, and unlimited data is the real story here.

http://www.virginmobileusa.com/cell-phone-plans/beyond-talk-...

Of course, you get what you pay for in coverage

http://www.virginmobileusa.com/check-cell-phone-coverage

Meanwhile in Canada you can't even get unlimited data over wired internet.

pedanticfreak··on Amazon Previews Rival Streaming Service to Netflix
No more awkward than Apple using Samsung to fab its chips.
pedanticfreak··on Microsoft backs H.264.
http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/biz/2009/09/123_52401.h...

South Korea built vast infrastructure around IE6 and ActiveX. Just a year ago a full 60% of Korean traffic still came from IE6. Why? Because they relied heavily on features that were not in the spec that Microsoft deprecated and nobody else can or will implement.

An extreme example. But it highlights the importance of sticking to specs that can be freely implemented by anyone. Five years from now when MPEGLA decides to throw down the crap hammer do you want to have to keep around old Safari binaries just for sites that migrated to h264 while the rest of the web moved on?

pedanticfreak··on Microsoft backs H.264.
Until the W3C officially adopts a royalty free codec as part of the HTML standard, Google and Mozilla should assume HTML video is dead. They might as well make the <video> tag inoperable by default. Just parse it and ignore it.

Of course, Google owns VP8. So they are pushing it so it might become a defacto standard that later gets officially adopted. Despite meeting the requirements to be part of the HTML spec, without the official backing of the W3C it is no different than any other out of spec extension to HTML.

pedanticfreak··on Mozilla Chromeless: making desktop apps with web technologies
Is Mozilla intentionally trying to create market confusion? It isn't obvious from the name, but this is built on XULRunner and has no relation to Google Chrome.
pedanticfreak··on Gruber on iOS In-App Purchases
I'm not sure about the IRS, but I know for a fact non-profits have been in a bind with Apple for years for just that reason. Apple wants 30% of the donations. Or rather, Apple will not allow credit card transactions that do not go through in app purchase.

Every charity wants to arm its people with an iPad or send out a free iPhone app to collect donations. Ever notice how there aren't any?

pedanticfreak··on Gruber on iOS In-App Purchases
It's downright ridiculous if section 11.2 is applied universally. So does Apple get a cut of Cisco's WebEx contracts whenever a customer decides to fire up the free iOS app? Does Apple get a cut of OverDrive's contract to deliver eBooks and audio books to local libraries if someone downloads the iOS app? This doesn't even make sense.

Are Netflix and Hulu going to hand over 30% of their subscription fees to Apple if the user wants to fire up the service on an iOS device? Is that even feasible?

Are the Apple tax examiners going to look for login screens and reject apps based solely on that now?

No, probably not. It's probably just a cover for Apple to beat up on its competitors (Amazon, Barnes and Noble) and to let everyone else (Netflix, Hulu) get a free pass. Much like how Apple singled out Adobe yet allowed Appcelerator and UNITY to continue without pause.

pedanticfreak··on Microsoft’s Bing uses Google search results—and denies it
Why didn't Google's investigation go further? Why didn't they decompile the IE8 toolbar to figure out what it was really doing? Maybe that's against the DMCA and Google can't admit to it?

Having the evidence in code would have made the accusation irrefutable.

pedanticfreak··on Apple responds: we want a cut of Amazon, Sony e-book sales
My understanding is that Amazon was guaranteeing some publishers the same profit per sale that they would get from a hardback book in exchange for allowing Amazon to fix the price at $9.99. In some cases the profit was more than the $9.99 Amazon was charging so Amazon had to pony up $1 or $2 on each sale.

I think more recently Amazon has allowed publishers to use an alternative agency model that lets the publishers set their own prices and Amazon takes a fixed percentage cut of the sale. This doesn't cause Amazon to lose money, but now publishers can sell eBooks at nearly the same price as paper books which hurts the Kindle's attractiveness and slows adoption.

Regardless, this is an unworkable situation Apple has constructed. Amazon barely makes 30% of the sale price of each book if it even makes that much at all. It can hardly afford to give away its entire fee and then some to Apple.

This is either a strong arm attempt to get Amazon to agree to a strategic agreement for a fraction of the revenue or Apple is simply trying to destroy the Amazon Kindle app entirely. Either way Apple wins and Amazon loses. I suppose consumers can come out ahead if the strategic agreement allows in app purchasing of Kindle books for the same price, but it could also be bad if the iOS Kindle app disappears.

pedanticfreak··on Tired of Apple's rules? Build your own touchscreen handheld
Nexus S? Nexus One? Nokia N900? OpenMoko FreeRunner? OpenPandora?

There are more than a few more powerful alternatives to an iPhone that are open source and ready to hack. Most of them can even make phone calls.

pedanticfreak··on S.F. Yellow Pages ban to be considered
Let me know when they finally ban the pink plastic shopping bags from Chinatown.
pedanticfreak··on Apple responds: we want a cut of Amazon, Sony e-book sales
The point is the competition still lags, so Apple still has a free pass with users and developers. And if the competition suddenly caught up, Apple only needs pull back just enough to make us all forget.

Really, it's stunts like this that shows how much iOS leads the competition. Like electing a convicted murderer to public office because his competition is that incompetent. Android isn't forcing Apple to compete on its terms at all.

pedanticfreak··on Optimal Employment
There are other troubling inconsistencies as well. But I decided to stop there. I only want the author to go back and fix his numbers, I don't want to write the article for him.

Without a doubt, this whole thing is a poor abuse of statistics. It doesn't take a genius to figure out you can make $100,000 and keep a lot in the bank by living like someone who makes $30,000. Which, by the way, there are quite a few of those people in the United States.

pedanticfreak··on Apple responds: we want a cut of Amazon, Sony e-book sales
This reminds me of the "no intermediate code" snafu that was later repealed. Apple keeps testing the boundaries of what we will tolerate because it knows it can get away with it while the competition still lags behind.

This newest development sets a truly frightening precedent, though. Any subscription service that sees significant growth through their iOS app is vulnerable to Apple's tax collectors. As soon as it looks like you're making money, Apple can jump in and extort 30% of your gross revenue or sink your whole business. Granted, maybe you owe some thanks to Apple, but 30% can quickly turn a sustainable business into a bankrupt one.

Considering Amazon already loses money on each Kindle book sold, losing an extra 30% on top of that may not be a financially viable option. Apple is effectively trying to edge Amazon out of its marketplace.

pedanticfreak··on Optimal Employment
Something is wrong about the author's numbers here.

The Consumer Expenditure Survey the author cites says the 25-34 year old that spends 37.1% of their salary on housing is only making $58,946 per year, NOT $100,000 per year.

Whether intentional or not, the survey is being misrepresented to the benefit of the author's argument.

pedanticfreak··on Amazon leaks details of Netflix-compete, Free for prime members
At $79 per year, Amazon Prime is cheaper than Netflix streaming only (12 x $7.99 = $95.88 per year). And you get free 2-day shipping to boot.

It's an incredible value. Almost too good of a value actually. But that is what Amazon might just need to compete with the likes of Netflix. Much like the losses they have been taking on Kindle books, maybe they will start eating it on streaming video rentals, too.

pedanticfreak··on Poll: Where do you work (geographically)?
I agree. Since when was Great Lakes a region? Most people call it the Midwest.
pedanticfreak··on Facebook phone rumors resurface: cloud-based, HTC-built?
Why not? CES saw over 100 tablet launches, most of them Android based. Every big company should make their own Android spin. Even Disney has one:

http://www.engadget.com/2011/01/17/disney-to-sell-android-ph...

HTC, Foxconn, and Samsung will build it with your logo on the back; Google will provide the OS updates; and you just need to provide the value add like integration with a popular service whether that's Facebook, MTV, or Disney. Even Barnes and Noble was able to make a nice Android device with its own App Store.

Such a venture could easily pay for itself like Google's Chrome and Android projects did. It's a tough call. No matter what Facebook is reliant on Google and Apple for its mobile future. Then again the easiest path for Facebook (i.e. Android) also ties them even more closely to Google's whims.

pedanticfreak··on Pandora: Community driven linux based hardware project, actually shipping units.
OpenPandora had great promise. When they started it there was nothing more powerful. But now it's slower than even the most dated Android phones on the market.

600 mhz A8? We're in the 1.2ghz range right now. Two, three, and four core designs are about to be commonplace.

pedanticfreak··on Tim Cook Is Running Apple, but Not Imitating Steve Jobs
Institutional investors love predictability. But the company needs to be nimble and avoid making unnecessary commitments.
pedanticfreak··on The Most-Read Blogs By Venture Capitalists
What's with the alternating bolded lines in the list? It kind of makes the odd numbered names seem more important for no reason.
pedanticfreak··on Send to Kindle: any web page text, with one click, using Chrome browser.
Direct link: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/ipkfnchcgalnafehpg...
pedanticfreak··on The World's Happiest Countries
Empirically verifiable data is good and all, but this so-called prosperity index is just a perversion of statistics.
pedanticfreak··on Send to Kindle: any web page text, with one click, using Chrome browser.
Regardless of whether we should or shouldn't emulate the real, I still stand by my statement that swipes and taps are superior to the Kindle interface. Perhaps in your case despite rather than because that interaction is more like reading a physical book.
pedanticfreak··on The World's Happiest Countries
I find it interesting they make up a bunch of metrics which they claim are related to happiness rather than just asking people whether they are happy.

It's as if I said I was happy and someone responded "What? You only make $50,000 per year, your country's GDP to pollution ratio is 4.25, and you had 2.13 medical procedures last year at a 26.7 percent premium over the global average, you CAN'T be happy!"

Wouldn't it make more sense to figure out which people actually are happy then figure out the statistical correlations? Although from what I've read there aren't any meaningful correlations. Happiness is defined and continuously redefined by experience.

pedanticfreak··on Google patent portfolio is too weak to protect android
I agree in general that Palm was grossly undervalued. But I also think the author is overvaluing patents. Microsoft, who supposedly dwarfs Google and Apple in patents, still struggles to profit from those ideas. And IBM, whose patent portfolio dwarfs them all, also has a smaller market cap than Apple, Google, or Microsoft.

Google might not have a quantity of patents, but it seems to have enough quality patents to sit quite comfortably.

pedanticfreak··on Send to Kindle: any web page text, with one click, using Chrome browser.
Some people do annotate in the margins. Especially non-fiction books. At the very least I've been known to add a bookmark (i.e. shred of paper) to a particular spot with some notes written on it.

My criticisms of the Kindle are for its page transitions and poor interface. The Kindle is really like the Blackberry of of digital readers. The interface is beyond clunky compared to simple taps and swipes that much more closely emulate the act of reading a physical book.

My best hope is that Mirasol comes to the Nook Color sooner rather than later as I highly doubt the iPad will come with a non-backlit display for several generations.

pedanticfreak··on DuckDuckGo Challenges Google on Privacy (With a Billboard in San Francisco)
Anyone else think there should be a DuckDuckGo of browsers that is similarly proactive about privacy? There way more ways than just cookies to track people nowadays and it's about time we implemented default behavior in the browser to block them. There's no reason to wait for Google or Mozilla to do it for us either.
Page 1 of 4Next →