HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

otabdeveloper4

3,240 karma · joined June 14, 2019

submissionscomments
otabdeveloper4··on Harmony Explained: Progress Towards a Scientific Theory of Music (2012)
> Also, other traditions focus on melody over harmony

Like Western electronic music written after 1960, for example. :)

(And electronic music is, like, basically all we have today.)

otabdeveloper4··on Our position on open-weights models
Could have fooled me, judging by the Iran and Yemen performance.
otabdeveloper4··on How is the Bun rewrite in Rust going?
> Using a LLM to translate a project in a short time, is by itself incredible.

Not really. Transpilers have existed since forever.

The hard part is all the edge cases. (And LLMs don't solve this problem; they probably akshually exacerbate it.)

otabdeveloper4··on The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models
Not really, a shitload of "open math problems" are bounded by constraints of simple text processing or heuristic search.

Much of math is just boring routine work.

otabdeveloper4··on The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models
> that there is discernible structure built into the weights

Yes, this "structure" is but the weights of the glorified logistic regression that's describing an extremely simple statistical process.

otabdeveloper4··on Simulate cassette tape audio profiles using FFmpeg
> I'm so happy these kinds of imperfections are optional now, and not baked into music distribution systems as an expected flaw.

99.9% of the stuff on the music distribution systems we have now is lossily compressed with perceptual coding. That introduces a shitload more artifacts than any analogue wobble.

(I wonder if people 50 years from now will have special algorithms to introduce that coveted "authentic mp3 artifact vibe of the vintage 2010's".)

otabdeveloper4··on Systemd Linger
> An init script is easy

Oh boy. Lmao.

otabdeveloper4··on The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models
> sort of crystallized a bit of the human thought process

a) LLMs don't think. They predict a most probable sequence of language tokens. Huge difference there.

b) Whatever LLMs do doesn't model human behavior whatsoever. LLMs are basically very fancy logistic regressors. I.e., it's a mathematical abstraction first and foremost.

otabdeveloper4··on The PImpl idiom and the C++26 std:indirect type
Lucky for you, I don't.
otabdeveloper4··on Passkeys were invented by engineers with zero understanding of consumer brain
WebAuthn is the standard for token authentication.

(I.e., Yubikeys and other USB sticks.)

It works fine and it a no-brainer to use.

The problems start when vendors start trying to shoehorn their shitty cloud auth services into WebAuthn.

otabdeveloper4··on Advertise in ChatGPT
> lament the loss of the „old models”

My Qwen GGUFs are still here.

otabdeveloper4··on Advertise in ChatGPT
The cost of LLM inference is orders of magnitude more than the typical ad CPM.

Not even "native ads" embedded in LLM output can offset the difference.

otabdeveloper4··on I Stopped “Creating Content”
FOSS is a legal and political tool that removes catastrophic dependency risk.

It's not something that exists simply because software developers had free time to waste.

otabdeveloper4··on Korg PS-3300 is back
Most of these are either discontinued or some sort of paraphonic and/or hybrid-digital architecture. :)

There's no point in trying to make an analogue synth that mimics the percussive nature of piano.

Synths are much closer to woodwinds.

otabdeveloper4··on Korg PS-3300 is back
Sorry, I can't make any sense of your comment.

"Polyphonic analogue synth" means several independent envelope generators and VCFs.

Doing this is pointless -- it increases your synth's costs by orders of magnitude and provides no musical benefit whatsoever except make it slightly easier for piano players with no synthesizer experience to play it.

> The growth of cheap analogue synths

Yes, but literally none of them are doing analogue polyphony. The entire idea is just massively stupid and makes no sense in the 21st century.

otabdeveloper4··on Hacker wipes Romania's land registry database
If you're using passwords as an authentication methods then you've already lost.
otabdeveloper4··on Hacker wipes Romania's land registry database
"It's corruption and cronies" is a generic cop-out answer that doesn't explain anything.

Like whenever someone gets caught in a compromising situation they say they "were hacked", as if saying that means anything.

otabdeveloper4··on Korg PS-3300 is back
It's for collectors. There's no musical value in a polyphonic analogue synthesizer.
otabdeveloper4··on The lost joy of music piracy
> You can absolutely press the same compressed masters on vinyl

Nah, there's physical limits of the needle-in-a-groove medium that prevent this.

> or release the uncompressed masters digitally.

Technically yes, but nobody is gonna do this and risk not "standing out".

> who can afford high-end equipment

The average vinyl record player nowadays costs less than $150. The market is absolutely flooded with low-end Chinese turntables.

When a modern person listens to vinyl records for the first time, the immediate reaction is "how the hell do I make this louder so it pops out more".

And the answer is that you can't, the medium just doesn't work like that.

otabdeveloper4··on The lost joy of music piracy
I'm just saying there is a market for vinyl records with no art or sleeves, but no market for sleeves and art with no record.

Clearly the art isn't the driver of this market niche.

otabdeveloper4··on The lost joy of music piracy
> Digital is more capable of faithfully reproducing sound than vinyl is.

That's exactly the problem that makes digital unsuitable.

Theoretically digital can reproduce sound faithfully, but if the medium allows sound engineers to compress the hell out of music, then they will abuse the opportunity.

Vinyl is a very limited format and you can't really do any sort of "creative" audio optimization bullshit with it.

otabdeveloper4··on The lost joy of music piracy
There's a shitload of valuable vinyl records that don't have any art at all or even any cover. Paper and cardboard doesn't last as long as the record itself.

No, the reasons for this are entirely technical.

otabdeveloper4··on The lost joy of music piracy
> It's largely driven by a kind of retro nostalgia

Incorrect. The reasons why vinyl specifically is still relevant (as opposed to any other "retro" audio format) are technical.

Vinyl avoids compression issues by design. (Compression both in the computer science sense and in the audio engineering sense.)

otabdeveloper4··on The lost joy of music piracy
> pretty much anything that most people want to listen to is on music streaming sites

If that were true, then vinyl sales wouldn't be growing.

otabdeveloper4··on The console wars have been lost
> From the statistics I can find, around 30% of console players are GenZ/GenA.

This is a theoretical maximum in a specific USA-centric bubble.

Consoles (and gaming in general) is just not a thing for teenagers anymore.

Gaming is gonna go the way of the electric guitar. Remember when guitar was actually cool and not just a midlife crisis marker for tired middle aged men?

otabdeveloper4··on Grok CLI uploaded the whole home directory to GCS
AI is created by big tech stealing other people's data. Yes, this has everything to do with AI - stealing data is a foundational feature of the technology.
otabdeveloper4··on The console wars have been lost
Yes, consoles are an expensive lifestyle item for millennials who have money now.
otabdeveloper4··on The console wars have been lost
> the console market is as large as it's ever been as gaming as a whole became genuinely mainstream

Yes, like I said - lifestyle item for gen-X and millennials who have money now.

> ...and kids absolutely still play on them

The vast majority is kids playing their parents' console.

If the market wasn't being driven by parents' demand then no modern kid would be asking to buy a console. (They can play Roblox and Brawl Stars on their iPhone/iPad.)

otabdeveloper4··on The console wars have been lost
> That will be the game to get the entire world on their games consoles.

Console gaming is like 15% of all gaming world-wide, and GTA 6 is like a single-digit slice of that 15% slice.

otabdeveloper4··on The console wars have been lost
"Game consoles" are a niche lifestyle item for gen-X and millennials with money to waste. (Like vinyl records.)

Nobody under 20 knows what a "console" is even for, they play games on their iPhone almost exclusively.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →