HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mdc

246 karma · joined October 24, 2011

submissionscomments
mdc··on CIA pulled officers from Beijing after breach of federal personnel records
I've never been caught. Does that make me good at cyberespionage? I think there's more to it than that. You might argue necessary but not sufficient, but I'd even disagree with that. The fact that the NSA was outed by Snowden has not made everything they're doing ineffective or we wouldn't be so worried about it.
mdc··on CIA pulled officers from Beijing after breach of federal personnel records
Being bad at defense doesn't necessarily imply being bad at offense. Security is hard because you have to win 100% of the time. Being good at cyberespionage means getting a win now and then. I'm not saying the US is good at it, just that neither the OMB breach nor the Snowden incident bear on that. And a lot of the info released by Snowden indicate they were pretty good at it (at least targeting their own citizens) or those disclosures wouldn't be such a big deal.
mdc··on Poor UI Design Can Kill – Air Inter Flight 148, a Harsh Lesson Learned
"Airbus did not anticipate that a pilot would stall a plane and fly it directly into the ocean"

Stalling and flying into the ground have been two common failure modes since flying began and they often happen in sequence. I would think they would be high in the list of misuse cases any aircraft designer would consider.

"we should refrain from being quick to judge which is more or less intuitive."

We should not be quick to judge which UI is more effective, but by definition we can be quick to judge which is more intuitive. In fact, the more time you spend with a system, the less qualified you are to comment on whether it is intuitive. Judging whether a UI is intuitive should take very little time and no expertise past understanding basic operations. I'm certainly not qualified to judge, but I'd think anyone who has experience with modern flight systems would be qualified to comment on whether a particular design was intuitive.

mdc··on Holdout
Or he's never had a home in the full sense of the word.
mdc··on 15 years ago, Congress kept Mickey Mouse copyrighted. Will they do it again?
That kind of implies that everything we create inherently belongs to the government, "they" let us use it for the period of copyright, and then it's theirs again to sell off. I can make a case for copyright ending and creative works no longer having an owner, but I can't make a case (philosophically) for them to automatically belong to the government.
mdc··on Security Check Now Starts Long Before You Fly
Do you really believe that DRY in coding precludes redundancy in implementation?
mdc··on Ask HN: I want to write a Sci-fi book. Where do I start?
Stephen King wrote a book called On Writing that is part memoir and part guide to writing. It's not intended to be a full writing course, but it's a great intro to the important bits presented in a really entertaining way.

I also really like the Self-Publishing Podcast. If you're interested in being an indie author rather than pursuing traditional publishing, it's a fantastic look at three guys finding their way in that industry. The Writing Excuses podcast (recommended earlier by joanofarf) is a better podcast for the craft of writing, but I find the Self-Publishing guys both entertaining and inspirational.

mdc··on Why I hate funnels.
A sieve would just be a one-step funnel. If your engagement involves more than one step (sieves in series) then it's a funnel.
mdc··on "Journey to Justinia" – how I got my 5-year-old son to sit still for 5 hours
I don't think jasonjei was being dismissive of real ADHD. He was just pointing out that it is often over and mis-diagnosed. Many kids are considered misbehaving or diagnosed with a medical problem because they can't sit still for hours at a time, but that really is just kids being kids.

I think jasonjei and you are on the same side of this issue. He was a normal kid that didn't want to be mis-labeled, and you have a real condition that deserves consideration. You should both be opposed to the lazy parents/teachers/doctors who extend ADHD diagnoses far beyond its real scope to medicate normal kids into compliance.

mdc··on Google backslides on federated instant messaging, on purpose?
The article mentions blocking invites, not messages themselves, so there's not really any content to use as a basis for spam filtering.
mdc··on Stop Corporate Takeover of New Internet Names
Not at all. I wasn't saying the .com namespace was crowded. I was responding to someone who thought it was and who thought the appropriate solution was increasing domain registration prices.
mdc··on Stop Corporate Takeover of New Internet Names
It seems like this solution means that if you want to have your own domain, either you must be rich or the website must be profitable. You're basically saying that only the rich should have access to domain-branded blogs and other non-commercial sites, and everyone else can make do with subdomains like a blogspot or blogger website. I think raising fees would have consequences for well-intentioned users far beyond the effect it had on domain squatters.
mdc··on What really happened at LivingSocial?
He says it slides but "gets nowhere near 4x". That's clear enough to preclude 5x.
mdc··on Ping-pong gun fires balls at supersonic speeds
You'd get a very strong puff of air. The air leaving the end of the barrel doesn't have a lot of momentum so it diffuses pretty quickly in the ambient air. You could shape the outlet to get a more focused jet, but it's still going to be a puff, not a strong sustained stream.
mdc··on Realtime Political Fact-Checking Becomes A Reality With WaPo’s ‘Truth Teller’
This system externalizes the risk of telling the truth. Too many people excoriate journalists who say things they don't want to hear, so too many journalists pander to their audience. This will let the journalists continue to say what their audience wants to hear and blame the algorithm for any uncomfortable truths.
mdc··on 900 foot-wide asteroid to make close approach to Earth today
I think you mean the circumference of geostationary orbit is 265000km. Diameter is about 36000km.
mdc··on Will the New Ethanol Blend Tank My Ride?
There's nothing wrong with ethanol as a fuel per se. It has the potential to be a great sustainable fuel made from farm waste and other sources. Unfortunately, the bulk of it now is being made from subsidized corn. This pits all of us who would champion ethanol as a sustainable fuel against it since the current state of the industry is based on very bad policy.
mdc··on Indiana Jones journal mystery solved
The USPS thought the fake postage was real after the fake package came out of its properly-stamped wrapper once it was already in the USPS process stream. It's always easier to pass a fake at a point where everyone assumes the fake has already been verified.
mdc··on Google Maps becomes the App Store’s most popular free app in 7 hours
There's a difference between not having a smart phone and having a smart phone that actively misleads you.
mdc··on Lego Finds Discontinued Set For Boy Who Saved Up For 2 Years
I didn't realize you couldn't reuse the Legos from the specialized kits. I better go tell my kids who have built all kinds of crazy contraptions over the years. Frankly, I think having a bin full of parts that used to be a few different kits makes for a lot more creativity than having a bin full of standard Legos. There are so many more options.
mdc··on Stackoverflow abuses nofollow (2011)
That's typically the strategy for blogs. Links in a blog post are known good and don't have nofollow. Links in comments have nofollow to deter comment spam. That works for blogs where the site owner is creating the main content and the comments are secondary.

Sites like StackOverflow only have comments from users; there is no original content from the site owners (except inasmuch as they might participate as users). Using the blog model, it does seem reasonable to not use nofollow on content created by users who have already been vetted by your reputation system.

mdc··on Larry said to Gaga, ‘Do you ever a/b test your music?’
In addition, she's part of a larger A/B test being run by the industry. Music producers have a nearly unlimited supply of cookie-cutter musicians who they can produce in different ways to see what works. They're expendable, so when they fail the producers can move on and the musicians can go back to playing local clubs or whatever they did to get the producers' attention in the first place. I've known several musicians who got popular in a local scene, got a "big break" and released one heavily-produced album that sounded nothing like their previous work, and then faded back into obscurity. Every now and then one of them breaks big and the producers can cash in for a few albums.
mdc··on Fog Creek is about to go down
We use Fogbugz for all our internal project tracking. The consensus among our engineers is that this downtime is understandable and we'd rather deal with it, even in a mission-important web app, than pay more every month to insure redundancy was available.

Frankly this is just making us appreciate Fogbugz all the more since tracking our time without it will be a real PITA.

mdc··on TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
I agree. I think this change is motivated by two things. First, it's a planned obsolescence by the manufacturers finally admitting a small health issue and offering a solution. Second, it's a move by the TSA to combat opt-outs and other pushback by providing the same privacy violations but now with slightly less cancer risk.
mdc··on Congratulations: You Killed LendInk And Denied Fellow Authors Lend Royalties
I don't think too many of the authors actually held the position you describe. You describe a situation where authors understood LendInk and didn't like the way it changed lending, but if you read the complaints from authors that accused LendInk of piracy, it's pretty clear the authors didn't understand what LendInk was doing and just reacted from a position of ignorance rather than informing themselves.
mdc··on The Marco.org Review of John Siracusa’s Review of OS X 10.8 Mountain Lion
If you listen to Marco's podcast, he'll occasionally say something like "I want to talk about this topic but Siracusa just talked about it on his podcast and did a great job so I'll be quick about it."

It think this review-review is Marco's way of saying that he knows he's expected to comment on the new OSX and everyone should just go read Siracusa's review. Plus it was funny.

edit: typo

mdc··on Mojang, makers of Minecraft, sued by patent troll
>it has no other reason not to send a bottle into the US

Except to serve it's customer, because if it doesn't meet import requirements then the customer's package will never arrive. I understand it may not be legally obligated so there's no repercussion except the shipment being confiscated, but it's in business to serve customers.

mdc··on Mojang, makers of Minecraft, sued by patent troll
Right. huhtenberg's analogy was flawed. His analogy to selling liquor only works if you remote-access a computer in Sweden and then buy Minecraft from that computer. Then when you copy Minecraft from the remote to your home system, you're the importer. If you buy from a US-based computer then it's Mojang acting as an importer to the US.

The liquor analogy would be if you ordered a bottle of liquor to be shipped to the US and the liquor store would be expected to comply with US import rules.

mdc··on Marco Arment on Dropbox: Don't use it for anything valuable
I use TrueCrypt to create encrypted files containing the sensitive data I want on the cloud. TrueCrypt is free and quick to install, so I can pretty easily access the files from any computer if I need to.
mdc··on Facebook Blames Email Problems On User "Confusion"
I think that Dilbert cartoon is very apropos. Facebook employees seem to treat their site as one big Skinner box and they're trying to see how far they can go.
Page 1 of 2Next →