HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartayyar

293 karma · joined September 17, 2012

submissionscomments
kartayyar··on The best Parts of Visual Studio Code are proprietary
I am grateful that VS code is free and if they want to monetize this by having some kind of paid upsell to another product, then all power to them.

They made a good product and if this is a way to fund improvements, I say it's a good thing.

kartayyar··on AMD Reports Q2 2020 Earnings
It's important to separate a leading indicator from a trailing one.
kartayyar··on Google’s top search result is Google
The way Google: ship it and make it work really, really well.

The product was so good that people noticed. They were able to take this and leverage this into being search for a really large property, like

Back in the 90s there were lots of search engines. People didn't pick Google because it was hard to switch, they converged on Google because the product was that good - there was Infoseek, HotBot, AskJeeves, Alta Vista, Lycos, Yahoo, Excite ... the list goes on.

It's a theoretical problem to have a significantly better search engine and not find users for it.

kartayyar··on Amazon met with startups about investing, then launched competing products
You as as a startup should be fully aware that a big player can enter the space at any time they want. This is not Amazon's problem. It's your problem.

Also, it's a flawed abstraction to view large companies as a monolith: the investing arms are usually very separated from product teams.

TLDR: If a large company wants to enter a space, that's their choice. Accept this as a fact of life if you want to go work on a startup.

kartayyar··on Hackers take over prominent Twitter accounts in simultaneous attack
Jeff Bezos too.

https://imgur.com/a/Zd668ao

kartayyar··on Google Acquires North
"Promising" could not be a more incorrect choice of words. It almost sounds like Google did them a favor.

This looks like a distressed fire sale rather than a good exit, considering the product failed.

kartayyar··on Ask HN: Which tools have made you a much better programmer?
Bazel. I really like the workflow of how it only selectively runs unit tests.
kartayyar··on Ask HN: Moving from a startup to a big co, what should I be aware of?
- Domain mastery is more important than being a jack of all trades.

- Realize you are signing up to be part of a bigger machine, and there are things you will have less control over. This is both limiting and empowering.

- Both people in small and large companies can be smart, but they are typically a different flavor of smart. Learn from them accordingly.

- You should plan to have a much longer lead in terms of getting things done if it requires a dependency on a team you don't work with frequently.

- The team you work on is far more important than the company you work for.

- Be active rather than passive about finding opportunities and projects to work on. You can easily get stuck working in a role you might not be a fit for or a manager you don't click with.

kartayyar··on Speech to Text on iPhone vs. Pixel
The Pixels get a lot of hate from people who haven't used them though I think they are great phones and I'll never buy a Samsung phone again.

There are so many nice software touches on them that you just have to experience to appreciate.

kartayyar··on How the biggest consumer apps got their first 1k users
Thanks. Though don't many forums treat links as nofollow and thus don't contribute to page rank?
kartayyar··on How the biggest consumer apps got their first 1k users
How did you get inbound links for your initial blog content?
kartayyar··on Using `make` and `git diff` for a simple and powerful test harness
I would suggest stop using a homegrown solution and use something robust like bazel.

https://bazel.build/

kartayyar··on Ask HN: How do you manage self-study?
Try to build something. That really forces you to push yourself to make sure you understand something.

And in particular, try to build things that force you do things from first principles vs. using a library.

kartayyar··on Google Meet premium video meetings–free for everyone
Google products ( and other tech company products ) are discontinued when they don't take off. Meet has a 100 million daily call participants.

And really with video conferencing product, I don't get the whole trope of "but they might discontinue it." - the utility is immediate in terms of the calls that you make with it, and time boxed till by when a call ends.

kartayyar··on Google Pixel Buds
As a counter point, the case is getting some pretty high praise here.

https://youtu.be/rcfItdQddZE?t=71

kartayyar··on “A Cold War Every Day” inside Apple's internal tools group
On average, a Google internal tool is better than a commercially equivalent tool elsewhere, especially if it's developer critical.

For example the code search, testing, code review tools are amazing and better than any commercial equivalent.

Other tools like the bug database are on par with the industry.

Others like the food, directory and interviewing tools are still pretty damn good and even if they are lacking some polish, are often far more functional than the average commercial equivalent.

And of course they are hit and miss - because there are so many of them. The ones that are commonly used are well funded and have lots of people working on them.

I no longer work at Google but still consider it a role model for how companies should take tooling seriously.

kartayyar··on How We reduced our Google Maps API cost
This seems to be violating the Maps API terms of service?

https://cloud.google.com/maps-platform/terms

(a) No Scraping. Customer will not export, extract, or otherwise scrape Google Maps Content for use outside the Services. For example, Customer will not: (i) pre-fetch, index, store, reshare, or rehost Google Maps Content outside the services; (ii) bulk download Google Maps tiles, Street View images, geocodes, directions, distance matrix results, roads information, places information, elevation values, and time zone details; (iii) copy and save business names, addresses, or user reviews; or (iv) use Google Maps Content with text-to-speech services.

(b) No Caching. Customer will not cache Google Maps Content except as expressly permitted under the Maps Service Specific Terms.

kartayyar··on Google redraws the borders on maps depending on who’s looking
This happens with all american books with maps in India too - it isn't a Google problem. It's a government problem.

I don't think this article has good reporting, because it suggests that the company has some hidden agenda, when really all it's doing is complying with local laws.

kartayyar··on Colab Pro
You should first check hourly instance pricing for GPU instances before making this complaint.

This is a very cheap price.

kartayyar··on Google Sheets was down
I think they are different tools:

Sheets -> Great collaborative experience for simple to moderate complexity use cases.

Excel -> The heavy artillery.

kartayyar··on What Is Systems Programming, Really? (2018)
One litmus test that a former coworker applied was "how resource constrained is the application"?

I think conceptually this is a better test, more so than say if you have access to a raw pointer - because more important parts of how to handle core issues like scheduling, storage management, concurrency, parallelism and distributed computation manifest themselves in many forms.

I started my career doing C programming in a OS / kernel environment. In retrospect a lot of pieces of applications I've worked on are what I think of as systems, and many parts of kernels are more applications than systems.

kartayyar··on Google cancels TGIF weekly all-hands meetings
As a Xoogler who just wanted to get on topic product updates ( and Sergey jokes I guess - he really is insanely funny), I actually found it frustrating that it was an overloaded forum for any and all random topics.

Were I working there, this would have made sense to me.

I didn't work there to be an activist. I worked there to go work on products.

I don't get other comments that say "courted activists". The recruiting pitch is about impact, a good work environment, compensation and interesting products.

kartayyar··on Hitman hires hitman who hires hitman who hires hitman who hires hitman
Microservices in action.
kartayyar··on Bazel 1.0
Xoogler here who used the internal version of Bazel ( blaze ) extensively, liked it and now opted to use it for our 2 person startup ( at least for the backend ).

You don't need a giant codebase to start benefitting from it. Even if you have a smaller codebase, and properly use bazel to setup tests, you only test what needs testing, and that makes a huge difference in productivity.

kartayyar··on Show HN: Finding cheap multicity flights with ML and constraint programming
Hi Hacker News,

We are a couple of Xooglers who worked in Google Research now working on making a better multi city travel planner / travel search engine called Preso Trip.

Live site: https://www.prestotrip.com/?source=hn

The blog post describes the details of what motivated us to work on this problem and the approach we are taking to find great prices for multi city deals.

Video demo: https://youtu.be/9ggFSjKAMIA

Product Hunt entry: https://www.producthunt.com/posts/presto-trip

kartayyar··on PyTorch – Tensor computation with strong GPU acceleration
This is really old, it came out in 2016.

Why did you reshare it ?

kartayyar··on Medical equipment pricing is completely broken when a sling costs $200
I went to a travel medicine clinic, and got two shots.

The cost for the shots was ~200$, and ~300$ for consultation, which was a PA giving me printouts about information of what diseases are found in which countries.

What a scam.

kartayyar··on Show HN: Saag as a Service – macronutrient-portioned Indian spinach curry
Okay I hate to be blunt about this: though this is super high calorie food.

All 3 variants listed are fabulously unhealthy coming in at 500 calories per serving.

If you want to pitch this as a tastier product and pursue that angle, that's one story but pitching this as "healthy" is quite flawed.

kartayyar··on Nvidia CEO says Google is the only customer building its own silicon at scale
This is not true. Deleted data is indeed deleted. Making sure deleted data is actually deleted is super important to Google and any other company because of GDPR compliance.

This is the kind of thing that you go over laborious detail in over privacy design docs at Google to make sure you have it covered.

Source: I'm a Xoogler.

kartayyar··on CodeFlow: Improving the Code Review Process at Microsoft (2018)
As a Xoogler, I really miss Critique.

Amazing tool. Great integration with version control, code search, continuous integration.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →