HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jkincaid

1,506 karma · joined April 18, 2008

Howdy, I used to be a writer at TechCrunch.

If you're looking to reach me, try jkincaid@gmail.com

submissionscomments
jkincaid··on Google Buzz
Try accessing it from Android/iPhone (buzz.google.com). I can access it on my phone even though it isn't popping up in Gmail yet.
jkincaid··on [dead]
I'm all for scrutinizing the recent intern situation at TechCrunch (unfortunately I can't really talk about it, other than to say it makes me feel sick to my stomach).

However, given the fact that a good chunk of the post seems to be a rant about TC itself, I think it's worth pointing out who this is coming from. I've known Loren since the day I started at TechCrunch and think he's a funny, smart guy. But he's also spent a lot of time in the last few months ripping incessantly on TechCrunch.

That's sort of his thing — he's been ripping on Scoble and Dave Winer for years, but I suspect he gets a bit more attention when he does the TechCrunch bashing simply because there are quite a few people out there who love to hate TC. You can get a sense of this by looking through the archives of twitter.com/1938media. Maybe he's really had some epiphany about TC being evil after being friendly with us for years, maybe he's bitter about Michael failing to attend his conference, or maybe he's just doing his schtick.

jkincaid··on Google adds multitouch to Nexus One browser, maps, and gallery
I asked a Google spokesperson about this and the response was pretty vague, but the gist seems to be that it will come to other phones once the manufacturers/carriers roll out this Android update. Obviously that could be a while for some devices.

I think there are rumors that the Droid will be getting Android 2.1 (which is what the Nexus One runs) in the near future, but I don't think anyone knows if it will include this update or if it will be what the Nexus One shipped with, which lacks multitouch.

jkincaid··on The iPad Literally Breaks Every Use Case I Had For It
I don't really get why everyone is talking about Flash and its relation to porn. If the the number of non-Flash playing devices grows, couldn't these porn sites just go to HTML5?(this applies to all other video sites, actually)
jkincaid··on View facebook friend list (hidden or not hidden)
I believe this has to do with the privacy changes last month, which made it so that Friends Lists can no longer be hidden.

After an initial backlash, Facebook made it relatively easy to remove your friends list from public search results, but it sounds like it isn't actually blocking access to them — they're just harder to find.

From Facebook's blog post ( http://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=197943902130 ):

"In response to your feedback, we've improved the Friend List visibility option described below. Now when you uncheck the "Show my friends on my profile" option in the Friends box on your profile, your Friend List won't appear on your profile regardless of whether people are viewing it while logged into Facebook or logged out. This information is still publicly available, however, and can be accessed by applications. "

jkincaid··on On the iPad
I can run whatever I want on my Mac. Can't on my iPhone. I think the latter is more closed.
jkincaid··on IPad: an Apple for Mom - The uncomputer for the people
Totally agreed. However, I think the iPad should come with a more robust photo app — something that lets you import and manage photos (all through fun drag and drop, of course). In my experience, many light computer users still take digital photos. It would also be nice if this thing could manage video importing, with maybe some very basic editing functionality similar to what's on the iPhone.
jkincaid··on iPad: Or, why you have to look at the advertising
Agreed on textbook/student note taking angle. But I really think you're in the minority as far as not minding touchtyping on a glass screen — I think that would get old fast for writing anything longer than a paragraph.

I'm eager to see how this works as an eReader. I still think that reading a book on a backlit display sort of stinks. I'm wondering if people will spring for the iPad as an eBook reader because it has so much else to offer, and then realize a few days later that they just can't ignore the eye strain.

jkincaid··on iPad: Or, why you have to look at the advertising
You say that the entire world wants an iPad. I disagree. I think this will appeal to a specific (but fairly common) kind of computer user. Namely, the sort of person who really doesn't know what they're doing on a computer, and only uses their PC for very basic tasks. This kind of person will be able to replace their laptop (or even their desktop) with an iPad, and I think it will be a fantastic solution for them.

The problem, though, is that this "magical screen" probably won't be very efficient for getting work done. Which means most people won't be able to replace their computers. And I think it's going to be hard to convince these people that they need a so-called "middle device".

EDIT: I should also add that I think the appeal will be much broader once publishers make digital books and textbooks that are actually superior to their paper counterparts. But that might take years.

jkincaid··on iPad: Or, why you have to look at the advertising
Other "display photos in a digital box" hardware has a sub $100 pricetag, which means you can leave them around your house doing nothing but display photos without feeling guilty (or stupid).
jkincaid··on [dead]
That ad was planned before we were hacked, the timing was a total coincidence.

Michael is out in Davos, Switzerland right now — he isn't masterminding an opportunistic ad campaign.

jkincaid··on Google strikes back at Apple, releases new Google Voice for iPhone
Read this: http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/08/21/the-simple-truth-whats-...

We also wrote quite a few other stories about the situation that you should be able to pull up using the Google query below. For more on applications that are similar to Google Voice, check out the stories on Line2.

http://www.google.com/search?&ie=UTF-8&q=Google+Voic...

jkincaid··on Google strikes back at Apple, releases new Google Voice for iPhone
Go back and read Apple's response to the FCC. It may not have any outright lies, but there's plenty of stuff in there that is questionable. They say some things that are factually incorrect about the way Google Voice works, and they try to claim that they don't fully understand the service. If you buy that, so be it. I don't.
jkincaid··on Google strikes back at Apple, releases new Google Voice for iPhone
Neither Apple nor Google will ever comment about this on the record. You have to look at what has happened and read between the lines.
jkincaid··on Google strikes back at Apple, releases new Google Voice for iPhone
I think Google is "striking back" in the sense that it's planting the Google Voice 'seed' while Apple probably wants to keep it off the iPhone entirely. If each company had an internal monologue, I think it would go something like this:

Apple: "We don't want Google Voice on the iPhone, period. But we'll publicly tell Google they're fine to put it on as a handicapped web app, because we couldn't stop that anyway, and it makes us look like we don't have anything against it. But we do. We are worried that Google will convert the iPhone into a shell for its own products, which is why we're talking to other search engines and are (probably) building our own Maps app."

Google: "Fine. We'll build a web app, and it will be sort of shitty. But we'll keep updating it with the latest HTML5 tricks and make it pretty damn good for a web app — far better than most other companies could do anyway. We're going to release Google Voice to the public later this year, and iPhone users will be able to try it for themselves with the web app. When they find out that the experience would be even better if Apple would approve our native app, maybe we'll see a grassroots movement. Maybe not. Either way, we're keeping our best native apps on Android."

To anyone who thinks that Apple is worried about the user experience and reproducing core functionality, that's all misdirection. There are plenty of applications that similarly reproduce some of the iPhone's core functionality. There are a few apps that do EXACTLY what Google Voice does, but are targeted at a different market. Apple is trying to keep its control over the iPhone for competitive reasons, not because they're worried about user confusion.

jkincaid··on Why 30.1% of numbers start with 1
This is awesome. Also, I can't help but wonder if this could be used in some sort of bar trick to impress members of the opposite sex.
jkincaid··on Where can I get unbiased news?
Spot on. A story can present totally objective facts, but it will still be biased because the reporter decided which facts to include and which to omit. Likewise, reporters choose which experts they want to quote in their stories.
jkincaid··on [dead]
Wow, you're trying to find something controversial on TechCrunch and this is the best you can do? Come on.

This wasn't astroturfing. First off, I don't think he ever says anything about Quora being "on the same level" as Wikipedia and Aardvark. David doesn't know anyone from Quora, nor has their PR team ever reached out to him. But the service does have a lot of buzz right now — I'm literally being asked on a daily basis if I have an invite, and I'm seeing many tweets about it.

If you look back through our other articles, you'll find that we often mention both new startups and established big players. It helps keep the small guys on your radar.

I usually enjoy the conspiracy theories, but this one was pretty weak.

jkincaid··on A 4 year progression of startup offices
Crystal Tower may be great, but it's a total eyesore for everyone else in the area. Anyone know why it was allowed to be 2-3x taller than the other buildings in the vicinity?
jkincaid··on Fake (Malicious) Mobile Banking App Discovered in Android Marketplace
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't it be fairly trivial to create a phishing iPhone application (even one that got accepted to the App Store?) My understanding is that nobody is combing through your code line by line, so you could sneak something in there that wasn't activated until after the app was accepted, right?
jkincaid··on The Google Phone
The Nexus One leaks are deliberate. No, Google may not have actually sent the photos to blogs themselves, but giving the device to that many people just before the holidays? It was basically guaranteed. They knew it would happen.

As far as Google's leak control, I think that they can be secretive when they want to be. Part of that comes from the fact that they have so much going on — you hear a rumor and it could well be related to some random research project or internal test, etc. But I've been to a few Google events where there were product launches that hadn't been previously rumored.

A good example is probably the Chrome launch. As far as I can remember, there wasn't any significant buildup in rumors of a "Google Browser" in the weeks before that announcement. Granted, the cat came out of the bag when a mailing company accidentally shipped the Chrome comics a day early, but that didn't come from an employee leak.

jkincaid··on The Google Phone
I suspect that these reviews are a little premature and that Google has a few tricks up their sleeve for today's Nexus One event. Google distributed this phone to thousands of people weeks before its launch, including some non-employees, knowing full well that it would leak.

That's a great way to build up buzz, but at the same time it makes for a pretty lame event. My guess is we'll see a few new apps or features that weren't baked into the employee phones (yet).

jkincaid··on Thoughts on a failed launch
Cheer up. There's a good chance that many of the big tech blogs didn't see your site at all, or your text pitch wasn't all that compelling (but maybe your site is), or any of a hundred other reasons.

The sad fact of the matter is that us tech bloggers get way too much Email. No matter how many Gmail filters we set up, it's a constant struggle to find those 'diamonds in the rough' — the sites that nobody has ever heard of and have no funding. If you get ignored by everyone for multiple launches then maybe something's wrong, but don't get too dejected because of one bad press push.

Shoot me an Email next time you guys launch a cool new feature (it's in my profile). Tell me why it's cool. Tell me why you're more than a Digg for style questions. No promises about a post, but I'll check it out. Also, just from a five second glance at the site, I think you might want to look into changing up the layout/colors a bit. I'm no designer though.

jkincaid··on How Facebook Is Making Friending Obsolete
Lying is actually against Facebook's ToS. Just called them out on it here: http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/12/15/facebook-lie-terms-of-s...

I think they're making a lot of mistakes and are going to hurt a lot of users. But ultimately they'll make a lot more money.

jkincaid··on Is Facebook unethical, clueless or unlucky?
I don't know if unethical is the right word. Maybe "shady" would be better?

If Facebook wanted to stay on the safe side of things, they'd have kept the default as the more private setting and then show some kind of prompt saying "Hey, this is a new Everyone setting. This is what it does. Would you like to try it?"

jkincaid··on Is Facebook unethical, clueless or unlucky?
That stat does not convince me that users actually know what they're doing. Maybe you're privy to more research about this, but I suspect the majority of users who select something besides the default change everything to 'old setting' because they don't know what the hell this stuff is and just want to get back to Farmville.

I seriously doubt most people know what 'Everyone' means. Or what can happen to data that's syndicated to search engines and is no longer in Facebook's control.

I'm currently in the process of reaching out to my friends who don't follow tech news to make sure they know what they've signed up for with the new settings. After explaining the 'Everyone' setting, responses are usually along the lines of "Facebook is turning evil."

jkincaid··on Android Sales Figures After Placing 3rd in the Android Developer Challenge 2
Yep, I actually wrote a post about that a few weeks ago http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/11/15/android-market-app-stor...

About 2/3 way through the post I talk about a model they could use where they push apps to you OTA, which could be cool. Hoping they're paying attention. I also think it's weird that they aren't promoting ADC winners at all from within the Market.

jkincaid··on Android Sales Figures After Placing 3rd in the Android Developer Challenge 2
Is it just me or does Google not promote these apps at all from within the Android Market itself? I'm looking for some menu option or banner that says "Check out these great apps", and am not seeing one.
jkincaid··on The End Of The CrunchPad
Mike left a comment when someone asked that same question in the post: "of course there is more to the story. but the point is we’d gotten past all the ugly sausage making that goes into any startup and had moved to within days of launching it. An email to us saying “the economics don’t work, we have to talk” would have been a reasonable request. But telling us that we aren’t important to the project, and stating that we don’t own the intellectual property, is just bizarre."
jkincaid··on What I Wish Someone Had Told Me (about starting a company)
The key words in your comment are "chance" and "possibility". If it really was just a simple matter of when you're putting in the time, plenty more people would do the 9 years of intense work for 36 years of freedom later on. Thing is, for lots of people a year or two of very intense work on a startup yields nothing but the learning experience of running a company.
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →