HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

inboulder

116 karma · joined July 20, 2008

submissionscomments
inboulder··on The Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem
"shouldn't the Agent have succeeded way faster/efficiently instead of using "4.9 million messages and used about 300 billion output tokens."" No. Have you seen LLM output? The fact that it managed to converge at all in the problem space is amazing, an LLM is a 'book', the context window is the page number, the page has a token, that's it, that this huge book of weights already contains a method to search a problem space at all and actually go down a 'good' path eventually is remarkable, but it's going to be incredibly inefficient at doing so, a book doesn't have any kind of real-time model building like a brain.
inboulder··on The Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem
LLMs are an excellent tool for discovering which problems mathematicians thought were interesting, actually aren't. If the LLM's haphazard jaunt (somewhat exhaustively) through the problem space can 'solve' it, the solution was never going to be particularly useful or illuminating.
inboulder··on Show HN: FastGraphRAG – Better RAG using good old PageRank
PageRank for better centrality seems neat, but it still doesn't address the probably unsolvable flaw with RAG, the reason why RAG basically can't work. All RAG DBs under-perform expectations because RAG fundamentally can't find relationships between words necessary to find the information the user cares about. Weird right, isn't this what the 'attention' mechanism is supposed to be good for? It just isn't good enough.

Example: Say you're searching an article and you want to know what occupation a mentioned person has, let's say the person 'Sharon,' is mentioned to have attended several physical chemistry conferences but her occupation is never explicitly mentioned. There's a very good chance every single rag approach will fail to return correct results, will fail to make this connection between 'occupation' attends conference, type of conference and infers 'chemist'. I could go on, but this sort of error is pervasive along all types of information when trying to retrieve with RAG. In the end, solutions like the above seem to just sort of reinvent other query methods, SQL, pagerank etc, with extra steps... there's little point in vectorization at that point...

inboulder··on Study: If aliens exist, they probably want to destroy us
I think this article makes a fantastically gross error, the conclusion is fine, however the authors gloss over the fact that any space-faring life has a high probability of being machine-intelligence, not squishy biological life which 'evolved in the same manner as on earth'. (note, this is already the trend with our space exploration)
inboulder··on Study: If aliens exist, they probably want to destroy us
You're neglecting many reasons extra terrestrial life may pose a threat.

The most obvious is they may want our planet, they want to live here, and if they've managed to travel across the vast void of space, wiping out humanity probably won't be particularly challenging for them.

Also, your second point is invalid, territorial reasons are not void. We may pose no threat now, however a technologically superior civilization may conclude we pose a future threat, and so wipe us out now before we can become one.

Also, the old 'dangerous biology from somewhere else!' is almost entirely null and void, organisms are adapted to their environment, they usually pose negligible risk to any other environment already inhabited by biological organisms. This is why, for instance we don't treat organisms from thermal vents as 'oh noes, biohazard material'.

inboulder··on Google Will Become an AI Company
Can you point out the way in which the "Google Wave Bots & Gadgets" had meaningful elements of AI?
inboulder··on Cheezburger Network doesn't show new hires the bathroom until they check in code
I don't think you understand my point at all. The pageviews Cheezburger garner ARE impressive. That it is possible to run a business with very low capital costs (based on wordpress blogs) fairly inexpensively (and thus grow or _shrink_ organically) is NOT impressive.
inboulder··on Cheezburger Network doesn't show new hires the bathroom until they check in code
Sorry, don't get me wrong, I understand it's easy to burn through cash.

My point is: I'm not sure why Cheezburger thinks it's impressive to set up Wordpress blogs of other people's images without breaking the bank.

inboulder··on Cheezburger Network doesn't show new hires the bathroom until they check in code
"Cheezburger has been a profitable business since inception. We have been profitable every single quarter, and never had a quarter with negative cash flows. "

Oh come on now, how could you have negative cash flow? Your whole business model is based around publishing content on the web you didn't create, (and 99% of the time probably don't even own the rights to), this is not exactly an expensive business to run.

inboulder··on The reverse job applicant
>> For example, Java, can you tell me the difference between volatile and synchronized as it regards the memory model without looking it up? What's a happens-before relationship and how is it relevant to those keywords? What's the transient modifier do?

>I didn't claim to be a Java guru. Very few Java programmers actually need to know the answers to those questions in day-to-day programming; I could probably (if asked to, which I'm not, thankfully) write thousands or tens of thousands of lines of Java without ever needing to know the answer to those.

You're wrong, and this proves the point. This isn't 'guru' level, the workings of volatile and synchronized is even on the basic SCJP test. This may not come up in your domain, but if the project deals with threading, an experienced dev will be more productive than you right off the bat, after two weeks, and probably after a year.

In fact, threading is pretty tricky, so it's likely you will be counter-productive to the team until you've made all the Java threading mistakes you need to make in order to understand why your code is bad. And, you might never know your code is bad unless a domain experienced Java dev explains it to you.

Domain experience matters.

inboulder··on Please write shorter emails
"Ernest Hemingway than Kurt Vonnegut"

I think you're trying to make a 'smart' reference but are confused. Overall, Vonnegut was generally at least as, or more concise; there is an entire page in _For Whom the Bell Tolls_ dwelling on the sweat on someone's brow.

inboulder··on Tell HN: hntrades.com
Hey, I've been looking for a URL for my new app, this one looks perfect: beeftard.com Domain Name Sale or Trade ca98am79 4 hours ago
inboulder··on Being Poor by John Scalzi
$300 is 15 lawns mowed, or 2k cans collected, or probably one post on your facebook page asking for donations.
inboulder··on Why Isn't the Price of Broadband Obeying Moore's Law?
Why Isn't the Price of Sheep in Sudan Obeying Moore's Law?
inboulder··on Why do the Japanese draw themselves as white?
This doesn't explain or even address why the Japanese favor 'large round eyed' actors in ads for beauty products, why darker skinned Japanese women are not featured on TV, and why the current depictions of beauty in Japan eschew many traits common to classical Japanese portrayals of beauty.

It is glaringly obvious that European ideals of beauty have enormously affected the Japanese aesthetic, especially including anime; almost any Japanese person you meet will readily admit to this, to claim otherwise takes willful ignorance.

inboulder··on Most common words unique to 1-star and 5-star App Store reviews
The biggest problem with App Store 'reviews' is that iOS asks for a rating on uninstall, this leads to many '1 star' ratings, with no review at all, leaving the developer in the dark as to what the user's issues are.
inboulder··on Ask HN: anyone leave a high paying job to work at a startup?
I'm not sure if you're just naive, but "rock star" programmers make a lot more than $100k/yr, try tripling that.
inboulder··on I'm an introverted hacker. I want to join a frat.
"Isaac Newton or Emily Dickinson" funny you should have mentioned both of these folks, they both died virgins. The world might have been better, but they never got to experience an important part of being human.
inboulder··on Why Reddit's Founder was "Terrified" to Launch New Startup, Hipmunk (YC S10)
"hipmunk" (I really hate domain squatters if this is best URL you guys could find available?) looks good, but I wonder if it's all flash 'agony' and name recognition (hey you got cnn to write an article already, sweet hook up!). As far as I can tell it has a pretty 'info graphic' interface, but doesn't really do the thing that would get me to use it: save money on flights.

Does hipmunk do anything different? It doesn't look like it can tap into sabre, ryan air db, etc, looks like it just scrapes and organizes, nor does it look like it has any fancy back end db of extensive flight info with a smart heuristics engine to predict future prices. So, beyond help those who have trouble visualizing a schedule, I'm not sure how this is any better than farecast et all. Can hipmunk predict if a particular flight's price (not willy nilly flights, I'm looking at you farecast) will go up or down?

inboulder··on Ask HN: Best Startup City - Outside the USA?
From growing up in, and visiting London frequently, I don't really agree. London is as, or more expensive than, NYC. Programmers are expensive in London, and in dealing with the British tech culture, they don't seem to have the 'entrepreneurial spirit' I'm used to in the US, it seems less 'young, talented, take on the world attitude' and more about working at satellite offices for IBM etc.

If I was going to pick somewhere in the EU, I'd go for Berlin.

inboulder··on On ‘Mad Men,’ The Allure of Messy Lives
Anyone else get bored with it after the first season? I mean, it's an ad agency, there's only so many plot-lines before it just became a soap opera. I also didn't understand how the main character hardly said a word, yet people seemed to think he was interesting, the writing wasn't very sensical.
inboulder··on High-Frequency Programmers Revolt Over Pay
Would anyone else like to see mandatory random delays added to markets just to put these window-breaking rent seekers out of business?
inboulder··on Sorry AirBnB Hipsters, I’ll Take Health and Safety Over the Cult of Disruption
"Sorry AirBnB Hipsters, I’ll Take Health and Safety Over the Cult of Disruption"

And you were free to do that already, why force everyone else? (what is that again hotel lobby?)

inboulder··on Sorry AirBnB Hipsters, I’ll Take Health and Safety Over the Cult of Disruption
Notice how this 'valid point' has nothing to do with all the other 'safety' red herring nonsense. Forcing the owner to be present cripples the opportunity to sublet, which is exactly what the hotels want.
inboulder··on Ask HN: Selling my first company - need help with the process
From reading a lot of VC blogs, the thing that affects their valuation the most is competition. I think the most important thing you can do for your deal is get a competing bid of some kind, any kind, any outside interest at all will do more for the price than you can do within the confines of the deal with company x. This may sound difficult and it is, but I think it's absolutely critical.
inboulder··on Ask HN: Selling my first company - need help with the process
0.9 to 1.6 as a multiplier is absolutely terrible, that's a crazy discounted cash flow rate, at those multiples you are guaranteed to be better off just holding onto the business unless you know it is going under very rapidly. 5x is starting to become reasonable.
inboulder··on Ask HN: Selling my first company - need help with the process
"This is really just a myth. If you present a buyer with well-justified and thought-out reasons for your number, it's going to be hard for them to counter-offer with something ridiculous, unless they're just being an ass"

Wrong, you're missing the point entirely, I'd like to buy a business from you...

The point is that if you offer a price first, this is the HIGHTEST the buyer will pay, he might have valued the business at more, in this case you have left money on the table.

inboulder··on Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in stealth mode?
Because implementing them isn't.
inboulder··on How I Graduated from Harvard, Turned Down Google, Got a Job Through Twitter
So basically you majored in arts and crafts at Harvard (and you're surprised BSing poli sci papers wasn't difficult?), wrote a bunch of blog posts and tweets, have an annoying 'young upstart' linkedin page, but don't know a linked list for a lincoln log, and are going into a non-technical entry level position for a random start-up?
inboulder··on Dallas - Fort Worth Area Startups Are Hiring
But then you have to live in Dallas/Fort worth....
Page 1 of 2Next →