HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gregallan

88 karma · joined June 19, 2018

submissionscomments
gregallan··on List Of Adhesive Tapes
From the datasheet linked there, it looks like the minimum recommended spacing to ensure electrical isolation between adjacent conductors is 15 mil (0.4mm). In an example I found here [1], the pitch between BGA pins is 0.5 mm to 1.0 mm, with pad sizes roughly half of the pitch. So it looks like for the larger pitches, it might just work. 3M also says they'll do custom tape with better isolation, but that might just be more expensive than a reflow oven.

[1] https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/application-note/AN10778.pdf

gregallan··on Electronics Flea Market
First one since 2019! But it’s back on the normal monthly schedule for the 2022 Spring-Fall season.
gregallan··on Roman slaveowners were the first management theorists?
Is this an attempt at humor? If so, it fell flat for me. Tech and finance workers are some of the most highly-compensated people in the world today. Comparing them to Roman slaves, who were considered property, had no freedom of movement, and were subject to brutal corporal punishment, shows a callous disregard for the real human suffering occurring around the world.
gregallan··on Is Google Search Deteriorating? Measuring Google's Search Quality in 2022
I think this is my biggest problem with how Google now works. It's always been disappointing when you didn't find what you were looking for. But you used to be able to examine the results and see how your search terms might not have been optimal, and adjust accordingly. It was the expectation that you'd have to tweak. Now, changing your exact search terms hardly seem to make a difference.

I think the major difference is that the algorithm used to highly weight matching of specific words and phrases from the search terms, so adding a word, re-ordering, and swapping for synonyms would drastically change the results. Now it seems they're using ML and natural language processing to try to actually understand what you're looking for and give it to you. You can change your search terms, but the language embedding doesn't change much, so the system is actually working as intended. I could see that this might actually be desirable for a large segment of the population who wants their search engine to "just work" in response to natural language queries. If the corpus being indexed was high quality, maybe this would be a good experience. But due to the ads, affiliate marketing, and blogspam that make up a large part of modern internet content, it's simply frustrating.

I wouldn't be surprised if they've done user testing that validates their approach. Programmers tend to be comfortable with the concept that a computer will do what you ask, even if it's not what you meant, but most people want to get the right results on the first try. The natural language/ML approach may be much more intuitive and forgiving in that regard. It's just not an approach that's compatible with the low average quality of the content being indexed, in that it takes away the authority of the user to improve their search results.

I think there's somewhat of a tradeoff in search performance between quality of results on the first try and ability to improve the results on subsequent tries, and google is now optimizing for the former at great cost to the latter. And honestly they're failing at both.

gregallan··on Y2K-Type Bug Causes Timestamp Overflow in Xilinx Software
Mindboggling that this could happen in the first place, and more so that it's still not fixed.
gregallan··on The welfare effects of eviction policies
If housing becomes prohibitively expensive to people in need just because we hold landlords accountable for abusive actions, maybe we should consider a different way to allocate housing resources.
gregallan··on Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement
Also MacOS and Windows have “App Stores” that you certainly don’t need to be logged into.
gregallan··on They thought they were going to rehab but ended up in chicken plants (2017)
For one, it requires the inmates to have been convicted of a crime. (Not that I consider that to be just either, for the record.) What the article describes is likely a violation of the US constitution in at least some of the cases.
gregallan··on Ask HN: Recruiters want people who do side projects, yet contracts forbid them?
When you say “graduate position” do you mean a position meant for a college graduate, or a position in a Masters or PhD program at a university?
gregallan··on Norman doors are everywhere (2016) [video]
This is also really common in New England in the US. I have no idea why, though.
gregallan··on Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video off YouTube
Note that I said dubious legality. I was just qualifying my earlier statement that it was legally fine. Hopefully we’ll get a legal ruling on this sooner rather than later.
gregallan··on Police officer plays Taylor Swift song to keep a video off YouTube
I think it’s a little misguided to praise the officer for allowing them to film. It would be illegal for him to prevent them from filming him performing his duties in a public place. I also find it slightly ridiculous for you to characterize citizens recording their interactions with police for their own protection as a “citizen surveillance state.” The citizens are not the state. The police here are representatives of the state and must be held to account in every interaction with civilians. I don’t deny that it’s a high-pressure situation for an individual to be in, and like you I find it hard to personally fault him for his strategy to prevent going viral. AFAIK it’s legally fine, and ethically grey depending on his exact intentions, which we can’t really know. In this case however, it’s more likely to result in a Streisand effect.

Edit: on reading the rest of this thread I’m more convinced of the dubious legality of the cop’s playing music with the expectation that the recording will be made public

gregallan··on Our vendor executed a system reboot that caused a shut down of the turnstiles
Interesting, but I wonder what the additional cost to the median income taxpayer would be. Is there a straightforward way to figure this out?
gregallan··on “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
Of note here: Wikipedia has a specific policy prohibiting this sort of experimentation. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:NOTLAB
gregallan··on A new moralism is gripping the literary world
Nobody is telling you you shouldn’t archive them. The publishers decided they weren’t comfortable selling them to be shown to children. I’m personally glad that you’ve helped preserve these once-beloved cultural artifacts. However, I’d hope that anyone would hesitate to give these particular books to children in 2021.
gregallan··on Ask HN: Why are e-ink note-taking devices so expensive compared to iPads?
I suppose you consider all 87 of the members of that subreddit to be the "real tech leaders", then?
gregallan··on TSA tries out another biometric system
This site is completely broken on mobile.
gregallan··on Book Review: Raise a Genius (2017)
I think the difference is that in this context it’s at least as much about what the other players are doing as the way the game actually works. Learning how to operate within the new rules is still just part of the game. Learning how to counter those strategies when your opponents adopt then would be considered the metagame. And sometimes the meta changes not due to changes in the rules, but simply because someone has an innovation in strategy or tactics which starts to be adopted en masse. Then someone figures out how to counter that and the cycle continues.
gregallan··on List of oldest continuously inhabited cities
I think your analysis is overly critical. The stated purpose of Wikipedia's no-OR policy is not to "reach or imply a conclusion not stated by the sources". The only novel conclusion being drawn here is that one can conceive of a list of the oldest continuously inhabited cities in the world. Wikipedia policy also notes that "The potential for creating lists is infinite." and prohibits lists that do not comply with Wikipedia's overall content policy as being "trivial, non-encyclopedic, or not related to human knowledge". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Stand-alone_lists#Ap...

I personally think that this list is really interesting and does in fact advance the state of human knowledge. The fact that it's currently at the top of HN and has garnered comment interest shows that you're probably in the minority in your disagreement.

If you feel strongly that this list is trivial, poorly organized, or simply "awful" you're absolutely free to join the discussion and contribute edits at Wikipedia.

gregallan··on In a Lab Accident, Scientists Create the First-Ever Permanently Magnetic Liquid
Care to elaborate?
gregallan··on 33 dead after arson attack at Kyoto Animation studio, dozens injured
This is pure whataboutism. The parent comment said nothing about the US to even imply there isn’t also a problem there.
gregallan··on Carbon dioxide levels in atmosphere hit record high in May
If you're saying that moles/m^3 of CO2 might be constant while pmm of CO2 is increasing, that implies that atmospheric pressure at sea level is dropping. And it isn't.
gregallan··on Virgin Galactic successfully reaches space
For context, the predecessor of SpaceShipTwo reached an altitude of over 100km in June 2004, becoming the first commercial venture to put a person in space [1]. A few months after that, Virgin got involved and it seemed like commercial passenger spaceflight was just a few years away. 14 years and two fatal accidents [2,3] later, the 80 km flight seems to pale in comparison to those expectations. In that time we’ve seen the rise of SpaceX and Blue Origin, whose aspirations and capabilities look set to far exceed those of Virgin Galactic. As impressive as this spaceplane is, its competitors are starting to make it look like the product of some (very expensive) backyard tinkering.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceShipOne#Development_and_w...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RocketMotorTwo#Related_test_pr...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VSS_Enterprise_crash

gregallan··on For collecting weather data, tiny satellites measure up to expensive cousins
Does this count?

https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/1522614

gregallan··on For collecting weather data, tiny satellites measure up to expensive cousins
There are other attempts at disposal of dead satellites that don’t rely on a long-shot like the BFR [1]. Besides, maneuvering a big heavy spacecraft like that to match orbits with a bunch of little satellites would be tremendously wasteful in terms of fuel. A much better use would be to remove larger satellites like defunct communications satellites. These are actually a much bigger danger to orbital space as well. See this event for example [2], which generated over 2000 pieces of debris large enough to track and many more of a smaller size. Small satellites are not nearly as dangerous because when they are defunct their low mass causes them to renter faster.

(FYI I’m a PhD student in the lab that built the satellite in the article.)

[1] https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2...

[2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_satellite_collision

gregallan··on YouTube’s Piracy Filter Blocks MIT Courses, Blender Videos, and More
It seems YouTube's statement here is really disingenuous. When they say "We are working with MITOpenCourseWare and Blender Foundation to get their videos back online." they mean that they are holding these non-profit organizations' video hosting rights hostage until they agree to enable ads! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17347560