HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

freditup

2,177 karma · joined March 6, 2012

submissionscomments
freditup··on Taxi Medallion Prices Are Plummeting, Endangering Loans
Just a small point of disagreement: Often, in busy parts of NYC, hailing a cab is much more convenient that calling an Uber. Ubers often take awhile to get to you whereas a yellow cab can be hailed within a few seconds.

I am interested in the question you pose though - about the social utility of the medallion system. Perhaps there's some benefit in keeping the number of cabs limited in order to keep the roads emptier and thus more usable?

freditup··on U.S. sues Oracle, alleges salary and hiring discrimination
That means we so far have:

* Palantir sued for not hiring enough Asians [0]

* Google sued for not turning over compensation data [1]

* Oracle sued for hiring too many Asians

While it's possible that discriminatory processes have happened at all these places, it seems these lawsuits can be targeted at whoever one wishes. It's always going to be possible to find data that indicates discrimination, unless companies hire in exact quotas (which would also be discriminatory really).

[0]: http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2016/09/26/palantir-...

[1]: http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2017/01/04/google-su...

freditup··on Attachment theory is having a breakout moment
> By the end of our first year, we have stamped on our baby brains a pretty indelible template of how we think relationships work, based on how our parents or other primary caregivers treat us.

It seems that the article is stating that one's attachment system is developed primarily in their first year of life? If attachment theory is true, I would've guessed that the first ten or twelve years of life would all contribute.

> [many people] are insecurely attached because their early experiences were suboptimal (their caregivers were distracted, overbearing, dismissive, unreliable, absent or perhaps threatening)...

If the first year is the formative year for one's attachment disposition, the meaning of "overbearing" is much different than say, it would be for a ten year old or early teenager. I'm curious what period of life these studies were looking at.

freditup··on Basic Economy Fares Don't Lower Ticket Prices, They Increase Ticket Prices
NYC to Pittsburgh is actually a subpar trip in terms of Northeast train travel. It's smooth-sailing from NYC to Philly and Philly to Harrisburg, but once you get west of Harrisburg, speeds drop drastically and the resulting trip is much slower than driving. This is because the tracks are shared with other trains and run through mountainous terrain. Because the trip isn't great, it's not that heavily used and Amtrak only runs one train a day each way between Pittsburgh and Harrisburg.

It's a shame really! A high speed track between Pittsburgh and Harrisburg would really improve accessibility for the city and be well used I think. I know there's been some talk of it, but no real progress made.

freditup··on Why Skee-Ball Doesn't Change
I'd also disagree that skee-ball is a game of chance, because at the least, it's a game where how well you do is determined almost entirely by how well you roll the balls. And it's not a game, like a ring toss game, where you have to get lucky to do well.

I've played skee ball at a couple places where it really is a "pure", fair, game and it's a bunch of fun. I can imagine less ethical places doing the things you've suggested, though I've never seen it myself.

freditup··on Why Skee-Ball Doesn't Change
I've played skee-ball quite frequently and done well using this banking method (as taught to me by my grandfather!). But I'm not sure why it's better. Do you know what makes it easier when banking as compared to rolling the ball straight?
freditup··on Offline First – A Better HTML5 User Experience
What about in cases where the commands may fail because of the actions of other users? For example, say you had a virtual market in a game and someone did a "buy from John" command while offline. they then proceed to use this purchase to beat future levels. However, once the user reconnects online, it turns out that John already sold to somebody else, and thus their purchase and everything after it is invalidated.

In your command queue pattern, what sort of ways do you handle this? Have certain "chokepoints" where the user must be online to proceed? What if you have an app where that sort of chokepoint seems to occur too frequently to make the queue useful?

Edit: I think this is similar to Fiahil's sibling comment, also relevant points made there. Thanks for the quality thoughts everyone!

freditup··on Postmodernism Generator
Your comment mirrors an observation of mine (although I am a native English speaker):

Trying to read the generated article gave me a very similar feeling compared to the feeling I get when trying to read an article that's much too difficult for me. I read a sentence or two and try to grasp at the meaning of the sentences and how they relate to each other. I reread these words a few times, and eventually draw out a little bit of understanding and move on to the next sentences.

In this case with the generated text though, eventually my mind concludes that it's all nonsense and gives up on finding any meaning. With a real text, hopefully, I'd derive more meaning little by little as I struggled on.

What's interesting to me here is that a nonsensical text can produce the same "in over my head" feeling as a highly intellectual and difficult text. It seems to imply that we could be fooling ourselves when reading difficult texts - perhaps a text is all nonsense, or perhaps it's brilliant, but we have little way to tell.

freditup··on U.S. judge rejects World Chess bid to block websites from airing moves
Also useful, the highlights from the first game: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Y_h3eZQ-j0
freditup··on U.S. judge rejects World Chess bid to block websites from airing moves
I think your analogy is wrong. Many websites broadcast live "play-by-play" info on MLB, NFL, NBA, and NHL games. These are typically done, for example, by showing a graphic of a strike zone and where pitches are located as they are pitched. However, the actual game audio and video is not broadcasted. I don't believe you need any sort of license to display this information (correct me here if I'm wrong).

As far as I can tell, that's what's going on here: websites want to broadcast the "play-by-play" of the chess game, but not the actual game footage. Now, the play-by-play for a chess game is more important than the play-by-play for a hockey game, so I can see why the organizers of the chess tournament aren't happy, but I think the correct decision was made here.

freditup··on Forget self-driving car anxiety: In the early days human drivers were the fear
Oh, don't be so dour and patronizing. Of course nobody wants traffic deaths. I explicitly stated that I'm not trying to start an argument about the definition of "suck". I was simply observing that I find it amazing that our roads work as well as they do now, given human propensity for error.
freditup··on Forget self-driving car anxiety: In the early days human drivers were the fear
I'm not so sure that I'd say humans suck at driving. When driving on a busy freeway, with cars merging on and off and variance in flow speed, I find it pretty incredible that there aren't more accidents. Similarly, when in a place like Manhattan, I'm amazed that there aren't more accidents given the flow of cars, bikes, and pedestrians.

My point here isn't to start an argument (clearly the definition of "sucking at driving" is relative), but just pointing out that I'm fascinated that our roads work as well as they do, all things considered.

freditup··on The Sad State of HTML Email Input Fields and IDNs
Also with type=number fields: some support showing a leading "0" while others don't. Seems like a small detail, but it all adds up to death by a thousand cuts and custom implementations of everything.
freditup··on React Implementation Notes
> You would really have to go out of your way to make that happen, though. React has a feature for batching state updates together to prevent unnecessary rerenders if all of the updates occur together.

These batched state updates only happen "within React's walls", right?

So for example, say you had an RxJs observable that omitted a list of items to display. When you first subscribe, it emits say, ten items, one by one, but all in the same browser tick. It may emit items later in the future as well.

In this case, each of the initial emitted items triggers a full rerender and you get the O(N^2) behavior, correct? My point here isn't that this is the end of the world, but just that it isn't that crazy to say that it might happen.

freditup··on GitHub Audio
This is an interesting example where the new expanded set of TLDs can get confusing. My brain interpreted the URL as something semantically like "audio.github.com". Put another way, I thought the site was actually GitHub-made at first glance at its domain.

Of course, this was possible in various ways before expanding TLDs, but I think the problem, and thus the ease of phishing, is greater now.

freditup··on Why Are People into Event Sourcing?
As an interesting comparison, some people see the Redux/Flux pattern as a front-end parallel to event sourcing.

[0]: https://github.com/reactjs/redux/issues/891#issuecomment-158...

freditup··on After New York Attack, Congress Wants TSA to Secure Amtrak, Buses
This is a key point - airport-style security at train stations would be a disaster. Stricter employee screening and more dog-handler teams, on the other hand, is a reasonable proposition. I think it's difficult though to trust the TSA to do this well and to trust it not to escalate into something much more intrusive.

Also notable though, is that it seems that much of this is about increasing TSA intelligence / data analysis:

The new bill “addresses gaps in TSA’s approach to assessing security risks and will help the agency better fulfill its role as a hub of analysis, planning, and information...”

freditup··on Investing for Geeks
If your company doesn't do any 401k matching, how worth is is to put money into it vs. regular investing? In my case it's likely I may want access to the money before retirement age, so I'm not sure what the best option is.
freditup··on Announcing TypeScript 2.0 RC
There are a lot of other new features as well that were introduced in the 2.0-beta release: https://github.com/Microsoft/TypeScript/wiki/What's-new-in-T...
freditup··on Show HN: In-view.js – Get notified when DOM elements enter or exit the viewport
You should get about the same results using a bundler. Perhaps the lodash.throttle package is for reducing `npm install` time or reducing bloat if you check in your node modules?
freditup··on All Olympic gold medal winners in the 100m sprint compared in one race
The world record marathon time, 2:02:57, works out to about 4:41 per mile. It's incredible that someone can keep that pace for 26 miles when most (including me I think) couldn't run that pace for even 200 metres.
freditup··on Too Poor to Afford the Internet
I live in NYC and pay $35/month from TWC for 50/5. It's an introductory yearlong rate, and goes up to $45/month after a year. But if you ask really really nicely, they'll let you keep the $35/month rate :)
freditup··on Facebook rolls out code to nullify Adblock Plus’ workaround
While I hate ads as much as anyone, and use an ad-blocker myself, surely there could be some measure of illegality in the other direction also? Or put another way, surely consumers don't have a legal right to access Facebook without ads?

Edit: To anyone who downvoted this: you're perfectly welcome to disagree or even adamantly disagree with me - but it's much more productive to explain why you disagree than downvote. I'm genuinely curious to hear an argument that consumers should have a legal right to view FB without ads.

freditup··on Why It Doesn't Pay to Be a People Pleaser
But aren't interactions with nieces/nephews usually filtered through their parents, until they're grown up? Maybe it was just this way for me, but I didn't have many real interactions with my aunts/uncles until I grew up and left home.
freditup··on UAE introduces federal law banning the use of VPNs to access blocked services
What counts as a crime though? Is reading anti-government articles a crime? Is viewing women in bathing suits (say you were shopping for your wife) a crime? Is unintentionally viewing a NSFW image on Reddit a crime?

It would be interesting to know how this law is really enforced - it could range from legitimate and fair to very authoritarian.

(Note: I've heard the laws in the UAE can be strict, but I have no idea if this is factual.)

freditup··on A practical security guide for web developers
The quote at the beginning of the SO question you linked to, one of the top-25 questions of all time, is so ironic given the current state of SO:

> We believe that Stack Overflow should not just be a resource for very specific technical questions, but also for general guidelines on how to solve variations on common problems.

SO is a great website, but I wonder how much more it could've been if this sort of a page was allowed now.

freditup··on The Surprising Ease of Plain Text Accounting
Don't know why people are downvoting you, your comment was grey when I read it. I see nothing that makes your comment invalid and I think it contributes to the conversation.

Perhaps it's not the popular opinion, but in a lot of cases I agree with you. Watching over every penny meticulously can become a much too consuming habit that produces little net positive result. It's easy (at least for me) to get caught up in trying to never waste money, and it's really not worth it.

freditup··on As a psychiatrist, I diagnose mental illness and help spot demonic possession
Thanks for the elaboration on your thinking - as far as I can tell, PostEverything is sort of an "anything-goes" op-ed section [0]. I fully agree that this would be a horrible "news" piece!

[0]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2014/05/27/...

freditup··on As a psychiatrist, I diagnose mental illness and help spot demonic possession
Why do you think it's unprofessional for the Washington Post to publish this article? I personally don't see anything particularly wrong with it so I'm curious as to what you find unprofessional about it.
freditup··on Palantir Buyback Plan Shows Need for New Silicon Valley Pay System
Curious what your estimate of a 50th and a 99th percentile developer salary is for a new grad? And do you mean a 50th percentile CMU grad, or a 50th percentile CMU grad developer, or just overall?
← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →