HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bangkoksbest

159 karma · joined August 28, 2021

submissionscomments
bangkoksbest··on Schiphol conducts trial with self-driving buses on airside
Self-driving in ports is a vastly simpler problem though because the environment can be closed and controlled and devoid of any UX concerns, making it basically a simple robotics problem.
bangkoksbest··on Margaret Mead, the Cold War, and the Troubled Birth of Psychedelic Science
Not really impressed with your undamaged brain's potential.
bangkoksbest··on Y Combinator – Biggest waste of time for startup founders
Why is everything "real" about writing code, when one of the standards is making users happy? Users presumably are not simply enthralled by your GitHub repos and might like to have interpersonal interaction about what the software is intended to do for their real contexts... And writing code writing code writing code is not obviously the way to satisfy that.
bangkoksbest··on Borges and AI
arXiv is for researchers in different science and mathematics subcommunities to post pre-prints, surveys, reviews, lecture notes, manuscripts, documentation, etc... but also historical/archival research, philosophy papers, and meta-essays, as long as they are relevantly targeted to the subcommunity.
bangkoksbest··on Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
I'm an engineer and I find some of his stuff useful, particularly when it comes to thinking through how to think about how to use large p, small n data.

But I also don't have a strong reactionary anger to Deleuze's penchant for writing in an obscurant quasi-post-modern literary style, and I get that many do. In any case, it's not like similar ideas are not also worked through in less cryptic ways in contemporary philosophy of science journals.

bangkoksbest··on Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
As the parent commenter, I already put a reply you could respond to
bangkoksbest··on Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
To be fair, I did intentionally write them in a style to mimic propositional logical statements (which are tautologies) but you are correct that they're not in a formal system so they can't actually be tautologies.
bangkoksbest··on Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
Of course they're tautologies in a logic sense, and I deliberately wrote them that way (whether they are pejorative tautologies is not really a material point.) They're statements about the methods for empirical thinking, the statements were not supposed to have empirical content themselves.
bangkoksbest··on Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
The Stove essay (in truth it's a prolonged rant) supposedly extols the virtues of empirical thinking, and you invoked it to back up the sense you had that the description of Deleuze's philosophy is vacuous... And yet...

Difference and multiplicity are core to empirical data and scientific & engineering modelling. To make a measurement you assume there is a scale to measure difference. To have a variable is to assume that something can vary. To be a cause is to assume something can make a difference. To have a process is to assume a system that can change and transform. There's nothing vacuous about this.

bangkoksbest··on Please ignore the deluge of complete nonsense about Q*
The model is the instance because the instance is what is being used at inference time. The training simply produces some set of weights.

Open source would mean someone could see and run the model code locally/independently to create an instance. For an LLM, this is much less insurmountable of an issue in terms of resources needed.

bangkoksbest··on Please ignore the deluge of complete nonsense about Q*
What is human-level intelligence is a normative and philosophical question, which means it will not be resolved in some objective manner. There's no requirements for us to know, there's only requirements for us to propose in the form of norms.

The only approach we will be able to claim objectively can produce systems with human-level intelligence is procreation.

bangkoksbest··on US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban on Atomic Weapons Tests
If you write "I saw an analysis recently..." it's best to link to or at least describe the source of the analysis, otherwise the rest of us are just left with completely unsourced hearsay
bangkoksbest··on Localization Failure: Temperature Is Hard
Sure, same with heat index. They are tools for communicating the impact of additional axes (wind speed for cold and humidity for heat) on subjective perception. I won't wander out without a scarf, or neck covering, if it's freezing and 40mph winds, but I don't mind to if it's freezing and no wind.
bangkoksbest··on Localization Failure: Temperature Is Hard
Yeah, it's not like Fahrenheit or any temperature scale is literally calibrated to human perception (they're all now defined as transformations from kelvin anyways), that's just a (minor) ancillary impact that can be discussed.
bangkoksbest··on Localization Failure: Temperature Is Hard
This is not true, and it's why we developed separate scales for wind chill (which factors in wind) and heat index (which factors humidity).

Looking at the wind chill chart[0] for frostbite times, there is nothing particularly special around the freezing point temperature, even at absurd wind speeds. Ironically, actually, the 0 point for Fahrenheit is far more relevant threshold for frostbite.

[0] https://www.weather.gov/safety/cold-wind-chill-chart

bangkoksbest··on Psytrance Guide
Yeah, I'm not saying all the genres operate the same with BPMs. Compared to most house and techno events I go to, I do feel that psytrance events are a bit more "unrelenting" in bpm where I wish there was more variety.
bangkoksbest··on Psytrance Guide
Because it's how DJs connect tracks together. That's the target audience for purchasing psytrance, and most electronic dance music, tracks.
bangkoksbest··on Causal inference as a blind spot of data scientists
Acyclic structure on variables is a very strong pre-supposition that, honestly, is not how many systems in engineering are well-described by, so I don't like this idea of boiling causality solely down to DAG-dependent phrases like "d-separation" or "exact causal structure". Exact causal structure a.k.a. actual causality is particular to one experimental run on one intervention.
bangkoksbest··on Tesla sued for severe harassment of black workers at California plant
Yeah, it's a civil case, not criminal. Only criminal trials should have standards as high as criminal trials do because only criminal trials punish you by taking away your personal autonomy and freedom. Civil trials cost you money, so obviously the standard is lower.
bangkoksbest··on Tesla sued for severe harassment of black workers at California plant
The standard for civil cases is literally "a preponderance of the evidence"...
bangkoksbest··on New insights into the origin of the Indo-European languages
Yeah, my wife is Ethiopian and she was shocked to see in TV news coverage how "Ethiopian" a lot of the Houthi rebels in Yemen looked, but this is actually not surprising once you know the histories of the Horn of Africa and Red Sea at a greater detail.
bangkoksbest··on Booking a Ryanair flight via an online travel agent might hold a nasty surprise
Yeah I definitely have experienced more delays with them than with Ryanair. I rarely experience any meaningful delays in arrival time with Ryanair, so I'd say they are the best deal to service ratio.
bangkoksbest··on Booking a Ryanair flight via an online travel agent might hold a nasty surprise
Another thing I like with the discount airlines like Ryanair and Wizzair is that, because they are dirt cheap and point-to-point, I end up visiting places on a whim.

For example, a couple months ago I noticed I could take an affordable weekend trip on Wizzair to Cluj-Napoca in Romania (never heard of the place before); I booked the flight, visited, and found it a very lovely little city that was perfect for a 2 or 3 day weekend trip.

The caveat of course is that they nickel and dime everything, so if you need hand baggage or don't want flight attendants trying to shill perfume mid-flight, they are annoying to fly with, but on the other hand you pay much less so if those aren't big issues, then the deals are great.

bangkoksbest··on Booking a Ryanair flight via an online travel agent might hold a nasty surprise
There are times when booking through Ryanair over their app gives €X price, but through some 3rd party like Kiwi I might find e.g. €(X*0.5).

However, even though I almost always fly with just a small bag, I still might hesitate taking the 3rd party service because they insist on doing stuff like checking in "for me", which I don't need (since that is a trivial process), and I have experienced them not sending the boarding pass in the time I arrived at the airport.

bangkoksbest··on Generative AI space and the mental imagery of alien minds
I mean, theoretical physics models are still physics models. Functional analysis is still a valid mathematical tool for physics modeling even if it doesn't (usually) produce finitely calculable solutions. Physicists assign physical interpretation to certain parameters, even if they are not (yet) observable.

I suppose there's probably a higher mathematical representation going on here that is finitely computable though. Something like a symbolic representation of the solution functions for the wave function are calculable even if the parameter values are not.

bangkoksbest··on Generative AI space and the mental imagery of alien minds
There are physical models are not computable (in the sense of producing number values in a finite algorithm), particularly in quantum physics, e.g. the wave function.
bangkoksbest··on Tokyo Is the New Paris
I suppose I should have thought of that—I'm wearing Japanese raw denim jeans right now—but I forgot all about fashion, so good point bringing that up. I don't know if there's much "you have to be in Tokyo" for, given the exportable quality of clothing, but it's a fair point on cultural output.
bangkoksbest··on Tokyo Is the New Paris
I'm assuming there is a fuller post behind the paywall because the one that I see seems extremely short.

I'm also going to assume the author is referring to the mythical Paris of the early 20th century for its artist/creative opportunities. If that's the case, a couple things:

1. None of us actually experienced early 20th century Paris, so we judge it romantically on the output (particularly in English/Spanish) of creatives living there.

2. Do we have (or the author have) evidence of a similar kind of creative output (particularly in English/Spanish) from Tokyo? My sense is no, even though I like Japanese food and Japanese punk. I don't like or follow anima/manga so maybe that is a blind side for me to see such evidence.

3. Tokyo is cheaper than Paris/NYC/London, but it's still not super cheap, and Japan is not the easiest country to move to. I'm not aware of many "creative" foreigners moving semi-permanently to Tokyo in anything comparable to Paris, 20th or 21st century.

bangkoksbest··on Douglas Hofstadter changes his mind on Deep Learning and AI risk
Those first two points are pretty wild assertions that are offered without much compelling evidence.

The final two points are more plausible, although the last one is sort of tautological since any risk is by definition something we aren't certain won't happen. However part of their plausibility as risks is because the first two points are not anywhere near our current state, and therefore it's unclear to us how to clearly evaluate risks that are based on unknown and possibly fictional contexts.

bangkoksbest··on Ask HN: Is it just me or GPT-4's quality has significantly deteriorated lately?
Pretty strange that I would think of myself under a new identity if I moved to a new place with a different social perspective. Seems like that is a deceptive abuse of what the word "identity" entails, and, while sociological terms are socially constructed and can be defined differently, I find this to be a very narrow (and very Western-centric) way of using the term.
Page 1 of 3Next →