HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

acephal

195 karma · joined October 8, 2019

submissionscomments
acephal··on Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness
>Whatever the Abrahamic influence on the course of Aristotelian thought, there is no reason to believe that Abrahamic influence was absolutely necessary to "universalize ethics" (take the early Stoics, for instance). This is expected and returns to my original point, that much of ethics is knowable in principle through unaided reason alone.

Aristotle directly refutes this in Nichomachean Ethics, this is why I wrote that it is “a very qualified doing”. He asserts that you can’t simply “get good” at committing virtuous acts because they require the correct upbringing firstly (“it makes a very great difference; or rather all the difference”); a good amount of that text reads like a parenting book; you can’t turn the skip later in life. So when you say:

> freedom to choose between alternatives apprehended by the intellect

I don’t think this is exhaustive in describing what’s going on in Nichomachean Ethics to any degree to render all else negligible. Given the way he talks about “soul” (a word which also conveys the worst interpretation of what he’s talking about in De Anima), it becomes clearer to me why conditioning is so important to him.

acephal··on Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness
>One very common error people make is to believe that ethics - at least epistemically and for the most part - is sectarian. This view seems to stem from an ultimately nihilistic presupposition that morality is a fiction supplied by the fiction of religion. But that is not the natural law view and thus a view alien to both Aristotle and to Christianity.

I didn’t make that claim in any implied way, I asserted, correctly, that Aristotle is not an Abrahamic thinker.

> The natural law view is that human beings have a nature, which is most centrally to be a rational animal with the freedom to choose between alternatives apprehended by the intellect. Thus, Man has moral responsibility, because he plays a part in choosing what he does. Accordingly, because human nature defines what is good or bad for human beings (that which actualizes human potential in accord with reason vs. that which frustrates or opposes reason and the actualization of potential in accord with it), we bear responsibility for how we exercise our powers. Aristotle wasn't completely, but the core principles in the Metaphysics or his ethical works or in epistemology are - in my view - spot on.

The Nichomachean Ethics doesn’t discuss ethics within any context of absolute free will even, it is a very qualified doing. Aristotle explicitly points out that the actions of slaves are entirely disqualified from being considered ethical. Most Christian theologies would vehemently disagree precisely because having the supra-knowledge of the Mystery imparted upon one necessarily brings one's being into the dimension of revealed universality. That's not what Aristotle is talking about.

> What Christianity does or claims to do is supplement what is knowable by unaided reason with revealed knowledge - the object of faith - which, of course, does have ethical import, but it does not negate or supplant what is knowable by unaided reason.

All three of the Abrahamic theologies were infected by Neoplatonism, which . The Europeans revived their Neoplatonism through the Muslims even. The Middle Ages Christian theology of the "chain of being" is a riff on Neoplatonist "ladder of being".

Aristotle was describing in Metaphysics a cosmology concerned with unpacking the notion of motion as the actualization of potentiality, hence, "First Mover", which is not at all an Abrahamic idea.

> FWIW, Aquinas drew heavily from Aristotle and had such enormous respect for Aristotle, he referred to him as simply "the Philosopher".

This doesn’t interact with my point since it requires us first to ask how he read Aristotle, whom was not an Abrahamic thinker. An aside, but the Muslims called Aristotle “The Philosopher” (Ibn Rashud, Ibn Sina), and that tradition was received through the Muslims by their European readers.

acephal··on Aristotle quotes on virtue, knowledge, and happiness
It’s weird and messed up because Aristotle’s audience isn’t Christian or even Abrahamic the slightest. He’s right about rejecting abstract definitions that aren’t grounded in the elements of a situation however.
acephal··on June in Servo: real world compat, media queries, SharedWorker, and more
New browser engines have not
acephal··on What was nice about the UI of Windows 2000
Sad watching Apple design repeat Microsoft’s mistake of trying to push through a single UI paradigm across mobile and desktop (and, especially, VR in Apple’s case)
acephal··on Learn SQL Once, Use It for 30 Years
The amount of em dashes in Nietzche; the amount of semicolons in Hegel
acephal··on 2002: Last.fm and Audioscrobbler Herald the Social Web
> My favorite thing about Napster and LimeWire was when you could find a song, and then BROWSE the hard drive of the person hosting that song.

Soulseek lets you do this and is still going

acephal··on Framework Raises DDR5 Memory Prices by 50% for DIY Laptops
From what I've read, he's tied up RAM manufacturers through 2029. That's a lot of quartely earnings reports for many firms in the economy where they watch consumer spend come to a screeching halt.
acephal··on Framework Raises DDR5 Memory Prices by 50% for DIY Laptops
Altman should be jailed for this. Single-handedly crashing consumer spending in an entire sector of the economy. At the very least for the reason that that was supposed to happen _after_ they had the AI in hand to supplant majority white collar labor, not before.
acephal··on DeepSeek-v3.2: Pushing the frontier of open large language models [pdf]
Facebook itself still has a big problem with it's lack of youth audience though. Zuck captured the boomers and older Gen X, which are the biggest demos of living people however.
acephal··on WBlock: A New Ad-Blocker for Safari
Is there any reason to prefer uBoL over Pi-Hole/Adguard Home?
acephal··on Are you stuck in movie logic?
The famous French psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan claimed that if everyone said exactly what needs be said, language wouldn't exist or something like that. I'd wager movies are a reflection of how our psyche works, including 'main character syndrome', omissions of causality for narrative coherency, etc.
acephal··on AI isn't replacing jobs. AI spending is
Only in America is this kind of anti-labor sentiment masquerading as "if you knew what was good for you now look what happened", as if businesses were so stupid as to be fooled by "if we don't make it apparent, they won't notice" and somehow this would shield programming from off-shoring. The actual reality is that post-WW2 exceptionalism in literacy ended; the developing world caught up. The entire premise of American labor exceptionalism was built on this faulty assumption. And rather than reconfigure your negotiation as labor, your first thought is how you can get back in the good graces of the 'big boss'.
acephal··on Dark mode by local sunlight (2021)
I never use this. Where I live, one will require dark mode well before the calculated sunset.
acephal··on Lux: A luxurious package manager for Lua
I've been awaiting the rocks.nvim team to migrate to this
acephal··on "Be Different" doesn't work for building products anymore
Yes, this is why the biggest winner of LLMs is off-shoring
acephal··on macOS becomes iOS: Safari video controls
Last I touched a Linux desktop was 10+ years ago and you had to muck about with FontConfig and third-party config packages to even come close to Windows or macOS type rendering. Has this seen significant improvement?
acephal··on Bring Your Own Agent to Zed – Featuring Gemini CLI
Any highlights?
acephal··on "None of These Books Are Obscene": Judge Strikes Down Much of FL's Book Ban Bill
Yes, the story I'm referring to also features veiled homosexuality (the King is only alone with the assassin cause he thinks he's gonna fuck him)
acephal··on Another reason to use expendable email addresses for everything
iCloud is almost justified by the number of expendable email addresses one can allocate
acephal··on "None of These Books Are Obscene": Judge Strikes Down Much of FL's Book Ban Bill
Don't forget the story in Judges where a Hebrew assasin stabs an obese Canaanite king in the gut and he shits himself but his guards outside the room were already used to him shitting himself so ignored the smell.
acephal··on Nobody knows how to build with AI yet
I had Claude, as an agent, get into an infinite loop trying to resolve a diagnostic in Java test that any human would easily figured out and fixed in a second.
acephal··on Where's Firefox going next?
Firefox's WebExtensions implementation still has service workers disabled and no File System API. MV3 requires service workers, so Firefox extension ecosystem is on a countdown.
acephal··on Study links mindfulness and meditation to narcissism and “spiritual superiority”
This is also Joe Rogan and his "just eat mushrooms" ideology
acephal··on Manifesto of the Silent Minority
High likelihood most of these responses are from well-placed SREs
acephal··on Netflix raises monthly charges for U.S. subscribers
Highly recommend watching the Italian show Gomorra
acephal··on The Vikings Were More Complicated Than You Might Think
And Russia and Ukraine
acephal··on The Vikings Were More Complicated Than You Might Think
Of whom Queen Elizabeth is a descendant
acephal··on Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
>At first glance, these dates may seem much too recent to account for long-isolated Indigenous communities in South America and elsewhere. But “genetic information spreads rapidly through generational time,” Rutherford explains. Beginning in 1492, “you begin to see the European genes flowing in every direction until our estimates are that there are no people in South America today who don’t have European ancestry.”
acephal··on The Foundations of Liberia
>Like who, Umkhonto we Sizwe? Patrice Lumumba? The MPLA?

We're talking ground-floor interactions from what I've seen that obviously do not speak to any kind of unanimity but a surprising extent nonetheless. One such video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkKi1vC_IEA

> Is this new? The South Africans had Buthelezi to go around the world criticizing the anti-apartheid movement, and there were ones before that.

The writers in question weren't criticizing the modern anti-racism movement in America, however, but the form of its response and its presumptions. Perhaps a minute difference but one nonetheless.

Page 1 of 4Next →