After a friend mentioned Arc to me today, I gave it a try. I'm a long time Brave user and have no love lost for Chrome these days (though I need to stick to Chromium browsers for plugin compatibility reasons).
* First launch is a full screen, loud ass, unskippable video. I literally Cmd+Q'd the browser right there and then. If it wasn't for my friends insistence I try it, that would have been the end of my Arc experiment right there.
* The "Login before you start" is stupid, I get it, but stupid. As a techy who uses lots of devices, something that has built in sync is actually appealing to me.
* The settings is a strange mix of UI/UX's. There is clearly some quasi-chrome settings in browser, but then a settings screen that is more traditional Mac pop-out style. Sometimes one links to the other and it's...disjointed.
* "Max" the AI tooling has potential. While I love ChatGPT, I don't need AI in everything and it really annoys me when AI is shoved into products unnecessarily... so far so good on Max. The "ask on page" feature works surprisingly well and the 5 second previews is cool on a site like HN.
* ChatGPT in the command bar. Cool, I guess. It's just a quick way to get to your existing chatgpt account. I'm glad it's my account and not yours - so win for that. Too bad Cmd+Opt+G is taken by Google Drive.
* It's tab management is ... fine? That's something that will clearly take some getting use to.
* Spaces & Profiles. I don't like that a new profile needs to have a new space create first. It's unintuitive for those of us who are used to profiles from Chrome. I get that Arc is trying to allow us to organize. But I want two VERY separate worlds. One work, one personal. Just allow me to create a new profile directly from the Profiles settings, and open that into a new window. Like every other chrome-clone
* The tiny stupid URL in the left bar is... tiny and useless and stupid. But you can View > Show Toolbar easily - so that's good. In a world in which the web is an ever more dangerous place, obfuscating the URL to the point in which I can't even read the domain... is poorly thought through.
* The import system seems to work extremely well. It imported all my plugins (which all work, awesome) and even my session cookies... so getting "up and running" is much easier.
* Sync only sync's open tabs. So it's effectively useless.