1,822 karma · joined August 4, 2009
HN can be one scary angry mob which is nice to be backed by, but horrible to be on the end of. Remember the Aria Richards debacle which was heightened by this community. Just one of many. (That wasn't my intention by the way and everyone's been pretty calm.)
The HN effect is a strange one. :)
But anyone can get a site at foo.tumblr.com and post anything. So there brand can be attached to absolutely anything.
You raise some great points and if they feel the need to protect their brand then I understand. But it was a website to HELP their users.
I think the biggest thing was the fact they spent all the time removing Missing E rather than adding a few features people wanted.
For example, when flying to Germany I had the Lufthansa app. An hour before the flight it popped up on my home screen and stuck there. (As in, no cancel.)
Then when I go to the airport, I swiped it and the lady just scanned it in - and me and my girlfriend both had our tickets printed.
The truth is that it's easier to critique in person than online. If you don't know someone's personality and can't read their nuances it makes it a lot harder.
But thats a very good critique advice.
If I were to buy a tshirt for HN, which I might possibly do - I'd want it to show off a message rather than it looking like it could be for anything. This doesn't feel personal to the brand to me – I could buy this anywhere for a number of reasons.
And of all your description of what you want the community to be - do you want it full of snark like your response? Your response was far more 'schoolyard bullying.'
We're adults here, if we can't take critique without crying foul - the internet isn't for us.
(And this is not me attacking, or having a go.)
Everyone saw this coming. Everyone. I don't understand how they couldn't prepare better?
Mitsubish are selling product, while this is a portfolio design and thus should require less attention while you work on clients.
The solution is not to blame the victims of the theft. Agreed that shaming isn't always the best idea either though.
I've used both Browserstack and Mogotest on and off the past few years and I have to admit its invaluable.
A BIG THANKS to all those who've upvoted this.
We're really trying to get the two disciplines together. As someone who's done well in both fields, I know there's tension and I know that it can be scary to want to learn more. I'm hoping to bridge that gap with some amazing speakers and workshops :)
Apple are exactly the same too. The stuff I love the most has come from elsewhere.
As said, the the article itself was good though.
I'm not sure what's to learn from this other than: * Tumblr is down * Killing the DNS is bad
But the latest series of flat designs do often rely on rounded corners too. Glad you wrote this though as I was about to do the same :)
But, it's an interesting suggestion I am sure many of us have pondered. Although a distaste for startups that sell out quickly as we have learnt time and time again: everyone has their price.
If you ask for $5000. Chances are you're going to get closer to that, than $50,000. If you ask for $500,000. Chances are you're going to get higher than the $5,000.
Plenty of people have gone for the big dollars. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/obsidian/project-eternit... Granted it's Obsidian, but people still blew it out the water.