HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yterdy

634 karma · joined May 20, 2022

submissionscomments
yterdy··on Don Bluth's Garage Band
>Some are that way I suppose but as I was learning, many far more experienced, late-career gurus went out of their way to teach me. It does require asking good questions and showing some genuine interest and engagement in learning though.

IME, reminding them of themselves is far more important than any curiosity, aptitude, or drive you may bring to the table (other than in that it reflects their self-image). That similarity often creates a pseudo-familial affinity which serves as the unconscious backbone of the relationship. This is the reason why cross-ethnic and cross-gender (and cross-class, cross-sexuality, etc.) mentorship seems to happen less often than when the mentor and prospective mentee are of the same gender and ethnic identity.

You got lucky and/or are a straight white dude in a field largely occupied by straight white dudes. What happens for the rest of us is usually one of two outcomes:

a) The mentor makes an effort to support the mentee, but holds them to unreasonably high standards per unconscious bias, generally causing the relationship to disintigrate over time.

or

b) The mentor is threatened by the prospective mentee's aptitude appearing in an individual that they can't bring themselves to relate to; they will withhold support, if not actively impede their growth.

yterdy··on Don Bluth's Garage Band
>As Bluth remembered, older technical tricks like the “shadows or the reflections or the double passes through the camera” were “evaporating before our very eyes.”1 The problem was bigger than that, too. Bluth and many of the other young trainees didn’t know how to make a movie, and they weren’t sure how to learn. According to Bluth’s colleague Gary Goldman, “We didn’t even know what questions to ask.”

>“We were learning to animate,” Goldman explained. “We were learning to in-between, clean up … and we said, ‘Wait, there’s so much more we need to know.’ ”

>That included writing, scene planning, editing and more. Even the Nine Old Men had “forgotten” much of what went into Disney’s older films, said animator John Pomeroy.

IME, this is an incredibly widespread problem in the Age of the Retiring Baby Boomer. Many of them jealously guarded their professional knowledge, for fear of replacement, or simply never documented it. When it comes time to pass it along to juniors, they either can't or won't; then, with little official notice, they're out the door, and you're left building from first principles or trying to make sense of process spaghetti. I'm not sure if this is better or worse than the Boomers who stay on into their 70s and 80s - still refusing to train their juniors, but also preventing the advancement that would allow younger workers to even attempt to learn the position. ...No, I suppose retirement is better. At least there's some runway, instead of the incumbent simply dying one day and leaving everyone scrambling.

EDIT: >and there was a sense among the garage artists that Disney’s management didn’t care to implement most of the lessons from Banjo.

“All of our learning is only going to do us any good,” Pomeroy remembered thinking, “if the higher-ups will accept what we’re trying to make happen.”

And there's the other side of the deal. When you make people go off and learn things on their own, they often learn... that they can go off and do things on their own. Disney sort of won in the end, but Bluth was a thorn in their side for quite a while.

yterdy··on 'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal world scientists argue
>But there is a vast gulf between humans, even those with severe developmental disabilities, and the smartest animals. Only a handful of animals can even pass the simplest knowledge to other, or learn by seeing others of their kind do something.

You're not doing your argument any favors with this kind of hyperbole. Many animals mourn and communicate that mourning. Many animals have been shown to pass along information to others about helpful or hurtful humans, good places to hunt or forage, even elements of culture like behavior or personal calls. African wild dogs will die of a syndrome akin to heartbreak if separated from and unable to communicate with their group.

It's not too much to say that humans and other animals think and communicate differently. Most do not have the physiological capacity for certain types of advanced and abstract thought that are central to our own experience of reality. But that's a far cry from having no semblance of conscious cognition. Too many animals exhibit behavior indicating an awareness of the self as a separation from the other and the environment for your characterization to be unequivocally correct.

yterdy··on 'Irresponsible' to ignore consciousness across animal world scientists argue
Prairie dogs are another example that likely goes against your understanding. They also serve as an example of how we might miss complex communication in other species: researchers had to slow down their chirps and calls in order to find the patterns that made up their syntax and grammar. I imagine that LLMs will be useful in the future in helping us to find patterns in behavior or vocalization that might serve as language or language-like communication.

Also, in response to your second point: most people with domesticated pets could give examples of deception or signalling intent.

yterdy··on Ghost Shark: the huge stealth advantage of autonomous submarines
These feel like a technology that should be approached like mines, in that a breakdown in military capability or will conceivably leaves untold numbers of these roaming the depths (or sinking and disrupting habitats) without anyone knowing where they are or what they could do if you came into contact with one. It would be a not-good thing to turn the entire ocean into a Zone Rouge.
yterdy··on One UX researcher ignited changes to how the company (YouTube) built product
There are Firefox/Chrome add-ons that do this, but of course this doesn't help you if you're on your phone. I finally nixed everything but the search bar from the homepage in the hopes of avoiding game spoilers in rec thumbnails.
yterdy··on One UX researcher ignited changes to how the company (YouTube) built product
Oh, so it's their fault YouTube is a disorienting, addiction-driving hellscape now. Good to be able to put a name to it.

>The homepage showed a bunch of videos that were driven by a mass algorithm (and was pretty much the same experience whether a person was logged in or not).

This was good. Your experience was grounded. Same thing with every video showing the same recommendations for at least a few weeks at a time. The idea that UIs need to be constantly shuffling content so that you can't tell which way is up as you navigate and will therefore submit more fully to The Algo is poisonous.

yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
I would question if that has changed in a significant way since. I also don't know that a single anecdote suffices. I've seen enough just on this site to be confident in my wager. You're going to find more tech workers who are hopping mad about DEI than ones who would risk their employment or perception of their own safety for the safety of black people.
yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
I actually tend to agree. Characterizing it as a terrorist attack was a mea culpa; it is absolutely better categorized as a counterattck/insurgency against an occupying force.
yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
No, we cannot agree to disagree. 3 of your 4 statements are verifiably false. Notably, 33000 dead over 6 months is roughly a 9/11 every 2.5 weeks (if you're going to say, "I said 2 weeks," I said 2.5 weeks). You are wrong. You should ask yourself why you cling so hard to that. It is your duty as a human being to recognize and denounce the genocide that is taking place.
yterdy··on Google Fires 28 Employees After Multi-City Protests
Also Marc Andreesen, weirdly:

https://twitter.com/pmarca/status/1778898760971821271

yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
Your opinion is incorrect and concerning in its confidence. Oct. 7th has been characterized as Israel's 9/11 (with, frankly, fewer deaths). Meanwhile, Israel has perpetrated a 9/11 roughly every 2.5 weeks for the past 6 months in Gaza. The difference in Hamas versus the IDF's allowance of accessibility to basic needs is also stark. In essence, a terrorist attack is not proportional to a siege.
yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
We should also mention why the chances are slim. There are several components to this, with regard to the West's role in the matter: the role of the military-industrial complex, the ramifications for further reparations to other groups, and the ramifications for elections in the US. Point-by-point, very briefly:

1) Israel is an important intelligence ally, military foothold in the region, and both source and buyer of military research and applications. Anything that disrupts this arrangement risks hundreds of billions of dollars and the perceived national security interests of multiple countries.

2) Reparations to Palestinians would not only be extremely expensive, it would also raise questions of potential reparations to other victims of Western imperialism and apartheid, including to Native Americans, Native Austronesians, and much of the African continent and diaspora.

3) Securing the existence of Israel as an ethnostate drives political support from Western Zionists and Evangelical Christians. Even a change to a more stable, secular, multi-ethnic Israel would see not only the revocation of support but also active retaliation that, at best, would get your a chapter in a Profiles in Courage reboot.

yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
I think it's funny that you think that tech workers would protest police brutality against black men, let alone in such a way that would put their jobs on the line.
yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
She's saying that the alleged Oct. 7th rapes (or at least their characterization as widespread) are a hoax, echoing previous hoaxes. Without wading in too deeply, I do think that the fog of war makes conclusions difficult, and an investigation after all this is over is warranted. I do also think it's very disingenuous to point to rape as a crime exclusive to Hamas when sexual assault of Palestinian prisoners happens regularly in Israeli jails.

Suffice it to say, the statement above doesn't disqualify the speaker, any more than someone saying, "The deaths in Gaza are a tragedy, but all I care about is that the hostages come home."

yterdy··on Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2B Israel contract
That's begging the question, unless you have evidence that they did something else that falls under defacing or vandalism.
yterdy··on Identical twins both grew up with autism, but took different paths
Here is me encountering the pitfalls of speculation as a layman: the phenomenon I stumbled upon is already well-documented.

Thank you for the link and explanation.

yterdy··on Identical twins both grew up with autism, but took different paths
No, I do think this is still an example of disordered expectations. What you're pointing out doesn't strike that notion as valid; it expands it from "an expectation of a response to an entirely different question, " to, "an expectation that you will pretend to be and behave as a neurotypical person to suit my comfort even though I know that you're not."

Which is probably worse.

As the other reply mentioned, there is an empathy (double empathy) problem, but the answer is not for one party to have to assume responsibility for the other's comfort entirely by having to guess all of their unspoken emotional desires for the conversation. "The query explicitly didn't include [...]" is kind of a ridiculous thing to expect someone to respect or even predict.

Also, I don't mean to pick apart your comment, but:

>Neurotypical communication 101 is that a casual conversation question about your favourite things is probably a cue for you to be enthusiastic and effusive about things you care about rather than a prompt for you provide names only

I don't know that this is true. If anything, doing this seems to get on their nerves.

yterdy··on Research into why some people have a better sense of direction
While we're fixing this, I'd also like a "South-up" option. Maybe even "West-up" or "East-up" one.

I'm not joking. Beyond training one to think about their location in multiple orientations, it also opens your eyes to assumptions one makes about places based on their location. West Wing famously flipped the script (literally), but there's also the lateral bias to think about. Go into Google Maps and flip it 90 degrees; does your understanding of distance, shapes, and spatial relationships of "familiar" geography change?

yterdy··on Identical twins both grew up with autism, but took different paths
Because the explicit query was, "What's your favorite episode?". It's frustrating to be accused of disordered thinking on your part when the actual issue is disordered expectations from the other party. What they actually should have asked was, "What happened during your favorite episode?", which might have produced the response given by the sibling.

It's not like neurotypical people don't also experience this frustration with having to divine what people actually desire in any given quantum of communication. I would even offer that people speaking with those on the spectrum might be primed to be less generous and forgiving with that anticipatory instinct; they jump to, "This person is weird," instead of considering the ways in which their own communication style is wanting. The reason they can get away with it, and autistic people can't, is simply a matter of how many people like them are around to validate their subjective experience. See your given CS department/TTRPG club for the flipside of this dynamic.

EDIT: Might also explain the phenomenon of smug, "What you ACTUALLY wanted was-" responsed on SO. We've trained people with precise thought to assume that anyone coming to them with questions doesn't actually know what they're trying to accomplish. We've created monsters.

yterdy··on Upscayl – Free and Open Source AI Image Upscaler
Video2x/Waifu2x GUI. Unfortunately, the models they ship with are tuned towards anime.
yterdy··on Upscayl – Free and Open Source AI Image Upscaler
Unfortunately, for video, nothing I've seen yet has matched the quality of Topaz Labs' (paid) tool. Clarity and consistency always seem to be an issue with other implementations. If love to be proven wrong because I have a project that's stalled due to the low quality/resolution of the source.
yterdy··on First-in-human implantation of bionic device to halt Crohn's disease (2023)
Taking this tangent and riding it: it's well-known that undiagnosed celiac disease in children stunts growth. After diagnosis and transition to a gluten-free diet, there is usually a period of catch-up growth (which unfortunately does not close the gap fully, usually). If there are a bunch of these silent sources of malnutrition, it could - alongside things like poor perinatal care for mothers and children, as well as the various sequelae of America's high level of economic inequality among developed nations - be one piece of the puzzle for why the adult height of Americans has stalled when compared to Europe (which would be an empirical finding and not just gussied-up scientific racism).
yterdy··on How the California forest that was Endor in 'Return of the Jedi' was obliterated (2022)
That's one way of putting it.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/07/29/olympics-i...

COP displaced 30,000 people (though, I suppose it's not as bad as Seoul, where over 700k people lost their homes due to Olympics redevelopment).

yterdy··on Why Are Older Americans Drinking So Much?
Also, responding to the racism (embedded in American culture, in a sense, through the propaganda of big businesses chasing profits in, shall we say, agricultural interests) of the white American middle class. As with lebensraum, the American suburban experiment doesn't make a whole lot of sense outside of a hysterical need to ethnically cleanse one's neighborhood.

Older people who live in cities and planned, theme park-like communities - which facilitate car-less, low-distance daily social activity outside the home - tend to do better.

yterdy··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
Africa runs on WhatsApp (atleast, West Africa, Kenya, Uganda, Egypt, Tanzania...) IME.
yterdy··on Vision Pro: What we got wrong at Oculus that Apple got right
Layman's take: All of them are afraid of making the system that fulfills the promise nominally, but that lacks some key component or is on hardware that doesn't get adopted, only to have a competitor swoop in, clone that system with the necessary fixes, and essentially do what Apple did with MP3 players and smartphones. They're all trying to establish market dominance BEFORE giving us a reason to use the devices (bass ackwards) - and are even happy to see the market collapse, if it meant that, simply, no one cracked that particular nut.

Apple, Meta, Microsoft like how things are right now. These pushes are much-hyped, but they're made less out of real passion for the promise and more desperation to avoid being left behind.

yterdy··on Why are most sofas so bad?
Contrary to those coming out of the woodwork to tell us how much we can't have dignity and decent things, let me just, "Hear, hear!" you.

We have so much stuff we don't need, and we barely scratch the surface of utility of the stuff we have before throwing it out.

yterdy··on OpenAI board reappoints Altman and adds three other directors
Club, ain't in it, etc.
yterdy··on The hottest trend in U.S. cities? Changing zoning rules to allow more housing
In this case, it does. It (and accusations of incivility) is also right in-line with the historically racist and classist character of these discussions. You think that you're being polite, but it's a "measured" tone in service of monstrous ends: continuing a status quo that sees Americans routinely without shelter, or insecure in it. It is selfish, it is irrational, it is egotistical.
← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →