HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xenocyon

2,460 karma · joined May 10, 2019

submissionscomments
xenocyon··on I moderate /r/kafka; people mistake it as a subreddit about kafka the product
Impenetrable bureaucracies are actually the central theme of two out of three of his full-length novels.

(Incidentally, at least in my opinion his three novels are his finest work, but they seem to attract much less popular attention than his short stories and novellas.)

xenocyon··on Why lifeless AI is not intelligent
Is this simply an argument in favor of genetic algorithms or is there more to it than that?
xenocyon··on Letting users tick a ‘none’ checkbox
IMHO, the bad nature of much of the UX we see around us is in the gray area between incompetence and malice. It's hard to sincerely concern oneself with usability when the main objective is to manufacture consent, manipulate the user into doing something you want, and use novelty or gamification to engage or convert. The poor design, flashy animations and other such cruft are a byproduct of this mentality - they may not always be inherently malicious in themselves but they are the result of a mindset which doesn't truly prioritize the user's interests.
xenocyon··on Griswold Cast Iron – History, Value, Identify Guide
> Life is too short to spend babying a pan.

Strangely enough, this is a good reason for preferring cast iron over Teflon! Cast iron is close to indestructible, whereas with PTFE or other non-stick coatings one is constantly worried about scratching.

xenocyon··on Indian Railways Works Manual (2000) [pdf]
Another factoid to add to your list:

Indian Railways is a state owned enterprise - a very large one. Until recently, India's central government released two annual financial statements (budgets) each year: one for railways, and the second for everything else.

xenocyon··on I'm “still afraid to use spaces in file names” years old
Not exactly spaces, but I have been bitten by something like this at my work quite recently. A Confluence page with special characters in the page title was working fine for a while. At some point there was a Confluence version update which made the page URL broken (and apparently unrecoverable, or at least not easily recoverable).

One way to look at it is that people of a certain generation eschew spaces because the tools of their formative years simply couldn't handle spaces - but another is that the olds have learned that generally erring on the side of KISS ("Keep it simple, stupid!") isn't a bad idea.

xenocyon··on The popularity of e-bikes isn’t slowing down
The ebikes I am familiar with have a governor such that the power assist turns off entirely above 20 mph.
xenocyon··on The “Ultimate” ThinkPad (2020)
Where do you find well-made batteries? OEM batteries for my X230 are no longer available, and I've had a hard time understanding which third party batteries are safe.
xenocyon··on Timeline of the Human Condition
For me at least, this xkcd graphic really made clear how anthropogenic climate change is truly unprecedented in the planet's history - it's the massive rate of change. And it's going to be impossible for the biosphere to adapt well to so sharp a spike.
xenocyon··on I’ve been reading a whole lot about tomatoes
For one thing, your own source shows that tomatoes are a rich source of many different vitamins, minerals, and fiber. But furthermore, this treatment of nutrition is a little reductive. You could eat highly processed food that is formulated to deliver the desired daily value of major nutrients, yet it would fail to deliver the same benefits as a simple diet of fruit, vegetables, small fatty fish, and nuts - even if the latter isn't optimized for nutrients. Why is this? We don't seem to know enough to answer at this time, but it appears food is more complex than a tabulation of various nutrients.

So does this mean we should be trucking tomatoes long distance? Not at all. People should eat whatever fresh produce grows locally, and supplement with canned or fermented foods that capture the benefits of faraway and out-of-season crops without the downside of wastage and shelf-life optimization.

xenocyon··on By 2500 earth could be alien to humans
"By the end of this century we'll have the technology to make carbon capture"

We have this technology already. It's called "trees". Whether we choose to use it is a different matter.

Environmental sustainability - like most hard problems in the world today - is not so much a technological challenge as a political one. I do believe technological progress in the future is a certainty, and will bring many good things with it, but it will not do the hard work of encouraging humans to do the right thing. That is something we have to do for ourselves.

That's the bad news. The good news is that this work is something we can do immediately, right now, without waiting for the hope of our utopian Star Trek future to become reality.

xenocyon··on Countries are gathering in an effort to stop a biodiversity collapse
I'm paying close attention to the direction that (my native) India takes w.r.t. GM food crops, which have so far been illegal.

Background: India went from colonialism-induced massive serial famines to self-sufficiency and then some, while entirely eschewing GM foods. (NB: this doesn't mean there is no malnutrition in India, where inequalities are rife, but it means that the country as a whole is able to produce more than needed. The causes of hunger are non-intuitive; for e.g. the dumping of cheap foods is more likely to cause hunger than solve it, as hunger stems from poverty which stems from economic disablement - which is caused by dumping cheap foods.)

Now, the Green Revolution did result in a loss of biodiversity (among other problems) but without creating the kind of monocultures you see in the US. For example, there are still numerous varieties of rice in India, especially locally variated.

Despite this, the Indian government has been increasingly warming over recent years to introducing GM foods (which is largely a solution in search of a problem, in the Indian context). The threat from GM foods is almost always misunderstood. It is not about the individual health effects of eating GM foods; it is about the largescale replacement of a system where farmers own their biodiverse seed, with a top down monocultural approach that essentially makes farmers franchisees of a massive corporate behemoth and eliminates biodiversity, putting all eggs in one basket.

xenocyon··on Southwest new CEO denies walk-off rumors, defends pilots amid schedule meltdown
"Even" HN? HN is massively prone to conspiracy theories and misinformation. Just to pick one example of many, I have seen more Covid denialism on HN than any other milieu I'm part of.
xenocyon··on U.S. Tech Salaries Grow, but Not for Everyone
Regarding Simpson's paradox, you can see a good treatment here [0] describing whether splitting a group is correct or not (based on causality); see Section 2.2 specifically.

[0] http://ftp.cs.ucla.edu/pub/stat_ser/r414.pdf

xenocyon··on U.S. Tech Salaries Grow, but Not for Everyone
"The more dimensions you analyze, the close to 'truth' you can get."

Data scientist here. The above is not the correct takeaway from Simpson's paradox. It is not generally correct that the trends seen in subdivided groups are closer to truth than overall groups; sometimes the opposite is the case. It depends entirely on what the divisions are and whether they make sense.

With regard to gender-based pay disparity, there are a multiplicity of factors, from the most obvious ("equal pay for equal work") to other factors such as the fact that professions largely staffed by women tend to get paid less than professions largely staffed by men. For instance childcare is miserably compensated, despite being a position of high responsibility and impact.

The consensus regarding women during the pandemic (not limited to tech workers) was that women have disproportionately sacrificed their careers to cover the needs of childcare and at-home schooling during the pandemic.

xenocyon··on The Perils of an .xyz Domain
As a consumer, I can see both sides of this. On the one hand, I like energetic spam blocking without fear of legal liability, even if there are occasionally a few false positives. On the other, I do not want ISPs/telecoms to be the arbiters of traffic (net neutrality).

The net-neutral solution is for ISPs/telecoms to not spam-block, but rather have spam-blocking be an optional, additional, layer that the consumer can choose at will, or not have at all. But the problem with that solution is that it requires the consumer to do extra work to obtain spam protection, and the consumer would not be protected by default. It also means extra work by all parties delivering spam messages. Unless spam ceases or things otherwise change, I think the clunky solution we currently have is fine for the most part.

xenocyon··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
> But the U.S. murder rate is not all that remarkable, really.

The data appear to disagree with you: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:2010_homicide_rates_...

xenocyon··on Will Xi Move on Taiwan?
* India: the Partition led to massive loss of life, displacement in the tens of millions, traumatized communities, and deadly polarization between peoples to this day.

* Palestine: the end of the Mandate and the 1947-1949 Palestine war saw largescale displacement, loss of life, and (as is obvious to everyone) once again a deadly and unshakeable polarization between peoples that persists to this day.

On the one hand, it is certainly true that the British did not intend for these consequences, but on the other, the British were fully in charge as the sovereign government of India and Mandatory Palestine (unlike the US in Vietnam or even Afghanistan) - in particular having ruled India for over three centuries by the time they left - and so more deserving of blame.

xenocyon··on Smart kids should skip high school (2015)
Another way to drill down into the question is to start with smart kids and then, if people more or less agree with that, to talk about all kids.

Think about it: if smart kids benefit from a more personalized, stimulating, and nurturing approach to education, then this is even more true for the kids who are less intelligent. Why do we assume that the kids who are academically behind are well served by an apathetic, inflexible, impersonal system?

For example, consider very small classes taught by highly trained, highly motivated, highly paid teachers - but instead of having this be the solution for an elite cohort of "smart" kids, let this be the solution for all kids.

xenocyon··on Our fridge just emailed us to say we opened its door too many times
In that case, depending on your hardware, you might be able to simply disable wireless transmission (on my CPAP machine, this is called "Airplane Mode").
xenocyon··on Our fridge just emailed us to say we opened its door too many times
I have a CPAP machine. Your doctor is telling the truth. If insurance is involved (even if it's a high-deductible plan and you haven't hit the deductible), they typically require the data verifying usage.

You're directing blame at the doctor, but it's the insurance company making the rules, not the doctor.

xenocyon··on We still believe in private offices (2015)
The article is self-congratulating and glosses over its contradictions. An office enclosed in glass is not private. The insistence that remote workers have an equal footing in terms of online meetings is rendered dubious when it's followed by the fact that lunch and beer are considered highly important for connecting with coworkers. These contradictions are acknowledged, but then quickly glossed over. It's a corporate PR piece, not a rigorous take.
xenocyon··on Financial literacy is a passport to financial freedom
The article talks about financial literacy as it pertains to ordinary folks.

But - perhaps more relevant to the HN audience - I have noticed a surprising amount of financial illiteracy among the tech-savvy middle-to-wealthy class as well. A lunchtime conversation with my coworkers showed that most put more faith in their own instincts with picking stocks than in index or mirror funds (something that evidence shows is very unlikely, but people like to believe). Another time, I found that a majority of my coworkers were filing their stock-option taxes incorrectly.

Though no doubt wealthy folks are more literate (including financial literacy) than the poor, my suspicion is that most of the difference in financial outcomes comes to the fact that poor people simply have less capacity to save than middle/wealthy, and more severely feel the impacts of poor decision making.

xenocyon··on A Convivial Chap Led Easily Astray: On G. K. Chesterton
The first part of your assertion is subjective and the second is really not true at all; for e.g. Orwell (neither a "petty" nor a "modern" writer) roundly called out Chesterton's flagrant antisemitism, as did many others in his own time.
xenocyon··on Court rules California's Prop. 22 on Uber, Lyft drivers unconstitutional
Unions vote for union leadership, not management. Are you speaking of general elections? While some executive positions are elected rather than appointed, they are still elected by the public at large, not by union members. In fact, public sector management is generally not pro-union any more than private sector management.
xenocyon··on Ask HN: Recommend sunglasses made in the west and independent of Luxotica
Shuron frames are made in the USA, have an iconic style, and in my experience have been more durable than any other frame I've had. https://shop.shuron.com/
xenocyon··on Police can get your data – even if you aren’t suspected of a crime
Was it mandatory to comply with such a request? I was under the impression that mandatory court orders need to be signed by a judge (not a prosecutor).
xenocyon··on The recycling myth: A plastic waste solution littered with failure
You're leading with energy use but that's really not the point.

The point is that plastic takes many centuries to degrade, and we go through a lot of single-use plastic. For example, a disposable diaper takes >500 years to biodegrade.

It's nice to imagine all this plastic going into walled-off landfills that protect the rest of the earth and water from being contaminated, but in practice this is a myth. US localities are seeing an unsustainably growing amount of plastic contamination in local waterways and beaches, some of it visible, some of it not.

Incidentally, this doesn't mean you need to use a single-use paper bag instead of a single-use plastic bag. Instead, use a durable bag made out of any material you like. The phrase is "reduce -> reuse -> recycle". Recycling was never meant to be the foremost part of our sustainability efforts.

xenocyon··on What does the "mean" really mean?
> In many systems, the mean really does summarize the whole

That's quite true, and the same statement also points to where the arithmetic mean isn't a good choice: where the goal isn't so much to summarize a whole as to give an insight into populations. For instance, if you are trying to figure out the "average" income in a city, the median provides better intuition than the mean.

Furthermore, there are many situations where both the mean and median (and even the mode) fail to provide insight. For instance, the average person has one testicle, whether defined by mean or median (and even the mode is not much help here, with its equally useless value of 0). We should really think of summary stats as something to only be used when a distribution is well understood. In other cases, a simple frequency distribution diagram provides much better insight, and isn't very hard to do.

xenocyon··on Sheriff’s Office letter targets residents for ‘increased accountability’
I think it's worth remembering that this is an elected position, and this sheriff is overwhelmingly popular, to the point where he ran unopposed in the last election. Per the Tampa Bay Times:

Nocco's uncontested re-election in 2016 is indicative of the sheriff's popularity, his political prowess and the county's continued tilt to the right, which puts Democrats at a decided disadvantage during general elections. Pasco's current registration numbers show the Republican Party with a 21,000-voter advantage over Democrats.

"I'm incredibly blessed that the citizens have so much faith in what we're doing,'' Nocco said about an uncontested re-election.

(https://www.tampabay.com/news/politics/local/sheriff-nine-ot...)

In short, no improvement can be expected when the voters themselves support this kind of authoritarian overreach and curtailment of human rights.

Page 1 of 10Next →