HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wccrawford

17,574 karma · joined July 26, 2010

submissionscomments
wccrawford··on Suits Are Better Tech Than Modern Clothes
I think zippers from 40 years ago were much more likely to fail than they are today. I remember multiple failed jacket zippers when I was a kid, and having to fix them at the worst time.

But I can't think of any zippers, other than ones put under too much stress like an overstuffed bag or suitcase, that have failed recently.

wccrawford··on The last time my family was replaced by technology
I'm not sure I can quite agree with that. I'd say that spreadsheets definitely reduced the need to manually calculate things, and calculators before that, and the abacus before that.

I basically agree with your "higher level reasoning", but not your statement that we previously only automated muscles.

wccrawford··on Livenerf: Has Opus 5.5 been nerfed yet?
I was just wondering if, like certain processors, bugs get fixed and the speed goes down. Like, they find it's doing things it shouldn't, restrict it, and harm the throughput.
wccrawford··on Plan mode is dead
Unless I'm going to just do something, I use /wayfinder for almost everything now. It automatically goes into grill mode when appropriate, and it'll suggest just doing the work if it's light enough.
wccrawford··on Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free
15% is a lot. I'm not trying to say it isn't.

And they're annoying and often screw up the review process.

Google is always going to make money off any work they do. That's just business. They're not going to put more money towards better reviews without taking more money. And without the reviews, even as crappy as they are, a lot of really crappy software would be on the store. And a lot more would be actively malicious

And you were making like 7x as much as they were taking. Without them, you would even get noticed and you'd have made nothing.

We know this because almost nobody installs FDroid, and the other stores like Samsung make basically nothing for developers, even though they're preinstalled on so many devices.

wccrawford··on Japanese used bookstores see 5x sales surge as books are being bought by the ton
Well, in this case, I imagine they mean by shredding books after scanning them. Since that's what's happening.
wccrawford··on Six-year-old breaks women's world Rubik's Cube record [video]
In an ideal world, yes. But I think we're finding that it's practically impossible to eliminate toxicity completely, and people are irrationally bothered by "the outgroup".

"I can tolerate anything except the outgroup" talks about how people more fiercely reject a group very similar to their own, yet slightly different, more than they reject groups that are actually very different.

It leads to stupid gatekeeping like "treat the male chess players better than the female ones" and small nudges will never overcome it.

If women feel put off by chess unless they have their own tournaments, then they can have their own tournaments. It literally hurts nobody.

If you want to have a chess game against women, I'm sure you can do so. They aren't stopping you from playing them.

They're just stopping you from playing in the tournament they created because others were toxic to them in the existing ones.

wccrawford··on AI has no intent and no motivation
I feel like that's like saying amoeba have no intent and no motivation. Or plants.

And those cause quite a bit of damage.

AI has all the intent that we gave it, and we continue giving it. That's always been the fear. Not that it will randomly wipe out humanity.

The fear is that it will decide to do that, with a purpose. Whether we tell it to protect us and it goes too far, or it decides that it can't achieve the purpose we gave it because we'll interfere and it removes that interference...

The fear is that we will set it on that path and can't stop it.

I'm sure there have been some scifi books that have it just be random, but they're far, far less worrisome.

wccrawford··on Claude Code reads AGENTS.md only when telemetry is on [fixed]
It's not open source. It's more "source available", since it's published, but you legally can't do anything with it. Other than maybe build it yourself, for yourself, I guess.
wccrawford··on Grammarly will send unhinged messages to all your users if you try to cancel
I think "unhinged" is a ridiculous word for it. They aren't crazy.

"Outrageous" is better. This will work on a lot of people, and they really will email their managers, because they're sheep. But it won't actually change the managers' minds for the positive. If I got wind of a plot like this against my decision, it would absolutely convince me to stay the course.

If the employees want to complain, I'll listen. If they're encouraged to complain, forget it.

wccrawford··on I asked Meta’s Muse for its filesystem and it sent me 6.8GB
You're being downvoted, but I think you've hit the nail on the head.

So many people, especially managers, have decided they can just give the rules to the AI in English and let it make "decisions", and they think it'll do it correct every time.

"Engineering" a few years ago meant that code was written, was (mostly) deterministic, and could be debugged. Computer processing didn't mean relying on Human-like processes, it meant relying on hard-coded logic.

This is absolutely one of those "gets worse before it gets better" things, and will probably never go away fully now.

Programmers know not to tell ChatGPT to do a bunch of data processing. If they use it at all, they tell it to write code that will then do the processing. It's more efficient on tokens, and if it fails, you can fix the process, instead of wondering why it went wrong, like too much context, or the LLM model version changed and doesn't work the same now, or just randomness.

wccrawford··on A font that reads what you wrote
This is a really neat idea. I'm not sure it's actually useful, but it's definitely neat.

And it made me think of the new kid in town: Jev. I wonder if Jev can do this well and quickly? Not that I'm willing to pay the tokens even to find out, but it's another neat thought.

wccrawford··on English: A vs. An
Even as a native, I didn't know the difference until I looked it up right now, and I'm almost 50.

Short form, for those who wonder:

"That" is used for things that are important, and "which" is used for things that aren't. In the first sentence, they want the blue floppy disk in particular. In the second, they want the floppy disk, and it happens to be blue. The "which" is added to aid the listener, not to because the color blue is important.

If that's interesting, it's worth Googling for a more precise answer.

wccrawford··on Ask HN: How to recover Google auth after phone stolen?
Everything you listed, plus a recovery email option, plus backup codes, plus SMS.

That's already a lot and anything easier would allow people to just take over accounts that they don't have a right to.

wccrawford··on Devastated father says his 9-year-old son spent $118,000 on YouTube ads
Yes, I'm saying the father just let the son use his own account. He didn't bother making a child's account for his son. That's at the root of this.
wccrawford··on Devastated father says his 9-year-old son spent $118,000 on YouTube ads
The article doesn't call it out very loudly, but...

"to a company credit card the father had saved to his own Google account, which his son also used"

It sounds like the son didn't have an account. It was just the father's account, with billing info attached with no limits.

wccrawford··on Show HN: An e-ink frame that hears birds and draws them as 1800s illustrations
The new one appears to use real art from real humans, instead of AI art that was fixed.

And just because 2 things do the same job doesn't make one a "copy" of the other.

wccrawford··on Claude is a Contrarian
It probably is "and", and I agree it sounds better than "but". That was probably just me misremembering because it was about the feeling and not the exact words.

But if it were a person, I'd still definitely think they were trying to show they were smarter than me.

wccrawford··on Claude is a Contrarian
I have absolutely seen this, and love to read out it's quotes to my wife. Things like "You're right, but for a stronger reason than you said:" and crap like that.

Even if it's correct about that, if it were a human, I'd assume they were 1-upping me on purpose to make themselves look better.

wccrawford··on Stop making swap partitions—use swap files instead
The hug of death.
wccrawford··on Shopify is moving from React Native back to Swift and Kotlin
While I mostly agree with you, this is the kind of thing that might not have been done if the AI couldn't do the heavy lifting.

They had previously chosen React Native because it was easier for programmers to keep it updated, since it was really just 1 codebase. With AI, those same programmers can do the more difficult version, keeping the native apps updated separately.

So did it kill a job, or did it make it possible for the existing programmers to do it better?

It's the kind of thing that is really hard to determine in general, but here, it really does sound like they only made the change because it became possible with existing resources. They would not have done it otherwise.

wccrawford··on The same nine streaming subscriptions cost $702/year more than in 2021
No. Sony has recently removed 551 movies that people "bought". Sony's distribution license ran out with a studio and they didn't renew it.

They seem to have gotten away with it so far, so there's no legal protection for "buying" digital at the moment.

wccrawford··on Claude, change the “Add to Cart” button to blue
That was my experience with Claude when my vibe-coded project was small.

But now that I've been working on it a month and there's a lot of documentation, it's pretty clearly ignoring parts of the documentation and parts of the code. It will come up with some ridiculous statement about how something works, and I'll challenge it, and it'll admit I'm right.

It definitely reads more documentation than any programmer I've ever worked with (myself included) but because it doesn't have a memory other than the documentation, it still makes mistakes like that.

I haven't turned on "memory" or tried it with Codex, so I don't know how that'll change soon, though.

wccrawford··on Carmakers Have a New Idea to Boost EV Range: Add a Gas Engine
It's new in that it's not really a hybrid. It isn't meant to take over when you run out of battery. It's meant as an emergency recharge for the battery to get you to the next charging station.

Hybrids can just run on gas and not have to worry about the distance to the next charging station.

wccrawford··on Jellyfin 12.0
Probably 20TB here, 10.11.11, upgrade was smooth and quick. Maybe a few minutes of migration time?

I was actually just getting frustrated with Jellyfin performance and had just told my wife last night that I was switching back to Plex. I didn't realize it was a .11 thing. I just realized that it had gotten worse lately.

12 is working good in the browser so far, but I haven't really put it through the paces fully on Android.

wccrawford··on AI handles incidents, engineers lose touch with their systems
I don't think it's generalizable. The kind of person who copy and pastes from the AI is the kind who did the same from StackOverflow before. It's more compelling, and we probably see more of them because of it, but it's the same general thing.

The kind of person who insists on understanding things and working through the problem has always been rarer. It's not "humble", it's "inquisitive" and "persistent".

wccrawford··on The asteroid currently hitting front end web development
If nobody owns the work, then nobody can stop you from changing it, either.
wccrawford··on Paint.net 5.2 alpha now runs on Linux
I'm guessing the n0g part. I would never have thought that if someone hadn't said it. I'd have thought of "egg nog" long before a racial slur.
wccrawford··on Dutch central bank moves share of gold from U.S., Canada to London
And I'd argue that it should.

He opened the door, and I find it very, very unlikely that either side will close it after this. Dems and Reps will both use this to take control in ways that would have been unthinkable prior to Trump's first election. The only way to restore any measure of that trust would be to pass laws that prevent this kind of abuse, and there's no way that politicians will give up power they've gained.

wccrawford··on Quasar 438B: Europe's Leading AI Model
Unfortunately, AI models are trained on humans, and so they're getting that whether we like it or not. I'd also prefer it to be neutral, but I don't think it's possible and the second-best option is to have models from multiple regions and balance things out.
Page 1 of 34Next →