HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

varelse

2,997 karma · joined October 19, 2011

Perma-banned, if you're reading this, you opted in, don't get all huffy that I hurt your fee fees. I am a very bad person and if you're that delicate, opt out.

One snarky comment a day keeps the Sam Altman Fanboys at Bay

Or you could just delete all my comments but you won't because this is creepy.

submissionscomments
varelse··on A surprisingly hard CS problem: sums of square roots (2018)
Back in the day, the downvotes here would flow like a river at the suggestion that an engineering career behooved one to understand Calculus and Linear Algebra with Statistics and Differential Equations if possible thrown in for good measure because Peter Thiel said college degrees were worthless and he was even offering $100K to some lucky winners to prove his point. Admittedly, I would have probably taken that offer had I been 18 and then gone to college afterwards, but it seemed to deliver mixed results.

For the above math comes up again and again writing software. Pure math like real analysis, graduate level algebra, number theory and topology not so much. I'm guessing the rise of AI demonstrated the previous mindset against math was poppycock all along so now we've gone to the opposite extreme and made it a religion? I think people are bringing their own biases into that interpretation and you are right about which biases.

But, also, not my problem. My personal bias is that I recognize this problem as exactly the sort of thing that gets brought up as a gotcha interview question by people who couldn't come up with that exact solution themselves yet understand it just enough to use it to make an interviewee squirm.

varelse··on The Writing on the Wall: Sci-Fi’s Empty Techno-Optimism
Sci-fi authors get to do whatever sci-fi authors wants to do. If the author of this hit piece has a problem with that then maybe the author should be writing science fiction that exemplifies what is apparently now required of it according to his new rules.

Or maybe he should just go back to reading some Nevil Shute or some Walter M Miller if he thinks science fiction is so optimistic across the board.

varelse··on Nvidia prepares to abandon $40B Arm bid
Likely Qualcomm bales them out as they have offered to do so and eventually takes them over quietly by osmosis so no one notices until the deal is done.

https://www.barrons.com/articles/qualcomm-offers-to-rescue-a...

varelse··on A surprisingly hard CS problem: sums of square roots (2018)
Not going to criticize you, I think it's a cool math problem, but I've experienced people throwing problems like this at me at job interviews in the past so it echoed. And in those cases, they weren't looking for an answer, they were looking for the answer they knew about and no other answer would do. I once ended an interview early over one of these questions.

I am relentlessly production focused but that doesn't mean I don't like math. But by the time you get to FP64 with this thing, the probability of finding a fail case seems insanely low and in fact for the most part you can provably bound the error of the sum and therefore likely prove you have found the solution. Anything beyond that is a corner case as the mathematicians love to say. And now I see the criticisms coming.

varelse··on Meta Unveils New AI Supercomputer
Which itself requires hours of listening to alternative influences in order to develop, no? The pressure to conform within 2 sigma is strong in almost any society IMO.

What people don't seem to grasp is that most of the supposed alternatives to mainstream are pretty mainstream too or we wouldn't have stores like Hot Topic in the first place.

varelse··on Meta Unveils New AI Supercomputer
Those models are surprisingly tractable. You're nowhere near as interesting and unique as you might think you are at scale.

Evidence: actual work experience at building latent representations to characterize customer behavior at FAANG. It's hard to come up with something that really gets you, but it's not hard to come up with something likely to make you spend more. You're surprisingly predictable on that axis and even if you aren't because you put the hours into being a crazy outlier, almost everyone else is, and you don't matter.

varelse··on A surprisingly hard CS problem: sums of square roots (2018)
And I admitted it's a cool pure math problem. The challenge in the tech industry is balancing the rigor of a pure but nearly intractable solution with using the theory to pump up an O(n) imperfect solution to acceptable reliability. I find the latter more interesting, YMMV.

But if that isn't as interesting as the original problem, maybe stay in academia? AI itself is an example of tailoring activation and pooling functions to deliver imperfect solutions that are "good enough" to ship. It's unfortunate these two viewpoints are seen as contradictory rather than complementary, but that does echo our political balkanization so I guess I shouldn't be surprised.

varelse··on I was deceived about Covid vaccine safety
"red pilled" + "Glenn Greenwald" == bozo bit already. Add "Robert Malone" and we have the guy with a clever brainfart unwilling to do the gruntwork to ship that brainfart as a useful product so no, not changing my mind one bit.

Downvotes welcomed and expected snowflakes, I am truly aiming for zero karma here as an experiment and a commentary on Sam Altmann's hell site, so you're doing me a favor with your downvotes, have at me.

while I hate being part of a flash mob science experiment myself, and while I will not be surprised if there are long-term negative consequences to repeatedly vaccinating, I will be even more surprised if they are worse than the consequences of repeatedly catching variants of this horrible thing because we politicized masks and containment efforts. So I picked the least crappy option according to my doctorate in biochemistry. You do you. I'll do me.

varelse··on A surprisingly hard CS problem: sums of square roots (2018)
Sure and there are a lot of simple ways to improve the accuracy of the simple approach before you go for the pure math sledgehammer here. It's all a question of how accurate the answer needs to be.

For example, It's pretty easy to come up with an FP64 error bound on the sum. And if the difference between the two sums is greater than that error bound you don't need to do anything more complicated. Where this would get complicated IMO is if you were dealing with 128-bit or higher integers.

Edit: I am learning so much about the mindset here and what triggers acute attacks of the heebie jeebies. This place has really changed in the past decade since I joined and not for the better. Yes good, good, more downvotes. Show your love with downvotes. I'm stuck at 2970 karma, only you can help me on the journey to zero. Can we beat -4? Let's find out.

varelse··on A surprisingly hard CS problem: sums of square roots (2018)
This problem is a perfect example of better is the enemy of good enough. What's striking here is that the simple FP64 solution is for the most part more than good enough for any practical application you would find working in Tech. Anything beyond that is likely unnecessary gold plating.

If I were asked this on a job interview and they didn't accept that answer and started going on about me missing the pure math here that would be a great sign that such a place probably doesn't ship things very often. I would also bring up that no one can solve the traveling sales problem either but that approximately optimal solutions run the world of logistics on a daily basis.

Yet much like you can dedicate an entire supercomputer to calculating the energy of two hydrogen atoms to arbitrary precision, it's a really interesting problem with respect to the pure math. But come on, the guys most likely to bring this question up are relying on 16-bit floating point to train their neural networks.

Exponent.Mantissa.Boom. In practice, I know just about no one anymore who can tell me the format of 32-bit or 64-bit floating point because they're so used to abstracting that away.

varelse··on Uniqlo dangles $8.8M salaries to draw talent in Big Tech showdown
In tech, engineers that aren't paying at least some attention to the compensation of their peers will not fare well IMO. No one wants you to undervalue yourself more than the org underpaying you to undervalue yourself. I'm for open compensation personally, but since we can't have that lest there be madness or something, make sure your grass is sufficiently watered to remain green.
varelse··on Uniqlo dangles $8.8M salaries to draw talent in Big Tech showdown
Raising the ceiling on compensation for exceptional talent seems like good business strategy to me. This is a great time to understand technology as we become a science-hating culture completely addicted to science and technology to survive. Milk it for all it's worth no matter what your skill level. If your boss can afford to buy bottled farts from reality stars and Bored Ape NFTs they can afford to pay you more.
varelse··on Starlink satellites hindering detection of near-Earth asteroids, study finds
You say we can't wire up America, but what's your source? I'm not personally seeing a problem with a TVA-level engagement to bring high-speed Internet to as many people as possible. Starlink looks like it will be half the price, but Musk has gone on record saying this is for rural areas.

https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/03/musk-...

Further, I was getting 150 Mb a few months back, but now I'm down to 30 Mb. This isn't a polished product yet and it's in danger of losing federal funding.

https://broadbandbreakfast.com/2021/12/starlink-download-spe...

varelse··on Starlink satellites hindering detection of near-Earth asteroids, study finds
Sure but between the current situation and the outskirts of Wyoming and Montana there's plenty of low-hanging fruit.

For example, my neighborhood is 1.5 mi away from gigabit internet. Good luck with that last mile and a half so Starlink it is.

The study I'm linking here says it would cost $80B to fix the current situation. That's chump change. I am so fed up with the tiny minded thinking that is trapping America in an endless loop of failure. But watch trillions materialize instantly if we have to go to war with someone again.

https://www.brookings.edu/research/striking-a-deal-to-streng...

varelse··on Starlink satellites hindering detection of near-Earth asteroids, study finds
And yet countries like Vietnam have pulled exactly that off. If we have $1.7T for the f-35 fighter, we have the money to give everyone 100 Mb or better internet, it's just a matter of priority. I'm a satisfied Starlink customer but only because there are no other viable alternatives currently where I live.

https://www.defensenews.com/air/2021/07/07/watchdog-group-fi...

Since the comparison to Vietnam is triggering some people, let's add some hard numbers and really get the downvotes going.

Vietnam's GDP is $271B, The US is $21T or ~77x higher with ~3.4x as many people living in a space ~30x bigger than Vietnam. And yet we still cannot deliver cellphone reception and broadband on par with Vietnam. Wonder why? Also wonder why this is such a triggering statement to make but I guess some things will just remain a mystery. And won't you do your part to bring this post to -10? We can do this together.

varelse··on A $3B bet on finding the fountain of youth
From what I have heard the CEO is not only worse than you imagine, he is worse than you can imagine. But it's all scuttlebutt and hearsay for now. Rich aging VC got to reach for those stars...

http://www.cafepharma.com/boards/threads/hal-barron-racks-up...

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/banks-ready-34-billion-financ...

varelse··on A $3B bet on finding the fountain of youth
There's 6 years of free beer longevity just figuring out what the United States is doing incorrectly and what Hong Kong is doing right. I wonder what that's actually worth.

https://www.worldometers.info/demographics/life-expectancy/

varelse··on Google Kills YouTube Originals
It's a golden age to me and I don't know how long it will last. But I'm all there for the spin-off shows that would have once been fanfic on Usenet and little more. Have you seen Peacemaker? It's utterly amazing and I'm happy to wade through oceans of crap to get to gems like this. I am genuinely beginning to wonder if James Gunn made The Suicide Squad sequel so he could make a TV series out of Peacemaker.
varelse··on IRS Will Soon Require Selfies for Online Access
Cue the emergence of "This taxpayer does not exist."
varelse··on Felony charges are first in a fatal crash involving Autopilot
To give your car a devil tempting you to do something stupid like let down your guard and trust it to do the right thing which it will usually do right up to the point it doesn't?
varelse··on Can a squid fly out of water? (2010)
Why is this trendy? I looked into this yesterday and I found this video because it's trendy but why is it trendy?

https://youtu.be/4hCa0sEJl_4

varelse··on Toxic culture is driving the great resignation
So there are a number of people on this site who are not at that level and they get resentful that someone might get a deal like that rather than try to find a path to getting a deal like that for themselves. That's crab mentality and it helps no one.

The way to get there is to refuse to sign non-compete agreements unless they come with an equivalent clause to what I got. When you sell yourself short, you sell everyone else along with you.

varelse··on Toxic culture is driving the great resignation
There's a trade off between exploration and exploitation. And sometimes, because they put on their best face to recruit you, you can't figure out that a seemingly promising idea is actually nonsense and it will never work without joining the effort for at least a month or two to go far enough down the rabbit hole until you realize it's full of manure.

I've lasted anywhere from 30 days to over a decade depending on the gig. And every one of those moves was the right choice. I prefer to rely on my own research of the person's career track and the number of people they can summon as references to say nice things about them. Tech culture brings out survival traits and I'm not going to hold anything against people who act in their own best interest.

varelse··on Ask HN: Should I publish my research code?
You absolutely should publish the code and dump it on GitHub somewhere. I did that 20 years ago on sourceforge and it backs up a lot of claims that would otherwise get dismissed as me making s** up. Plan ahead and make sure you have the receipts because if your research ever becomes relevant you want to have all the receipts.
varelse··on Toxic culture is driving the great resignation
Yes you have figured out the secret (tm) in my opinion. Sturgeon's law applies to tech which is to say 90% of it is crap. Don't waste your time with that 90% and if you find yourself in one of those positions feel no guilt whatsoever running away as fast as you can.
varelse··on Toxic culture is driving the great resignation
RSUs happened IMO because Warren Buffett didn't understand tech. But they're fine, really, the same competitive pressures that led to compelling ISOs now lead to compelling RSUs. Not sure what problem that solved though but give me a couple beers and I'll probably come up with one.

https://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/11/business/stock-options-ar...

varelse··on Toxic culture is driving the great resignation
I once had to sign a non-compete that came with paying me my full salary during the noncompete period to do anything but what I was doing. I was great with that. And when I left, they chose not to enforce it anyway, but I felt like that was a fair deal.
varelse··on More than 1M fewer students are in college, the lowest numbers in 50 years
In the short term I agree with you that trades pay very well, $250,000 a year even at the higher end. Even more if you're willing to risk your life on power lines or windmills.

But that's a starting wage in tech in Seattle or the Bay area for an engineer that's in demand and it only goes up from there. Those engineers that are in demand all have undergraduate degrees, it's a huge virtue signal for hiring for now. A new college graduate with one year of industry experience got poached for $400k by a competitor. And that doesn't begin to cover what AI superstars make straight out of school.

Ironically as someone in the later phases of my tech career, I am increasingly interested in trade skills over tech skills. And doubly ironically there's a lot of intellectual overlap.

varelse··on Toxic culture is driving the great resignation
If I have to sign an agreement that gives my employer permission to terminate me at any time for any reason with or without cause, they should not be surprised that it also grants me the right to quit at any time for any reason with or without cause.

And yet, all that fuss about these job hoppers. How about creating an environment and culture where sticking around beats job hopping instead?

As for the alternative? Check out the severance packages that executives and TLAs get. Try scaling that down to the employee level. Not going to happen.

varelse··on Toxic culture is driving the great resignation
And that's the thing, it's okay with me if I'm wrong. Or as I responded to a doctor who asked a similar question: "Do all your patients live?" It's not a question of being special to me, it's a challenge to figure out what will make them stick around and make the company money and it's usually strongly correlated in my experience.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →