HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

utopiah

1,781 karma · joined December 9, 2014

See https://fabien.benetou.fr for more, code at https://git.benetou.fr and videos https://video.benetou.fr
submissionscomments
utopiah··on Ask HN: What are you reading?
DCC book 4

The economy of anonymity by Amaya

Artificial Intimacy by Sherry Turkle, just out

utopiah··on Why Is Sam Altman a Free Man?
It's a plutocracy. Maybe it wasn't obvious until now but the current administration is quite clear about when one is invited to buy a dinner with the commander-in-chief by donating to his crypto coin.
utopiah··on Show HN: A working 3D model of an Enigma machine
> bit nervous about putting it out there before I'm sure that ...

At the risk of being presumptuous I believe that's the wrong way of looking at it. The point isn't to show the entire World that everything you did is perfect (because it's not, for anyone) but rather to grow from potential collaborations, even if only just discussions in issues. It is a humbling process to show how something was built but with a positive crowd it is definitely leading to growth!

utopiah··on Show HN: A working 3D model of an Enigma machine
Neat, would be great to have it in WebXR with hand tracking, imagining 2 modes :

- AR where the machine can be put on your desk, next to documents

- VR where the machine is in context, e.g. a 3D model of German Naval Signals HQ in Guernsey, eventually stepping back to a broader context.

utopiah··on US sanctions force The Netherlands off Microsoft and toward alternative NixOS
I think it's true but only in equitable societies.

Putin or Trump are totally isolated from economical and political consequences so they have no problem severing ties. If there are genuine co-dependencies, including for the leaders, they it's much harder to break peace.

I imagine the ideological aspect is the deeper motivation but it only matters with the right circumstances.

utopiah··on MicroLLM Lab – Try 7 tiny LLM's in the browser
Firefox on Linux doesn't support WebGPU https://caniuse.com/webgpu should enable via a flag.

Adding a warning about it could help.

utopiah··on Show HN: PaperMono, e-ink fridge magnet shopping list with mobile web page
I'd check https://github.com/Josh-writes/microslate-firmware/ for the xteink as it is less focused on only reading, but keep in mind it's a screen only, so not touch. Buttons though are pretty good so enough for tick items on a list IMHO.
utopiah··on Jensen Huang says AI distillation is 'competition.'
Guy who sells shovels says there is gold everywhere, go figure.
utopiah··on Malleable software: Restoring user agency in a world of locked-down apps (2025)
> I want a world where ...

> I have the skills and desire to do these things.

Please check out my page on the topic https://fabien.benetou.fr/Content/SwappingPartsOfTheRestrict... and let me know if I could improve it somehow to help you.

Overall though my recommendation is :

- do what you can TODAY no matter how small

That means if the OS is too big a of a step, start with an application. If the hardware is too locked down, start with data so that next time you buy hardware, you will bring over that data then switch. Don't postpone.

utopiah··on Fakecloud: Local AWS cloud emulator for integration tests
> decoupling your services from cloud providers

doesn't it boil down to not using unique services?

If nobody provides an alternative today that could switch as quickly as changing an endpoint and token then you are coupled.

It's not a technical decision as much admitting in the strategy that we are cutting corners because it's cheaper/faster today but some hypothetical day in the future when we'll magically have more resource we won't?

utopiah··on When did Google get so weird?
If you are serious about the topic check out "Artificial Intimacy: Who We Become When We Talk to Machines" by Sherry Turkle coming out tomorrow.

It's not about NVIDIA stock, it's not about your latest harness, it's not about code review on generated code, instead it's about what happens to us when something not human fakes being human and the dangers of it.

I only started reading it but if it's as fundamental as her previous "Reclaiming conversation" then I expect it to change my life for the better, even if it means fighting against the dangerous behavior of the majority of people around me.

An AI is not a person and when you elevate it to that status you lower yourself. It is very dangerous, even more so when it's done, like mobile phone and engagement more broadly before, for profit.

Protect yourself and those around you, regardless of how you like or dislike AI, and trust actual humans specializing in studying human behavior, not psychopaths craving billions.

utopiah··on The Murky History of Soviet-Born Tetris
Tetris: The Games People Play 2016 graphic novel by Box Brown is pretty good too.
utopiah··on Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free
That's because you the user are not the customer of Google and such services. You are actually the product being sold to the customer, namely advertising companies, by Google.

The farmer take care of his pigs but only to the point they get slaughtered.

utopiah··on We're gonna need a lot more mathematicians
> Maybe the model is just getting better, and maybe I'm being less careful while under pressure to ship more and more often. But model capability is obviously growing.

If you are a normal person research (e.g. https://arxiv.org/html/2606.22721v1 but there are a lot more, not necessarily on coding) has shown that you indeed are being less careful. It most likely also works better simply because more resources are being poured in.

utopiah··on What even is an OS now?
I feel like most articles challenging OSes have no idea what an OS is.

Sure question what the latest tool can offer and how to integrate with it... but that's just being an app, or a window manager, or a package manager, or a distribution, that's not challenging what the OS itself is and does.

If your OS doesn't change how a computer allocates resources, then you are talking about higher level, and that can be super valuable too, arguably more valuable, but ... that's a different thing.

PS: also chroot (half a century, just checked for the fun of it), jails, containers, VMs, etc limiting how the allocation can be done do exist and have been used for decades already.

utopiah··on Yes, Claude can do nine loops
I'm an AI skeptic, or even anti-AI, and even I would have a hard time to admit it hasn't gotten any better.

In fact I will even admit it, yes AI has gotten better... but also how could it NOT? It has literally all the resources it can has, namely attention from everyone, everybody talks about it, a lot of workers, from state of the art researchers to annotators, all the material resources, from dedicated chips to networking to water to electricity, the entire available dataset of Human written and said thoughts, literally everything published and thus categorized.

AI literally has everything humanity can provide, it better be "better".

utopiah··on F-Droid 2.0
No, there are a lot of DRM free books, e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48709186 mentioned here or https://www.defectivebydesign.org/guide/ebooks more broadly.

Piracy and stripping DRMs though definitely work.

utopiah··on Dutch governments builds alternative for Microsoft based on NixOS
clearly shows the need for federated forges, where you get to decide on your own rules but you still benefit from interacting with a broader set of collaborators.
utopiah··on Meta VR Glasses
Ah! That's actually exactly why I don't use WhatsApp, Google, etc anymore.

When Meta bought Oculus a decade ago I though "why the heck are they buying this VR company..." which prompted me to read "The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power" 2018 Shoshana Zuboff's book.

The idea is precisely that they don't need more of the same data, they have enough (even though they do need to keep them up to date) but they instead need more KINDS of data to keep on earning money from selling ads.

They don't care for the technology itself, only for ways to distinguish needs better and that's exactly what a new digital medium provides.

TL;DR: yes.

utopiah··on Meta VR Glasses
On the contrary, if Meta didn't acquire Oculus which hadn't poached Valve staff maybe the Steam Frame would have been out years ago.

It wouldn't have been touted at the "metaverse" and a revolution of having business meeting in a virtual room... looking like a boring office and maybe it would "just" be millions of gamers, but to stay we are in a better state because of Meta is questionable.

They did invest a ton and their products (if one can manage to make abstraction why they even exist in the first place) are actually well done but the line their brought on the entire industry created unrealistic expectation.

Is it good, is it bad, I'm not actually sure but I'm rather confident to say it's not obvious.

utopiah··on Ideas on modernizing the open-source desktop
It's been a week that Valve has started shipped KDE in a VR headset running Linux.

Meanwhile it's been years since KDE Connect allows devices to talk to each, sending SMS on desktop from phone, pausing phone podcast from desktop, sharing files from XR headset to desktop, etc.

A lot could be improved but the modern open-source desktop is already doing great.

utopiah··on Ideas on modernizing the open-source desktop
grep -ir something /etc half a century ago.
utopiah··on MiMo v2.6
Isn't it precisely why models are made there, in order to provide economical value (arguable) while being politically and culturally aligned?
utopiah··on MiMo v2.6
I'm curious about that, do you have relevasnt metrics? I imagine stats out of universities, engineer schools, etc and maybe number of patents could be used but fearing those could be gamed.
utopiah··on Show HN: Radius – A Meetup.com Alternative
Makes me wonder if an RSS feed with a namespace extension for a GPS coordinates field would be enough, with a basic Web page client with a radius limited with a reasonable default based on threshold of results and user adjustable.
utopiah··on Qwen Image 2.1
no worries, I was wrong too, it is multimodal but only for inputs apparently, so for now there seem to only be text as output but no image as output
utopiah··on Qwen-Image-2.1: Compact, efficient, and unified image creation
I haven't used llama.cpp for image generation either but I recall an issue about it. Unfortunately I can't pinpoint it now and there is the older closed issue https://github.com/ggml-org/llama.cpp/issues/4408 so unless mtmd supports also multimodal outputs out of the box safe to assume output is still limited to text.
utopiah··on Qwen Image 2.1
like https://github.com/ggml-org/llama.cpp/tree/master/examples/d... ?

At the risk of stating the obvious llama.cpp isn't just about LLaMa as https://github.com/ggml-org/llama.cpp/blob/master/src/llama-... someone else pointed out.

utopiah··on Qwen Image 2.1
Seems I'm missing something. Does this model support other inputs?

Image outputs are supported, videos I'm not sure but I don't think that's an output, just a preview of the equirectangular example, so, same question here, what does this model outputs that isn't supported?

utopiah··on Telling a Computer to Do Things
Right, and I would also argue that scripting goes way beyond the terminal.

Scripting in the terminal can manipulate windows too (e.g. xdg-open with KWin), or send notification locally (e.g. notify-send) to any devices (again or ntfy), or open dialogs (e.g. kdialog), or controlling other devices (e.g. curl to HomeAssistant API) so indeed it opens up an entire new world of possibilities... and it's combinatorial.

Also for another bit of context, scripting works ... on the weirdest newest devices, e.g. a Meta Quest on Android thanks to Termux. If there is an OS there is surely a terminal in there somewhere, and if there is, you can script on it. So... scripting isn't "just" for your desktop or a remote server, it's everywhere.

Page 1 of 33Next →