HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tlogan

5,935 karma · joined August 21, 2011

submissionscomments
tlogan··on New York to tax luxury second homes in NYC
From what I know this is going to be challenged in the court and it probably it is not going to pass the legal challenge (renting part is one interesting loophole - I think that one caused similar tax law in SF to be struck down).
tlogan··on New York to tax luxury second homes in NYC
I assume this will be challenged in court immediately. Does anyone understand whether it is likely to survive those legal challenges?

EDIT: Here is a list reported by Google search but I really do not understand or know how reasonable these challenges are.

Equal Protection: Owners may argue the tax unfairly treats similar properties differently based on second-home status, value threshold, or owner residence. This is likely a weaker challenge because tax classifications usually receive deferential rational-basis review.

Nonresident Discrimination: A challenge could claim the tax targets out-of-city, out-of-state, or foreign owners rather than property use. The law is safer if written as a tax on non-primary luxury residences, not on nonresidents as a class.

Assessment Inequality: Owners may challenge how the city values condos, co-ops, townhouses, and mixed-use properties. This could be significant if the $5 million threshold is applied inconsistently or without reliable valuation rules.

Due Process: Owners may argue the law lacks clear notice, proof, exemption, and appeal procedures. This would be especially relevant for disputes over whether a home is truly a second home.

Residency Conflicts: Taxpayers may challenge inconsistent treatment if the city treats them as NYC residents for income tax but non-primary homeowners for this tax. Clear coordination between residency rules would reduce this risk.

Home Rule Authority: Opponents may argue NYC lacks authority unless the state clearly authorizes the tax. This challenge is less likely to succeed if Albany passes valid enabling legislation and NYC follows required procedures.

tlogan··on Mistral's CEO: Europe has 2 years to stop becoming America's AI 'vassal state'
But working in UE gives you much stronger job protection.

So, in a way, you get what you pay for.

tlogan··on Mozilla to UK regulators: VPNs are essential privacy and security tools
I do not think parents are the one pushing these controls. They are busy raising the kids.
tlogan··on Mozilla to UK regulators: VPNs are essential privacy and security tools
Sadly, this is how societies eventually tend to become. They need the younger generation to be “properly” raised (definition of “proper” really depends on the society).

If the side effect is that you also end up controlling adults and making them behave “properly,” then that is considered a plus.

tlogan··on Green Card Holders Targeted for Deportation by New 'Removal Apparatus'
> The Department of Homeland Security is seeking to deport at least 50 green card holders ..

50 green cards holders? The total number of green card holders is 12.8 million.

tlogan··on Sam Altman's Business Dealings Under GOP Scrutiny Ahead of OpenAI's IPO
I am sure that nothing illegal was done here.

But the fact that OpenAI was a nonprofit and then suddenly became a for-profit is definitely something that does not feel right. I am 100% sure that it is all legal and such, but we have this mental model that “nonprofits are the good guys, run by people who just want to help humanity and nothing else.”

But that is not true, and probably never was.

tlogan··on Claude for Small Business
Maybe. The reason I think it might not be true is that some people are simply not wired to be developers: to think analytically.

Learning how to type commands and use a terminal is not something people cannot already learn right now. And that was the way before.

I think the real killer app is making marketing and other non development (non analytical) work better. In case of marketing, we have tried many AI tools for marketing, and so far they mostly make campaigns more generic, less exciting, and often worse. They help a little but you need to careful that they do not to make it worse.

tlogan··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
And apparently “anytime they want” is going to be this year.
tlogan··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
One smart old guy once told me that the only language you need to speak in the financial world is spreadsheets. No words needed.
tlogan··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
Why do we need to complicate here? cloudFlare is not making any profit. They are losing money.

The board probably wants profit now (they predict less growth) so the management needs to cut the costs.

This AI story is a just an excuse. If there is not AI they will say “high gas prices”. Or “inflation”. Or whatever …

It is true that the companies like Meta, Oracle and Microsoft are laying off due to AI but because they need money to build compute power.

There are some companies who maybe do lay offs due to AI replacing employees. But this might not be the one.

tlogan··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
Lets not miss the obvious: cloudflare is not profitable. I believe the board is probably telling the management that they need to cut costs.

All this “AI bla bla efficiency bla bla agents bla bla” is a convenient excuse.

tlogan··on Business Owners Are Worst Clients
This is kind of similar to what we are experiencing, but there is one important caveat: only business owners with no employees tend to be mean and borderline fraudulent. Not all but there is a tendency.

But that kind of makes sense to me. If a business has no employees, then either 1) it is not a real business, or 2) the owner is a jerk (unpleasant) and nobody wants to work with

In other words some people start the business because they are forced to start “business”. Because nobody will hire them or they lack “social intelligence” so they are never prompted.

But if a business has at least one employee, the owners are usually very nice to work with: professional and to the point.

tlogan··on Tesla Is Sitting on a Record 50k Unsold EVs
I think Tesla as a company is doing the right moves. The management (excluding Elon) seems solid and smart.

The problem is that we often attach a company or a larger idea to a single person, even when it is much much bigger than that individual. People started boycotting Tesla because of Elon Musk, without considering that Tesla is actually thousands of engineers, workers, and managers. And majority of decisions are not done by Elons.

But people tend to think in terms of heroes and anti heroes. Cesar Chavez is another example of how this dynamic plays out.

tlogan··on Police used AI facial recognition to wrongly arrest TN woman for crimes in ND
That is my assumption. I assume who ever was representing her made a mistake and challenged the warrant and that caused delay in the extradition.
tlogan··on Police used AI facial recognition to wrongly arrest TN woman for crimes in ND
Ok. The mistake was made by North Dakota police (and they blame AI - the AI just gave them a possible match. Whatever.).

What I still do not understand is why she spent nearly six months in a Tennessee jail. That part remains unclear and needs further explanation.

tlogan··on Police used AI facial recognition to wrongly arrest TN woman for crimes in ND
The judge likely issued the warrant based on the detective’s sworn testimony. In most cases, a judge does not have the ability or detailed knowledge to independently verify whether the detective completed all necessary checks.

This situation likely resulted from either sloppy investigative work or an honest mistake: the detective believed her booking photo matched the individual captured on camera.

Her booking photo from a prior arrest can be found here: https://mugshots.com/US-States/Tennessee/Carter-County-TN/An...

Do we have recording of the suspect they used for the match?

tlogan··on Police used AI facial recognition to wrongly arrest TN woman for crimes in ND
From reading more into the case, it seems the issue may be related to how her lawyer handled the case.

They probably did “identity challenge” arguing that she is not the right person. But from Tennessee’s perspective, she was considered the correct person to be arrested, so there was no “mistaken identity” in their system. In other words, North Dakota Wanted person x and here is person x.

Once a judge in North Dakota reviewed the full evidence (and found that person they issued warrant for arrest is not one they want), the case was dismissed.

tlogan··on Police used AI facial recognition to wrongly arrest TN woman for crimes in ND
This is a weak or misleading story about AI.

First, the detective used the FaceSketchID system, which has been around since around 2014. It is not new or uniquely tied to modern AI.

Second, the system only suggests possible matches. It is still up to the detective to investigate further and decide whether to pursue charges. And then it is up to court to issue the warrant.

The real question is why she was held in jail for four months. That is the part that I do not understand. My understanding is that there is 30-day limit (the requesting state must pick up the defendant within 30 day). Regarding the individual involved, Angela Lipps, she has reportedly been arrested before, so it is possible she was on parole. So maybe they were holding her because of that?

Can someone clarify how that process works?

tlogan··on AI overly affirms users asking for personal advice
This needs to be taken in context. In my view, AI definitely gives better advice than friends, acquaintances, or colleagues (at least in the US culture). But the advice from parents is still the most valuable.

Here is how I would rank it:

1. Parents

2. AI

3. Friends and family

4. Internet search

5. Reddit

tlogan··on 90% of Claude-linked output going to GitHub repos w <2 stars
https://ghe.clickhouse.tech/
tlogan··on 90% of Claude-linked output going to GitHub repos w <2 stars
The actual number is that 98% have less than 2 stars (0 or 1). About 90.25% has zero stars.
tlogan··on Slovenian officials blame Israeli firm Black Cube for trying to manipulate vote
Interesting. I have vey limited knowledge of Slovenian politics, but it often seems that whoever gets elected ends up facing corruption charges and ends up in prison after the next election cycle.

Since Janez Jansa will be prime minister he will be charged for corruption by end of his term and this could be the third time for him to go to prison (the first instance happened under the socialist regime, so maybe that does not count).

Anyway, I do not think Israelis needed to work hard here to find some dirt.

tlogan··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
We should do something here.

Nothing will be done at Federal level.

But california is big enough to make things moving without any federal level law.

For example, what about this:

- no sales taxes on new EV sales

- free registration for 5 years

- free bridge tolls for 5 years

This will be paid by increasing gas taxes, sales taxes on ICE, and registration fees for ICE.

That might convince some of companies to start making EVs again.

tlogan··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
I do not know. It is all about priorities.

Raise taxes on gas? Put extra taxes on sell ICE vehicles? Increase registration fees for ICE vehicles? (In short - ICE sales will paying for money lost via EV sales)

I’m not saying it will be easy. I’m saying that if we really want EVs to succeed we can do it.

tlogan··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
I 100% understand that nothing will be done on the federal level. But california is big enough to make things moving without any federal level law.

For example, what about:

- no sales taxes on new EV sales

- free registration for 5 years

- free bridge tolls for 5 years

That might convince some of these companies to start making EVs again.

tlogan··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
What about no sales taxes on EV purchases (full sales tax exemption) in California?
tlogan··on BYD is seeing a flood of new EV buyers
The problem with many of these EVs is that they were way too expensive. The main reason companies were producing them is due to regulatory requirements and how emissions standards are calculated, not necessarily because wanted to sell these EVs.

What we really need are incentives for companies to build more affordable EVs. California could play a role here, but given the strong opinions we have about Elon Musk, nothing will be done.

tlogan··on Honda is killing its EVs
We must not be visiting the same city.
tlogan··on Corruption erodes social trust more in democracies than in autocracies
Excellent insight. Trust is key for capitalism. And for functioning democracy. When trust is lost, whether in the system or in your fellow citizens, everything begins to suffer.

I think of society as an extended family. If you do not trust your spouse, many things in your home simply will not work.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →