HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

throwaway5752

11,221 karma · joined December 30, 2013

submissionscomments
throwaway5752··on GitHub is down again
This is Microsoft. They forced a move to Azure, and then prioritized AI workfloads higher. I'm sure the traing read workloads on GH are nontrivial.

They literally have the golden goose, the training stream of all software development, dependencies, trending tool usage.

In an age of model providers trying train their models and keep them current, the value of GitHub should easily be in the high tens of billions or more. The CEO of Microsoft should be directly involved at this point, their franchise at risk on multiple fronts now. Windows 11 is extremely bad. GitHub going to lose their foundational role in modern development shortly, and early indications are that they hitched their wagon to the wrong foundational model provider.

throwaway5752··on Betting on War: Prediction Markets and the Corruption of National Security
It doesn't take much of a genius to realize a bunch of AI based defense tech using prediction markets as a signal would allow a small amount of money to influence the markets.

These are transparently ways for other nation states or the wealthy to influence military, diplomatic, and foreign policy - that is to say, corruption.

throwaway5752··on TikTok users can't upload anti-ICE videos. The company blames tech issues
If someone demonstrates they are liars, there is a reasonable default reaction. Most people can ignore what they say, because liars made the conscious decision not to be credible.

It is an incredible time-saving productivity hack to disregard what habitual liars say.

throwaway5752··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
Yes. They are playing chess while the US is playing "shoot yourself in the dick".
throwaway5752··on Prediction markets are ushering in a world in which news becomes about gambling
natural consequence of the post-truth world we live in

We _currently_ live in. Truth and trust are older than computers. They will outlive computers, too. Computers and the system we have built will eventually yield to truth, not the other way around.

One can get a credit card and say they are living in a post-scarcity world until they hit the limit, but that doesn't make it true.

throwaway5752··on Prediction markets are ushering in a world in which news becomes about gambling
It's stupid gambling, nothing more and nothing less. Sports gambling is at all-time highs, also, because people have money to waste and haven't faced consequences for their poor decision making. When people have less money - and understand, this is imminent, at least in the US - they'll have less ability to stupidly waste the money they have.

Prediction markets have gotten attention lately because it's so easy to manipulate them with small amounts of money and get signal amplified in subsequent reporting of the prediction markets "counterintuitive" signals. It is a form of reality shaping.

To that extent, they'll continue to exist, with just sock-puppet level activity until they are ignored.

throwaway5752··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
I'm afraid I completely disagree with you and am not interested in arguing further than this.

Vietnam, Korea, Iraq, Gaza, and so many others are atrocities but they are well understood by anyone with a casual understanding of 20th century geopolitics.

Anything you could list is awful but still respected the norms and rules that exist between nation states. There is not a high bar for these things, but some people within a specific flavor of the Republican party reject these rules and norms. By a quirk of history they were able to gain power. I could describe this in more technical and impressive sounding language, but "FAFO, and we are in the find-out stage" goes by many names and is accurate.

throwaway5752··on Nvidia Stock Crash Prediction
Gold stocks, basic materials, MSCI world and emerging market indexes. Look at their prices and see how very smart people are positioning their money.
throwaway5752··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
Holders of US debt have no obligation to give a shit about the statutory background of the Fed, and to just make decisions about who is the best fiduciary of their currency.

If holders of US debt goes away, we have immediate inflation to the point where our currency hits trade equilibriums such that we can service our debt. All of your savings are worthless.

throwaway5752··on De-dollarization: Is the US dollar losing its dominance? (2025)
Yes, of fucking course it is. The US elected a convicted con artist who is incontrovertibly violating human rights law, breaking treaties with allies, militarily threatening neighbors, and in general making a global outcast of themselves.

The US is making an absolute mockery over the honor and responsibility granted to in the post-WW2 world. It has sophisticated rivals that are predictably and effectively making use of the self-inflicted crisis. So far the ruling class of the US has been happy enough to let this go, and has been too busy making rocket ships, fake computer currencies, and large estates in south Florida to deal with real world problems.

If you are in the US, buy some gold or a house so your savings aren't destroyed - utterly predictably - by the man who declared Chapter 11 bankrupcy at least 6 times.

throwaway5752··on Scott Adams has died
Aging is lonelier and more stressful than ever. The aging brain is already less flexible and there is a net loss of synapses and brain mass.

The internet has become a more unkind and manipulative place that ever. It is making people into the worst version of themselves, to serve the ends of groups that benefit from division.

I mourn many things with this news today. RIP Scott Adams.

throwaway5752··on Repair a ship’s hull still in the river in -50˚C (2022)
It's not okay to casually appreciate the vacation pictures of a corrupt Russian oligarch, even if they overlap with an area of technical interest.

Kapersky is part of a corrupt regime that has killed tens of thousands of innocent Ukrainian civilians and murdered leaders of rival political parties. You can get numb to it, but it is a horrible, historic war crime. He is complicit and his boat pictures can go to hell.

throwaway5752··on Should we drain the Everglades?
> there are parts of the Florida keys

Then allow me to ease your mind. Leeches are not a problem in the marine environment of the Florida Keys, unless you are a turtle. They person you replied to changed the topic slightly from the Everglades, where they could be a problem. In either case I'd worry about midges and mosquitos first.

Similarly with alligators, they are primarily freshwater and uncommon in the keys. American crocodiles can tolerate the marine environment better, but they are threatened as a species and have just two confirmed attacks in 75 years.

So wear a personal flotation device and you should be okay.

throwaway5752··on EPA Seeks to Eliminate Critical PFAS Drinking Water Protections
Incorrect. There is more fructose in HFCS used in Coke, HFCS 55. Fructose is metabolized in the liver, and stored as fat there. Glucose is directly metabolized by cells throughout the body.

Also there is no single reason that HFCS is demonized, there are multiple good reasons why it is harmful in the US. It is also not a singular cause to all US diet related pathologies.

Staying on topic, the chemicals the EPA will no longer enforce the laws for pollution for are demonstrably harmful.

The EPA has unilaterally decided not to do its job because it doesn't care about the health of the citizens of the US.

throwaway5752··on The Stock Market Is Selling the Fed's Independence Because ZIRP Broke the World
He's going to mortally wound the US economy, which was already precarious.

The US is not competitive with China, absent the USD. The Federal Reserve is a foundational reason why the USD is the most important global currency for trade.

There are nontrivial odds of Venezuela style outcomes for the US. The US media - particularly partisan mainstream conservative sources like FOX and CNBC - is drastically understating the damage this administration is to the US position in the global economic system.

supporting evidence: https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/south-korea-tells-china-...

throwaway5752··on Thai Air Force seals deal for Swedish Gripen jets
This is not some reciprocal action, it's just logical fallout that the US is no longer reliable as a military ally under this administration, and capable of electing similar leadership in the future. Much, much more of this is ahead. It will impact the USD.
throwaway5752··on With waters at 32C, Mediterranean tropicalization shifts into high gear
Plants and any organisms in photosynthesis-dependent food chains may have issues with modifying the degree of insolation.

Also, again, the Mediterranian is 1/100-1/200th of global ocean surface area. And we have melted a lot of ice cap/glacier mass. The latent heat of fusion of water is very large, also.

Long term, insolation and retention are important, but short term we are reaching the limits of the "Free Ride" portion of climate change where energy sinks absorb the additional delta created by the CO2 induced greenhouse effect.

edit: the tsar bomba was to try to make it tangible, as people don't understand these orders of magnitudes well.

throwaway5752··on With waters at 32C, Mediterranean tropicalization shifts into high gear
You can mock this, but the data doesn't care what either of us think.

Current Mediterranean water temps are +6C above normal, as observed over peak human civilization in the 20th century. That is 6kWh per cubic meter, in just the Mediterranean. The article briefly mentions this extending 30m down.

To give the order of magnitude of the energy involved, the Mediterranean surface area is 2,500,000,000,000 sq m. At 6kWh cu m and 18m deep, that is the energy equivalent of about 390,000 megatons. Or about 8,000 Tsar Bombas. The Mediterranean is small, about 0.7% of ocean surface area.

throwaway5752··on With waters at 32C, Mediterranean tropicalization shifts into high gear
At this point you just have to make peace with very bad futures. We will all die, and sometimes there is nothing you can do to prevent things. To save the world, more people have to be willing to fight for this than currently are.

The pure physics of the situation are staggering. The specific heat capacity of water is huge. The volume of ocean surface is huge. We are completely fucked. Everything you've read minimizing this or pretending we can continue with business as usual is a lie. Atmosphere SO2, enhanced rock weathering, ocean iron fertilization - it is horseshit. We had to reduce emissions 30 years ago, and simply chose not to.

The idea we can preserve our standard of living through technology is comically false. At this point, every large nation on earth would have to simultaneously cut emissions by more than half, we'd have to create a coordinated global Manhattan Project around alternative energy, and another global Manhattan Project around geoengineering (while not tipping ourselves into an ice age). It would require unprecedented leadership and cooperartion.

The US currently has the stupidest president it has ever had, surrounded by psychopaths that do not care about human suffering and act on base zero sum power calculus. The world is at war. The tech industry is greedily and actively accelerating this with crypto and AI buildout. The odds of the human species successful navigation of this extinction - at a civilization level - event is almost zero.

bondarchuk: I changed this, please delete your comment.

throwaway5752··on What does Palantir actually do?
One and the same. It would be like if I tried to call my product Tactical Software as a Service

It would still only be software as a service, but I would just brand it in a way to make it more appealing to certain buyer personas without any actual investment or commitment on my part.

throwaway5752··on What does Palantir actually do?
Forward Deployed Engineer = Consultant

I will not allow Palantir to extend their reality distortion field to me. They are consultants. They are also engineers. Other places call them FEs. But they didn't invent some new class of engineering, they just rebranded one.

throwaway5752··on Mexico to US livestock trade halted due to screwworm spread
Question, are they morons? Is your disagreement with them really that simple? Was it necessary to call them that? I don't like posting this comment, because it will be distracting and tone policing. I was just going to downvote and flag your comment and move on, but I think you offered some valuable information about the policy and I'd like to hear more without the divisive parts that add less value.
throwaway5752··on Trump orders firing of labor stats chief after data showed jobs growth slowed
I missed https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44760734 that previously posted about this.
throwaway5752··on Cloud-forming isoprene and terpenes from crops may drastically improve climate
I indelicately started a contentious topic that didn't have to exist. If I were given a fresh chance, I'd have just said that carbon emissions and the changes they are causing to the planet are a bigger problem than any single economic class or nation.

That might have caused some controversy, too, but is closer to what I meant. Your point is well taken, but maybe if I posted differently the ensuing discussion would have been less acrimonious.

throwaway5752··on Cloud-forming isoprene and terpenes from crops may drastically improve climate
Having a child is on of the most carbon intensive actions any given person can make.

The numbers are what they are. Rich people have much greater obligation to reduce their emissions. They benefit most from economic activity and they cause the most emissions per capita.

If there were zero rich people tomorrow we would still have an emissions problem for the climate.

throwaway5752··on Cloud-forming isoprene and terpenes from crops may drastically improve climate
Yes. Poorer people buy things made overseas that requires a lot of shipping, and are lower quality that require more frequent replacement. They tend to have more children. They usually have more polluting energy sources. And there are many orders of magnitude more of them than rich people.

None of this is their fault, but ignoring it isn't good either.

All aircraft emissions are just 3% of US total. If all rich people (either the top 1% or 10%) reduced their emissions to zero tomorrow we would still not reach reduction targets needed to avoid catastrophic warming.

Everyone needs to contribute.

throwaway5752··on US economy shrank 0.5% in the first quarter, worse than earlier estimates
While I think this is borderline in terms of following guidelines, it is much more concerning that the comment accurately quoted the source: https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/2025/06/trump-effect-hig...

nickff: I agree it was borderline. My sentiment was closer to suggesting we look past tone to how shocking the content is. The human brain tries to normalize things, but a statement like this would have been unprecedented before 2016. People would have resigned or been fired, it would have been a scandal.

throwaway5752··on What would a Kubernetes 2.0 look like
I've come to think that it is a case of "the distinctions between types of computer programs are a human construct" problem.

I agree with you on a human level. Operators and controllers remind me of COM and CORBA, in a sense. They are hightly abstract things, that are intrinsically so flexible that they allow judgement (and misjudgement) in design.

For simple implementations, I'd want k8s-lite, that was more opinionated and less flexible. Something which doesn't allow for as much shooting ones' self in the foot. For very complex implementations, though, I've felt existing abstractions to be limiting. There is a reason why a single cluster is sometimes the basis for cell boundaries in cellular architectures.

I sometimes wonder if one single system - kubernetes 2.0 or anything else - can encompass the full complexity of the problem space while being tractable to work with by human architects and programmers.

throwaway5752··on Sandia turns on brain-like storage-free supercomputer – Blocks and Files
I feel like there is a straightforward biological analogue for this.

But at in this case, one wouldn't subject to macro-scale nonlinear effects arising from the uncertainty principle when trying to "restore" the system.

throwaway5752··on Amelia Earhart's Reckless Final Flights
I appreciate the civil and informed discussion. I appreciate your expertise and connections, but I think we will end up disagreeing.

I think interested parties should look at the JATR report (Joint Authorities Technical Review Observations, Findings, and Recommendations) -https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/2021-08/Final_JATR_S...

With respect to "unstable", I will quote the findings

"Observation O3.4-B: Extension of MCAS to the low-speed and 1g environment during the flight program was due to unacceptable stall characteristics with STS only. The possibility of a pitch-up tendency during approach to stall was identified for the flaps-up configuration prior to the implementation of MCAS"

Regarding flight crew expectations, this is dry, but I will quote it in its entirety, anyway,

"Recommendation R6.1: The FAA should ensure applicants improve adherence to failsafe design concept principles when designing or modifying systems. The FAA should encourage applicants not to design only for compliance, but also to follow basic principles to design for safety when developing or changing system functions. This should include elimination of hazards and use of design features, warnings, and procedures.

- Observation O6.1-A: Proper flight crew action was considered an adequate mitigation to risks such as erroneous activation of MCAS.

- Finding F6.1-A: The JATR team identified that the design process was not sufficient to identify all the potential MCAS hazards. As part of the single-channel speed trim system, the MCAS function did not include fault tolerant features, such as sensors voting or limits of authority, to limit failure effects consistent with the hazard classification.

- Finding F6.1-B: The use of pilot action as a primary mitigation means for MCAS hazards, before considering eliminating such hazards or providing design features or warnings to mitigate them, is not in accordance with Boeing’s process instructions for safe design in the conception of MCAS for the B737 MAX.

- Finding F6.1-C: The JATR team found that there was a missed opportunity to further improve the system design through the use of available fail-safe design principles and techniques presented in AC 25.1309-1A and in EASA AMC 25.1309 in the MCAS design"

and further, on flight crew expectations

"Finding F6.4-A: When all flight deck effects are considered, the introduction of the MCAS function invalidated aircraft-level assumptions for flight crew responses related to erroneous AOA failures under certain conditions. A complete workload assessment was not performed for validation of the erroneous AOA effects with the added MCAS functionality. The same assumptions for flight crew responses to erroneous AOA were carried over from previous programs without formal validation."

The Technical Advisory Board's report is also interesting - https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/2022-08/737_Technica...

The discussion around AOA DISAGREE conditions is educational regarding MCAS for others who might not be familar with the technical root cause. But I would specifically encourage you to read the Flight Controls and Flight Deck Interface Assessment and Training Evaluations. They don't avoid the issue of flight crew training and trim system awareness, but I they illustrate how workload created by the erroneous MCAS activation was contributing.

As for your pilot conversations, I will make two short points. First, pilots don't always suffer for a lack of self-confidence. Maybe it would have never happened to them, maybe not, and thankfully we will not get to find out. Second, passengers are owed a safe aircraft based on the full range of quality flight crews, with a wide margin for error. I do care if a highly skilled qualified crew would have avoided the accident, I care if the least-skilled qualified crew would have. And 610's captain had 5,176 hours on the 737 and 302's captain had 4,120 hours.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →