HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

te_platt

2,781 karma · joined November 11, 2007

http://www.tracyplatt.com I go by ALousyPlayer on lichess.org.
submissionscomments
te_platt··on Ask HN: Do you feel bad when devices aren't utilized to the extreme?
Yes, very much. Growing up I used to scramble to get whatever computer equipment I could. My parents didn't have much money but many of my friends parents did. I hated asking to borrow stuff even though people didn't seem to mind. Now when I see my extra equipment not get used I imagine some kid really wanting to just use it for a bit. Maybe just my own mental issues here but I know what you mean.
te_platt··on What is the Strategic Petroleum Reserve?
From March 13, 2020: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/13/trump-asks-energy-department...

Also: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-04-02/china-to-...

te_platt··on Earth may have been a 'water world' 3B years ago, scientists find
Not so bad. Assuming a spherical Earth in a vacuum and a bunch of other slightly less reasonable assumptions we have:

1E+45 photons from sun per second

1.49598E+11 distance to sun in meters

6365000 earth radius in meters

2.81229E+23 surface area of solar flux at earth orbit

1.27276E+14 surface area of earth exposed to sun

4.5257E-10 ration earth area to solar flux

4.5257E+35 photons hitting earth per second

6.49E+15 one light year in meters

1.947E+25 meters in 3 billion light years

4.76367E+51 surface are of sphere 3 billion ly across

9.50046E-17 photons per m^2 at 3B ly

1.05258E+16 m^2 per photon

57883255.23 radius in meters for mirror to reflect 1 photon/second

57883.25523 radus in km (Only 10x larger than Earth!)

Then given a reasonably competent engineer to make a descent mirror with no aberration and a good telescope on a clear night away from the city, and a good bit a patience, you could watch a replay of the last 3 billion years.

te_platt··on Using neural networks to upscale a famous 1896 video to 4k quality
In most ways, yes. For me the first 5 seconds or so were fantastic. It felt like seeing a behind the scenes "How it was made" documentary where I was seeing the actors out of character. Or like it removed the sense of being from another era. Soon the artifacts and warping became distracting, and then watching the original put it back in time. Maybe it was a sense of nostalgia but overall the original seemed better to me.
te_platt··on Eigenvectors from eigenvalues
It's something like an economist finding a $20 dollar bill on the ground and it's actually a real $20 bill that no one has picked up yet.
te_platt··on Falsehoods Programmers Believe About Names (2010)
The one I would add is:

Names are a reasonable indicator of the person's sex. Go ahead and prefix a Mr. / Ms.

te_platt··on Spanish government orders GitHub to take down Tsunami Democràtic repository
My (Chileanized) Castilian is pretty rusty but I thought your translation was in line with how I read it. Instead of "withhold" I would say "hold onto for myself" ; as in "Retener mis derechos". The broader context seemed to imply preserve the records as in don't delete anything as we investigate, but I can see how it could be taken the other way. In the sentence as written what word would you use in place of retener if you meant to be clear to stop dissemination or publication of the content?

Edit: In place of "la retención".

te_platt··on Beware of Cranks: Misguided attempts to solve impossible mathematical problems
I agree with the main argument but would like to note "crank" in not an all or nothing description. Sometimes the problem as publicized doesn't exactly match the precise problem. For example you can trisect an arbitrary angle if allowed an infinite number of steps. Sometimes the problem is in breaking the abstraction layer. For example one of my kids thought you could make arbitrarily slow motion videos by taking slow motion videos of slow motion videos. And that brings up the issue of how to handle a crank. I loved that my son thought through the video issue and didn't want to inhibit future thinking. We ran some experiments taking video of the tv and it was fun. Sometimes people won't accept counter arguments and evidence (sometimes that person is me) and there's a time to move on. Still, in my experience few people are true die hard cranks and most people respond well if given the right direction.
te_platt··on Estimate the size of your English vocabulary (2014)
I wonder how they take into account the kind of people who take a test like this are likely to have a good vocabulary. I suppose that might not be true but I don't think I'd do something similar for a test that measured something along the lines of matching faces to pop musicians.
te_platt··on People with Greater Intellectual Humility Have Superior General Knowledge
A few years ago the guy I was sharing an office with at work was cleaning off his desk and found a stack of resumes. He said they were all from the batch that I was hired from and asked if I wanted to know why I was picked. Very cautiously I said yes. He told me I was the only one who when really pushed during the technical interview said "I don't know". Their initial strategy had been to start easy on some topic and just keep going deeper until they had a measure of what level the applicant was at. After a certain point they were just surprised at how far people would carry on into nonsense.
te_platt··on Mathematics all-in-one cheat-sheet (2013) [pdf]
Nice touch: 4.15 FERMAT’S LAST THEOREM: ... General case when n>2 was proved by Andrew Wiles (1994). The proof is too long to be written here. See: http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~anindya/fermat.pdf
te_platt··on Dear Client, Here’s Why That Change Took So Long
My last two projects have been for the military and a medical device. The example here seems so wonderfully simple (even as an example of how much has to happen on a simple change). Add in all the process/design/QA/validation documents that need to be created -> passed off -> executed -> recorded and you are at much longer than a day.
te_platt··on How Many Type Parameters Can a Java Method Have?
I was both impressed and horrified. Well done.
te_platt··on Google may rank sites for queries that don't appear on the page at all
Having never worked on a search engine myself I will avoid guessing as to why Google's results are the way they are. As a search engine user I noticed Google's results seem to be less useful than they were before. After a particularly poor series of results I tried DuckDuckGo and found the results better. It seems similar to when I switched to Google from MetaCrawler. Whatever the reasons I just want to find what I'm looking for.
te_platt··on Facebook, YouTube Blindsided by Mosque Shooter's Live Video
Neither of whom is white nationalist.
te_platt··on The Alter Bible
As well as sarcasm, emphasis, irony, puns....

I really like this sentence from Douglas Hofstadter: "Every word in this sentence is a gross misspelling of the word 'tomato'."

There are so many ways a translator could go with that.

te_platt··on The Alter Bible
I've always been fascinated by the difficulties of translation.

There is the issue of expressing the original thought. Already I've edited this post several times.

Then there is the issue of the surrounding context which will be different for different people. Even for people in the same culture at the same time in the same place.

Then the issue of the attitude of the reader. It's not uncommon to get different meanings from the same text on different days.

Now with the Biblical text we have copies of text from a different time, culture, and language. I like how this article shows how hard it is to handle even one sentence.

te_platt··on Ask HN: How to self-study mathematics from the undergrad through graduate level?
I think you are right on both points. There were more details and his answer was just a quick way to say:

He didn't care about the status of having a PhD

He didn't need a PhD to advance his career

He was having fun doing math stuff anyway

te_platt··on Ask HN: How to self-study mathematics from the undergrad through graduate level?
My oldest brother had a real love of mathematics and got a masters degree but never even applied to a PhD program. When I asked him about it he just said he was tired of working on other people's problems.

He had a quiet programming position in a large company that gave him time to work on personal projects. Among other things he volunteered at the local schools teaching "fun" math. I guess I'm just agreeing with you about finding something that inspires you and go with it.

te_platt··on Can a Supernova Cause Mass Extinction?
It's nice to read an article like this that doesn't try to invent some controversy. It looks like a supernova could cause a disruption large enough to cause an extinction. No, there's not enough evidence to say it actually. Yes, it is an interesting idea and if anyone has anything to add go for it.

A good story has some fight in it. Not every theory does and that's ok.

te_platt··on Smoking Banana Peels Is the Greatest Drug Hoax of All Time
The hoax I wish would get around is that it is really good to smoke is dandelion roots. I love to imagine groups of teenagers running around at night digging out dandelions from random people's (especially mine) yards.
te_platt··on The moving sofa problem
That especially hurt me too read as just this morning I helped a friend move a couch. We had had to turn it pretty much every way possible and the only reason we kept trying was because we knew somehow she got it moved in. It's interesting that in so many different areas knowing there is a solution makes finding the solution easier.

In a related story my dad remodeled his house and put in a new wall blocking in a couch. When it came time to move it (years later) I thought it was going to be a permanent feature of that room. My dad came up with the solution of getting a saw and cutting the couch into pieces.

te_platt··on Floating in the Air: The World That Made Dostoyevsky’s Crime and Punishment
A few years ago I re-read Crime and Punishment, 30 years after trying to get through it in high school. I was blown away by how deeply it affected me this time around. It's not so much a crime story as much as a "why is there crime?" story - or even a "what forces in my mind and in everyone else's minds are really shaping my moral actions?" story. (I just searched the internet for that last quote and apparently I need to read more Kant). I had some Russian friends where I was working at the time and asked them about Crime and Punishment and they all just frowned and nodded for a minute before one of them said "yes... very dark..."

For any of you here who may have read it too young I highly recommend going back and reading it again

te_platt··on Undercover in a Toronto factory where a temp worker died
The ability to get another job.
te_platt··on In Defense of Probability (1985) [pdf]
If you are interested in a deeper dive into the topics covered in this paper I would suggest "Probability Theory: The Logic of Science" by E. T. Jaynes

available athttp://www-biba.inrialpes.fr/Jaynes/cpreambl.pdf

It is probably (ha!) the most enlightening math book I have ever read.

te_platt··on A Candle Loses Nothing by Lighting Another Candle
I have a little brother and a brother in law who each went from bad financial situations to making a lot of money in a relatively short time. By a lot I mean much more than I make, and I do pretty well. I found it strange that I was both happy for them and resentful at the same time. We got along well before and after their success and I never felt like they became arrogant or condescending. I think my resentment came from having to face up to my own mistakes and weaknesses. Maybe there were reasons they were more successful than I was; that it wasn't just luck. Thankfully the resentment has long since faded.

The experience also made me think what would happen if you were at a party with a large group of friends. God appears and gives everyone with a birthday on an odd numbered day a million dollars then leaves with no explanation. How happy for their friends are the people who didn't get anything? They are no worse off but I can't help thinking they would be happy.

te_platt··on Ask HN: Does anybody else feel overwhelmed while reading HN?
Hardly. You still need:

1. An in depth understanding of Physics, History, Literature, and Philosophy. You can just make up whatever you want in Economics, Sociology, and Bitcoins as fits your political leanings.

2. Learn to resist weapons grade grammar analysis.

3. Learn to recognize sarcasm in short, written text.

te_platt··on Americans from Both Political Parties Overwhelmingly Support Net Neutrality
On top of that I think hardly anyone has a good idea of what net neutrality is or what specific actions would be affected.

Should an ISP be allowed to throttle or block data from a competing service?

Should an ISP be allowed to throttle or block data from a politically controversial site? From a suspected piracy site? From ip addresses involved in DOS attacks?

And then on top of that what is in the actual proposed legislation purporting to be supporting net neutrality? Even if politicians make an honest effort to do right (could happen....) how confident can we be that it will actually be for the better? My main point is we need to be vigilant in the details and not get caught up in a tribal fight over a label.

te_platt··on Tallest Lego building with 4 pieces?
Very fun! It reminds me of teaching my son to play tic-tac-toe. He started in the top-left, I went center, he went top-center, I blocked top-right, he went in between top-left and top-center and quickly claimed victory. I gave him that one and said he had to go in an unused square. Next game he started top-left, I went center, he went top-center and then before I could go he hurried and went top-right and again claimed victory. I don't remember what we did after that but I do remember thinking it was more fun pushing the rules than the actual game.
te_platt··on The Patek Philippe Caliber 89 and Horology’s Easter Problem
I'm always curious when Gauss turns up in the solution to a math problem. Wikipedia has a section on the algorithm here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computus#Gauss_algorithm

The same article also explains why it is a hard problem:

"Easter calculations are based on agreements and conventions, not on the actual celestial movements nor on indisputable facts of history."

Sounds a lot like many user requirements I have had to code for.

Page 1 of 14Next →