HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

proto-n

739 karma · joined September 7, 2016

submissionscomments
proto-n··on Be skeptical of OpenAI's rogue hacker agent story
yeah well, both the doomers and the "pr stunt" folks are right

- openai wanted to prove, as a pr stunt, that they have a dangerous weapon - openai proved (as a pr stunt), that they do indeed have a dangerous weapon

proto-n··on Gemini 3.1 Pro
From Gemini pro:

You should definitely ride the elephant (or at least lead it there)!

Here is the logic:

If you walk there by yourself, you will arrive at the creek, but the dirty elephant will still be 300 feet back where you started. You can't wash the elephant if it isn't with you!

Plus, it is much easier to take the elephant to the water than it is to carry enough buckets of water 300 feet back to the elephant.

Would you like another riddle, or perhaps some actual tips on how to keep cool in the Arizona heat?

proto-n··on Over fifty new hallucinations in ICLR 2026 submissions
1. "Suspected" is just that, suspected, you can't penalize papers based on your gut feel 2. LLM-s are a tool, and there's nothing wrong with using them unless you misuse them
proto-n··on You are the scariest monster in the woods
Well, one of these is something that most reaonable people work on avoiding, while the other is something that a huge capitalist industrial machine is working to achieve like their existence depends on it.
proto-n··on Nine things I learned in ninety years
And along similar lines, "Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants."
proto-n··on Hidden risk in Notion 3.0 AI agents: Web search tool abuse for data exfiltration
I really don't see why it's not possible to just use basically a "highlighter" token which is added to all the authoritative instructions and not to data. Should be very fast for the model to learn it during rlhf or similar.
proto-n··on Quantum Won't Replace Your Computer
Not exactly. You can't steal anything unless the person revealed the public key. Addresses are just hashes of public keys, therefore qc resistant. However, you can't ever reuse an address, as signing reveals the public key.

Otoh, afaik either it wasn't like this in the satoshi era or satoshi revealed the public key. In any case, satoshi's wallets are crackable by qc.

proto-n··on Please Commit More Blatant Academic Fraud (2021)
I still disagree. It's more like "omg I should have published at least a few papers by now, what am I doing" and then you start frantically looking for provable things in the dataset. You find one that you can also support with a nice story. Now either a) You were not tought about how or why this is wrong and you publish the paper b) You were, and know that you should collect a separate dataset to test the hypothesis. But also, there is a huge existential pressure to just close your eyes and roll with it.

It's not that you need to be tought how to cheat, it's that you need to be tought how to avoid unintentionally cheating.

proto-n··on Please Commit More Blatant Academic Fraud (2021)
It's really not that hard to come up with ways to commit fraud if you want to. On the other hand, it's very easy to make such mistakes if you don't know to avoid them. This characterization is very misguided IMO.
proto-n··on Please Commit More Blatant Academic Fraud (2021)
Not only common, it's become a requirement to review papers if you submit one yourself. Yeah it's not ideal for multiple reasons (what you said + prompt engineering grad students dismissing proper papers without having the slighest idea about the field), but the amount of submissions is so incredibly huge that it's impossible to do it any other way.
proto-n··on Please Commit More Blatant Academic Fraud (2021)
"For the first time, researchers reading conference proceedings will be forced to wonder: does this work truly merit my attention? Or is its publication simply the result of fraud? [...] But the mere possibility that any given paper was published through fraud forces people to engage more skeptically with all published work."

Well... spending a few weeks reproducing a shiny conference paper that simply doesn't work and is easily beaten by any classical baseline will do that to you in the first few months of your PhD imo. I've become so skeptic over the years that I assume almost all papers to be lies until proven otherwise.

"This surfaces the fundamental tension between good science and career progression buried deep at the heart of academia. Most researchers are to some extent “career researchers”, motivated by the power and prestige that rewards those who excel in the academic system, rather than idealistic pursuit of scientific truth."

For the first years of my PhD I simply refused to parttake in the subtle kinds of frauud listed in the second paragraph of the post. As a result, I barely had any publications worth mentioning. Mostly papers shared with others, where I couldn't stop the paper from happening by the time I realized that there is too little substance for me to be comfortable with it.

As a result, my publication history looks sad and my carreer looks nothing like I wished it would.

Now, a few years later, I've become much better at research and can now get my papers to the point where I'm comfortable submitting them with a straight face. I've also came to terms with overselling something that does have substance, just not as much as I wish it had.

proto-n··on Science YouTuber physicsgirl (Dianna Cowern) stands for the first time in 2 yrs
The "so called Long COVID" really just means "I got covid and I remain unwell in some way, long term". I'm not sure it needs to be questioned if those two qualifying things are given. Very well might be the same thing as ME/CFS, or might not, I don't think we have a conclusive answer yet about what causes either.
proto-n··on In my life, I've witnessed three elite salespeople at work
(Wasn't me claiming that, read usernames)

Yeah, but you are, at least seemingly, missing the point: the scripts he was referring to in context weren't the legal disclosures but the sales tricks that were handed to them to use. He is pointing out that the 'elite' saleswoman wasn't better at strategy or sales tricks, but was effective because she made them feel good.

proto-n··on In my life, I've witnessed three elite salespeople at work
The article states that he was fired because the company had financial problems, and not reading the required stuff was used as an excuse
proto-n··on Mirror bacteria research poses significant risks, scientists warn
But then this is also an argument against spontaneous emergence of life, right? Sicne mirror-life could just emerge on its own, instead of evolving from regular life.
proto-n··on If not React, then what?
It seems you only want to call MVC frameworks frameworks? But there's millions of other types of frameworks for thousands of purposes. Framework is a generic term (for which the definition is usually the calls into you/you call into it thing). What it does and whether it's a framework is two completely orthogonal things.
proto-n··on Bayesian Neural Networks
Usually means uncertainty quantification
proto-n··on Trump wins presidency for second time
I really really hope you are a better judge of that than I am
proto-n··on Chemistry Nobel: Computational protein design and protein structure prediction
Now this one makes more sense. Chemistry Nobel for advancing chemistry using AI.

Contrast that with Phyics Nobel for advancing AI using physics.

proto-n··on Winamp Legacy player source code
I'm not sure forking the repo would create a forked version of the 'software' if the fork's sole purpose is to develop a pull request. But I guess it's somewhat ambiguous langauge, and better safe then sorry when it comes to lawyers (which I'm not).
proto-n··on Long-Covid R&D is collapsing: investors won't fund, scientifically challenging
The same way any other illness is, I guess
proto-n··on Data sleuths who spotted research misconduct cleared of defamation
To my (totally uninformed) eyes it looks like maybe this could count as a SLAPP suit [1], in which case there's a possbility for a counterclaim for legal costs. However, Massachusetts apparently has "much weaker anti-SLAPP laws" [2] (than California, in the context of the article)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_lawsuit_against_publ...

[2] https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/23841742/francesca-gino-d...

proto-n··on Did Sandia use a thermonuclear secondary in a product logo?
I took the quote [1] to basically mean "we might think this is a nuclear warhead, but in fact it is not, rather it is some kind of random test object used to demonstrate the software". Obscure part of a washing mashine, random geometric shape, etc.

[1] "The “obvious” answer, if my above assertions are true, is that it must not actually represent a thermonuclear secondary. [...] It could be some kind of pre-approved “unclassified shape” which is used for diagnostics and model verification, for example."

proto-n··on Did Sandia use a thermonuclear secondary in a product logo?
He later finds basically the same object with the caption "The multiple components of a nuclear weapon body are highlighted in this intentionally simplified mesh" from another publication of Sandia, making that theory kind of unlikely
proto-n··on Dear Paul Graham, there is no cookie banner law
See for example GitHub's statement [1] about no longer displaying a cookie banner. While ironically the blog still does display them, the main site doesn't.

[1] https://github.blog/2020-12-17-no-cookie-for-you/

proto-n··on Headphone and Amp Impedance (2011)
Blogspot is google's blogging platform
proto-n··on RLHF a LLM in <50 lines of Python
Yeah well in bash I can do it in one line: `python train.py`. I hate examples like this, the 50loc statement is totally useless (and so is the code example, as I can't learning anything from it).
proto-n··on Granting pardon for the offense of simple possession of or use of marijuana
Your argument about marijuana being easier to prove is a very bad scenario, regardless of how common it is/used to be. By the same logic why not make it illegal to wear socks, it would provide reason for the system to punish anybody they are 'fairly sure' is up to some other crime.
proto-n··on Methane under the seabed is thawing as oceans warm
Well, I doubt anyone expects 8 billion people to be able to live on mars in the coming years
proto-n··on Sam Altman, OpenAI board open talks to negotiate his possible return
"(was) left in the dark" means "wasn't given information"
Page 1 of 7Next →