HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

objclxt

8,408 karma · joined September 8, 2011

submissionscomments
objclxt··on Don't Use AI to Write
> Does coding not require thinking or what?

Code is deterministic, and language is not. If I write:

total = 0 for x in [1, 2, 3]: total += x

…nobody is going to argue with me that “total” is anything but 7.

But language is different. What you perceive and what I perceive from the written word can be completely different (e.g https://youtube.com/watch?v=naleynXS7yo&ra=m )

objclxt··on The Art and Beauty of Blade Runner (2015)
> The Directors Cut is the unbutchered version.

The Director's Cut (released in 1992) drops the narration and adds the dream sequence, but despite the name is not entirely approved by Ridley Scott.

The Final Cut (released in 2007) is the only version where Ridley Scott had full final cut approval. It re-masters the audio, fixes some of the effects (replacing faces on stunt doubles, removing wires, etc), and changes a few lines (most notably "I want more life, father" instead of "fucker"). The color is also re-graded.

Some people prefer the Director's Cut over the Final Cut, especially the color grading, although I saw the Final Cut in 35mm when it was released and it looked pretty spectacular. In any event the changes in the Final Cut are nowhere near as egregious as the Star Wars special editions or the AI remasters of James Cameron's films.

objclxt··on Factories are just rooms
> All of my kids spent hours pouring over a book we had called 'The Way Things Work' with a delightfully funny Mammoth and a good description of how things actually work

I grew up with this book - I have vivid memories still of the pages about a nuclear reactor - and I was pleasantly surprised to visit a bookshop recently and find it still in print, updated with new things like LIDAR, 3D Printers, MoCap, etc.

objclxt··on Q&A with Micron's VP and GM of Memory
> Usually, companies like Apple are largely to blame

Just as a point of fact, Micron and its peers have in the past operated an illegal cartel that engaged in a price fixing conspiracy to manipulate the cost of RAM.

> mega-buyers like Apple caused various issues, and the production equipment that was scaled back during that time is now leading to supply shortages in the upcycle [2]. Apple fans probably won't admit it, though.

That's Micron's problem. Nobody held a gun to their heads and made them accept the prices Apple was offering. Micron willingly took those deals.

objclxt··on Identity verification on Claude
> Many such IDs are designed for local physical verification, like proof that the mobile phone owner is above certain age or has a valid driving license, they are not designed for remote verification.

This is incorrect, the Digital Credentials API[1] is designed so that identity information can be remotely verified in a cryptographically secure manner.

There is no reason Anthropic could not use the DC API for this in countries and states that support digital identity, I assume they simply aren't because they threw this together at the last minute and simply out-sourced it to Persona.

[1]: https://www.w3.org/TR/digital-credentials/

objclxt··on Noam Shazeer Joins OpenAI
> Google and Apple both need a culling similar to what Elon did with Twitter after taking over.

You could cut Google's size by 40% and they'd still have more corporate employees than Apple.

(Google has ~190k employees, Apple has ~160k but 50k of those are retail staff, so ~110k corporate)

objclxt··on If LLMs Have Human-Like Attributes, Then So Does Age of Empires II
> note that any entity in a sufficiently-powerful substrate, such as LEGO or the Greater Boston Area, could also present such attributes.

See also, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_brain

objclxt··on Meta enables ADB on deprecated Portal devices [video]
> They scaled up the team briefly, which meant that lots of weird stuff was tried, but the roadmap was diluted.

Boz never cared for Portal, it wasn't his product. I was one of the original engineers on Portal. The VP running the research lap responsible for Portal was canned in a political coup, and her entire org moved under Boz, merging it with Oculus into the AR/VR team. There was some ham-fisted justification around why a smart home product should be part of AR/VR, but it never really made sense.

Portal had a bunch of other problems, including:

* Massively over-specced hardware, the SoC was the same SoC as the Quest, even though it had no reason to be. The BOM was something like $500. We were selling these units at a huge loss.

* Cambridge Analytica broke right in the middle of development, which completely tanked any remaining trust in the Facebook brand. Everyone knew the product was completely sunk at that point, but nobody wanted to come out and say it. At the last minute we had to stuff a plastic camera cover into the box as a result.

* Boz was convinced we could build a voice assistant for Portal and Quest that was better than Siri, but the Assistant team at FB was completely out of their depth. We ended up right before launch having to sign a deal with Amazon to ship Alexa on the product.

* So much politics. AR/VR had a virtually unlimited budget so there was a massive land grab to hire as many people as possible, with no consideration around what they'd actually work on. Even though Quest and Portal had the same SoCs, they had completely separate Android OS builds and engineering teams, because everyone was trying to build the biggest engineering teams they could. People were constantly leaking shit: I found out we were delaying the project because an executive leaked it to Bloomberg while the executive meeting was still happening.

objclxt··on Squillions: How money laundering won
> It's common here in France for credit card operators to have fees in the 5-10% range (or 0.30€ per operation + 2% of the amount)

Interchange in the EU is capped at 0.4% for credit cards. Typical costs for processing are much lower than 5-10%.

For example, Adyen charges the 0.4% interchange + their fee of 0.6% and a flat 0.11€. On a 10€ transaction, that's 2.1%.

In most cases this is cheaper than handling cash. When you accept cash, you have to pay somebody to close and reconcile the drawer, take the cash to the bank (or have a security company do it for you), account for shrinkage / mistakes...it's a bit of a myth that cash is cheaper for businesses to handle, especially in places like the EU where card interchange rates are highly regulated.

Now of course, if your cash is not going the usual routes and isn't getting accounted for in the books...that equation can change.

objclxt··on United Airlines 767 returns to Newark after Bluetooth name sparks alert
> That sounds like bullshit to me.

Have you taken a US domestic flight? Everyone wants to bring their massive roll-ons into the cabin, nobody wants to check if they can avoid it.

objclxt··on Tesla Solar Roof is on life support as it pivot to panels
> SpaceX already produces solar panels for the 10,000+ satellites it has in space

No they don't, they procure them from Taiwan Solar Energy Corp. They do not produce or manufacture their own cells, they're using off the shelf components.

objclxt··on The Boston library where you still can borrow a giant puppet
> Beneath the Emmanuel Church on Newbury Street in Boston, tucked away in the basement, sits a library

This is underselling it: it's in a side street off Newbury, where nobody would have any reason to go, with a tiny little door about half the size of all the other doors marked "Puppet Library"[1].

I visited many years ago by complete accident: I was out running with some friends on a Tuesday afternoon, we were going down the public alley because Newbury was heaving, and saw this sign. We wandered in, and...yeah, there's a lot of puppets.

[1]: https://maps.app.goo.gl/pa6sTiQ1cFsp2mqcA

objclxt··on BYD Seal 08 debuts with Blade Battery 2.0: 1,000km range, 5-min charging, 684hp
> Meanwhile in Germany: Let's stick to combustion engines for at least 10 more years with 500km range and a multiple of energy and maintenance costs...

BMW is heavily invested in Neue Klasse[1], the iX3 has a long waiting list and a 800KM range.

[1]:https://www.bmwgroup.com/en/company/neue-klasse.html

objclxt··on The secrets of the Shinkansen
> Actually, it can barely fix the literal busiest station in the country

Liverpool Street isn't managed by TfL, it's managed by Network Rail.

objclxt··on Apple update looks like Czech mate for locked-out iPhone user
> Majority of California based companies employee English only or English and Spanish speakers possibly with some Indian language as well [...] Never mind rarer languages like Czech or Greek.

That may be generally true, in this case Apple actually has an engineering team in Czechia that works on biometrics and authentication:

https://zpravy.aktualne.cz/ekonomika/apple-posili-v-praze-ty...

https://jobs.apple.com/en-gb/details/200636301-2611/software...

objclxt··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
> Your post feels like the last generation lamenting the new generation [...] There's so much plumbing and refactoring bullshit in writing code [...] I've had my excitement

I don't read the OP as saying that: to me they're saying you're still going to have plumbing and bullshit, it's just your plumbing and bullshit is now going to be in prompt engineering and/or specifications, rather than the code itself.

objclxt··on US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private
> in any other threat model, security is an advantage of closed source

I think there's a lot of historical evidence that doesn't support this position. For instance, Internet Explorer was generally agreed by all to be a much weaker product from a security perspective than its open source competitors (Gecko, WebKit, etc).

Nobody was defending IE from a security perspective because it was closed source.

objclxt··on iOS allows alternative browser engines in Japan
> What kind of control would Chrome have over the web? Adding APIs doesn't force the billions of websites to adopt them.

You are assuming adding APIs is a net positive, and the debacle that was Chrome’s privacy sandbox initiative suggests that’s not the case

> why are we all dependent on Apple, alone, to save us from ~60% Chrome?

How’s Firefox doing now? They’re literally dependent upon Chrome to exist. Without Google they have no money to fund development.

The only viable non-Chromium browser engine today that is not funded by Google is WebKit.

objclxt··on Reverse engineering a $1B Legal AI tool exposed 100k+ confidential files
> Building physical buildings is a much simpler, much less complex process with many fewer degrees of freedom than building software.

I don't...think this is true? Google has no problems shipping complex software projects, their London HQ is years behind schedule and vastly over budget.

Construction is really complex. These can be mega-projects with tens of thousands of people involved, where the consequences of failure are injury or even death. When software failure does have those consequences - things like aviation control software, or medical device firmware - engineers are held to a considerably higher standard.

> The private market is perfectly capable of performing this function

But it's totally not! There are so many examples in the construction space of private markets being wholly unable to perform quality control because there are financial incentives not to.

The reason building codes exist and are enforced by municipalities is because the private market is incapable of doing so.

objclxt··on NTSB Preliminary Report – UPS Boeing MD-11F Crash [pdf]
> quite puzzling is how the Air India disaster still does not have a root cause analysis done

Not that puzzling: the most likely explanation is pilot suicide and the Indian government does not want to acknowledge that.

objclxt··on China intimidated UK university to ditch human rights research, documents show
"Need blind" here just means that your ability to pay the fees doesn't factor into the admissions decision, not that the admissions office doesn't know how wealthy you are (...since as you note, this is often easily inferred).

In other words, you won't be refused an offer simply because the university thinks you can't afford it.

objclxt··on The Swift SDK for Android
> Can I now build my app in Xcode with an Android target and use that binary in the Play Store?

No. The vision document[1] lays out the direction of travel. Currently the focus is on shared business logic and libraries, rather than full native applications (although that's certainly a goal, albeit a very long term one).

[1]: https://github.com/swiftlang/swift-evolution/pull/2946/files

objclxt··on Focus Is Saying No
> These tasks aren’t business priorities and had no impact on customers and other teams

...the author has reached the wrong conclusion from this. The problem is they weren't able to articulate why the modernization tasks were business priorities, not that the modernization wasn't a business priority in the first place.

If the tech debt is problematic, fixing it will presumably bring a number of benefits (faster development cycles, reduced defect rates, etc). They were doing the wrong work - they were doing a terrible job explaining why that work was necessary.

In many ways, tech debt and modernization is a near guaranteed way to have business impact, in a way product work is not. If you're at Meta and you figure out how to save 1% of total CPU time on the server by fixing some tech debt you can expect to be showered with money.

objclxt··on Offline card payments should be possible no later than 1 July 2026
> I wonder what the technical details will look like

It’s already a thing, the EMVCo standard predates ubiquitous internet connectivity. Mass transit systems typically use it, airlines used to for in-flight purchases before the advent of reliable WiFi.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMV#Offline_data_authenticat...

It is somewhat common to maintain a denylist of known fraudulent cards, but as you note the main mitigation is on the bank to track the card down. One of the key things you need to figure out with an offline payment system - and what I imagine is needed here - is a consensus on who has the liability for offline transactions and what the dollar limits are.

objclxt··on Instant Checkout and the Agentic Commerce Protocol
> This is textbook strategy [...] attempt to build a moat around something that ideally is open and interoperable

It's so textbook that Google two weeks ago came out with their own competing "open" standard for doing the same thing!

https://ap2-protocol.org

objclxt··on Cognition (Devin AI) to Acquire Windsurf
> I've seen a lot of harsh, misguided takes over the past few days, like that the Windsurf founders screwed over their employees [...] In this case, this seems like a happy ending for all parties involved

There is no evidence at all in the announcement that is the case. It just says "100% of Windsurf employees will participate financially in this deal". What "participate financially" looks like is not elaborated upon.

It is possible you're right. It's also equally possible that the founders have still screwed over their employees, we just don't know. Nothing in this post supports either position.

objclxt··on Jokes and Humour in the Public Android API
> How the hell did this pass code review? Are booleans strings on Android?

You are misreading the documentation, it's a key/value API.

`DISALLOW_FUN` is the string key you pass to `setUserRestriction`, which takes a boolean value.

objclxt··on CivitAI Policy Update: Removal of Real-Person Likeness Content
> MasterCard and Visa have no business unilaterally, secretly, and unaccountably policing their idiosyncratic idea of moral righteousness. They need to move money and shut up.

Mastercard and Visa don't block companies from processing because of morals, they block them because they lose them money. They will happily process your payments for all kinds of shady schemes that are - to them - low risk.

objclxt··on On loyalty to your employer (2018)
> the OP is in the EU and UK, where none of the above is true.

You can absolutely be dismissed without cause in the UK, protections against this only kick in after two years of employment.

objclxt··on AI hallucinations: Why LLMs make things up (and how to fix it)
> Gemini and Chat GPT with search are both perfectly capable of producing decent essays with accurate citations

OK, but this quote from your essay:

> The National Cancer Institute (NCI) reports that "cigarette smoking and exposure to tobacco smoke cause about 480,000 premature deaths each year in the United States."

...that citation is wrong. It's not from the NCI at all, the NCI cited that figure which came from another paper by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

The essay doesn't have accurate citations, the model has regurgitated content and doesn't understand when that content is from a primary source or when it in turn has come from a different citation.

Page 1 of 34Next →