HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noir-york

1,833 karma · joined September 19, 2013

I'm @brianazzopardi
submissionscomments
noir-york··on An ode to Apple’s awful MacBook keyboard
Oh absolutely! As soon as I flip open my mac in a cafe, every other patron immediately turns towards me to jealously admire my mac before slowly turning away to continue drinking their coffee and work away on their own mac...

Of course a laptop doesn't have that effect on people! I was being tongue in cheek. But beautiful objects in general - think fine art, expensive watches, etc - sure.

noir-york··on An ode to Apple’s awful MacBook keyboard
Apple built its brand on beautiful design.

But why do people want beautifully designed objects? Just to own something beautiful? Sure.

But also because it makes you look cool, attractive to members of the opposite sex, and earns the jealousy of yours.

But a keyboard which sucks ain't cool: sure the externals are great, but wrestling with a stuck capslock is the opposite of exuding je ne sais quoi.

Not cool Apple. Not cool. And therefore not beautiful.

noir-york··on DeepLog: Anomaly Detection and Diagnosis from System Logs (2017) [pdf]
So what does your organisation use for intrusion detection? Humans eyeballing logs doesn't scale. Rule-based approaches?
noir-york··on A Parlor Game at Rebekah Mercer’s Has No Get Out of Jail Free Card
I'd love to get a copy of this game. Google turned up nothing.
noir-york··on Show HN: Bistro Streams – A light-weight column-oriented stream analytics server
I get the impression that Bistro has a lot of thought put into it, but after quick skim through the docs and examples I still am not sure what Bistro is except "Like Kafka streams but different".

The example code is spread under core and server and very sparsely documented. It is not clear what is going on.

If you had a walk through of the examples that would go a long way to conveying what Bistro is and how to use it. If there already is such a document apolgies, I must have missed it.

noir-york··on In Memory of Isaiah Berlin
Berlin's Four Essays on liberty remains one of my most treasured moments (and books) in my intellectual journey. Lucid and intelligent writing, with none of the obscurantism. Of course, I have all Berlin's books.

A recent book and very good read I can recommend is Isaac & Isaiah by Caute which charts the rivalry between Isaiah Berlin and Isaac Deutcher (the author of an influential biography on Trotksy). I had not been aware of Berlin's (priviledged) background and the book helped contextualise his thinking.

noir-york··on Opening of Romeo and Juliet Recited in the Accent of Shakespeare’s Time [video]
For more check out https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPlpphT7n9s where there is an explanation of how original pronunciation was rediscovered.
noir-york··on High-quality schools can increase academic achievement among the poor (2010)
So where is all the money going? The UK has a (diminshed) NHS and spends less as a % of GDP.

I suspect that a big part of it is that money is being wasted (the Fed.Gov cannot negotiate drug prices!), and not reaching the intended beneficiaries. My perception is that there is an industrial-welfare complex that diverts the money.

noir-york··on High-quality schools can increase academic achievement among the poor (2010)
It used to, and then Schröder passed the Hartz reforms and the German welfare state has never been the same since.
noir-york··on High-quality schools can increase academic achievement among the poor (2010)
> The hundred billion dollar question is how do you scale it?

Its been done. Its called a funded welfare state.

> Show me a school model that's succeeding with the most at risk subdemographic within disadvantaged communities and then I'll be impressed.

Absolutely right, because it takes much more thatn just a good school to eradicate poverty. If you really need to help children, you need to start by helping their parents: national healthcare and decent well paying jobs.

Parents will have time to dedicate to their children if they are not busy and drained struggling to keep their head above water.

noir-york··on Every Ruler in Europe Every Year Since 400 BC
Fantastic video!

Seeing centuries of European history flash by reminds me of the rich history - whether you count it in blood, culture or intellectual progress - of the part of the world that I happen to live in, and rather proud of it.

Its one thing to know of the decline of the Roman empire, its another to see the rapid decline graphically.

noir-york··on Binary SMS – The old backdoor to your new thing
Great article! Thanks for posting.
noir-york··on Is capitalism a threat to democracy?
Yep, Augustus didn't like sharing power :D He must have felt guilty about it though because the Empire post-republic tried to keep up the appearance of Rome as Republic, if not in substance.
noir-york··on Is capitalism a threat to democracy?
The UK is what is called an aristocratic republic* as it retains the Roman Republic's setup: - Sovereign / House of Lords (Senate) / Lower house.

The US Founding Fathers copied England, and Rome's model but replaced the sovereign with a President.

Representative democracies are necessarily republics - although some, like my country, skip the upper house. Rome introduced consuls / republican model because the population was too large, unlike the Greek polis, to be politically manageable. Rome of course was not a democracy.

*or monarchic. I am away from my books so cannot confirm exactly the term. Sorry.

noir-york··on Is capitalism a threat to democracy?
Indeed, which is why modern democracies, or at least Western ones, don't describe themselves as democracies (except only as shorthand), but republican liberal* democracies.

* liberal here meaning political liberal (JS Mill liberalism), and not what is understood by "liberal" in US politics.

noir-york··on Is capitalism a threat to democracy?
Polanyi as a thinker isn't frankly particularly imaginative or interesting: for someone who read British economic history, it appears he missed Adam Smith's Moral Sentiments, political liberalism, and the rise of a parliamentary labour movement in England (as opposed to a revolutionary party).

If Polanyi had considered the above he wouldn't have come to the conclusion that the two possibilities are either socialism or fascism.

The prescriptions - social welfare, etc - at the end of the article are known. The question is why they haven't been implemented in the US (they have in most other Western counties to various degrees).

I address other points in another comment below.

noir-york··on Is capitalism a threat to democracy?
Is capitalism a threat to authoritarianism?

The Chinese Communist Party certainly was worried that capitalism would pose a threat. Turns out the Party is doing just fine.

"capitalism", i.e., a market-based economy is flexible and can be harnessed to serve whatever purposes a society desires.

So, no capitalism is not a threat to democracy, or communism for that matter.

Let's not forgot that capitalism is a recent invention. Kings and emperors were imposing their rule on their poor subjects without the help of free market economies for most of human history.

Right wing resurgence is back because the parties of the left forgot who gave birth to them - the working class. "Working class" is anachronistic now. The children of the working class became middle class. The new working class is now the middle class, increasingly being hollowed out.

What's to stop authoritarianism:

1. remove proportional voting. Coaltions allow parties to divide up the electorate. On the other hand, forcing parties to win 50%+1 of the vote forces parties to take broad-based policies that appeal to wide swathes of the electorate.

2. Invest in a social safety net. Education, healthcare and affordable housing promote social mobility, and more importantly, give peace of mind to those in the middle class who are afraid of losing the gains made by their parents.

3. Campaign finance reform. Its easier to turn out the vote and raise funding when parties turn to identity politics because nothing is more personal - and fires one up more - than appeal to one's identity.

Identity politics is cancer on democracy. Both left and right play the game and identity politics should be banned in a liberal (the John Stuart Mill kind) democracy.

4. Ban targeted political advertising. A liberal democracy needs a shared public space, and a discussion among all voters. Targeted political advertising breaks up that public space into millions of shards. Another option could be to force parties to post publicly all political adverts for everyone to see.

I ought, indeed, need to know what a party's policies are regarding pensioners or education even though I am neither a pensioner nor have children. Why? Because my taxes will be funding such items.

5. The left needs to be remember its origins. Sounds simple eh?

6. Finally, we need to drop the left-right way of identifying policies. It reduces policies which impact people and society into a basic for/against divisive manner. There is a better way.

Enough for today :)

noir-york··on What’s the waiter doing with the computer screen? (2012)
> Excel is an (eghem) excellent example of this concept in software

Excel is indeed an excellent example, and excellent software. On a related note, pivot tables must be the next best invention after the spreadsheet itself.

noir-york··on Blocked by Facebook and the Vulnerability of New Media
> creates its own aggregated newsfeed/filter

I am trying to build this very thing but Facebook's recent privacy issues have caused it to over react and I keep getting the below error:

"Access to this data is temporarily disabled for non-active apps or apps that have not recently accessed this data due to changes we are making to the Facebook Platform."

The API call getting the error is to retrieve the list of posts from a page. Getting an error for that is just silly. If anyone can help please contact me!

noir-york··on What Good Is ‘Community’ When Someone Else Makes All the Rules?
Well written article with excellent points. "community" is another instance of using language to frame or spin an issue, with the consequent diluting of what a real community is.

"Community is the spoonful of sugar that makes the othering go down." was particularly evocative.

noir-york··on Startup says it wants to fight poverty, but a food stamp giant is blocking it
Why? The countries I am familiar with (in Europe) manage to provide most social services through the government agencies just fine. When there is a scew up, its usually when the provision has been out-sourced (at great cost).
noir-york··on Startup says it wants to fight poverty, but a food stamp giant is blocking it
> What incentive would there then be to offer these services?

Justice.

The state should be providing these services to low-income people itself. Low-income people are not 'customers' - they are citizens and any money that is diverted to profit is money that is not going to the people who need it.

noir-york··on Startup says it wants to fight poverty, but a food stamp giant is blocking it
Propel is a feature, a digital skin over Conduent's data. If Propel really wanted to help poor people, it would help them go out to vote for candidates who want to fund social welfare and a higher minimum wage.

You would be forgiven for thinking that Propel, seeing the huge (in absolute terms) fed govt spend on programs, wanted a piece of that pie while draping itself in moral virtue. But that would be cynical...

noir-york··on Facebook to change user terms, limiting effect of EU privacy law
> How about freedom of association and freedom to contract

How free are you when one of the parties is naive (in the context of the contract) and has little power, and the other party has the interest, the means and the power to force an unfair contract?

Freedom of association implies the freedom to NOT associate. Yet non-Facebook users are tracked by Facebook, without their consent.

Laws like GDPR are needed to help protect individuals from powerful interests.

noir-york··on The ASUS Tinker Board is a compelling upgrade from a Raspberry Pi 3 B+
If its at all possible, and if so, has someone built such an SBC?

Alternatively, is there a practical way to attach external DDRAM to an existing 64-bit SBC, perhaps using the GPIO pins?

I have zero electronics knowledge so forgive my questions if they are stupid.

noir-york··on The ASUS Tinker Board is a compelling upgrade from a Raspberry Pi 3 B+
Maybe someone can help: is it possible to build an SBC can boot Linux and has just a CPU, gig ethernet and gobs of RAM (at least 8gb)?

Don't need display port, GPU, WiFi, Bluetooth, GPIO pins, etc - just a CPU + lots of RAM + an ethernet port to get stuff in/out.

noir-york··on Time to rebuild the web?
I think you're on to something.

A thought which came to mind would be for a country to levy an access charge (think of the BBC license fee) to access social networks based on usage. The money would then be used to clean up the negative externalities caused by the social network in that country.

noir-york··on Time to rebuild the web?
The web reduces the cost of information transfer to pretty much zero so anyone can publish, with no gatekeepers (of old).

Scale matters. Information inequality was inevitable.

Free trade led to growing concentrations of economic power and rising economic inequality. We also have information inequality to go with it, and because information transfer is much lower cost than trade, information inequality will be much higher and power more concentrated (social media stocks should thus be valued higher than companies which make real things)

Not sure the article understands that inequality is inherent in the structure of the web.

If you wanted to reduce inequaliy there are two options: 1. redistribution 2. raising the 'transaction' costs

In economics we know what those look like:

1. progressive taxation and a welfare state 2. legislation to raise environmental standards, increase minimum wages, etc.

What's the equivalent of a social welfare state and higher minimum wage when it comes to information?

Another way of looking at this is in terms of externalities: free social media generates both positive (connecting with old friends) and negative externalities (fake news, election mischief, etc).

One way of internalising both would be for Facbook to charge users. That is never going to happen. Carbon credits and the like make polluters internalise the costs that society would otherwise incur. So, what kind of legislation (and it will have to be legislation) would get social media companies to be pay for the negative externalities?

noir-york··on Causes and consequences of the Sicilian Mafia
From the article: "The historical record shows many instances in which the Mafia fought against the Peasant Fasci and collaborated with the military in suppressing protests and killing protesters."

However, according to Wikipedia: "Some historians emphasize that the leagues were engaged in class struggle against a coalition of landowners and mafiosi and ignore evidence of strategic alliances between the Fasci and the Mafia."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasci_Siciliani#Mafia_involvem...

I wonder which is it. Perhaps the Mafia was opportunistic and would ally with the Fasci (the workers) or the landowners depending on the local conditions. Its not like the Mafia is one single entity but composed of smaller (themselves warring) factions.

noir-york··on Birds can see Earth's magnetic fields because of cryptochromes in their eyes
The moral framework used generally tends to determine where one falls on the major debates in ethics. As I happen to be aware of the different moral frameworks, I do not have the luxury of being beholden to an unexamined, implicitly "chosen" moral framework. Often times my internal debate is which framework is the most appropriate to evaluate the ethical question at hand. I am talking about hard ethical problems here like euthanasia, not the everyday things like lying, theft, etc.

To answer your question, while in my personal life I take a more deontological (Kantian) moral approach, if I were in a policy making role I'd take the pragmatic, utilitarian road; that bird would be sacrificed if it really did help advance science. Ecce homo.

← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →