HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noibl

1,165 karma · joined April 18, 2010

submissionscomments
noibl··on Show HN: Hacked Hacker News - new comment highlighting and keyboard navigation
Very nice. If it had a key handler to collapse the current comment with all replies[1], then I think it would be heaven. (Helps with long tangent threads at the top of the comment page.)

I know, this should be a pull request...

Edit: BTW, I just saw '(-1 unread)' which I'm guessing has something to do with showdead being on.

[1] http://alexander.kirk.at/2010/02/16/collapsible-threads-for-...

noibl··on Fujitsu Not Pleased With Windows 8 Demand, Either
I know I said I was done but since you keep harping on the point, I'll just leave this here:

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Technology/Pix/pictures/...

It shows global PC sales flat since the start of 2010. The iPad debuted in April 2010.

noibl··on Why your paycheck is getting smaller, no matter what
> I thought that Christmas was supposed to be about spending time with loved ones, not about blowing thousands of dollars on unnecessary gifts.

Did you really? I guess that means you don't have kids.

> Has anyone stopped to consider that maybe we should stop wasting so much money during the holiday season?

Actually lots of people, since before Dickens, and often with ironic reference to the basic moral tenets of Christianity. And yet here we are. Like the Diamond Jubilee of Queen Elizabeth II, it is what it is.

> more money to Chinese factories ... killing more Arabs or corporate welfare

You seem to be saying that on the one hand, workers don't know how to spend their pay while on the other hand, neither does the government. So perhaps 'ideally' it's not such a bad thing to have the money end up in a part of the world where millions of people a year are actively raising themselves out of poverty on the back of export demand.

noibl··on Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
Thanks for clarifying. In the context of not addressing the question over Greenwald's credibility it looked sarcastic to me. You see, it's very confusing if you express appreciation for something that seems to contradict your point but then don't address the contradiction.
noibl··on Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
That's OK. Sneering non-responses are also informative.
noibl··on Warrantless wiretaps? Congress votes yes
> moves the goalposts to suggest Obama abandoned that objective by casting a yea vote that indemnified telcos for (a) lawful surveillance (b) conducted under the color of an entirely new statute in (c) a bill that mostly consisted of new limitations on FISA surveillance powers.

On (a), how or why can one be indemnified for lawful activity?

The bill to which Greenwald refers does in fact grant retroactive immunity from lawsuits seeking to show that the telco's participation was unlawful.[1] Such lawsuits would occur because other parties to the activity are protected by other mechanisms.

On (b), not sure what you mean by 'under the color of'. Hopefully not a reference to retroactive legalisation.

(c) doesn't seem at all relevant to the specific point here.

[1] http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/intel/RL34600.pdf

noibl··on Fujitsu Not Pleased With Windows 8 Demand, Either
> What claims have I made that are false?

You said they're growing. They're shrinking.

I'm out.

noibl··on Fujitsu Not Pleased With Windows 8 Demand, Either
It's not desktop Windows. It's Windows.

See my posts re declining PC sales for why this would matter (hint: people are getting work done on devices).

Then we can fall back to the argument that consumer PCs aren't really important anyway.

noibl··on Fujitsu Not Pleased With Windows 8 Demand, Either
I guess you missed the part where demand for this hugely anticipated OS release is looking decidedly weak?[0][1][2]

(I love that after telling one person they don't know what they're talking about, while making obviously false claims yourself, you continue to lecture about 'reality'.)

BTW, I'm not posting in support of Lewisham's thesis, so I have no need for straws.

[0] TFA

[1] http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/Articles/2012/12/03/Why-Window...

[2] http://news.investors.com/technology/101612-629557-intel-bea...

noibl··on Fujitsu Not Pleased With Windows 8 Demand, Either
> the rate of PC shipments is still increasing.

Gartner and IDC: PC shipments tumbled over 8 percent in Q3[1]

That's the second consecutive quarter of negative global growth.[2]

>> The consumer PC market has cratered since the iPad

> There are a lot more PCs sold per quarter than iPads

I don't think 'since the iPad' meant losing out solely to iPad sales.

[1] http://www.engadget.com/2012/10/10/gartner-and-idc-pc-shipme...

[2] http://www.consumerit.eu/index.php?option=com_content&vi...

noibl··on Fujitsu Not Pleased With Windows 8 Demand, Either
Regarding sales as opposed to usage:

Windows once held an overwhelming lead in 2008 with about 70 percent of the OS market, Forrester found in estimating overall personal computing device sales by OS. By 2012, that market share had shrunk to about 30 percent.

-- http://rcpmag.com/articles/2012/10/22/microsoft-os-market-sl...

According to a Goldman Sachs report acquired by The Seattle Times, Windows lost massive share in the global compute market-- from being the OS of choice in 97% of all computing devices in 2000 to just 20% in 2012.

-- http://www.consumerit.eu/index.php?option=com_content&vi...

noibl··on How the U.S. government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition
While the Tuskegee experiment followed the natural progression of syphilis in those already infected, in Guatemala [US Public Health Service] doctors deliberately infected healthy people (having just defeated the Nazis).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guatemala_syphilis_experiment

noibl··on How the U.S. government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition
Other [denaturing formulas] used bitter-tasting compounds that were less lethal, designed to make the alcohol taste so awful that it became undrinkable.

This approach was also applied to non-industrial alcohol products, leading to another round of mass poisoning:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamaica_ginger

noibl··on Merry Doomsday HN: All of my YC Facelifts are free to download and use
Sorry but to me the overuse of gold just says 'You can be Donald Trump.' I understand the idea behind it but the contrast between the designs highlights a problem with this kind of project: lack of input.

Exec's current design makes the whole proposition feel more normal and the way they've put the personal elements up-front helps allay any latent worries about somebody being exploited. I don't think this is accidental.

Web designers sometimes forget that visual communication is about so much more than layout, colours and fonts. The visual content is extremely important. And I suspect that with reference to their marketing goals, Exec have done well here. (Of course there's room for improvement.)

FWIW, I think this is the weakest of the designs the OP has presented, and that because of a difference in message. Not at all saying you're bad at what you do, Kyro. Speaking of exploitation, I've downloaded the pack and will no doubt learn something from it. Thanks!

noibl··on The Inconvenient Truth About SEO
http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2012/12/11/seo-the-inconveni...

Sweet.io: why?

noibl··on Mozilla Game On
Thanks. Your response to the issue reflects well on your organisation (imho). I'm making a note here: 'huge success'.
noibl··on Mozilla Game On
> (long story)

I hope I'm not being a dick by commenting on this but the subthread is getting fairly long with 'me too's. Can you give any kind of explanation as to what's been going wrong?

Also, this is the first I've heard about Game On 2010 so I went to find out more[1] and it looks like all of the links (winners list, game gallery) have been stomped by this year's site. I can still see Google's cached screenshots but no info.

And ninethly: loved Browserquest. Competitors, get your MMO on!

[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=mozilla+game+on

noibl··on "Gun" "Control"
> If we legislate 3D printing to prevent weapon manufacture, we run directly counter to the idea of "Print anything you need at home!".

It's not necessary to refer specifically to the means of manufacture. Homemade weapons are already regulated. The legal risk you run by illegal possession is separate from how you obtained it.

> Is it desirable to require that 3D printers can recognize infringing mechanisms?

Again, a simpler question would be: "Is it necessary?" And the answer, of course, is no.

Seriously, this article is talking about completely hypothetical problems. There is plenty of time to legislate on 3d printing if and when it becomes a serious problem in and of itself.

noibl··on Tor trip report to an FBI conference
> http://parley.co

Excellent writeup. It really helps when the conversation is steered away from terms like 'amendment', 'advertisers', 'enforcement', 'criminality' and steered back to the central idea of recovering and safeguarding an intuitive and traditional idea of privacy in personal communication (postcard analogy). Lots of people, many with vested interests, insist that this isn't possible, that the genie is out of the bottle. But let's at least try, right?

In fact, PGP was a neat solution for the internet of the '90s with its quaint directory services (Bigfoot, anyone?) and dialup links. I think it had Pretty Good uptake too. So I'm very interested to see what can be done in today's environment.

(Your exchange with jmillikin looked promising too. Did it continue?)

noibl··on Tor trip report to an FBI conference
You said '(be it Outlook, your phone, or the web-mail host)'. I was just providing a relevant historical example to support your point. (Lavabit does have a webmail interface.)

FWIW, the Hushmail ex-CEO seems to strongly agree with you on both the ethics point and the need for users to take blind trust out of the security equation.

---

So I've just gone to the Lavabit site and it looks like that they store your private key on the server.[1] That doesn't strike me as being more secure than Malone's idea of externally-audited client-side crypto. But then, as you say, you've arrived at PGPGPG.

The fact, then, that Zimmerman was involved with the company so early on and they still fucked it up just goes to show that faith in the efforts of 'a few dedicated folks' doesn't get you very far.

[1] http://lavabit.com/secure.html

noibl··on Tor trip report to an FBI conference
> alter the binary that interfaces the client

Which, in case it's not clear, is exactly what Hushmail did/does.

http://themonetaryfuture.blogspot.com.au/2009/05/pgp-creator...

noibl··on How to Make Your Site Look Half-Decent in Half an Hour
Just wanted to say thanks to you and your contributers over the years. I always thought 24 articles in 24 days was a very ambitious idea but somehow you guys always deliver the magic.

I'm not the target audience for this article either so it really is hard to judge, but I got something out of it and I can see that a number of people found it helpful and timely.

Don't change!

noibl··on Ask PG: What Changed?
Right, right. Or! We could stop redefining common words and agree that 'pay' is a verb in the present tense.

(Please don't kill me.)

noibl··on Ask PG: What Changed?
> A question can be one we consistently pay attention to without being in the top 10.

Sure, but the query was about "pay most attention to".

I wonder if hacking the YC app process via PR stunt became too obvious an answer to the question over time.

noibl··on Stephen Hawking pushes for posthumous pardon for Alan Turing
> It's kinda weird to me as many in the UK wouldn't be particularly accepting of that sort of age gap now, particularly not for casual sexual liaisons. The age of consent for homosexual male sex was lowered to 18 in 1994 - that means that up until 1994 Turing's actions were illegal in the UK.

1. I don't see how continued discrimination against gay people into recent decades (and, indeed, the present) supports your claim about public attitudes towards 'age gap'. Unless you're suggesting that there's some kind of morally significant link between the two. In that case, maybe you can explain why the age of consent for girls (16 between 1885 and 1994) needed to be raised from 13 in the first place.

2. In a debate over equal rights, assertions about the moral sentiment of some presumed majority are completely irrelevant. Appealing to legality and the democratic process and in the same breath to some vague idea of mob 'acceptance' is hypocritical. You can't have it both ways.

3. Even if discriminatory age-of-consent statutes were relevant, it's not 1994. The age of consent in the UK has been 16 since 2001 -- that's one third longer than the preceding period that you suggest reflects current public sentiment.

> lifestyle choice

Oh.

noibl··on Hacker News Google+ Community
> Given that [the existence of r/4chan is met with scorn on 4chan], it would seem that r/4chan is composed entirely of people who don't actually browse 4chan!

Non-sequitur (really a classic syllogistic fallacy if you consider who does the scorning). Peer pressure exists ('meekly admit'). One could even imagine that the kind of 4chan user who might prefer to sometimes express themselves in a more 'moderate' environment such as on Reddit would be the kind least likely to provoke a visceral response by outing themselves as a user of r/4chan.

It's very difficult to know anything about the 'average' member of an online community, especially without surveys.

noibl··on My open source cure for brain cancer
> But Traditional Chinese Medicine and Homeopathic Oncology are not treatments; they operate under fraudulent principles - they are, at best, Lifestyle interventions

The foundational principles of traditional medicine (Chinese, Ayurvedic, whatever) are generally bullshit. But that doesn't mean that everything that emerges from them should be ignored. If researchers have the resources and inclination to engage with specific claims and put them to the test, surprising discoveries can still result in this day and age.[1] Of course, that doesn't mean that discussion of any one patient's treatment should always be surrounded by a haze of quackery. But we shouldn't close the door completely. We should be careful to distinguish the fanciful principles of traditional therapies from their observed benefits over centuries and from the actually fraudulent nature of later pseudomedicine such as homeopathy.

[1] http://www.washington.edu/news/2011/04/04/high-dose-of-oxyge...

noibl··on Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out
Thanks, now I get it. Having a UI cue when you're on the DDG website is a good idea.
noibl··on Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out
Wait, 'one-click'?

In Firefox if I click the dropdown on the search field, then click 'Manage Search Engines' I get a dialog in which can be found a link to 'Get more search engines...'.

Clicking that opens an add-ons store tab with the 'Search Tools' filter applied, none of whose above-the-fold suggestions has anything to do with DDG. That's not one-click, it's a runaround.

In contrast, Chrome automatically adds search engines as you browse the web and lets you set any one of them as the default. It also has clearly labelled fields to let you create your own by copying the format of the ones listed. Getting to there takes 3 clicks and a scroll.

Two reasonable gripes: the existence of the free-edit fields is not immediately obvious upon clicking 'Manage search engines...' and neither is the fact that the domain name in the second column is an editable keyword.

noibl··on Social Media Companies Have Absolutely No Idea How to Handle the Gaza Conflict
That's a shameful distortion of what I admitted.

Pron explained why the association with your comment was unfair and I admitted that it was. Your comment, however, remains.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →