1,319 karma · joined November 21, 2018
THC in the blood doesn’t mean actively high for habitual users, which would be most users if THC consumption is high. It means recent use, but not clear impairment.
Another example by Searle is a computer simulating digestion is not digesting like a stomach.
The people saying AI can’t form from LLMs are in the consensus side of the Chinese Room. The digestion simulator could tell us where every single atom is of a stomach digesting a meal, and it’s still not digestion. Only once the computer simulation breaks down food particles chemically and physically is it digestion. Only once an LLM received photons or has a physical capacity to receive photons is there anything like “seeing a night sky”.
> Yann LeCun was first, fully coming around to his own, very similar critique of LLMs by end of 2022.
> The Nobel Laureate and Google DeepMind CEO Sir Demis Hssabis sees it now, too.
Why they focus on feelings is a different issue.
All of it has the appearance of sounding so smart, and a few sites were genuine. But it got taken over.
How about: some pasta and bread to enable physical exertion.
Every skill and skill level is specifically assigned and hired in the RLHF world.
Sometime the skill levels are fuzzier, but that’s usually very temporary.
And as been said already, IMO is a specific skill that even PHD math holders aren’t universally trained for.