HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mathperson

203 karma · joined November 19, 2016

submissionscomments
mathperson··on Ask HN: Best books you read in 2017?
I actually much prefer the years of LBJ to the power broker. Caro uses the extra length to go soon much deeper.
mathperson··on Vanguard Founder Jack Bogle Says ‘Avoid Bitcoin Like the Plague’
yes!
mathperson··on Vanguard Founder Jack Bogle Says ‘Avoid Bitcoin Like the Plague’
Is this a joke? If so its really funny. If not...you definitely are missing the point
mathperson··on What Made the SR-71 Blackbird Such a Badass Plane (2015)
"The landing gear situation is something only crazy cold war people would approve of."

oh gee whiz. this is such a great comment. I almost spilled coffee laughing on my keyboard. A+.

mathperson··on Google will ‘de-rank’ RT articles to make them harder to find – Eric Schmidt
eh.....I think the dust hasn't really settled yet on franken. also you are just wrong. the russian story is very real and very serious...
mathperson··on Grad School Tuition Wavers to Be Taxed as Income in Congress's Tax Plan
I think you are just wildly wrong on 1. These waivers are a part of graduate school support for most if not all Phd programs. I.e. I do research, take classes,and perhaps TA. The university pays me a small stipend, and pays my 'tuition' for whatever courses I take, i.e. paying itself. That implicit part of my compensation WOULD be taxable.

"This means most students unaffiliated with the school would be protected from any tax on graduate school tuition aid."

This clearly not true from the article you cite and the verge article (see the comments by the spokeswoman). Where is this claim coming from?

mathperson··on Intel to Develop Discrete GPUs, Hires AMD's Raja Koduri as Chief Architect
they are companies directly competing...it is very possible AMD engineer could bring proprietary information to INTEL. as in this literally recently happened and received massive press coverage with UBER and WAYMO- resulted in intense legal action.
mathperson··on Testimony of Facebook, Google, and Twitter to US Senate
To be honest I find a lot of what you wrote here irrelevant. The goal of mueller is not to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that russian support was effective. We can't prove what caused millions of trump voters to be persuaded. (However, I think it is clear it had a significant effect). He is investigating crimes not causality. Frankly whether it worked or not doesn't really matter-the crimes committed by american citizens in the process and how to avoid similar actions by foreign governments again are what matters.

As for your statements about 2008 or 2012 I would need a lot of citations for claims about russian interference in those elections.

Your statement about this current anti-russian wave is wildly off base.

Comparing an innocuous diplomatic statement and a line during a debate with a prolonged and consistent pattern of contact between campaign officials to obtain intelligence provided by the Russian government through hacking....

Moving on-yes- lobbying is bad.

The next paragraph where you talk about Podesta is baffling to me. The strongest case against the president (note these might not actually be crimes-often the cover-up is more damaging and criminal) is that his campaign officials met with agents of the russian government (who represented themselves thusly) and intelligence services to proffer damaging material on a domestic political opponent. Your contention that it is possible that "the campaign was equally clueless about the entire thing" is belied by the fact that three of the key principals (Manafort, Kushner, Don Jr) in the trump campaign met with agents of the russian government...(among many any other incidents).

Hell there was a new york times article this very day about how the trump campaign was aware of the DNC hacks months before it became public knowledge. Donald trump cheered the hackers on in debates. Claiming the campaign was entirely unaware is dead wrong.

You then mention how there needs to be a demonstrated pattern of pro-russian behavior. I mentioned a fair few above-adding in that trump still has not implemented a recent round of sanctions.

To the geopolitical point-the actions of America are very far from perfect. I have many frustrations with the actions of my government. But I do not know if the world would be much more stable if America did not exist and neither do you.

I assure you- the united states is not a russian puppet and will never be so.

mathperson··on Testimony of Facebook, Google, and Twitter to US Senate
Are you serious? Donald is SIGNIFICANTLY more pro-russia than Hilary would have been. Ex-post facto that justified it. Actions of Donald: 1. Intense skepticism of NATO (Russia hates this). 2. attempted to remove sanctions 3. Return spy compounds 4. America turning inwards and rejecting its international role as the hegemonic power and guarantor of western institutions. 5. The russians have preferred the republicans for a few years now since they were viewed as being more real-politik.

But mostly Donald wasn't hilary. Putin HATED Hilary for complex reasons linked to 1. bill clinton's expansion of NATO 2. What putin perceived as american support for violent regime change i.e. which he viewed as an existential threat. This included Hilary speaking in public in support of Russian dissidents and her exulting in the overthrow and execution of gaddafi (while she was secretary of state) 3. Hilary was basically an anti-russia hawk in general.

It seems the active measures campaign was never expected to result in Donald winning. I think the reasonable expectation was that hilary would be discredited and ineffective after winning with no clear mandate and intense resistance by the right. It was by no means random. It is intensely idiotic to think a nation state ruled by a canny, KBG trained, dictator would invest substantial resources and risk American retaliation to cause 'randomness'. His actions had chaotic results to be sure...but he had clear goals.

"If Mueller's final report says the Russians had a major influence on the election then what happens? I can't imagine it being good for anyone."

and the alternative being we close our eyes and pretend not to see? hopefully it would result in a return to paper ballots and hardened cyber security all across the Western world.

At this point though, we all know what the Mueller report will say in its generality. YES the russians had major influence on the election. Denying that at this point is delusional! Mueller is more about what role auspices of the trump campaign violated the law in their acceptance of russian aid...that is still somewhat of an open question as to degree and the level of criminality but it is quite clear that the Trump campaign had some amount of communication and coordination with agents of the Russian government.

mathperson··on How a destructive idea paved the way for modern math
There is also "counterexamples in topology"!
mathperson··on Ask HN: We have a great team and capital but can't find a good idea
Do something about nlp+social network -> Russian fake news detection. Sell it to Facebook/twitter so they can shut down propagandists
mathperson··on 108 F-35s Will Not Be Combat Capable
the legacy fighters are pretty old airframes and I think even the new blocks are going to be outclassed in any seriously contested airspace. the real comparison should not be between the f35 and f16.

it should be between the f35 and a different program which isn't a gross hodgepodge of the demands of everyone and their mom. concurrency, one size fits-all-fighter...madness.

mathperson··on Many junior scientists need to take a hard look at their job prospects
Depends on field.
mathperson··on University of Chicago Graduate Students Vote to Unionize
-no longer has to ensure hyde park DOESNT experience urban decay
mathperson··on University of Chicago Graduate Students Vote to Unionize
I'm not sure the uchicago sell off is because they are cash strapped. probably because uchicago feels like it no longer has to ensure that hyde park experiences urban decay (aka why they bought the buildings) and to shift those funds it into something with a better rate of return.
mathperson··on University of Chicago Graduate Students Vote to Unionize
http://knowthefacts.uchicago.edu/ eligible voters are "All graduate students in the School of Divinity, School of Social Service Administration, Division of the Social Sciences, Division of the Humanities, Division of the Biological Sciences, and Division of the Physical Sciences who are or were compensated as full-time and regular part-time teaching assistants, research assistants, course assistants, workshop coordinators, writing interns, preceptors, language assistants, instructors, lecturers, lectors, and teaching interns, in at least one quarter of Autumn 2016, Winter 2017, Spring 2017, Summer 2017, or Autumn 2017, and who have not yet attained their degree or otherwise completed their course of study."

Some wikipedia resulted in 600 (law)+ 400 ( medschool)+ 3140 (business)+noise term ~5000 grad students. I bet the rest of the gap is just low turnout

mathperson··on A convicted felon who became a Georgetown law professor
You are answering your own question.
mathperson··on A convicted felon who became a Georgetown law professor
Did you read the article? It is pretty clear he is quite competent..
mathperson··on How the Transbay Transit Center Is Reshaping San Francisco
because a major infrastructure project is WILDLY overbudget..
mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
I found him in some tabroom results for LD and public forum-so he definitely competed at least a little in the events he criticizes-but I agree it seems a tad deceptive.

I feel bad attacking his credentials-I am sure he was a fine debater. This article is of course...quite silly. Comparing children reading foucault and baudrillard or cass sunstein and talking quickly about nuclear proliferation with "the kind of language currently poisoning our public sphere" is not even wrong.

mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
This also reminds me of how often people on hackernews complain about scientific papers of being overly technical and abstract..The complexity is to a large portion necessary to communicate meaningful arguments instead of 'used car salesmen'
mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
yes!
mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
yeah this actually exists..there are a LOT of debate circuits that basically only allow parents to judge so you are being judged by 'typical' citizens.
mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
There are debate formats and tournaments that encourage 'actual, useful rhetoric'. I.e. Congressional Debate, Parliamentary Debate, and certain tournaments and competitive circuits in LD. I.e TOC bidding tournaments are oriented towards the high speed fun stuff with Nietzche and Kritiks etc etc compared to the National Debate Tournament which ruthlessly enforces a much more traditional style of debate... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LFFOLNdSOWE

High School Debate is not some monolithic top down hierachy- there is a vast array of tournaments and events that cater primarily to the needs and preferences of the students who choose to compete in them for fun.

Fast debate with competent judges doesn't just stop being debate...everyone starts slow and over time learns to speak cogently at speed. If their arguments don't make sense at speed to the judge they are typically discarded outright. Fast debate really opens the competitive landscape, since you have a lot more time to open up complex ethical frameworks and longer arguments. If you and the judge and the other debater understand what is being said..well..why should we restrict ourselves from having an educational and fun round? because it matches the preconceptions of some musician on hackernews about what 'debate' is? pish posh

mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
I think it's this event. I assumed he was talking TOC or the event you posted. Ive never even heard of this format.. But it looks pretty dull in my opinion compared to ld or policy or even parli

https://www.regis.org/articletest.cfm?id=7403

mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
I second this. Debate was really fun and if you didn't want to talk fast there were plenty of lay tournaments and forums.
mathperson··on The Corrosion of High School Debate
lol the mountain represent /\
mathperson··on UC Berkeley research fellow Michael Cohen dies at 25
less arduous is a bit subjective no? different types of intellectual labor different types of standards etc including length.
mathperson··on A Serf on Google’s Farm
This is probably the best content I've ever seen from TPM. Took a lot of negative feelings I have towards Monopoly and effectively crystallized a small subset of the harms in a particular case. Digital capitalism is not so different from the old forms..
mathperson··on On Melissa O’Neill’s PCG random number generator
I am not sure why you are being downvoted. I think this is clearly true.

An easy way to make research accessible is to write a monograph!

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →