HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lthornberry

268 karma · joined July 26, 2014

submissionscomments
lthornberry··on Fewer students are enrolling in doctoral degrees
Most academics teach in departments that don’t grant phds. They’re at liberal arts Colleges or regional state universities. True that statistically only a small percentage of grad students will go on to have their own PhD students, but that doesn’t mean there are no jobs for the rest.
lthornberry··on Fewer students are enrolling in doctoral degrees
The fact that you don't understand something is not evidence that it's not valuable.
lthornberry··on Fewer students are enrolling in doctoral degrees
This is Dunning-Kruger in sentence form.
lthornberry··on Fewer students are enrolling in doctoral degrees
The glut is primarily a function of the fact that universities have decided that it's fine to have most of their courses taught by poorly-paid adjuncts. That is, actually, a bad thing. If we returned to having tenure-track faculty do a substantial majority of teaching, most people who get humanities degrees would get jobs in the end.
lthornberry··on Show HN: Ricotta – Language Learning to Replace Anki
Yeah, I noticed later that the example sentences used the correct translation. Presumably that's because it's easier for translation software to differentiate among the various meanings of "used" when it's in the context of a sentence.
lthornberry··on Show HN: Ricotta – Language Learning to Replace Anki
How are you generating the decks? There are some incorrect translations, at least for for the version of Spanish I learned. Maybe there’s a dialect that says “ser usado” instead of “acostumbrarse” for “be used to”?
lthornberry··on Why is homeschooling becoming fashionable?
Those numbers do not mean what you seem to think. 1st, proficiency on that test is a pretty high bar. There are kids making perfectly adequate progress who don’t score proficient. Second, average per-pupil costs are meaningless. Baltimore city pays for two of my kids’ educations. One costs the city about $8k (the money that a school gets for a kid with no extra needs). The other costs well over $100k, due to significant disabilities. Baltimore has a disproportionate number of kids with significant needs of some sort, including learning disabilities, extreme family poverty, and ESL learners. Those kids need extra resources. A voucher system isn’t going to change that.
lthornberry··on Maybe Bluesky has "won"
The decision to promote blue check replies is a product-level decision that has made the user experience much, much worse
lthornberry··on Amazon Makes It Harder for Disabled Employees to Work from Home
There are tort firms doing that in every area of tort law. ADA cases are not easy wins and don’t often produce significant awards.
lthornberry··on Ticketmaster’s attempt to game arbitration services fails
Basically similar situation in the US, that’s what the article means when in references “formation” issues.
lthornberry··on The evolution of nepotism in academia, 1088-1800
Eh, I teach in a university and that experience makes me extremely skeptical of most high-school graduates' ability to get an education from online resources. If you can do that, great, it's certainly a much cheaper and convenient route. I don't think we should discriminate against people who got their education that way. But most people need more structure and expert guidance.
lthornberry··on The evolution of nepotism in academia, 1088-1800
It also creates conflict of interest problems among the owners. How do you ensure that only your share of the business profit is getting siphoned off to support your kid? Does each owner get one fail-son slot?
lthornberry··on ‘America does so much more to subsidise affluence than alleviate poverty’
I also support a shift to UBI, but your description of TANF/WIC is not grounded in reality. TANF has a 5 year lifetime, and many states actually have lower limits food stamps do not come close to covering the costs of feeding a family People do sell food stamps sometimes, not because they have more than they need, but because they are desperate for cash to pay for other necessities such as utilities.

The idea that people are getting by for years and years based on these as sources of income is a myth.

lthornberry··on Fire Them All; God Will Know His Own
This is the important point. Anyone paying taxes in the US is subsidizing Harvard.
lthornberry··on Bikes, not self driving cars, are the technological gateway to urban progress
Cars are also not compatible with many types of disabilities. Cars will need to be part of the transit mix, but they don't need to dominate it.
lthornberry··on The quiet cost of family caregiving
That's not what the Canadian system is, though. The state kills people, and not just the terminally ill. There is lots of room for coercion, and more than a few disabled people have stories of someone trying to persuade them to consider MAiD even though they have never expressed any interest.
lthornberry··on The Portuguese can no longer afford to live in Portugal
For many decades, California has had extremely restrictive building regulations, especially in the most desirable areas. That is slowly changing, but the actual building has always been straightforward. It is getting the permission to do so that is complicated, expensive, and often just impossible.
lthornberry··on Don’t teach kids to fear the world
Ironically, I live in the notoriously high-crime city to your north, with kids basically the same age. The older one has free reign of our neighborhood at this point. We live in a walkable neighborhood with streets narrow enough that cars can't pick up any significant speed. Everyone agrees that Columbia is "safer," but I'm way less worried about my kids up here.
lthornberry··on U.S. News pulls Columbia University from its 2022 rankings
This kind of thing is much more likely to happen in the discussion section of a large lecture class than in a small seminar, because the discussion section is likely taught by a graduate student with little prior teaching experience.
lthornberry··on U.S. News pulls Columbia University from its 2022 rankings
This is a plot point of the season of The Wire set in the school system. In Baltimore, it is definitely tied to funding--schools get per-pupil funding, but students have to actually be in attendance a certain percentage of the first six weeks of school in order to count for the funding formula.
lthornberry··on Why America can’t build
There's significant research showing that housing-first policies (which means getting people into housing with basically no strings attached) are effective not only at reducing homelessness but also at improving mental health and addiction outcomes.

Literally incarcerating people just for being too poor to afford decent housing is also ethically abhorrent, of course, but it's also not the most effective way to reduce the problems that are bothering you.

lthornberry··on Why America can’t build
It's a result of not funding appropriate community-based supports after deinstitutionalization. Deinstiutionalization could have worked out very, very differently, if we'd been willing to pay for the alternatives.
lthornberry··on Microsoft will include pay ranges in all U.S. job postings
I don't know anything about Texas non-compete law, but "right to work state" refers to restrictions on unionizing. It has nothing to do with non-compete clauses.
lthornberry··on Please, don't build another Large Hadron Collider
Agree. The total US non-defense research budget has hovered below 2% of federal spending for the last four decades. The military budget has been around 15%. We need more research, not less.
lthornberry··on Ask HN: What is the best jurisdiction for internationally distributed teams?
The issue isn't just whether you actually are a US Person; it's whether banks, etc., believe that you're not. Risk-averse institutions may just avoid doing business with anyone who seems like they might be, and can use whatever proxies they like to decide who they don't want to transact with.
lthornberry··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
This varies massively by school or district. I teach history to undergrads, and some of them come in having had entire high school classes on the history of civil rights--these students are usually either from majority-black districts, or from elite private schools. Others had history classes that don't even acknowledge that slavery was the cause of the Civil War.
lthornberry··on Google cancelled a talk on caste bias
Age discrimination is illegal by statute - the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. If you haven't seen that, it might give you pause about whether you have enough information about this subject to form an informed opinion.
lthornberry··on So I took a corporation to arbitration
There are good points here, but the equal protection clause has nothing to do with this issue. There are standards in contract law that apply (and are state-specific). Those could be statutorily changed.
lthornberry··on So I took a corporation to arbitration
I’ve rented in CA as well as other states. CA rental protections were great for getting my landlord to back down from withholding my security deposit for illegal reasons.
lthornberry··on I'm retiring from the engineering profession
That "because" is glossing over a massive leap in logic. "Not applying objective professional standards" is not just a government problem, as pretty much anyone with experience in a large-scale private organization can attest.
Page 1 of 3Next →