HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kiratp

964 karma · joined September 19, 2017

Co-Founder @ osmos.io
submissionscomments
kiratp··on DuckDB – An in-process SQL OLAP database management system
Its disappointing that C++ was chosen to build something that is going to live in-process. Rust would have been so much safer. All the segfaults you get when running DucDB supports this statement.
kiratp··on Docker 2.0 went from $11M to $135M in 2 years
Sometimes it’s better to just change your workflow to match the tool if that avoids you having to build and maintain your own ticketing system
kiratp··on New video of Tesla crash demonstrates the problem of semi-automated driving
This looks like the vehicle tried and failed to get the driver to engage and pulled over best it could. There is no shoulder there so…

Let’s wait to get more info as to what the driver was doing and if they were incapacitated.

The FSD beta is pretty aggressive on making sure the driver is paying attention via both steering sensors, the in-cabin camera and the touch screen.

kiratp··on Why Not Mars
Antarctica has the same gravity and radiation levels (magnetosphere) as everywhere on Earth.

In HN speak - “to learn to build a filesystem, build a web server first!”

kiratp··on Why Not Mars
Speaking for myself, the Prime Directive is the survival of humanity.

Any other altruistic Prime Directive (ala Star Trek) is a luxury affordable only by a species that has figured out a way past the eventual explosion of their system’s star.

kiratp··on Why Not Mars
> And there’s nothing in the foreseeable future (the next 10–15 years) that changes that.

If we cannot, at a nation-state level, apply ourselves to 30-50 year goals, we might as well just give up on the survival of humanity.

kiratp··on Why Not Mars
We will continue to kill each other at a similar rate regardless of the outcome of colonization. At least, unlike “Manifest Destiny”, there are no innocent sentient beings we will be attacking.
kiratp··on Why Not Mars
https://mars.nasa.gov/msr/

Sample return step 1 (collect samples) is already underway.

kiratp··on Why Not Mars
Arguments against human colonization of the solar system (moon/Mars/etc) sound just like trying ot argue against the westward expansion from the 13 colonies.

We will have a Donner Party-like memorial on Mars. And there will be a McDonald’s next to it.

You’re not going to win this argument because it is an argument against the basic nature of humanity, the basic urge of a species to expand over all available domain.

kiratp··on Safari's date-picker is the cause of 1/3 of our customer support issues
> now that Edge switched to a compatible render engine

What is the definition of “compatible” here?

The point of “one specification, multiple implementations” is to explicitly leave the door open for slightly deviant implementations.

kiratp··on Peter Norvig critically reviews AlphaCode’s code quality
Given that we are able to prompt GPT (davinci) to learn proprietary DSLs that it would have never seen and build programs with it on data it has never seen… I find it really difficult to buy that there is no internal representation of logic in the model hidden states.
kiratp··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
Quoting you: > To make this even more clear, let's make it concrete with one plausible future: In 2032, Waymo (or Didi, whoever) achieves true 'level 4' fully-self driving with proprietary technology. Their tech is seen in trucks, busses, taxis, as well as being equipped to a few thousand private vehicles.

I see no possibility where existing large automakers will let Google (Waymo) own the FSD stack (and thus own the data and huge piece of value chain) and be relegated to a mere maker of a dumb car.

And if GM is not going to buy Waymo tech, Tesla will definitely not.

kiratp··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
You seem to imply that for progress to be classified as “R&D” it MYST be published.

A huge amount of R&D is never published. Eg: lithography tech at ASML.

kiratp··on Atom was archived today
But it doesn’t act like an application. Most of the OS right click services, keyboard shortcuts, menu items are all missing. Accessibility tools don’t work.
kiratp··on IvorySQL: Open-source Oracle-compatible PostgreSQL
The software license will still stop you from doing that. No business that would need Oracle will run Oracle software knowingly violating the license.
kiratp··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
Announcing partnerships is the easiest thing to do. The proof is in the pudding. Right now Waymo is paying carmakers for the vehicles, not the other way around.
kiratp··on The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who drives trucks
- Changing lanes with someone in my blind spot just behind the B pillar

- someone changing lanes into me while cruising

- car tried to cut across from lane to my right to lane to my left. Got blocked from going to left lane and slammed brakes in front of me

- saw brake lights farther than I could in a snowstorm

It’s like having someone with 100% attention and 360 visibility watching your back at all times.

kiratp··on The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who drives trucks
Yes. Everything you need while driving is on the wheel or at a well defined corner of the screen (which big touch targets). And that too can be avoided if you’re willing to use voice control.
kiratp··on NIST is announcing that SHA-1 should be phased out by Dec. 31, 2030
As an industry we need to get over this pattern of scoping down usage of something that has failed it’s prime directive. People still use MD5 in secure related things because it’s been allowed to stick around without huge deprecation warnings in libraries and tools.

SHA1 (and MD5) need to be treated the same way you would treat O(n^2) sorting in a code review for a PR written by a newbie.

kiratp··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
Literally making their own AI training chips with novel architecture doesn’t count as participating in research?

Google has tried and failed at commercializing similar technology in other verticals (like building environmental automation from their DC tech). The reason is actual incumbents (rightly) see the value of their position while Google comes at it as “our AI is the value, you just make dumb things”.

I expect the automakers to ship mediocre stacks that are put together by existing players like Bosch.

As an ex-Googler I would be floored if Waymo actually lands a sell-into deal with an automaker. A fully vertical taxi service is their path today because they tried and failed to sign any partnerships.

kiratp··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
Believe it or not, if you spend enough time with a Tesla, you quickly realize that actually detecting things is a solved problem.

The thing they need to improve and are doing so rapidly is actual trajectory policy calculations.

And that’s not going to get better with more sensors seeing the same things it already sees.

kiratp··on Waymo's collision avoidance testing
This claim is not true.

As someone who drives a Tesla with the FSD beta, the vehicle has been getting progressively better since 2018.

It’s drives smoother and brakes more predictably dive they stopped using the front radar.

kiratp··on The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who drives trucks
Except the driver (user) is not the buyer.

See also - medical health record systems.

kiratp··on The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who drives trucks
> This is a KNOWN issue. There's very very little upside to any sort of touchscreen in a moving vehicle.

That’s a very confident statement to make without data to back it up.

Strong disagree. I see a huge number of benefits from the touchscreen in my Tesla. Continuous improvements to how the fundamental controls operate. New features that could only have been possible due to the controls not being hardware…

And generally speaking my vehicle seems to save me from human lapses in judgement even when I’m paying perfect attention so I’m not convinced about the argument that they purely increase distraction.

kiratp··on Ledger Stax – Hardware wallet with eInk display for digital assets
The only way to be sure that your HSM is about to sign what you told it to is if it shows you what was sent to it to sign. Otherwise you’re trusting that something didn’t MITM between your computer and the HSM (eg: driver) such that you see one thing but end up signing something else.
kiratp··on Starlink speeds in US dropped from 105Mbps to 53Mbps in the past year
Not even close. As an example, waiting for my consoles to update games and losing half my hour of free gaming time is terrible - and I have 10G wired around my house to a 1G Comcast connection.
kiratp··on Stable Diffusion 2.0
1.4 runs on iPhones. I’m sure we will rapidly see similar for 2.0

https://apps.apple.com/app/id6444050820

kiratp··on NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
Starship has absolutely undergone extensive testing and continues to do so - https://youtu.be/gA6ppby3JC8

These are decades long investments and technologies. The next Artemis doesn’t launch for something like 2 years. Starship/Superheavy will be flying by then. I don’t see the point of declaring non-compete just because it’s not flying at exactly this moment.

SpaceX’s refueling for approach may need iteration but they have shown incredible ability to iterate. It’s also cheaper by orders of magnitude.

If you were running a business and deciding on a 5 year vendor contract, would you just ignore the vendor who had a 10x better product but required you to wait a bit (and you were not in a rush?)

kiratp··on NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
You keep stating that spaceX only really does software, not hardware.

Re-linking my earlier response about Raptor engines: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33620423

They are the only current player building with stainless steel.

Software alone doesn’t let you catch a rocket out of the air when it lands.

We literally just pulled out old shuttle engines from storage for today’s launch. And new ones will cost 146M a pop. And they aren’t as sophisticated as the SpaceX Raptor.

kiratp··on NASA – Artemis I Liftoff
Starship is very real and did an 11 engine static fire last week.

I have a hard time understanding the stance of “if it’s not ready exactly when SLS launches then it’s not comparable.” We are talking about decade spanning technologies and investments here

https://youtu.be/7x1-W7k9V-s

← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →