> Would it be reasonable for any company to hire Holden? If not, is there any chance for Holden to productively rejoin society?
> I am concerned, however, that a judgment like this will have a chilling effect on the hiring of certain groups of people.
My personal viewpoint on this is that - depending on the range of offences committed - there's some professions / occupations that should get closed off for a good while. You don't want your fraud-convicted individual working in finance or accounts, nor someone convicted of theft, assault, etc. working in people's homes, particularly potentially vulnerable individuals.
The latter case seems to be what Charter is accused of here. It's commendable to hire those that have served their time - to help them rehabilitate and repay any debts to society - but you need to ensure they're not put in a position where they might be tempted to offend again.