HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

josephagoss

1,595 karma · joined February 29, 2012

submissionscomments
josephagoss··on U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger
Isn't this the purpose of the secure enclave on iPhones? Taking the drive away from the secure enclave makes the drive useless and the enclave only allows a few password attempts.
josephagoss··on Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten years in jail
Regarding your example of this person being forced into a mental institution, are you able to provide a source? I'm interested in learning more especially as I'm living in Australia, this is quite terrifying indeed.
josephagoss··on A tweet storm explaining the history and state of Ethereum's Casper research
How does this compare to the PoS in the Tezos network?
josephagoss··on Facebook lifts cryptocurrency ban amid rumours of Coinbase takeover
> Why wouldn't they just roll out their own crypto?

Roll your own crypto is playing the game.

Running an exchange is being the house.

The house always wins.

josephagoss··on Bitcoin Gold Hit by Double Spend Attack, Exchanges Lose Millions
Every POW coin should either switch to POS or if they are going to stick with POW they need to focus on a different algorithm and let ASIC development happen. The key to being a weaker chain is to encourage the community to build an ASIC just for your coin. I don't understand this push by many POW coins on sticking with commodity hardware, except for a few giants (zcash, eth, monero) you're going to get destroyed.

Dedicated ASIC only for your chain = good. Commodity hardware = bad.

josephagoss··on Facebook urged to make GDPR its “baseline standard” globally
Based on the first link, that letter scares me a lot. I have a feeling that this level of regulation will destroy any social startup. You'd need a compliance department larger than engineering just to remain legal. This is clearly a win to Facebook.
josephagoss··on Craigslist takes personals sections offline in response to FOSTA
> What do you see changing?

As the internet becomes a resource that is completely boring and out of touch to 15-40 year olds people will flock to a less restrictive system. As eyeballs move over people will invest time and effort into making those systems usable.

This happened with the internet and can happen again with decentralized systems.

josephagoss··on EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content, including code
Give any technology time to sit long enough weeds in the form of lawyers and regulators will grow over it and snuff it out. Rarely is society left with an efficient technology after government is done with it.

Unfortunately most of my peers call for more and more regulation of business and all technology. More regulation is always good in their eyes.

I've explained how regulation should be viewed as a constant push and pull, as society needs to be willing to repeal a regulation if it's not logical or relevant.

Unfortunately the word repeal and regulation in the same sentence is dirty and I get looks for even mentioning how large unnecessary barriers to entry via regulation isn't always a good thing.

In some ways this is why I support crypto currencies. Not for the scams and pump and dumps of today, but rather the building of a decentralized internet that may survive the lawyers and usher in a new era of freedom and creativity. Of course we are still about 5 years from having a GitHub or a search engine on top of crypto currency at the current rate of development. Unfortunately the bubble craze attracted a lot of unsavoury characters that is currently doing this space a lot of harm. Thankfully the lawyers can't shut Bitcoin down so we're safe for now.

josephagoss··on Ethereum fixes serious “eclipse” flaw
A thing I've noticed about cryptocurrency news. The people that are pro cryptocurrency are often far too optimistic and sometimes are not the most academic people. However I've also noticed that those that constantly critique cryptocurrency are often so wrong about their assumptions it's just pointless reading on. It's so hard to actually get a reasonable discussion about cryptocurrency.
josephagoss··on Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails
It doesn't surprise me that IOTA followers are toxic considering the founders are toxic individuals. I find it interesting how IOTA founders are the complete opposite of Satoshi and Vitalik.
josephagoss··on Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails
It's a wild west, we need a winter of sorts to destroy most of these projects. If IOTA isn't secure it should fall sooner than later.

Hopefully what exists in several years time will be good technology, and hopefully the scams have gone away.

I'd wager than marvels like Bitcoin and Ethereum will still be here.

josephagoss··on Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails
I think that if half of their ideas could actually work and be secure, it would be a good thing. If IOTA was a real thing for example I would happily be apart of that community. Unfortunately it's a total waste of time. I remember avoiding IOTA early on due to the arrogance of the founders, I really didn't like their tune.

I know most of Hackernews hates Ethereum, but I really like Ethereum and their ideals, although I am mostly anti ICO. I'd prefer most of these DAPP ideas to be using ETH and not yet another token.

josephagoss··on Cryptographers Urge People to Abandon IOTA After Leaked Emails
A lot of my ideas for blockchain technology work a lot better using ETH for example, rather than yet another token. I think we'll need to wait a few months/years before the ICO craze dies down and we can get back to focusing on building tech on top of Bitcoin/Ethereum without the word ICO.
josephagoss··on Four companies dominate our daily lives unlike any other in human history
The article calls for the splitting up of Apple, Facebook, Google and Amazon.

If the companies are not being anti competitive is it fair for a Government to break up private enterprise that is not breaking the law?

I feel that it's going too far allowing Government to split apart corporations acting legally just for being successful.

What are your thoughts?

josephagoss··on Uber and Waymo Reach Settlement
> Spend can't really be the

> reason a company gets a

> public good, right? If I

> want to own a city park,

> and I spend a bunch of money

> trying to own it, that

> doesn't mean I do, in fact,

> own it or should own it.

Isn't the error here assuming that the IP invented by the private entity is automatically a public good?

To me a public park is not equal to IP invented with private funds.

josephagoss··on Is developer compensation becoming bimodal?
What did you study?
josephagoss··on Secret Bitcoin billionaires to renounce their US citizenship before cashing in?
Do you have a source on the UK having a lower tax rate for early Bitcoin holders?
josephagoss··on Worries Grow That the Price of Bitcoin Is Being Propped Up
Volume of trades from exchanges show that daily 5% of the market cap is traded. (About $25 billion traded vs $500 billion market cap) How does this compare to Apple or another large stock?
josephagoss··on Worries Grow That the Price of Bitcoin Is Being Propped Up
Look at trade volume. Last time I checked tether was 10% of worldwide trade volume.

That's huge. If this volume is based on fake dollars then I think the entire space could be massively inflated.

josephagoss··on Worries Grow That the Price of Bitcoin Is Being Propped Up
As bitcoin is quite impossible to value via traditional methods it's very hard to say where the price could end up after a tether pop.

I've heard many in the cryptocurrency space throw figures around such as $1,000.

I fear that the crash would be far lower. The argument is that the entire run up is fake therefore a realistic price would be back around $100.

josephagoss··on How a malicious seed generation website stole $4M
I'm a cryptocurrency supporter but I'm not anti tax or anti government. I genuinely think that decentralized trust based systems such as blockchain have a place in our world even alongside government.

With that said, I would like to believe that if caught, these types of seed hacks could be prosecuted. (If viable)

josephagoss··on How a malicious seed generation website stole $4M
Is this just a technical possibility or is there evidence that this could be the case?
josephagoss··on Why the IRS Fears Bitcoin
> Bitcoin is not anonymous.

This is true and massive mistake on the reporters part.

However the overall concept of the article could be easily applied to coins such as Zcash and Monero that do have anonymous transaction methods.

In my comment [1] I argue that even then, these types of trades are not a concern for the IRS.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16216069

josephagoss··on Why the IRS Fears Bitcoin
I don't think the IRS fears Bitcoin. The examples in this piece are quite easy for the IRS to get around.

For tax purposes one of the key concepts in mining Bitcoin and trading Bitcoin is the use of a third party. If you have moved coin to a third party to execute a trade and the IRS audits you, it's up to you to prove that these addresses are owned by third parties.

So then you need to supply the entities individual or corporate name. If you're lying and cannot produce the identity of the exchanger, then you're going to be a world of trouble. Even if it's a decentralized exchange, you're going to need to show the transaction that execute the trade.

Even if you're doing these trades with shielded Zcash transactions (these are completely anonymous transactions) once you supply addresses A, B, C, etc... to the IRS (or the ATO in my case) and you get audited, you need to show who these third parties are.

Honestly, cryptocurrency is not an issue for the tax office, even cryptocurrency such as Zcash and Monero are not an issue.

josephagoss··on Artists and writers whose works enter the public domain in 2018
I disagree.

I think that copyright should not expire during the creators life. I can profit from my business activities for the entirety of my life, so should an artist.

After death? Absolutely expire that copyright. In fact I think that perhaps a limit of 14 years after death so that a widow can make use of it but no more.

josephagoss··on Artists and writers whose works enter the public domain in 2018
I think 70 years after the creator died is really enough.
josephagoss··on Buy, sell, send and receive Bitcoin Cash on Coinbase
Here is a counter point I would argue. Anyone can make a Bitcoin fork, in fact Bitcoin forks are being made every week now. Is every Bitcoin holder now liable for that?

Also these forks often collapse, so when was the income gain? The same day? You'd have people owing more tax than their entire net worth. (Forks often pump in the first day/week then drop to nothing.)

If this is possible then you could attack every Bitcoin holder by making millions of forks each day and making lots of trades to give each fork real value. If you don't declare each fork you end up getting penalties.

I would imagine a more sane way to deal with this is like how the ATO deals with Bitcoin mining. You mine Bitcoin but it's not realized until transferred to a third party.

I would argue the same for forks.

A fork is made, you have coins. But it's not like you received those coins. Technically you always had them as they are old coins just now on a different chain. If you sell the coins then it's a gain that you owe tax on.

But forcing each user to track every fork as income is impractical and not viable. You'll see more of this as thousands of forks come into existence over the coming years.

This is something I would actually look into getting a private ruling about.

josephagoss··on Why you can’t cash out part 1: Bitcoin’s “price” is largely fictional
Tethers are total crap, please do an article about them.
josephagoss··on Why you can’t cash out part 1: Bitcoin’s “price” is largely fictional
You can cash out Bitcoin and the price is actually very accurate. The money I see in my bank account is real I can assure you of that. Also I know friends that cash out six figures at a time and the price they get is within less than 1% difference to the last sell price.

The number is accurate enough for most orders under $10,000,000. Has this person actually traded Bitcoin?

You might not be able to sell a large order to the cent, but with Bitcoin you are certainly able to cash out within less than 1% of the listed price. I move orders around a lot and I see real money, so I know it's not fictional. In addition I frequently use an exchange with about 100 times less volume than the USA exchanges.

Also shares have a spread too.

The Bitcoin order book is not razor thin, unless you are trying to sell $10,000,000 in one go. Then you just need to spread out the sell over about 5 hours.

Also the issue with arbitrage isn't the Bitcoin side of the transactions, it's often the USD or AUD side.

But arbitrage does work and the price is much closer worldwide than it used to be.

These little islands that the author talks about range from $1,000,000 24 hour volume for the smallest exchanges to $200,000,000 24 hour volume for a mid - high size exchange.

TL:DR I can assure you the price is real, cashing out is easy and viable. If you want to cash in $10 million just expect your limit order to execute gradually over about 5 hours.

josephagoss··on The End to Apple’s Cash Dilemma
I agree with everything you said except the double taxation of dividends.

Australia has probably the best system in the world for dividends. We use a franking credit to offset the tax paid by the corporation so effectively we have no double taxation of dividends.

I've never seen the point to any double taxation and I applaud any government willing to help citizens and business work around double taxation.

← PreviousPage 2 of 18Next →