HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

icarus_drowning

1,306 karma · joined August 4, 2010

Freelance composer for film/media. You might have heard my music on Starbound, for which I composed the original OST.

You can listen to my music on my website: http://curtisschweitzer.com

submissionscomments
icarus_drowning··on Anyone with a smart cover can break into your iPad2
It clearly should be fixed, as it is a bug. I'm just a bit amused at the OP presenting it a somewhat sensationalist fashion.
icarus_drowning··on Google+ Activity on WebGL Rendered Globe = Beautiful
Late 2008. Soon to be replaced, and a bit behind on the OS too.

I've had no end of problems with the graphics card and graphics card drivers on this model-- both times I've brought it in to be serviced the Apple techs have simply nodded and had the machine sent in for a new logic board without even testing. I guess NVida produced a terrible batch of GPU's that Apple used on these models.

icarus_drowning··on Anyone with a smart cover can break into your iPad2
Isn't it trivial to "fix" this by just disabling smart-cover unlocking? Isn't that exactly why this is a user-enabled feature of the smart cover?

It isn't that I oppose viewing this as a "bug" (obviously the user is led to believe that a password in and of itself would prevent this), but I would think that anyone security-conscious enough to have a password should be disabling smart cover unlocking anyway...

icarus_drowning··on Ubuntu and GNOME jump the shark
The only really valid criticism I see here is the binary blob problem-- clearly this is a poor way to store user configuration data, and completely antithetical to the kinds of philosophies that undergird Linux and Ubuntu.

But really, the core of the issue that's been raised by Unity is that Ubuntu seems to be moving away from catering to power users to cutting features essential to them in favor of appealing to more amateur users. One can lament that decision, and even disagree with it, but I don't know how fair I think it is to criticize Unity for lacking those kind of power user features.

After all, it isn't like power users are exactly wanting when it comes to replacement options in the Linux space.

icarus_drowning··on Google+ Activity on WebGL Rendered Globe = Beautiful
Well, this completely crashed my MacBook Pro. Although to be fair, I think it has to do with the fairly unreliable graphics card/drivers than anything else.
icarus_drowning··on The world economy is heading towards a black hole unless bold action taken
A question: how does the fact that these are revenues instead of rates play into this discussion? I.E., one of the arguments of free-market proponents is that lower tax rates can increase revenues by allowing the economy to grow-- which, if it were true for some or all of the economies, would actually undermine the point.

I'm genuinely curious about this, not trying to stir up a giant political debate.

icarus_drowning··on Netflix Secures Streaming Deal With DreamWorks
Well, it certainly is nice to see that Netflix's promise of securing higher-quality content is at least partially coming to fruition.

Also, it is nice to see a content creator finally start talking seriously about internet streaming versus traditional cable as a means of content delivery.

icarus_drowning··on CERN press release regarding neutrino experiment
Look, I know there's some disagreement with this comment, but why has this received so many downvotes? It isn't wildly unhelpful, is rather reasonably phrased, and doesn't attempt to pounce on the situation and make sensationalist claims...

Again, I'm not arguing this shouldn't be addressed if you disagree with some or all of it, but it isn't like this is some kind of trollbait that usually receives this kind of aggressive downvoting...

icarus_drowning··on Rethinking Sheet Music, With A Few Bells And Whistles
Yeah, my degree is in Music Theory/Composition, and while I understand where people are coming from when they complain about music notation, I can't see myself investing any significant amount of time learning an alternative system when I already have the current system down well enough that I can sight-read and sight-sing a vast majority of music.

tl;dr I'm not giving up the ability to look at an orchestral score and have a pretty good idea of how it sounds just to learn that skill all over again.

icarus_drowning··on RIP Higgs Boson (with 95% confidence)
I agree that it would be nice to know where mass comes from, but that fact absent any useful application (or a probability of a useful application) is of limited value to me.

I guess if you don't see potential applications of understanding where mass comes from, we're at a bit of an impasse here. It is difficult (if not impossible) to make predictions about what the discovery will bring, but the mere possibility that this research could or might lead to the ability to manipulate mass seems rather valuable to me, in many concrete ways.

[UPDATE:

I guess if you want to see this as a gamble, you need to take into account the very good track record of abstract scientific discovery leading to enormous benefits. Given that understanding electricity, magnetism, relativity, and countless other scientific discoveries have brought incalculable value to the human race, I guess I don't understand why one wouldn't believe that science was worth the gamble.]

icarus_drowning··on RIP Higgs Boson (with 95% confidence)
This is, I think, a dishonest question, because we can't know "what they [got] out of it". There is a 5% probability that they might "get something out of it" in the future, and an unknown (likely greater than zero) probability that they will "get" a great deal out of it through readjustments of previously invincible models of how the universe is constructed.

Remember, we're trying to figure out why things have mass here, (which, I think, is rather prima facia a very important question to answer) and if we're wrong about how that phenomenon arises, we now have a very big clue to look somewhere else.

In short, they got petabytes of data out of it, and frankly, that will most likely prove to be invaluable in and of itself.

icarus_drowning··on Microsoft UI has officially entered the realm of self-parody
I'm not sure why, but I've never really gotten used to the ribbon. Especially in Office 2010 , I find it incredibly difficult to navigate and, frankly, hugely annoying. To see it brought to something like explorer is horrifying, especially considering the large amount of vertical space it takes up.

Shouldn't there be more intuitive ways of doing these things? Why is there a need for a move button or copy (one or the other) when you have drag and drop? I know it is very much in vogue to abstract the file system away from the user, and it strikes me that this is exactly the opposite, and just might be just a little over engineered.

icarus_drowning··on Resigned
I've been quite critical of Gruber recently, but I agree. A wonderful, thoughtful, and bittersweet post.
icarus_drowning··on Superfast military plane hit Mach 20 before crash
Yes, but launching an ICBM has the rather unfortunately consequence of telegraphing the message that you are about to nuke someone. Hence the program is a non-ballistic one that seeks an alternative means of delivering a payload as quickly. As a bonus, I gather that the HTV program promises to be more accurate.
icarus_drowning··on Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA
Whether one is focusing on national or global wellbeing, the point is the same-- the incentives work against either.
icarus_drowning··on Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA
Yes, but I think that's a bad analogy because winning a chess game is good for you, but preserving a national infrastructure of innovation and manufacturing is good for everyone.

It can be difficult to make choices that preserve the common good at the expense of one's own short term good.

icarus_drowning··on How Elon Musk Thinks: Reasoning from First Principles.
Many people don't have first principles to begin thinking from. While you're certainly right that the quality of one's first principles is at issue in judging their conclusion, the mere fact that so many people don't even bother to try to think presuppositionally seems to be more of the point of the video, IIRC.
icarus_drowning··on How Elon Musk Thinks: Reasoning from First Principles.
I think Musk is right to point out that many people don't reason from first principles-- basically, that they consciously decide not to think about something, but to allow other's thinking to guide their thoughts. ("It has always been done this way")

I recently began teaching in a school where students are required to write extensively in every class, including "extras" like PE, Music, or Art. I've found that, generally, students who have been subjected to that system for a number of years are far better at reasoning (and expressing that reasoning, naturally) than those who are new to the school. (It is astonishing how quickly new students, who inevitably struggle with complex reasoning at the beginning of the school year have made leaps and bounds in this area, and are far more skilled at verbal reasoning by the end of the school year).

All of which is to say: I think that this style of thinking is greatly buttressed by enhanced linguistic ability, as language is critical to higher-level thinking.

Very interesting video, and the interactive transcript was extremely cool.

icarus_drowning··on Balls
Look, this is Gruber's bottom line, all of his caveats aside. At the end of the day, that's how he views this story, and I don't think it is unreasonable to assume that this is going to be a fairly succinct example of his thinking and arguments going forward.

That strategy is going to conveniently rely on his readers forgetting his near-obsession with Google's supposed doom at the hands of Apple and Microsoft's patent portfolios.

That's why it is a reversal-- because patents, once so important, probably aren't going to factor into his incessant Google criticism in the future, despite the fact that he has made them the cornerstone of many of his arguments until now.

icarus_drowning··on Balls
I appreciate the advice, but I did read the article carefully and completely. My original comment, read carefully, has far more to do with the nuances of Gruber beginning to turn his arguments now that he can't bray night and day about how very threatened Google is by the combined patent portfolios of it's enemies.
icarus_drowning··on Balls
Because Gruber's summary of the entire story is "I think Apple and Microsoft probably feel pretty good, competitively, about having forced Google into spending $12.5 billion for Motorola — a handset maker with rapidly declining sales, no recent profits, and misguided management", which ignores the single most salient factor in the deal. Ultimately, Gruber would like us to believe that, all things aside, Google has bought a crappy handset maker, rather than a massive patent portfolio.
icarus_drowning··on Balls
The primary issue that I have with Gruber's argument is that it seems to reverse some of his more recent assertions about the Google Patent Wars(TM). Haven't we been hearing from Gruber for months on end how patents were going to somehow destroy Android (or cripple it, which is basically the same thing)? Now we're supposed to simply ignore that Google bought 3x the Nortel patents at 3x the price[1] (Gruber's math, not mine), a move that greatly diminishes (if not negates) their loss in the Nortel auction? Now we're supposed to focus on Motorola's problems as a handset manufacturer?

I get that Gruber's mainly going after the over-the-top Lyons piece (a piece which strikes me as poorly thought out and terribly argued). But it does seem like this is Gruber's first move toward a pivot away from the importance of patents in Android vs. Everyone.

You know, those patents that Gruber has been trumpeting for weeks now as the death knell of Android.

Just ignore those.

[1]: Or cheaper?: See recoiledsnake's comment below: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2890038

icarus_drowning··on In wake of riots, British PM proposes social media ban
I think it does make more sense. Does it make sense why those of us who have responded don't read your first comment that way?

(I appreciate the clarification, btw)

icarus_drowning··on Did Apple tamper with evidence in the German Apple v. Samsung case?
Of course Gruber is spinning this to be about "one image." Pro-Apple spin is largely what he seems to do these days. Does anyone think that, were this situation reversed, that Gruber would be intentionally trying to make this about a single image? Of course he wouldn't.

I still read Gruber everyday- he has a lot of interesting things to say about technology in general and Apple in particular. But it is increasingly hard to take him seriously about any story related to Apple's anti-android litigation, because he seems to have abandoned any attempt to present the situation fairly, to the point where he has really become a rather naked shill for Apple.

I am typing this on an iPad 2. I love my iPad 2. I tried a great number of tablets prior to purchasing it, and I genuinely find it to be the superior product, and by a long shot. I am even sympathetic to Apple's claims in this case, as I do think the resemblance between the Galaxy and the iPad to be more than simple coincidence. But it seems pretty clear to me that this is about much more (or should be about much more) than one "doctored" photo, and I am absolutely sure that Gruber knows it.

The thing is, I don't think he cares, because it seems as if he's completely abandoned even the pretense of presenting a just and fair picture of any of Apple's recent patent litigation.

icarus_drowning··on The Blackberry Shift: From the executive phone to the phone of the urban poor
Because it isn't racist.
icarus_drowning··on In wake of riots, British PM proposes social media ban
How is it at all interesting if it isn't a fair comparison? What you are suggesting isn't what you are defending here: you're suggesting that we compare two entirely different scenarios and then defending it by saying it is worth doing an entirely different thought experiment.

(For the record, I'm appalled that anyone would consider anything that could remotely be called "web censorship" as a response, I just don't think you're making any sense here).

icarus_drowning··on More on Google and Patents
Google’s blog post comes across as whining that Apple and Microsoft (Microsoft especially) aren’t sitting back and allowing Android to destroy their businesses.

No, Google's blog post rightly points out that Microsoft and Apple haven chosen to fight against Android by litigation rather than invention. If Google where "whining" that Microsoft and Apple were building cooler stuff into their phones, it would be laughable. But that isn't what Google is saying. Suggesting that Google wants MS/Apple to "[sit] back and [allow] Android to destroy their business" is an obvious and clumsy strawman.

Gruber isn't arguing the merits of the platforms. He's arguing that the patent system as-is does work, and that Microsoft and Apple shouldn't be criticized for using it. The problem is, they aren't merely using it, they are abusing it, which seems to suggest that it doesn't work nearly as well as Gruber says it does.

[EDIT: Minor grammatical cleanup]

icarus_drowning··on Why aren't there any Open Source laser printers?
I was able to get this to work on an HL2140 last year. I just taped a small piece of construction paper over the eye on the cartridge and it happily went about printing for quite some time- I made it through an entire ream before the quality degraded. Since then, I always cover the eye on new cartridges before I insert them and use the quality of the prints, not the printer itself, to let me know when to buy more toner.
icarus_drowning··on Video Viewing in Lion Freezes New iMacs
I have encountered precisely the same problem on a 2008 era MacBook Pro. While that problem is very well known (and much more general- it is triggered by any heavy graphics card usage), it manifests exactly like this. In my case the faulty GPU ended up having faulty NVRAM onboard.
icarus_drowning··on “Real Names” Policies Are an Abuse of Power
Again, My issue is that Boyd asserts intent, which I don't think she has the grounds to do.
← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →