HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

herbertl

14,406 karma · joined November 17, 2020

submissionscomments
herbertl··on Ask HN: How do you organize your knowledge?
Physical 4x6 index cards (organized with the zettelkasten method—https://zettelkasten.de/posts/overview/) and corresponding digital version in Notion
herbertl··on What AI Can Teach Us About the Myth of Human Genius
Thanks for the book recommendation! I'll make sure to check it out.
herbertl··on Only ~1/3 of “indie” music market today is operationally independent
Full analysis here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/49752018
herbertl··on Hit songwriters ask pop stars to stop taking credit for songs they didn't write
You may like this piece! https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2012/03/26/the-song-machi...
herbertl··on Inside a viral website
One part of me is a huge proponent of learning, but the other part of me is learning (lol) that a huge part of earning involves figuring out what you already know or have invested energy/time/cost into learning, and finding ways to create value for others from it. This was a nice way of doing that, and this posts squeezes the extra value from that experience by sharing insights on going viral.

In no way am I saying the only reason for learning is business—there's plenty of intrinsic value. But all that learning has to subsidized with something...

From a business perspective, there's a good chance there's more than a handful of earning opportunities right under each of our very noses every day. The key is to find the ones that align with our strengths, personalities, skillsets, etc...

herbertl··on Why You Stay Up So Late, Even When You Know You Shouldn’t
"Revenge bedtime procrastination” is a mouthful, but I like how precise it is. I recently noticed how many things I actually do as a "revenge" for things I'm dissatisfied with. e.g., I shouldn't be so stressed about work, so I'm going to revenge-eat this pizza, is the most obvious one. I wonder to what extent shopping/consumerism is revenge-buying, etc...
herbertl··on Douglas Adams' note to self reveals author found writing torture
I'm glad the notion of the shitty first draft has grown more popular. For me, I believe I heard it from Anne Lamott–which is basically that first drafts should be expected to suck. I heard it when I was relatively young, so it seeped in. It really gave me permission to let go of expectations, results, hope, despair, etc. and just write.

Frankly I don't know if it actually makes things more "effective" per se—the editing phase is the most difficult for me. I've collected some tricks to edit my own work (e.g., read out loud, change the font, triple space and print on paper, etc...) and also enlist the help of a friend, a peer, or a freelance editor. But this is where the doubts I had let go of come boomeranging back. By then though, the idea is usually strong enough for me to make a case for it and to keep refining. (If it's not I'll just shelf it and start on a different draft.)

herbertl··on YouTube and Patreon Still Aren’t Paying the Rent for Most Creatives
Hi Philip-J-Fry, thanks for reading and responding! I really appreciate it. I actually totally agree with you—my original title for this piece was actually, "If You Can't Afford to Do It for Free, Don't Be a Creator." (Editors suggested a new title so I deferred, but you can see a trace of it at the URL.)

The problem is, more and more people are turning to this as a viable source of income. In the piece, I reference the tragic death of Mocha, who turned to Bilibili to stream when he had nowhere to work (https://www.inkstonenews.com/society/aching-hopelessness-nob...).

There's some more evidence—say, people trying to calculate how much TikTok engagement they'll need to stream to get Christmas gifts (https://twitter.com/robyncaplan/status/1328432778942312449). That, plus the survey that more children want to become a vlogger when they grow up (https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/07/american-kids-would-...), is why I wrote the piece.

Of course, dream jobs change as people grow up and figure out feasibility, so I'm not too concerned about that. Plus, I have no intention to squish anyone's dreams, but I was hoping for this piece to do two things:

1. Paint a clearer picture of the economics of platforms, and that—for most people—it's generally a terrible way to make money. 2. Encourage media, platforms, and other creators to share more data and facts, instead of another, "This high schooler made $1 million in 5 weeks on Snapchat." https://people.com/human-interest/snapchat-high-school-senio...

This is an old story. People will know the odds of starting a band and becoming a rock star, and still do it. So I just want to make sure people go all-in on it with deliberation, and that the most marginalized people don't turn to it when they most need it.

Williamdclt put it well: "Well, it's not that simple is it. For decades actors, musicians and artists have been complaining that they have to live in misery to pursue their art and fighting for better conditions, it's not like they've always been OK with the status quo."

If platforms do have an opportunity to better distribute the income for creative work, I think it's worth collective action from creators to put pressure on them to do it. If that means changing the algorithm to spotlight more people's videos, which means the popular videos effectively cross-subsidize them (like a record label would back in the day), I would think it's worth trying.

I did not expect so many comments on this entry, so I'll do my best to contribute—but yours was at the top so I figured I'd start here! Thanks again.

herbertl··on The Art of Reading More Effectively and Efficiently
I definitely appreciate this. Your point reminds me of what Beeple once said about art and creative work:

"Looking at creativity as something that’s much less precious will help you stick with it long-term. Along with that, people around you will be a lot more supportive if you’re a bit more flexible and a bit less douchey about it. Like you’re not so pretentious in terms of, 'I’m an artist, I need to blah blah blah.' If you take it down a notch and just look at it as something you have to do today, just like taking a dump or eating supper, then it will be more sustainable in the long run."

https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/3/21046790/beeple-mike-winke...

herbertl··on Quality through quantity: A structure of practice, motivation, and experiments
Someone else submitted an earlier piece I wrote (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11058255), this is my sequel to it. Hope you enjoy, would love to hear what you think!
herbertl··on The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket (2019)
Definitely... At an abstract level, it reminds me of "Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25406072
herbertl··on The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket (2019)
Ah I didn't know this, and the author mentioned it but obviously glossed over the details... more details here: https://casetext.com/case/rothstein-v-american-airlines
herbertl··on 80% of musicians earn less than £200 a year from streaming
That's just the business model of streaming—unlike labels, there is no cross-subsidization (e.g., a more popular artist "paying for" an obscure critically acclaimed artist who doesn't sell well). You're incentivized to get plays, which ultimately gets everyone to converge.

It's going to be really tough for the "middle class" of independents—whether you're in content creation or apps. But if you use streaming platforms purely as a way to get discovered, and build direct relationships with your audience, you can price and sell your own stuff. No more $0.006 per stream or whatever. (https://qz.com/1507361/mariah-careys-record-breaking-day-sho...)

That requires self-reliance, which is tough, but will be worth the payoff. I write more about it here: https://herbertlui.net/own-your-marketing-own-your-income/

Ryan Leslie is a good example of this—took his music of Spotify and went direct to audience, sold fewer albums but made more money. https://shift.newco.co/2017/03/10/ryan-leslie-shifts-the-con...

Increasing more relevant: Derek Sivers writes the way to be happy while being creative is to keep a good, steady, easy, full-time job and to create just for its own sake: https://sive.rs/balance

herbertl··on Improve Your Creativity by Applying Constraints
That's exactly it. Obstacles shape the creative process, making it unique to each person.

A friend said to me, "I don't know how," is just the beginning—and the process of discovering how is where the energy from creativity comes from.

herbertl··on Hieroglyph, a research tool to easily view a YouTube video's transcript
Thank you for making it!
herbertl··on Why are great athletes more likely to be younger siblings?
This is a really cool topic to me, I vaguely remember coming across a book on how birth order determines personality (or life), but I can't remember it now. Diving into that link to try to find...
herbertl··on Hieroglyph, a research tool to easily view a YouTube video's transcript
I'd love that too! It doesn't right now, I just import it into Otter.ai if I decide that video has something I want to quote and link to or excerpt from.

Nonetheless, it's still a great tool to help me preview or "skim" through a video.

herbertl··on Ask HN: How do you work through large ideas?
This! I see this as a research question, because to even begin to work through the problem requires proper framing—noticing the history of the problem, seeing what the best of modern thinkers are thinking, discovering what has not been applied yet probably from different fields, etc. This is the hard work it takes to have an opinion about something.

Whether you use metaphors or first principles, to even capture the scope of the problem and the important pieces that influence it is the first task.

herbertl··on We’re Optimizing Ourselves to Death (2019)
This was a great piece, covering a really good topic. It's worth considering that work today is probably defined differently than before—and comes with different meanings and expectations to different generations. Would be good to pair it with this one: https://www.economist.com/1843/2016/03/02/why-do-we-work-so-...

Secondly, what do we lose at the expense of increased productivity/work output? What were the unseen fruits of chilling and leisure?

herbertl··on Ask HN: How do you stimulate your creativity on a day like today?
Ah—I just meant I would delete the copywork, which is the essay of someone else's I just typed up! I just figured it wasn't mine, plus I get some small satisfaction of "cleaning up," like a very non-sacred version of colored sand in Buddhism.

Cool link. I need to spend more time with this, Peter Drucker is brilliant. It sounds like you and I write similarly, I am a meticulous outliner.

I really like voice dictation as a writing alternative, but I need to be really focused. e.g., I tried "freewriting" by voice when I was cleaning the bathroom once, and it turned out sloppy.

Thanks for starting this topic btw, great question and I'm really liking the discussion.

herbertl··on Ask HN: How do you stimulate your creativity on a day like today?
Same thing as you! I also like to visit ideas I've written down and develop them. Sometimes I'll do copywork, and just type out or re-write an article I really liked, just to feel what it's like to write something I liked... I cribbed this from someone else, I can't remember who. I delete all of it after, but it gets my ideas flowing for sure.
← PreviousPage 4 of 4