HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gpcr1949

297 karma · joined September 25, 2020

my main interests are chemistry and audio.
submissionscomments
gpcr1949··on XAI's Grok suddenly can't stop bringing up "white genocide" in South Africa
I think it is an underestimation to say ~800 people died in the Gaza war. The Ukraine number also seems like a serious underestimation.
gpcr1949··on The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 2024
Israel is committing what some experts are calling a genocide. In any case, they killed a lot of civilians. It can probably be debated whether this is noble or "striving to be better". But either way, the political beliefs and hobbies of the laureates aren't interesting to me, and I can't imagine the Nobel committee seriously taking this into account.
gpcr1949··on Editor in Chief of eLife replaced for retweeting The Onion tweet about Palestine
I am really surprised they fired him for a really relatively mild series of tweets. I know some of the Israeli scientists leading the campaign against him also pointed out he tweeted "Fuck Israel" in 2018 [0]. Due to the date, May 15 2018, he is probably referring to IDF slayings the preceding day during Palestinian border protests [1]. Nature also did a factual write up of this guy's firing [2].

[0] https://twitter.com/mbeisen/status/996404294529138688

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018%E2%80%932019_Gaza_border_...

[2] https://www.science.org/content/article/prominent-journal-ed...

gpcr1949··on The Destroyed Libraries of Louvain (2012)
Writing Basel as Bâle would be silly and non-standard too, yes. Maybe "wrong" is too strong of a classification. But for example, I wouldn't immediately recognize it as Basel in a headline. FWIW Leuven refers to itself in English as Leuven on their own website: https://www.leuven.be/en

Also somewhat interesting to me is that for some reason people think Belgium is mainly a French speaking country, but in fact there are actually more Dutch speakers than French speakers (56% vs 38% native speakers according to Eurostat in 2015) - I have the sense referring to Flemish cities by their French name reflects that

gpcr1949··on The Destroyed Libraries of Louvain (2012)
Interesting history, but people in Leuven call this city Leuven and not Louvain. No need to use the french term in a flemish city where almost no one speaks french as their first language. In fact, french language was the subject of some amount of political struggle in the 1960s, resulting in the founding of the french speaking university in "Louvain-la-Neuve", a planned city that was built in (french speaking) Wallonia for this purpose. You can read more about the politically important language discussion that occured in the 1960s here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Split_of_the_Catholic_Universi...
gpcr1949··on The rise of the new tech right
https://archive.vn/lByGj
gpcr1949··on Identifying organic compounds with visible light
They use a random forest classifier, which is an ensemble model that gives a consensus result of several decision trees. One way to achieve this consensus is voting. Random forest models are commonly used in building chemical models like this (and in QSAR), because they are quite robust. Due to the typically small size of chemical data sets (dozens to thousands, typically), more sophisticated methods are not usable and do not perform better.
gpcr1949··on The case for free-range lab mice
High-throughput screening (HTS), i.e. testing a large amount of compounds in simple biochemical assays can't be compared with testing 10 compounds in monkeys. The point of HTS is finding active substances in a large collection of compounds (finding needles in the haystack), and then using this as the initial step of a whole chemical optimization research program that may lead to a new drug candidate down the line.

Conversely, the 10 compounds tested in monkeys will usually be advanced drug candidates just before phase 1 trials in humans. If you would give monkeys 10 compounds from a HTS collection you would learn nothing about what works in human disease because most compounds are inactive at a given target.

Every large pharma company has HTS infrastructure and uses this for early discovery (in addition to animal experiments at later stages of drug discovery campaign) - and these companies are interested in making profit by discovering new drugs that meet the requirements to get approved, not in generating publications or boasting about their fancy HTS robot.

gpcr1949··on Not-such-better-living through chemistry
You can read about the development of this new route and its advantages here [0]. Ctrl+F for ibuprofen or go to p.54.

https://sci-hub.se/10.1016/B978-0-12-804190-1.00004-5

gpcr1949··on Not-such-better-living through chemistry
Agreed the process is very simple. The innovation that makes the resolution worth it is (as Derek also mentioned in the blog post) an efficient way to re-racemize the L-meth to DL-meth, which can then be resolved again. With steady state production and pooling this means it can be done using just one batch size (and not ever smaller "brsm" style bathces). If these steps are efficient enough you definitely get much more bang for your buck. Here is one such method[0] which probably inspired these drug manufacturers (as they use thioglycol and AIBN, which has been found in clandestine lab seizures).

[0] https://sci-hub.se/10.1021/jo061033l (published in JOC in 2006 - so only a mere 2 decades behind the curve)

gpcr1949··on Startup releasing particles into the atmosphere to tweak the climate
This is really a scandalously misinformed stunt. The chemical they released is SO_2 - one of the gasses and car pollutants causing acid rain.
gpcr1949··on The U.S. military is poisoning Okinawa
I was wondering the same thing. I found this in a guardian article

> The military’s firefighters use aqueous film-forming foam, or AFFF, which contains extremely high levels of PFAS, in training exercises and emergencies. Though AFFF is effective, it has led to widespread contamination around bases and airports, and Congress just mandated the military check for PFAS pollution at 700 facilities while earmarking $571m for cleanup, though observers say the cost will likely be much higher.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/06/military-bas...

gpcr1949··on Galactica: an AI trained on humanity's scientific knowledge (by Meta)
Good to see the results respect Benford's law and are therefore not fabricated.
gpcr1949··on Show HN: Game of Life on non-square topologies with 2^32 update rules
I may be misreading it, but doesn't the GoL as commonly understood also depend on diagonal neighbors (i.e. 8 direct neighbors)? In that case the rule space would explode beyond the 32 bit integer one. (to a 256 bit one)
gpcr1949··on An unidentified illicit drug has been discovered by Australian chemists
BOL-148 is not like the others. All others are N1-acyl analogs of LSD, so unlike bol148 they rapidly metabolize to LSD proper. This also means until they make a prodrug or analog law, it will be easy to keep on thinking of new LSD prodrugs. Here are a few free ones that will certainly work, no payment to me required: isovaleroyl, cyclobutanecarbonyl, oxetanecarbonyl(both isomers), cyclopropylacetyl.
gpcr1949··on An unidentified illicit drug has been discovered by Australian chemists
They definitely will, this is after all the intended purpose of these firms, and some of the more professional among them are producing cGMP APIs at scale in a completely legitimate context. Although if you have a need for ACE2 inhibitors (not sure which kind of binders you need for which purpose ...) that are marketed and formulated it may be more convenient to just source a large amount of the pharmaceutical product, though I can't comment on the legality of doing that.
gpcr1949··on An unidentified illicit drug has been discovered by Australian chemists
Fluorine on an aromatic ring is not labile: other examples of substances with fluorinated aromatic rings are fluoxetine(prozac), citalopram (celexa) and paroxetine (paxil), which are antidepressants many people are taking daily without fluorine-related toxicity
gpcr1949··on An unidentified illicit drug has been discovered by Australian chemists
With all due respect for the forensic chemists and their good work on identifying an unknown substance, it is fairly common for forensic groups to once in a while detect new chemical analogs of known drugs. A few years back, lots of new cannabinoids and cathinones were getting released constantly as older analogs were getting banned. Often, these novel analogs are pharmacological low hanging fruit. The drug in this article is also such low-hanging fruit: it is well known an N-methyl to N-ethyl substitution does not lead to reduced activity in this category of arylcyclohexylamine dissociative anesthetics (this was actually one of the SAR considerations taken by the designers of methoxetamine!). And indeed, this very same substitution was used here on 2-Fluorodeschloroketamine, leading to the drug from the article.

PS the Chinese abbreviation for "CanKet", 2F-NENDCK, most likely stands for 2-fluoro-N-ethyl-nordeschloroketamine. It is almost certain this drug was synthesized by a Chinese custom synthesis group (the most typical source for these type of substances at scale) and not by Australian clandestine chemists.

gpcr1949··on An unidentified illicit drug has been discovered by Australian chemists
Pretty unlikely. The F would be already in place at an early stage, the precursor is probably 2-F-benzonitrile, alternatively 2-f-phenylmagnesium bromide.
gpcr1949··on LSD-like molecules counter depession without the trip
(I have a background in organic chemistry as well)

I somewhat disagree with this. Measuring chemical similarity is notoriously difficult, see these two interesting blog posts from a cheminformatic angle [0][1]. The molecules are not only pharmacologically similar but even chemically at least somewhat similar, perhaps in the same way a dog has much more similarities with a flying squirrel than with, let's say a church. I would argue the main active molecule [2] is relatively similar to LSD (compared to other well known psychedelics) due the presence of the tetrahydropyridine unit, which is also present in LSD, albeit connected to the 3 position of the indole in a different way. Also, there is a pharmaco*phor*ic similarity: positively charged N and 5-6 fused aromatic ring oriented in the same way with some degree of rigidity (though you could argue this is just a roundabout way to bin it in a category of 5ht2a binders). So in this way, I feel that it has something like an LSD-based design philosophy to it.

Quantitatively, making use of one of the most common similarity metrics, the Tanimoto similarity of ECFP4 fingerprints, the similarities to LSD, psilocin, DMT and mescaline are respectively 0.17,0.15,0.18 and 0.07. In other words, the similarity is low to all compounds and the indole derivatives are about equally far removed from the compound from TFA, although a bit closer than mescaline. The numbers probably rather follow your line of reasoning.

Finally, I'd also like to remark that I consider the fact they generated quite novel chemical matter a plus: most of the people working on generating new 5HT2A agonists are currently using quite conservative classic SAR approaches, for example creating constrained (e.g. Lophora's azetidines) or deconstructed versions (e.g. Delix's ring opened LSD variants and ibogaine analogs) of better known compounds, or even just prodrugs of known compounds (Field trip's FT104 is a 4-HO-DIPT prodrug). This will also make it easier for them to fight patent challenges if this series of compounds will lead to a clinical candidate.

[0] http://www.dalkescientific.com/writings/diary/archive/2020/0...

[1] http://www.dalkescientific.com/writings/diary/archive/2020/0...

[2] The SMILES string of molecule 69 from the paper, which is the one from the cryo EM structure: `C[C@@H]1C=C(c2c[nH]c3ncccc23)CNC1`

gpcr1949··on A visual quine: a chemical you make just by looking at it
Of course, it's somewhat disappointing that any molecule you look at will result in isomerization of cis-retinal to trans-retinal - including a picture of the consumed cis-retinal.

Another interesting example where molecules will produce themselves is chiral amplification with autocatalysis. This article is fairly technical, but a nice example of a reaction product being a catalyst for its own (chiral!) formation: https://sci-hub.se/10.1021/ar9900820

gpcr1949··on Ask HN: How do you discover music?
Exploring the neighborhood around what I like usually works. This means: see what's released on the same music labels. See which journalists and bloggers wrote about the thing i liked. See what artists the original artist considers to be their peers, or inspiration. And reiterate once you find something nice. For random/distant discovery there are radio shows, can seach tracklists on (e.g.) NTS to see which shows play things up my alley. I really don't like the soundcloud UX but for me their recommendation algorithm is quite good, often recommending very obscure but good, and more importantly, relevant things.
gpcr1949··on Pure Data: an open source visual language for multimedia
a quick and dirty trick to have a limiter on the signal is put [tanh~] between your signal and the dac
gpcr1949··on 2022 NSA Codebreaker Challenge
> Sorry, that email domain is not recognized. -- An email address from a recognized U.S. school or university is required. If your school's domain is not recognized, please request it to be allowed by clicking HERE

edit: to add some comment: Too bad only this group can participate. Just wanted to have look what type of puzzles they are and recreationally have a stab at them.

gpcr1949··on Solein – Protein out of thin air
The nitrogen source is effectively in the nutrients (so not air/nitrogen fixation by their organism), and is provided as ammonia, according to this video by Solar Foods[0]. I agree this is cheating considering what is needed to produce ammonia from N2.

https://youtu.be/z8zuqR95fqA?t=136

gpcr1949··on Solein – Protein out of thin air
Yes, I read a bit on this (apparently real after all) business and I saw CO2 is the carbon source. It just confused me the promotional website does not even mention CO2. When they called Solein carbon neutral, I assumed they are talking about the product and process, not the entire cycle (in the same way you might call planting trees CO2-emission negative), though this makes sense. In any case, I still find it to be a pretty strong misrepresentation to call this protein synthesis out of "thin air".
gpcr1949··on Solein – Protein out of thin air
I understand it's fake (what is the carbon source? it is stated to be CO_2 neutral) but I guess I don't understand the point or punchline.

edit: as pointed out below and elsewhere, the carbon source is CO2, and I misinterpreted the way CO2 neutral is used here, my bad. However there are serious questions to ask about how they are representing and overselling their process. It is a complete misrepresentation to present this as protein synthesis out of air (in fact, the nitrogen source is ammonia [0], NOT nitrogen fixation).

[0] https://youtu.be/z8zuqR95fqA?t=136 timestamped video from solar foods

gpcr1949··on Popcorn Lung: A Dangerous Risk of Flavored E-Cigarettes (2016)
It would surprise me if acetylpropionyl will not have similar effects, it is a close analog of diacetyl, and an equally reactive alpha dicarbonyl substance, and for example generates free radicals at a similar rate as diacetyl[0] and at a higher rate than other flavorings. The only difference with diacetyl is probably that diacetyl's harms are more well-documented.

Speaking of beer brewing: diacetyl is actually generated during the brewing process and, although considered an off-flavor[1], is important for the characteristic aroma of some beers, one famous example is Pilsner Urquell.

[0] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/acs.chemrestox.8b00400 (figure 5)

[1] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/jib.205

gpcr1949··on Turkey Discovers 694M Mt of Rare Earth Element Reserves
You can't convert mass to energy like that in this context. A megaton just means a million tons (of TNT in an energy context). You can say: (the energy released when detonating) a megaton of TNT is equivalent to 46.55 g of pure mass to energy conversion (E = mc**2 type), but that would be irrelevant in this context because no one is planning converting this mass to energy, nor would it be possible.
gpcr1949··on Found: The 'holy grail of catalysis'– turning methane into methanol
i think parent refers to the sabatier process, so the source of carbon is concentrated CO2 externally provided, not from seawater
Page 1 of 3Next →