HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

garciasn

3,181 karma · joined August 25, 2020

linux, data/platform engineering, and data science nerd/herder with a grey beard who drinks too much coffee, according to everyone but me
submissionscomments
garciasn··on US man given prison sentence for bot-farming music streams
Generating the AI music wasn't illegal. Using bots to inflate /listens/ of an AI-generated song probably is against a platform's TOS, but isn't inherently illegal.

However, using bots to collect royalties on the songs generated definitely fits within the definition of wire fraud as he was using electronic communications (i.e., the internet), to carry out a scheme to defraud streaming services of money.

garciasn··on Beauty in DVD Menus
I used to specifically re-rip DVDs that had menus. They were hideously designed, overly complex, or just pointless when I just wanted the content to start when I put the disc in. Why?

1. Because it would cause confusion with my kids when they were trying to watch movies in the car as toddlers.

2. It was an annoyance when we were watching a movie at home.

I am finding a similar annoyance w/AppleTV's content ad/preview, recap, and intro skips. Like, for fucks sake, just play the episode already.

garciasn··on Book Recommendations from Hacker News?
It always blows my mind that Lonesome Dove is recommended across so many different communities, especially nerd-related ones like HN. I read ~100 books a year on average and it continues to top my all time favorites list; but, in all honesty, I cannot believe it appeals to the wide audience it does due to its content.

That said, here are some of my all time favorites (no particular order):

01. Pillars of the Earth (Ken Follett)

02. Lonesome Dove (Larry McMurtry)

03. A Painted House (John Grisham)

04. A Gentleman in Moscow (Amor Towles)

05. The Great Alone (Kristin Hannah)

06. All the Light We Cannot See (Anthony Doerr)

07. Annihilation (Jeff VanderMeer)

08. The First Law Trilogy (Joe Abercrombie)

* this encompasses three long books; however, I consider them one long epic novel

09. Mailman (Stephen Starring Grant)

10. Demon Copperhead (Barbara Kingsolver)

11. Lessons in Chemistry (Bonnie Garmus)

12. Hench (Natalie Zina Walschots)

13. Personal Librarian (Marie Benedict)

14. In Cold Blood (Truman Capote)

15. Life We Bury (Allen Eskens)

16. Ordinary Grace (William Kent Krueger)

17. God of the Woods (Liz Moore)

18. Maid (Nita Prose)

19. The Extraordinary Life of Sam Hell (Robert Dugoni)

20. The Heaven and Earth Grocery Store (James McBride)

garciasn··on California closed the Montana license plate loophole
I’m sure they were able to put pressure on her in order to stay silent; or, they had a gag order placed on her.

If she was doing it for him, she was likely doing it for others and thus it was in her best interests to stay silent for one to protect the revenue stream from the others.

garciasn··on Big Oil asks Supreme Court to kill climate lawsuits before trial
The Oil Companies are attempting to avoid this by claiming States do not have the authority to bring claims against them for pollution.

The States, figuring this would be TOCs stance, are attempting to argue this is not about regulation, but about collection of damages as a result of TOCs deceptive practices about the realities of pollution-created downstream effect.

With Alito recused, there is a potential for this to land as a split decision which would allow the current lawsuit to proceed.

garciasn··on Federal judge calls Flock 'indiscriminate mass surveillance'
https://networks.imdea.org/your-cars-tire-sensors-could-be-u...

Sort of. The problem isn’t necessarily the speed but the range. But it could be used. Bluetooth and WiFi tracking would be more likely in most real world scenarios.

garciasn··on U.S. postal inspectors shut down website selling counterfeit postage labels
You're going to murder people over a $126MM fraud? I know you're trolling and will eventually be flagged and downvoted into oblivion, but come on; that's just absurd.
garciasn··on 'That's so AI ' What gen Alpha's biggest insult tells us
Your entire premise is one that's missing important context. Based on the numbers you provide, you're probably in Chicago or Dallas, maybe Austin, but that's pushing more like 400K.

Homes in the median are generally not viable unless you don't have a family or don't care about quality schools. In my city (90K), two houses that are identical but divided by the school district boundary between rank #1 and rank #265 out of 359 is a difference of $300K. One would be within the median and the other well above.

And let me be clear: ALL HOUSING IS A SCAM FINANCIALLY. Rent screws you one way and housing screws you another.

garciasn··on Meta VR Glasses
From the video they have on their site: watching movies in places where you normally would stare at a tiny screen; they also show folks using virtual floating keyboards in front of a VR desktop to work.

So: no problems solved.

garciasn··on Jev in 25 Lines of Python
I guess I assumed they meant BERT, not some specific BERT-base model. Vanilla BERT does not support zero shot.
garciasn··on I don't want the details
I think you have a distrust of your leaders and are taking this from a very different place the author of the article was.
garciasn··on I don't want the details
> Of course it's possible that this story is just told badly and the SVP already knew the technical details, in which case the blog post is a bit misleading.

I don't think it's necessarily misleading; it's just reminding folks that senior leaders have a different perspective than those below them and tailoring your message to the audience is important.

In this case of this, it was a reminder that while it's easy to believe the SVP is being dismissive, that's not the case at all. Instead, they want systems-oriented decisioning, not detail-oriented.

If anything, this was the SVP helping to grow the leaders under him by forcing them to think at the levels required to interact w/the rest of the organization.

> How can you know if their "big change" is appropriate and good without knowing the details of the problem the change is addressing?

I'm a Senior Director leading three teams of engineering and science resources. I hired smart and capable people. Why should I, as a SrD be a technical bottleneck?

garciasn··on I don't want the details
> The best leaders I've worked with were paying attention to things from the bottom-up as well as top-down.

If I have a handle on things from bottom-up to top-down, I don't need them to rehash weed-level technical and specific details. I need them to tell me what we're going to change, and it needs to be a BIG systemic change, not minutiae, which is where many engineers thrive.

garciasn··on Jev in 25 Lines of Python
I think you're possibly arguing a point I wasn't making? I'm not saying Jev invented zero-shot classification, or that there aren't already zero-shot classifiers on HF that can do classification without fine-tuning; I was responding to questions asked in a silo.
garciasn··on Jev in 25 Lines of Python
I am in no way trying to sell Jev here as some panacea of the modern world; I'm only responding to your questions:

> But their example is classification but that would also be possible and faster with a classic BERT model.

With BERT, you need a large, labeled dataset, and you have to train/fine-tune the model. Jev is pitched as a zero- or 'few-shot' model. You define the schema in code, give it instructions, and it works without a traditional training pipeline.

> So their pitch is a task specific smaller model or am I completely misunderstanding the whole thing?

Yup; that about sums it up: it is more or less an optimized, task-specific small model with the flexible understanding of a traditional LLM.

garciasn··on Americans' Drinking Remains at Record Low: Gallup Poll
I already pay for the house I no longer live in but my ex-wife does as well as my own with a 7.6% APR. But, them not having a house has nothing to do w/it; they don't want to live somewhere like this.

Thanks for the idea though!

garciasn··on Americans' Drinking Remains at Record Low: Gallup Poll
I could take a $200,000/annual pay cut to move back to my hometown and live in an area devoid of things to do; but, you're right: I chose to move away and live somewhere that offered my children things I did not have and thus choose not to do that. I am also not sure how I could have my parents make the choice to live in an area that's more egalitarian and diverse; however, you're right, again: they choose not to.
garciasn··on Americans' Drinking Remains at Record Low: Gallup Poll
1. Hangovers are awful.

2. There are viable alternatives (THC; mocktails; 0.5%/0% beer that is drinkable).

3. The Third Place is dead and people don't socialize as much anymore.

4. Economic conditions are abysmal and directly affect prices and extra money to spend.

garciasn··on What It's Like to Work in One of America's Data Centers
TL;DR: you walk around smelling and listening for issues. Most of the staff on site are doing the same thing; the rest are private security hired by customers housing within the DC. You make between $66K and $120K/annual.

There, saved you from reading a story that isn't really informative and only was written because of the politics surrounding DCs are keeping them in the news.

garciasn··on The LLMentalist Effect (2023)
HN skews more technical, sure; but, that in no way means that they cannot be hoodwinked by behaviors that adhere to C3L.
garciasn··on The LLMentalist Effect (2023)
To root your statement in reality: there is the potential for bacteria to become intelligent and conscious so we probably shouldn't use them for any purpose.
garciasn··on The LLMentalist Effect (2023)
Because to the general public, LLMs are an example of Clarke's Third Law. Most folks, who are not remotely close to even a basic understanding of how LLMs operate at a technical level and only view their output cannot possibly evaluate what they're experiencing other than to believe it's conscious, alive, and/or magic.

Most people on Earth try to put what they're seeing into the context of what they understand; mental gymnastics to try and understand what is happening based on their prior experience. They have absolutely 0 understanding of how it works under the hood so, to them, it must be alive.

garciasn··on The LLMentalist Effect (2023)
Good news: at this time, they're not intelligent nor conscious as far as we consider humans to be. There should be folks considering the ethical and moral quandaries that COULD POTENTIALLY come about in the future, but it's not something that's happening today so you can stop worrying.
garciasn··on Instagram's head says engagement falls by half without the algorithm
> I have started to like the algorithms.

Unlikely; your brain has been trained to enjoy it because it's a psychological hit inherent with the way the app + algorithm work together to be addictive and keep you 'engaged' instead of doing something else altogether.

Engagement dropping is bad for a corporations ad revenue -> shareholders; it's great for individuals and their physical and mental wellbeing.

garciasn··on GPT-6 Astra
Because they earned it with their strong entrepreneurial spirit and grit.

Haven’t you learned anything?

garciasn··on Mom gets 6-month suspended sentence for letting 5-year-old walk to the pond
They charged her criminally instead of civilly, because in 2023 VA passed a 'free-range parenting' amendment to allow for actions that appropriate for the child's maturity and are not done in a grossly negligent manner that endangers the child. This is likely why the defense asked for comments from others on the child's maturity.

The criminal definition apparently has no such modification.

E: removed a double ‘likely’

garciasn··on Whistleblower warns Postal Service mail ballot system has catastrophic problems
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/mail-voting-in-the-us-dat...
garciasn··on Advertisers Could Soon Demand 'Verified Clicks'
I mean it’s a marketing PR piece that’s likely targeted toward CMOs who are in love with email marketing.

Email marketing is inexpensive, easier to measure, relies on the ridiculous CDPs and ESPs they’ve been tricked into investing in, and the measured numbers are larger than other digital channels.

The problem isn’t that bots are clicking, it’s that those big numbers aren’t going up and to the right in a reliable way any longer and those CMOs need to change how they’re measuring media.

At the end of the day, CMOs need to be measuring contribution to revenue, not meaningless marketing metrics the rest of the C-suite doesn’t give the slightest of fucks about. But that’s super hard for most organizations without competent Marketing Science or capable agencies, and it’s seemingly expensive because their budgets are already tight from all of the fly-by-night shit they’re over invested in. So; they continue to push what they know as well as chip away at their budgets with silly providers who provide little value instead of biting the bullet and doing the right thing.

garciasn··on Advertisers Could Soon Demand 'Verified Clicks'
https://archive.ph/PIrQi

The article is about email marketing. Some company has a proprietary algorithm that purportedly detects whether a click is legitimate based on 8y of development and data collection.

It’s definitely a race against the growing capabilities of the models in use and one that will be very difficult to win which is why there has been a significant push toward verification across the Internet—not because of the children, but because of the revenue.

garciasn··on Doctors are finally learning to manage antidepressant withdrawal
Lexapro, noted in the article, was literally life changing for me. I felt better within 3d and I notice severe issues if I miss ~3d of doses in a row, even though the half-life should support ~7d without according to my physician.

That said, yes; walking is the best medicine for me.

Page 1 of 29Next →