HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

elliotec

2,658 karma · joined January 23, 2014

Writing software and studying consciousness.

My blog - https://elliotec.com My non-profit - https://consciousnesslibrary.org My consultancy - https://elliodelics.com

Contact: mike@consciousnesslibrary.org

submissionscomments
elliotec··on Our position on open-weights models
It should not be an easy choice to trust the latter. Sure, "literal terrorists" exist, but guess what? State terrorism (and state-sponsored terrorism) in the form of massacres, genocide, torture, forced disappearances, etc. is far more deadly and far more prevalent than fringe ideological groups randomly attacking civilians.

These states and elites with the access to the scary weapons ARE the ones doing the damage. The call is coming from inside the house.

I don't understand your point on nuclear proliferation concentrated in the hands of a few states preventing nuclear war or terrorism. Remember, the only two nuclear weapons used in attacks killed a quarter million people, ~90-95% civilians. By one of the few states who had the power. This is the definitional paradigm of state terrorism. And like, now look at the status quo of nuclear treaties and agreements and proliferation. Not exactly a success story.

It's obviously not worth personally formulating a "defense plan" for an AI-enabled bio attack were I personally to have access to SOA weights, but if history is any indication, I feel pretty confident that the likelihood of that happening remains far greater in the closed-weight, elite-state-access-only scenario than the open, democratized, and collectivized one.

elliotec··on Our position on open-weights models
Closed-weight models can also pose biological risk, arguably more so than open-weight models, given the fact that they're being used by state actors (the United States military) to kill people right now.

Who should we fear more? All of collective humanity with the keys to build destructive (and defensive) stuff with AI, or small groups of elites, billionaires, and state actors who have the monopoly on violence and want to control the keys?

Open-weight models collectivize access and ability to do more for a greater good, and the expense of a frankly low-risk possibility that some randos want to use it for very bad things.

Closed-weight models keep the control in the hands of the few that actually are doing the harm to the world, and the rest of us have no way to stop it or defend.

elliotec··on The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models
This is highly contested, most likely not true, and probably not measurable anyway.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09567976251335583

elliotec··on Primate Is the Last Great Web Framework
This is like, the opposite of Rails and the "convention over configuration" style. It's making no decisions for you except to "use primate in the middle of whatever else you decide to configure!" Seems like it's actively encouraging making a mess of your stack. I don't understand it at all.
elliotec··on Primate Is the Last Great Web Framework
It can be on the client side. Middleware just means something between the operations of the application on a server and operations of the application on a client. Doesn't matter where it sits, it's just the link.

But to the parent comment, yes, I agree, this is a middleware.

elliotec··on The future of Flipper Zero development
Agreed 100% - they bricked the thing with official firmwares, and the "community" is the meanest most awful group of so-called hackers I've ever interacted with. It's more than just COA, they're actively aggressive and insular, not just on discord but reddit and less-known places too (which you can't know because you'll be banned for asking where you could find out).
elliotec··on United Airlines 767 returns to Newark after Bluetooth name sparks alert
Again, very rarely. Highly unlikely this particular one does.
elliotec··on United Airlines 767 returns to Newark after Bluetooth name sparks alert
Renaming a Bluetooth device like a speaker permanently for everyone (as opposed to a nickname you give it in your phone or whatever) is difficult if possible at all and usually requires firmware or hardware changes, unless the option is given by the device or its companion app (which is very rare).

So your assumption seems the most likely. I highly doubt a 16 year old kid is firmware hacking a cheap speaker just to rename it for a "joke"

elliotec··on The dead economy theory
Who uses those gas and oil repositories? Who drills it out and refines it? Who invests in it? Who uses this distributed wealth and how?

The point here is that human labor is the economic engine and without it, things like this cease to exist or matter.

elliotec··on Sam Altman and Dario Amodei are both walking back AI jobs apocalypse predictions
This is the "whole thing" in a nutshell for me too. It's useful, speeds some things up, but I've been doing this a long time.

The state-of-the-art or medium-term future of the tooling doesn't feel apocalyptic in itself, but the macro forces, implications of scaling, and general reactions to it on all sides are a different story.

elliotec··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
On average Steven Pinker is at best a fake hyperoptimist-by-aggregate who puts billionaires on pedestals and rewrites history to entrench shitty systems. Sometimes he says smart stuff but he ignores or actively disregards massive problems with a painfully self-serving neutrality.
elliotec··on I think Anthropic and OpenAI have found product-market fit
Here's a source from 2019 that says: "By 2023, the number of knowledge workers in the world will increase to 1.14 billion, with more than four-fifths of that growth coming from the emerging world."

https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/09-24-201...

elliotec··on Googlebook
You can still centrally manage Macs? Look at every tech company.
elliotec··on Online age verification is the hill to die on
"The government" is the same as those lobbying the government. The people in the government get paid to push it, so they push it, and get paid more when it goes through, by the people who want that PII to analyze.
elliotec··on The Abstraction Fallacy: Why AI can simulate but not instantiate consciousness
#0 Is what William James described as consciousness not being a separate substance, but a set of relations within experience itself:

> Consciousness connotes a kind of external relation, and does not denote a special stuff or way of being. The peculiarity of our experiences, that they not only are, but are known, which their 'conscious' quality is invoked to explain, is better explained by their relations — these relations themselves being experiences — to one another.

elliotec··on Google plans to invest up to $40B in Anthropic
Okay, so just to be clear you're not commenting on productivity? Or what does "changes that impact" mean?

I might be missing a lot of self-evident assumptions here but I feel like I'm still missing so much context and have no idea what this difference is actually describing.

elliotec··on Google plans to invest up to $40B in Anthropic
Forgive my ignorance, but what exactly is the vast difference? Who's doing more of what, or whatever you're implying? And how do you quantify this?
elliotec··on One item purchased, ten emails
An invoice/receipt is often necessary for booking purposes, reimbursements, taxes, etc. But to your point, just put it in the same email as the tracking number and move on.
elliotec··on Nvim-treesitter (13K+ Stars) is Archived
What successful services have you built because of entitled users?
elliotec··on “Collaboration” is bullshit
Exactly. The old Iron Triangle. One of the three will always be most important depending on the constraints. Two of them will be possible.
elliotec··on How to Not Pay Your Taxes
I don't know if you're right or wrong, but it is an incredibly common tactic and done all the time by many businesses and people. There are of course ways to do this that are less noticeable by the IRS (as acknowledged in the article) and it doesn't seem like they have the capacity to investigate and audit the vast amount of this practice. My understanding is they are typically focused on fraud and/or folks simply not filing.
elliotec··on US private credit defaults hit record 9.2% in 2025, Fitch says
> never the time to short a company

> can be part of a combination strategy

elliotec··on Leaving Google has actively improved my life
Kagi has tons of results from Reddit and they're always high and relevant. I don't know if this means they're doing it even though they're "not allowed to" or what but they definitely get it somehow.
elliotec··on Wirth's Revenge
I agree completely. The internet did reset our expectations and tolerance for latency. My observation was not an endorsement by any means, I don't feel one way or another about it. But it sure would be nice to have speed!
elliotec··on The time I didn't meet Jeffrey Epstein
> In reality tax rates go up or down on everyone at the same time, because that's how the negotiations shake out.

This is absolutely false, especially in the US. Progressive tax brackets, breaks for the rich, and targeted changes for capital vs. income, deductions, etc. are the norm. Tax rate change is _always_ selective.

elliotec··on The Waymo World Model
Another comment mentioned the Philippines as the manifest frontier. SF is not on the same plane of reality in terms of density or narrow streets as PH, I would argue in comparison it does not have both.
elliotec··on The Waymo World Model
Can you explain? I lived in PH, and my guess is that you mean navigating and modeling the unending and constantly changing chaos of the street systems (and lack thereof) is going to be a monumental task which I completely agree with. It would be an impressive feat if possible.

Edit: or are you talking about the allegations of workers in the Philippines controlling the Waymos: https://futurism.com/advanced-transport/waymos-controlled-wo... I guess both are valid.

elliotec··on The time I didn't meet Jeffrey Epstein
Money is power. So to answer your question literally, if MY taxes went up, I would not have more power, but if the rich's did, I would because they'd have less power.
elliotec··on The Great Unwind
Are you serious? You said “dozens of CEOs” have been jailed for their role in the 2008 crisis. That is categorically false.

The article you posted is about a banker convicted in 2013 for fraud committed in 2011 that has nothing to do with contributing to the 2008 crisis. No CEOs were jailed for that.

Take your anger somewhere else because the truth is that it’s still zero, just like it was 5 minutes ago and 18 years ago. What would you possibly have to gain from lying about stuff like this?

elliotec··on Wirth's Revenge
Yeah, I think a lot of this can be attributed to institutional and infrastructural inertia, abstraction debt, second+-order ignorance, and narrowing of specialty. People now building these things are probably good enough at React etc. to do stuff that needs to be done with it almost anywhere, but their focus needs to be ML.

The people that could make terminal stuff super fast at low level are retired on an island, dead, or don't have the other specialties required by companies like this, and users don't care as much about 16.7ms on a terminal when the thing is building their app 10x faster so the trade off is obvious.

← PreviousPage 2 of 32Next →