HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

coughupalung

61 karma · joined April 12, 2018

submissionscomments
coughupalung··on Unity Software with a 'company reset' walks away from film VFX and the Wētā Deal
I worked for Weta a few years before the acquisition, let me just say that I'm not surprised that Unity didn't know what to do with it. It was never a single DCC set of code, but lots of separate tools (many very old) that only sort-of worked together. I imagine they would have to throw everything out and start over to build something on the level of Maya or Houdini.
coughupalung··on Huawei teardown shows chip breakthrough
From my experience, I don't think this is true (at least not in the way that matters). I finished my PhD in CS as few years ago from a good school and I am now a researcher in industry. In my time in grad school and industry, I have only seen one of the many Chinese nationals I met during my studies return to China. The Chinese researchers and interns I work with have no desire to return to China. The interns express concerns about job opportunities and quality of life if they were to return to China after finishing graduate school. I have never met any non-Chinese researchers who expressed interest in working in China either in industry or academia.

Obviously this is anecdotal so take from that what you will. The computer graphics and machine learning communities in academia and industry are small (even with the ML/AI explosion), if this was happening in any significant amount it would be difficult to miss it.

As for research output, I think there are definitely more top-tier papers from Chinese universities than in the past. It still seems like there are more Chinese surnames from Europe and NORAM universities than from Chinese ones. The big names in the field are still in European and NORAM universities.

I wonder how these are articles you linked are counting numbers. It's hard to understand how something like this could be happening completely under the radar.

coughupalung··on What happened to Russias Air Force? U.S. officials, experts stumped
It seems like you're trying to shoe-horn in an entirely different point? How does maintaining air supremacy as a military tactic relate to mass casualties?
coughupalung··on Pollution from fossil fuel combustion deadlier than previously thought
I lived downtown Toronto for several years and I had to replace my car battery three times because I drove it so infrequently that they died. I understand that living downtown isn't an option for everyone, but I strongly believe we can build dense "city centers" even in the suburbs that offer similar conveniences with larger units for families.
coughupalung··on Woman may have tried to sell Pelosi computer device to Russians, FBI says
Yes! I thought the same thing. Such a great film.
coughupalung··on Leaked memos Amazon warn 'be vigilant' due to threats to blow up data centers
I don't want to defend that. I want to instead ask, what would the damage be if members of Congress were killed? I think the long-term damage would be much, much worse.
coughupalung··on Leaked memos Amazon warn 'be vigilant' due to threats to blow up data centers
I get what you're saying. In my mind, the plot to kidnap the governor of Michigan changes the priors in determining if it was purely symbolic.
coughupalung··on New Zealand relied on science and empathy
That's interesting. I wonder how they calculated the area. There's no way Yonkers is twice as dense as Auckland in a practical sense (I would guess it's similar). As for Wellington, there's a very limited amount of space to build on because of the topography. As a result, houses are small, streets are narrow, cars are small (I had a difficult time driving a tiny hatchback). The CBD is unusually big and dense for a city with a metro population smaller than Madison, Wisconsin. The airport is shoehorned in to the only flat space in the region. So why does it have a low density? I'm assuming undeveloped regions are being counted here. I suspect density in terms of "used space" is quite high. Totally anecdotal obviously.
coughupalung··on New Zealand relied on science and empathy
I agree on the isolation. I lived in NZ. As someone from North America, it was strange how isolated it felt. Especially outside of Auckland. As for density, I disagree. Most of the country is empty but the cities are surprisingly dense by North American standards considering the population size.
coughupalung··on State Department cables warned of safety issues at Wuhan lab
I'm disappointed that this didn't end up getting more attention on HN. It seems like a rather important bit of news.
coughupalung··on Delivery workers are keeping California fed. They say no one’s keeping them safe
I think it's still too early to tell. I live in Toronto and we've been mostly shutdown for two weeks. I believe we took actions earlier into our outbreak than Italy and the US did with theirs so hopefully that will help. We had testing already in place in January so I think the numbers were reliable. There are backlogs now and people with mild symptoms aren't getting tested. Most clinics have moved to tele-health consultations to avoid spread. From what my friends in healthcare have told me, we're not overrun yet but we've cancelled all elective surgeries, etc. It seems like there are PPE shortages and healthcare workers have been rationing.
coughupalung··on Nature will publish peer review reports as a trial
That's not what the OP said though. I am in academia and most of my colleagues would agree with you about publishers. That's why most of us publish pre-prints on our websites, so that everyone can access our work. We can debate the business model but the OP is saying it produces inept research without really supporting that statement.
coughupalung··on Nature will publish peer review reports as a trial
> It is only a poisoning if it is not true.

That is literally not the definition of the "poisoning the well" logical fallacy.

And if you actually did publish in Nature, congrats. You still didn't offer an alternative.

Edit: fixed typo

coughupalung··on Nature will publish peer review reports as a trial
EW has a PhD but I can't seem to find any academic publications under his name. That doesn't outright mean he's wrong but it does mean that he actually has limited experience with the process. I have several and I've reviewed quite a few papers. I would say that peer review is a pretty good filter for garbage. Typically reviewers want to see shiny new ideas so if anything it over emphasizes innovation and discourages incremental improvements. As for gate keeping, I don't think so. Again, reviewers want to be WOW'd with new ideas.

In general, I prefer papers from peer reviewed venues over the arXiv. Good work does get put on the arXiv though so I can't ignore it completely.

coughupalung··on Nature will publish peer review reports as a trial
How about you do something constructive instead and propose a better alternative. You're just "poisoning the well" with empty accusations and ignoring how successful the scientific method has been.
coughupalung··on GM lays off engineer who helped expose VW’s diesel fraud
Where in Washington? I grew up in Vancouver and live in Toronto. Compared to Vancouver, winters in Toronto are horrible. For 4-5 months per year it's too cold to be outside for anything more than a few minutes. Aside from the west coast, the rest of the country is as bad or worse. It sucks and I want to either move back to BC or leave the country. Why waste 1/3 of your life trapped inside?
coughupalung··on The LaTeX fetish (2016)
What journal/conference are you submitting to? I haven't come across any in CS/Math/EE that even have a Word template to submit with. Every last one has a latex template.
coughupalung··on China Is Hunting for Foreign Buyers for Its Sovereign Debt
Any reputable investment firm will have risk management reports. If you don't like your fund pouring significant money into A+ rate bonds of a country with potential headwinds then pull out or sue.
coughupalung··on China Is Hunting for Foreign Buyers for Its Sovereign Debt
When you say packaged into derivatives, what do you mean? I can sell you all sorts of derivatives today without ever owning the underlying.
coughupalung··on World's first fully electric bus fleet quietens Chinese megacity
Oh yeah? There are no democratic countries with high speed rail? Hmm... I wonder where the Chinese stole their high speed rail designs from then...
coughupalung··on Chinese hi-tech researchers ‘told not to travel to US unless it’s essential’
As long as they can continue to get away with it, sure. Let's see if their greedy algorithm continues to work.
coughupalung··on Companies struggling to fill jobs 'should try paying more,' Fed's Kashkari says
I remember seeing "leaders" in the Vancouver tech industry talk about a labour shortage and thought the same thing [1]. Given the cost of housing and the salaries Vancouver companies are willing to pay, it's not a mystery why there is an exodus from Van. Pay up buttercup.

[1] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/technology/bc-technology-lea...

coughupalung··on Getting ‘screeched in’ in Newfoundland
As a 30-something year old Canadian, I was surprised to learn about this place just last year!
coughupalung··on How a Gang of Hedge Funders Strip-Mined Kentucky’s Public Pensions
Ah right! Thank you for the correction.
coughupalung··on How a Gang of Hedge Funders Strip-Mined Kentucky’s Public Pensions
Don't forget mortgage-backed securities.. oh wait.

In all seriousness though, large pension plans have very diverse portfolios. Ontario teachers used to own 80% of the Toronto Maple Leafs. Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System owns Oxford Properties, which owns and manages the office building I work in (and many others).

Edit: Added "Employees" to OMERS.

coughupalung··on The City That Had Too Much Money
I imagine it's like most money laundering laws where the circumstantial evidence that prompted the investigation is enough to convict if you don't provide a verifiable explanation.
coughupalung··on The City That Had Too Much Money
Where in Vancouver? My wife's parents live in Richmond and three houses in their block are vacant most of the year. I have a relative that lives near Oak and King Ed. and it's similar there too.
coughupalung··on Vancouver signs first agreement in Canada with Airbnb for short-term rentals
What makes you say that Burnaby is a deadzone? Metrotown, Brentwood, Lougheed all seem to be growing like crazy. I moved to Toronto a few years ago and I'm find myself surprised by new buildings every time I go back.