HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cma

11,776 karma · joined April 26, 2009

submissionscomments
cma··on ChatGPT now knows what you do on other websites via ad collector
> What has no precedent is running it on an AI chat product.

Meta?

cma··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
I'm not advocating for it, I don't know enough. But we already slaughter lots of animals and raise them in horrible conditions, and all robot assisted surgery already goes through animal trials.

> Second, this still doesn’t cover all the properties that make math proofs doable. It requires working in the physical world. You must physically capture or grow 10T cuts worth of animals.

It would likely be sim2real with that as the post training, reducing that requirement a lot.

> Cancer cells, for example, could regrow over months.

In that specific scenario you would likely train on receiving no unrelated injuries during the surgery, and have induced conditions with stuff tagged molecularly that you can then verify efficacy from without waiting months.

Depending on how much more data efficient sim2real makes it, you could end up seeing companies pushing it only for actual procedures the animals need but economically would never get; botched surgery and the animal gets euthanized before waking up, which they could argue was already going to happen.

> And most people wouldn’t trust the world’s greatest vet to operate on them, anyways.

Robotic surgery systems, already go through animal trials before being used on humans. So do many purely human surgery techniques.

cma··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
Not all of it would translate, but robotic surgery could be done on anesthetized animals in a mass RLVR way.
cma··on Faster NumPy in the Browser
Packages like BLAS
cma··on Why I didn’t sign the Fields medallists’ letter
I was thinking more about this part

> Everything therefore becomes a hobby or a game. People do things because they enjoy them for their own sake, or because they are endeavours used as vehicles to socialise and enjoy others’ company, or because a shared social belief exists and is cultivated such that doing such and such a thing confers social status.

And the mother in the story:

> Vashti is content with her life, which, like most inhabitants of the world, she spends producing and endlessly discussing second-hand 'ideas'. She enjoys talking to friends but uses her work to defend herself against their invitations to be more social, remaining in her ‘room’ where all her basic needs are met.

She's basically something like an academic reduced to something more like wikipedia researcher while something else has the first-hand ideas, communicating with her circle through facetime/vision pro persona.

cma··on Why I didn’t sign the Fields medallists’ letter
The Machine Stops by E. M. Forester is basically this world.
cma··on OpenAI buys smartphone camera maker Glass Imaging for $300M
World locked rendering isn't a requirement for smartglasses. Some existing ones in glasses for factor do have more limited visual positioning systems. In more obtrusive formfactors they have positioning suitable for world locked.
cma··on The Inference Hardware Revolution of 2026
Big money from taking Tesla's place in line for an Nvidia shipment during a huge shortage without compensation.
cma··on OpenAI buys smartphone camera maker Glass Imaging for $300M
They already exist. Glasses used to have heavy (at high prescription numbers) glass elements instead of plastic. HUD glasses can already fall in that weight envelope, with better weight distribution.
cma··on Steam Frame starts at $1059
In the xreal form factor it is pretty viable. It just needs a bit more resolution, and for more immersive gaming a bit more FOV, what it has FOV wise is fine for screen replacement.
cma··on Garry Tan wants US open-weight AI labs to 'distill' frontier models, too
> OpenAI themselves has admitted a weak version of this (that prompts might inadvertedly end up improving the model).

2023:

"The approach also aligned with the company’s broader deployment strategy, to gradually release technologies into the world for people to get used to them. Some executives, including Altman, started to parrot the same line: OpenAI needed to get the “data flywheel” going."

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2023/11/sam-a... https://archive.is/NmO5P#selection-979.907-979.1177

I don't think this has been a big secret.

cma··on Sam Altman: I agree with Dario that we need to pace the frontier
Xi is supposed to visit the White House soon and there are supposed to be AI talks.
cma··on Don't let anyone take away your big box of cables
They make giant ones too for bigger stuff. I think Adam Savage has a video about them for grouping unfinished project parts together.
cma··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
I don't think it's as bad as that sounds; in math people work all the time with conjectures they aren't sure if true, and work out a lot of other interesting math based on whether it is or not. Something like Turing's Oracle machine gives lots of interesting math just assuming one could exist, even if it couldn't. It may be that there are things proved we can never come to a human understanding of, but still keep getting interesting math that relies on it that has aspects we can appreciate and enrich our knowledge from.
cma··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
It's also possible he shared drafts of the work with someone else, who asked chatgpt to explain it to them with training on. Tao seemed to know lots of details of the work before anything was published, though also worked on the problem in the past with big results so maybe just guessed.
cma··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
> and that humans are NOT making nice progress on

They've pretty much said their own work was heavily agent driven. Levent is in a particularly bad place here because while he probably had a lot of background in the Jacobian Conjecture problem, he made the solution to that one sound like someone asked the question and he just fed it to Fable during the world cup. Whether that nonchalantness was to just seem hip or was to promote Anthropic, which he has stock in, or was just the truth I don't know though. But it makes this one seem similar, when they might have had really had nearly a year of very valuable feedback to the models.

cma··on Don't Get in a Crash in a Cybercab
The vast majority of major global automakers program their vehicles to automatically unlock the doors immediately following a severe crash. I think they just weren't eliding the context and posting the full notes, not as criticism of this: nowhere in the commentary mentions it.

> Which seems to be referring to the unique ability to move the car, which other cars don't have.

Most cars with keys in the ignition/keyfob in the car after a crash have the ability to be moved if they are still operational (a requirement of this one too). I'm not sure about Waymo, the Jaguar one does still have a physical steering column though and isn't fully drive by wire.

cma··on Another researcher says OpenAI trained on conversations, then claimed breakthrou
For the base model?
cma··on More questions about whether researchers can trust OpenAI with unpublished math
I think Google does train on anything you put into docs if you aren't careful with the Gemini integration?
cma··on Tell HN: OpenAI keeps re-enabling the 'allow training' setting
I've been asked over 15 times by Claude code to turn it back on (with the prompt defaulted on so if you accidentally hit enter your data is sucked in if you don't catch it).

I do think it ended up being after a power outage though and it was some kind of config corruption.

cma··on GPT-6 Astra, looped transformers, and hidden reasoning
If you ask it not to think about something that doesn't cause the pink elephant issue?
cma··on Anthropic Is Building a Predictive Surveillance System to Monitor Activists
If I heard Palantir-like I wouldn't assume something like a perfect mirror competitor company.
cma··on How An AI math breakthrough ignited a controversy
Interestingly of the two solved, both have rejected the prize money.
cma··on How An AI math breakthrough ignited a controversy
API or consumer subscription? And did he share drafts of the work with anyone who fed it back in on a consumer subscription without disabling training?

I have reason to believe OpenAI doesn't respect training opt outs, but there is a good chance they let something get through without an opt-out too.

cma··on How An AI math breakthrough ignited a controversy
> results from GenAI so far have been limited to finding counterexamples

Not all.

Ehrhart’s volume conjecture

Quantum parallel repetition for general two-player quantum games

Erdős Problem #183 on multicolor Ramsey numbers

Erdős–Sárközy Problem #12(i)/(ii)

Erdős Problem #125

Log-concavity of codimension-3, type-2 pure O-sequences

Optimal O(1/t) last-iterate convergence for Anchored Gradient Descent-Ascent

cma··on iPhone Duo
It's a shame Samsung dropped stylus support after the 6, but I guess the 8 is a good bit lighter weight than the duo.
cma··on iPhone Duo
Lots of people use facetime for personal calls rather than zoom meetings.
cma··on Anthropic Is Building a Predictive Surveillance System to Monitor Activists
Explain, it looks like samdesk is in a more narrow domain but overlapping and very related methods and business. Un-palantir-like seems like it would be a stronger editorialization.
cma··on Navier-Stokes – Tristan Buckmaster [pdf]
You can opt-out of training in Gemini on personal plans, but it disables your chat history, just to be vindictive; there is no technical reason and the other companies don't do this.
cma··on I resigned from Anthropic today
I doubt the Hugging Face one would take that many if hacking Hugging Face was the direct goal being optimized.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →