120 karma · joined April 9, 2019
You've personally demonstrated that humans don't have to be reasonable and cooperative, but you're not at all refuting my claim.
Here is something I do not see with reasonable humans who are cooperative: Me: "hey friend with whom I have plans to get dinner, what are you thinking of eating?" Friend: "fried chicken?" Me: "I'm vegetarian" Friend: "steak?"
Note that this is in the context of four turns of a single conversation. I don't expect people to remember stuff across conversations or to change their habits or personalities.
Your goalpost is much further out there.
One common kind of interaction I have with chatgpt (pro): 1. I ask for something 2. Chatgpt suggests something that doesn't actually fulfill my request 3. I tell it how its suggestion does not satisfy my request. 4. It gives me the same suggestion as before, or a similar suggestion with the same issue.
Chatgpt is pretty bad at "don't keep doing the thing I literally just asked you not to do" but most humans are pretty good at that, assuming they are reasonable and cooperative.
Source: I am a PhD student, this is kinda my wheelhouse
For some reason I think I would find it less valuable if the idea itself came from an AI, too.
Given that, it's not surprising that they used an AI to help with translation.
Or, men have a parent they are close with plus a spouse, and then the parent dies?
I agree with the general sentiment that we should not just blindly trust LLMs though.
(The answer is billions of parameters)
In some fields, single author papers are more common. Also, outside of ML conference culture, the journal publication process can be pretty slow.
Based on the above (which is separate from an actual evaluation of the paper), there are no immediate red flags.
Source: I am a PhD student and read papers across stats/CS/OR.
From Impro by Keith Johnstone
That is to say, don't compare to the accuracy of an even coin flip; compare to the accuracy of a coin flip that flips according to the proportion of the people with the attribute you care about.
Edit: capri sun juice pouches!